High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRA-RF/263/2023disposed of

Avtar Singh And Others v. State Of Punjab

2025-08-27Mr. Justice Harkesh Manuja3 pages

& & & &2 2 2 2

& ($"&% ($"&% ($"&% ($"&% 3 3 3 3 +#+#+#+# &&&&= = = =&% &% &% &%+#+#+#+# =2 =2 =2 =2&% &% &% &%@? A;

@? A;

@? A; ",++&# ",++&# ",++&# ",++&# 3 3 3 3@ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$ ))"**(#$

")&#0"#$

!""#$ !

%&! !

(!'(#&,'(/09&,($" $'"())*+,(#$ -#.(#"'$(/00*/ -# #.(1 >>>> / / / /? !(*;

? !(*;

? !(*; & & & &2 2 2 23 3 3 3 &% &% &% &% 4 5(4&%)!""#$())*+,($+&#/)!( (4"!'(1""#6(0"%&!,&#0&# #+#7 $'"0"*(4&%3 30(4+#%+*+#7$'"!"9+"5())*+ ,($+&#

"( (!#"0$($",&-#"*'(%(+*"0$& %+*"!")*4$&$'"())*+,($+&#0") )+$" 1""#(%%&!0"0- -%%+,+"#$&))&!$-#+$4 &# #,"0"0*4/$'"&$'"!+6+*(!*4+$ $-($"0*(#0&5#"!)"!$(+#+#7$& $'" (6" (,8-++$+& # )!&,""0+#7 '(9" (*!"(04 1"

""# '"*0 "#$+$*"0 %&! $'" "#'(# ,"0 (6&-#$&%,&6) )"#($+&#)"!$(+#+#7$&$'"*(#0 +$-($"0+#!"9"#-""$($"&%+** (7" (!(-*+ (*(#:

:(!(-*+ '-!0/ "'+* '(!(!

!/ +$!+,$ &&)#(7(! ?#&5 (7(!;/$&$'"$- -#"&% </2=/32:)"!(,!"

("0$'"!"-)&#(#0())*4+#7 $'" )!+#,+)*" &% ) )(!+$4/ 1"+0" 7!(#$ &% .- $ (#0 %(+! ,&6)"#($+&#/ $'" *(#0&5#"!:())*+ +,(#$ 1"+#7 +6+*(!*4 +$-($"0 (!" "#$+$*"0 %&! 7!(#$ &% +6 6+*(! (6&-#$&%,&6) )"#($+&#/'&5"9"!/5+$'&-$(#4 4)(46"#$&%+#$"!"$%&!$'")"!

!+&0

&% 0"*(4 +# %*+# #7 $'" )!""#$ !"9+"5 ())*+,($+& &# # $'+ !"7(!0 !"*+(#," ,(# 1" )*(,"0 -)&# $'

'" 0",++&# &% &#B1*" -)!"

6" &-!$ +# ,(" &% F+#7() F+#7() F+#7() F+#7() ())( ())( ())( ())( '&$())( #7( '&$())( #7( '&$())( #7( '&$())( #7( (0+ ?"(0; $'!&-7'

"!- (0+ ?"(0; $'!&-7'

"!- )",+(* (#0 ,8-++$+&# )",+(* (#0 ,8-++$+&# )",+(* (#0 ,8-++$+&# )",+(* (#0 ,8-++$+&# %%+ %%+ %%+ %%+ %+,"! %+,"! %+,"! %+,"! (#0#&$'"!C/ (#0#&$'"!C/ (#0#&$'"!C/ (#0#&$'"!C/ ?<D;DD ?<D;DD ?<D;DD ?<D;DD #9 9+"5&%$'"0+,-+&#6(0"'"!

!"+#(1&9"(5"**(,&#$"#$&% $'" ())*+,($+&#/ $'"

(6" + (**&5"0 (#0 0"*(4 & &% 3 0(4 +# %+*+#7 $'" !"9+ +"5 ())*+,($+&#+'"

"!"14,&#0&#"0

"9+"5))*+,(

"9+"5))*+,( ($+&# ($+&# ($+&# ($+&# <

!( (4"! +# $'" )!""#$ ())*+,($+&# + %&! !"9+"5 &% $'" &!0"! 0( ($"0 <@<<= )( "0 14 $'+ &-!$ +#

& =2 &% @/ 5'+,' 5( 0",+0 0"0 (*&#7 5+$' ,&# ##",$"0 ())"(* 1"(!+#7

&3 &% @/ 1"+#7 )(!$+( (**4 (**&5"014"#'( (#,+#7$'",&6)"#($+&#(6&-# #$%!&6 =*(E'$& @*(E' )"! (,!"

"( (!#"0,&-#"*%&!$'")(!$+"(!"

"(0+0"6$'($$'"6($$"!)"!$(+# #+#7 $&$'"(6"(,8- -++$+&#:#&$+%+,($+&#!"*($+#7$&$ $'"(6"!"9"#-""$($"+"+** (7" (!(-*+ (*(#:

:(!(-*+ '-!0/ "'+* '(!(!

!/ +$!+,$ &&)#(7(! ?#&5 (7(!;%+*"0($ $'"+#$(#,"&%%"5&$'"!*(#0& &5#"!,(6"-)1"%&!"$'+& -!$/ 5'+,' 5( %+#( **4 0+)&"0 &% 9+0" .-076"#$ 0($"0 3<<D )("0 +#

@ @ @ @@ ? A @ ? A @ ? A @ ? A A;

A;/ $+$*"0 ( F'(7 +#7'

'(7 +#7'

'(7 +#7' 9 9 9 9 $($" &% -#.(1C $($" &% -#.(1C $($" &% -#.(1C $($" &% -#.(1C (!( $'"!

!"&% 1"+#7!"*"9(#$+ !")!&0-,"0'"!"-#0"!

"-*$(#$*4/ E"")+#7 +# 9+"5 "5 $'" (1&9"/ $'+ &-!$ + &% % $'" &)+ +#+&#$'($+$5&-*01".-$(#0() ))!&)!+($"+% </2=/32:)"!( (,!" + (5(!0"0 ( $'" 6(!E"$ 9(*-" " %&! $'" *(#0 &% $5& 9+**(7" +" ( (!(-*+ (*(# ?(#0&-*+ (*(#;

#; (#0 (!(-*+ '-!0 ?(#0& 0&-*+ '- '-!0;(*&#75+$'(**$($-$&!41"# #"%+$C

#9 9+"5&%$'"(1&9"(5"**(&# #(,,&-#$&%(7!""0$(#0$(E"# #14 1&$'$'"+0"& &#%(,$/$'"!"9+"5())*+,($+&# +0+)&"0&%+#$"!6&%0",+ +&# 0($"03<< <D)("0+#$'",("&%'(7 '(7 '(7 '(7 +#7'

+#7'

+#7'?-)!(;(#0$'"())*+,(#$ (!" "#$+$*"0%&!+6+ +*(!6(!E"$9(*-"G </2=/32 2:)"!(,!"(*&#75+$'(**$($-$ $&!4 1"#"%+$ (#0 +# #$"!"$ (9(+*(1*" -#0"! $'" (# #0 ,8-++$+&# ?6"#06"#$; ,$/ <D@2 &5"9"!

/ $'" ())*+,(#$ '(** #&$ 1" "# #$+$*"0 $& +#$"!"$ &# $'" "#'(# ,"0 ,&6)"#($+&#%& &!$'")"!+&0&%0"*(4+#%+*+#7$'

"!"9+"5())*+,($+&# 2

"# #0+#7())*+,($+&#?;/+%(#4/(!"( (,,&!0+#7*40+)&"0&% -7-$ -7-$ -7-$ -7-$3/ / / / $+E ? ? ? ? ; ; ; ; H'

'"$'"!)"(E+#7:!"(&#"0 " '"$'"!!")&!$(1*" " :& :&