Dy. Commissioner Karnal And ANR v. Sunita And ORS




   
 
 


  

 !"

"#"

$"

% 

&'( )  ( (

""

$ %



*&(&'(
 

 
 (+%,

$!""

$ %



&'( )  ( (

""

$ %



*&(&'( '&-&.(./0 1  */2 345&* 67('.&('.(3!7*.'' 345&* 67('.&3*.&*(.83(.37 /   + %(

%"# $$#  3""

" 

%"##"





"

 

$



   ") 9+ $9 :"

%"##"





   5% (

;% $9 :"

   0

< %% === 
  
 '%

 $ %"##$

 ,  " "# 

22 #" > % "  





#$<  

 !"

"#"

$(<

"#

:
.

?"

$

 

#$<(+%,

$!""

@ % 
#:$< 

"#   .

 ";"

%A$; $"$ 

"

$ <%#"

$(

;#6$; ,%<%, 


B C D 

#$<( (

""

$,  % 
   0

< % %   ""#   +

;  E"

%

;   %   :$

;

 $"$    


@20"

;  

( (

""



"#   .

< %"

, 2% #:$< %

"#   %"

< "## ,$"

$%  :$

;

"

; 

( (

" 

%

"#   .

%"

< "

5   :

;  %  E

 #", 

9 #9$ 

 % ""#

:

" ;

9< ": %:"



"#      .


%

   $    "

 F%   4:

<

0#:$< $ 

"$ < 
< "# " "

$< ;

#" 9

<# %"" &#:

%   +#":

-<" 0 (

(

"
  %

,"

#:$"



%  

"G6  0 "A  %< %  , "

$ , %%  :

; %

 %   '%  



  #:$< %   < $"E

"# ;, %%  : 9"

$"9  % 

 !"

"#

:

9

;%

%   :

$% 

 

%    $E

 

 !"

"# 9 $#$"$D   "%

$% (<

"#

:
 #.

 :

9 " :

"#

;"

 *#12 %3""

"

"#&#:

D1C
%

 $    "

 F%  &#:

 *#  D1C4    :

$"

  

:   

 ";"

  %  

   %      '%  (< 

"#

:
 # .

$ :$"$0   "##% < %   :

9

:

"#

  " 

%

: %    :

$ 

";"

%    %$"  "

$#":

@$ % :

"#

;,"

%#$ ,% :%,"

" $$< <    

0#:$<  

"$<
<

;

#" 9

<# %

"#""  0#:$<

  #:$  <  $  %    

:   

 ";"

  %

%   '%$#

;

$% :$

;

  "

;% 

'%"

;0#:$<    

:#$

;%

%   $"

$$ 

;

% 

2:

: 9 < :<"##  "

$$  %  

9 , %

%

;

:: $$%"

 

%"

< "

$<, 2% $#:$<    "

$"

(:


0 %3""

"

"#: D10
%

 $ "

F%:4 %

%"##<$$ %"9 9":"$%

: %

%   '%  

  "

$  ,  %  #:$  <  %    ,% $ $    % 

#$ % $  ,   

 :%"## ;

;  %   :$

;

 "

;   

%    %;  %"

 %$"

0#:$< %   %

;

:$ % 

2:

: 9 < : <"##  "

$":$ ##;"##"

$"< "

#,% #A:

;%E 0 #:$< :<"##  3 : % :$

;

"

; 

%  < % , %"

,"

##;"#"

# "<# < "

'%#"

$(

;#6$;"## ,$%, 

"

% :$

;

$"$  


@20"

; 

 

%   ,% # < 9

;%",% 0 #:$< %  %"$$"

$$ :<"##  %

;  

:   %  

;  ,"

 $  <  $    :

$:  %   

< :<"## 

%

;"$ %#"

$(

;# 6$;# $ "

5 :%A$; %

  $"

 



   C

22 *0 

;"

% $A$;  % ,  %"9<

#$

"

$ : 

#  % "##"

,% # 

;   <2

:


"

$
0 (:

 %:"

$*#12 %&#:

*# D1C ";$%""

%#;"#E    

 

"

"#  

 <:"

$, % %     #

 %"

, 2% $  %#:$ <  %"    :%" 

"

$, %%   %"  ;% %#:$< %   %

%  

$$ %"99":"$%

G%

*#12 %&#:

D1C 9 % :$ :

$:

;% 

 9$";"

%   "

$%"



,% :%

:% 

 <:

$$ "

$: 

#";$%" %

<2 :


"

$
0 (:

 %:   $*#12 &#:

D1C  %"

<  9 $$%" 

";"

"  

E $ < 9 < : <"## 

'% #E   $(:


0 %:"

$*#12

%&#:

D1C

%"

% 

:"

$, %%  

#

%"

, 2% %#:$< %   %

   %     

 $$    %"9  9":"$  %

G% 

"

$: 

# %";$%"

% :"

 %#"

$(

;# 6$;%"

:  $;"9 ##;"# ,% #% #$

;%"

:"

 "<

$"

"9 < :<"##  % %

;

:

$<  $ $:% 

< :<"##  " :#"#,%  

0#:$< #:$< %"$:#"#"

$ E 9 :"##

 $  %    

:   

 ";"

  %  

   %    "

$: 

#";$%"

5 :%$:

%

 


   
"# $ <%#"

$(

;#6$;

"# :"<#

% :"

 "

%":"

  

"

$";"

%  < % , %"

,"

%#$ <9"# '%E

%" 

 < 9 <

:<"## ,"

"

$

%":"

"

$: 

# %";$%" "

5 :% %

 




 

  D
*0 ,%

%#"

$(

;#6$;,"

"< 5 :% :#"##" $ , %"%

 9

%:"

$% &#:

D1C%"" 

% #$<"

$<"

:<"##  "

$% 9

:

"

$

*#1 %&#:

D1C ,% :% 9 $ #:

%

< :<"## :"

< "$"# :"<# "

; 

.%"

< %#$%"

 

:"

$, % #

%"

, 2% %#:$< %   %

%"##< $$ %"99":"$%

G%

%# ;%  ": %"

<

2"# "";$%"%A$; "

$<%#"

$(

;#6$;

 "

"<#

 % %%"

$ #"

$: 

#    0 ";$%"% ;% <2 :


"

$
0 (:

 %:"

*#12 %&#:

D1C$   9 $"

 :

 :$ " 

 9 < :<"##  

"  $"

$  :  <"##   ,"

 "$  <  0  #:$  <  %    %

;

: :

"#

;,"

$<  $ % 

2:

: 9 < :<"##  '%

,"



"#   #"

 "

$  "

:"

%  ,

%   % #:$  <  %    .%"

< %";$%" "

"

%  #:

 :

 :$ 9 

;< :<"##  % #$%"9<

"$ $ "

$: 

# %";$%"*#1 %&#:

D1C 9 %"

:"

 #:

%

"

$) :2

"   

<   $:"

$"

 %"



":%

: %9 

%"##<<<"##  :: $

; %#"

$: 

# % " :$ % #$%"9< ## ,$  9"# %

%) :2

"

$: 

#";$%"

9 , (:

 %8 "##" : CD1"

,##"

(:

C % A"<8 "# #" : CDC %

;

: %

; 

"< :

:

: :$ <$  9"#  % #$%"9 ## ,$% "  :$"

 <$ #:

%

  %



#"

$: 

#    0# $ 

5 :%$:

%

  $"

    

2C2

   D1 60 ?  

!  # $

% D16

D?"

$  

&  D16

"

$: 

#"#  $ :"

< 9"

 "$ 

 " $:

 %

   

'    ()* $ +   



$,DD 601"

$
    
""

,##"




   
"

 :

;%9"

 <

"$<#"

$ : 

# %" $;

;% ;%%A$; :

$<% , " % 

%"

": $:

: "

% :"

 %

## ,

;E

#",""

:

$"

/2
B%% $ <2 :


"

$
0 (:

 %: $*#12 %&#:

D1C " 

:  ";"

  %  

    ) :2

   "



"#  

E $ < 9 < : <"## H

B%%% :$ #:



"

"#   "

 9 $$ $*#1 %&#:

D1C 

   <  ## ,$  ,% #  :

;    

 

"

"#   *#12 %&#:

D1CH

B%%%

;

: " :

"#

;:

9 $

:

$"

 

 $*#12

2D2 %&#:

D1C

$<  $ % 

2:

:";"

"   9 <

:<"##  

$"

$$<"

#:$< " :#"# ,% ,

%  %"

, 2% %#:$< %  ,% "  

;% 

:#"H 5 $"#

;%"

$E

, ##<"  " E :"

 9

%:"

$%&#:

D1C 

 $  ":

"%:

 9 

9 #9$

"

:"

'   ;%  %  7<"

  :"#  8 9   ,% :% 

$$    <  % $      .

 8 9    "

$   

  % $ :":  "  %  ;"

    #9#  1 %  " $   ,"

 "$ 

 % 



 .

 :#   0   0I8  ,

 $:$ 

 % 



 :#   0*   9   : 

 

"#

 :# 0' 9  9"

"

%

"#   

"#  # 

"#  "

%:"

"<  :#  07   9   $"

 

"#  :

 "

$  :#   0I  9 #:

 %

"#

 

 $:

;%"

 :#

%



" 9"

 " $ ,"$

3""

"

"#: D10 

:

:, %%"

$ :#

(:

C %: 9 #:



"

$) :2

%

"#   '%

 ) :2

 "

22 

"#  

 <#:$< <

*#1
 &#:

D1C 9 %"

# :"

$"":%

%

 ) :2

  $  :%:"

$" %"## <$:#"$ %"9< $##:$ <   $:"

$"

 %"

 ":%

: %9 

%"##<<<"##  (:

 %: 9  

2:

:";"



 ) :2

 ,% :%"$  $/2
-.

 +    *             # *  / 

 



  

 

 

 



 

 

     

      

  ! "#  $

   $   

  

  



 

 % $     $  

  

 & '   

        



    

$  

    

 

$          $    

  

 

 (  '    

 



     

     

  

 

    ) * 

        

  

  !

 "#  

    

 #     

22

        

 

   

 



 

 



 + 





 



  

                 

 

$     

   

, (:

 %: 9  9"# 

 ) :2

,% :%"$  $/2 0--  #         # *   /   ) -    $       $      $       



 

  

             .

/

             

    

 

  

   



0

 

$  !  "#  $

 ) -     



 

$

  $

                 , '%

$

 :<,  9"# 

 ) :2

 (:

 %:"

$"

 

%

 ) :2

 $(:

 %: '% 9"#

 ) :2

 %

::"

<"$ %;  "<  %

 ,  %"< "# #  %

$

B%"

 $(:

 %:  "

;" 

%

22

    ) :2

  <    #

 %"

 , 2% $   %  #:$ < %   % %"##<$$ %"99":"$%

'% <A:"



(:

 %:

9:#"%"

#:$

# %:

: %3  "

$" 

:

:"

$";"

% , %%   #

%"

, 2%

%#:$< %   %

$$ %"99":"$%

 "

 

2:

:";"

< #

%"

, 2% %#:$< %  " " :"## #"$  %

 9"# '%    :% 

"

$ %

$$ %"99":"$%

'%



(:

 :

%",% "

%"

# %   , 2% %#:$ < %   %:"

"

'% :$ :

9 "

$:

$:% :

"#

; 

%"

<  <$ $*#12 %&#:

D1C ,% :%"$  $/2 1-*  /  2                # *  /%    



  

   

 

      

     

     0         

 

      $

             

.

/

             

           

  

  

202 "#1  

  !

   

      

  ! "#  $

   $           0        &       

  ! "#  $    $   



       

           

      



  



  % $

 

  

.

/

 

   

 

    # 





  

  

   ( '   

                      

$   / 

    

 

$          $    

  

 

, ) $  %  "

$  *#  "  :#"   :$  %"

 <   9 $$ 

E

;  %  

;   %      "

$  :

;   

 ) :2

'%

"< ; 

% :$ .:#"# 9 %"

% % "#

< %< %  "+",  E  %  

 <

;

;" 

%

 ) :2

 % 



$<  $ 9 "

%   :

$"

 

2  

 ) :2

 "

%:"

"< '%  

" %%  #  %

"%

$

: ,%

%"## <<# ,%"

+ &@"

"

 

  %"## 9 " :

"#

;<;

;" : #

%"

 $"

%:

$"

 

 #  $%"

<

 9 $$%" :%

%  %"##<:

9 $ #



@ % %"

#" $

:%$" #"



;:

9 $

%

 (<2#
"$, %(:

 
0 %: :#"#  9 %"

$

; 

% 

:"

$ , %%

  #

%"

, 2% %#:$< %   %

 ) :2

%   "

%:"

"<  %"## <$$ %"99":"$%

'%



%#;

#"

 $:

;  %  "

$   9

 :#"  %" 

 

    ) :2

"

"#  # %"

$:

:   %"

, 2% %#:$< %   "

% < "

" #

 

%  %

 ) :2

:"

"

%

:"

$% %"##< $$ %"99":"$%

'% % $(:

 %:

 $*#12 %&#:

D1C %

E  %" "

:"

%,

% %#:$< %    

2:

:%"

 < 9 < :<"##  , 2% $#:$ <  %  "  #  

;% 

 

22

:";"

%   

%"

"

#

%"

+

%

; %"9

;#

%"

2% $< %#:$< %   % 

2:

: 9 < :<"##  %

;

: %

E $ +%"A ;  %#:$< %   :"

% 9 < :<"##   #

"

"

,% % 9

#", :#"#E %" 

%"

 < 9 < : <"##  %

;

: %

$<  $ % 

2:

: 9 < :<"##  9 %"

+

#:$ < %   5,% "$   9 $ : <"## 

:"

 :

; 

%) :2

%   %: :"

# $#"$ :%  9

#",

" %,

% %3   %< %  

:#" % , ##<  %

;

: %

; % 

2:

: 9 < :<"##  <

:"

<#"

$$ , "#",%"

"##:

: "

%

;



:

$<  $ % 

2:

: 9 < : <"##  

$"

$$9 < < %    : 9 % ":%", 2% $#:$< %  %"9  #"

 E 9 :"##  $% 

2:

: #<;

;

%    : 9  "

$"9  <  "#  <  

;  %

;

"  %  :$

;

%

;%#$ :

; 

2 '%:



#"

$: 

#    0 %"% :$ <$ $*#1 %&#:

D1C

#:

;%

 ) :2

"

"#  <

:<"##  % #$%"9< ## ,$ ,% #:

; 

 

 ) :2

 "# :"

<"::$

# :"

$"":%

%

 ) :2

  $ % *#1 %&#:

9 

;< : <"## 

E $ ) 

;< :<"## 

E $  #

<   $:"

$"

 %"

 ":%

'%

 :$%"

 <"$ $ #

:"

 #:

%

 ) :2

 < %"

%E  :

; 

%  

  ) :2

 3  %   

   %    < "::$ A:$ , 2% %#:$< %   "  

; 

 % %"

 <$:#"$ <:"

$  ::

##  #

 9":"

: %

B% #

%"

, 2% %#:$<

%  :#"#  E 9 :"##"

$  #  % 

2:

:";"

 % %

$:"



;

: %

; "

+% <  @

"9  % 

2:

:< :<"## 

'%"

:" :

$"

< "

5 :% %

 




   
" %":"

 

212 

;:

9 $ :

; 

  #:$ < #:$< :"

:

"#

;"



  #  $% 

'% #

,"

:%"## ;$ %;  $%" 

% #$%"9<

"

$ #< :<"## "

<

;

;% #

<, 2% "A  %<

%":"

  ,"

"# ";$%"% :$  <$ $*#1 %&#:

D1C #:

;%

 ) :2

% ;% :<"##  % #$%"9< ## ,$ ,% #:

;% 

'%

5 :% %

  ,% #A:

;% $:



%"

 < 9$"

 $/2
 

             



       

  

   

  $  



2  

 %    3 4

  5 3    

    





 '  $

   

                   



   

$ / 

6

/ 

$    $

  

 



        $3 4%   5 3 $   

   

 / 

6

/ 



  

$  

3 4%  5 3 

    

      

  / 

 6

/ 

      

$   ' $   

2C2 

      



'  

 



 / 

 

  

       



         

$  / 



  

 

, !

9 ,% ": %":"

  ,"

 < 9$%"9 E ,"

"$<"

  :<"##  '%

 < 9"

  

$   %:



#"

$: 

#    0 %" 

 < 9 < :<"##  %":"

%" %$:

,"

%"% :$ *#1 %&#:

*# D1C:"

<"$"# :"<#

:"

 :

;"

$"

;

 

'%#"

$(

;#6$;# $ %$:


    
"  ,% #  ":%

;  %  :

:#

 %"  %  

;



: %

;,"

$<  $  :

$:% 

 

< :<"##    

" $$:

:% %"

< "+ <%#"

$(

;#6$; %":"

    < 

"#  # ,% " $$%

; D<

 $% 

%

"#   # '% $ #

,"

"

$< % , %"

'%

%  

"#    #  :%"## ;$  %   :$

;

 "

;   

%  <

#

;, 

%;  $%" % 

% #$%"9<  9 "

$:

$$% ;%:"

:<"##  '% $, 

,"

$



$<%

5 :%

2D2 %

  ,% # < 9

;"

 $/2
7   

 

      )9     '

# $,.3345-6 # 47. 

 

  /:5 3 $%;+        





      ; '    

  

<  4$ ==4%%

            

  # / %  

   

  

8    %;  

     

 

%;  %;    

 

    



   

     / 

   



         %=

     # 8     9$2 7:;4-<<:  .3-<<10

   



   



   



 >  $        





     

 



                 

       

      '       



           

      :    )

  9       , - %"

$ < 9"

" %A$;

:#"%"

22  

2:

:

 $<, 2% %#:$<

%  9 < % , %"

% 

$$ %"9 < "

$";"

3 ,9 %#"

$

5 :%

"" %A$; %"

 < 9$%"%"$%

$"

$$"

:<"##  %

;

:, #$%"9< $<  $ :

$: %9 

;< :<"##    

,"

%

< % #"

$

5 :% "

 ,%% $"

$<"<    "<

;



 "

$" :#"#,% "A ; 

, 2% %#:$< %  "  

;%  

2:

: %

;

:

$<  $ %  

 9 < :<"##    

,% %#",$  E %"% 

2:

:

 < 9 < :<"##  %

;

:

$<  $ % 

  :<"##  # %"

+

 , < %   ,% " ;

#



 '   
" #"

$(

;#6$; %

  :

$$%

: %" %":"

 % 

2:

:  ";"

  %  

   %      ,"

 "

$  < E

"A  , 2% $#:$< %   < % ,

%"

 ":%" <$"

$$9 

% 

< :<"##  :



,"

"

$%"% 

2:

: % #$%"9<  9 < :<"##  "

$ " %  #:

;%

'%

:



,"

A:$"

$%

22  

2:

:"

$";"

,"

%#$ ,% # < 9

;%"%" #"

; #:

 %:   $%  9"# <  

:2<" #" E

 # : B% #

 ;" 9 %;

#" #;

#" % "A < % 

 

$ ,%%  %&@: 9%"

":$

:

 , %% #", ,% :%%"9< 9"# $# ":$ &9

""

$

"<#%"%

:: <"##  % #$<"

"

$""###9#

%:

$: "##  :$

;

":

  $:"

<E"

%$ ##

 $ %"9<

"

$

9 #"

%#", .%"

< %%#$%",% :

 :$%"

<  <$ "

" 

2:

: %

;

: %

 <  $  ## ,% :$  <$ #:

%

B% #  "

;  %  :



 %"  ,%  *#  12  % &#:

D1C$   <"

 :$ 

;%  

2:

: <"##  % %

;

: % #$%"9

## ,$% " :$"

%"

<  <$ #:

 ) :2

 $*#1 %&#:

D1C #"

$: 

#    0# $ %$:

    
" ,% :%%"

< ## ,$

,  %:"

'% %:"

"

 % A"<8""

:%"": D (:

D $ A"<8""

:%"": D
"

"# :"<# %(" 3""

"  9 %" <A: " 9"# % :  %(""

:%

22 "< 9$  %

:<""A  %9  %"

:%



;%8""

:%""" @" $

"; "#

;%#$ , %9  

 : %":"

  ,"

%#$%"% 3""

"8""

:%""&#:

D1 $   <%"

,% :%"

%"

:% %:

$"

2:

 

%(""

:%

 <:"##$"

$:

$:$  9

  <2

:


 (:

D $:$   9 $%"



,% :% :%"

 <:"##$"

$:

$:$ %"

"

#"

$

5 :% %

  ,% #"#

; 9

(:

 %8 "##" : CD1 %#$%"

% 9"# (""

:%<"

;" 2:

: #

%"##"# <%#$

""



,% :%"

%#:

%(""

:%

 < %#$   

$$:

    
"

"# :"<# % ": % :"

"

:"

 %  9

:#"

(<2 :


"

$
0 (:

 %::#"# #"$ , % :$ :"##

;

:

; 

 

$%"



,% :% :%

 <:

$:$

'   
""

$ 
   
"  %"

<

:#"##"

$$ , %"%A$;     
"

"# :"<# 

": $:

: "

%:"

"

; $% 3""

"  

"# :  D10  "

$  %  &#:

 *#  D1C  "$ %   ""

%3""

"

"#: D10"

$%&#:

202 *# D1C":

$ % " 9"; "< ; 

'%

  

% :"

 %

:  

9 +% 9

(:

 %8 "##" : CD1

.

9 , %"< 9 "

,  "##%%E

;

% :"

; ";"

%



E #  ,  "   %  

 %"  %  ;

$ A$; "

$<%#"

$(

;#6$;

 "

"<# 3 : < % % ""# ""## ,$"

$% ;

$A$; $"$ 

 "

$<%#"

$(

;#6$;

"

#
  
$   %&'!( !"

 #
 

 $

$A