High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3180/2012dismissed

Satbir And ANR. v. Hukam Singh And ORS.

2015-09-15Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih8 pages

!"# $#%&'&() * +

* !",&-!($!(".#- /00#11!("' 2#-'3' 34!5&(6.!($".#-' /#'0($#("' ) 7 8 88

-#'#(") -'.&'.30"!9$:%!"#9 -".#!00#11!("' ;;; <.#".#- -#0-"#-' 1%!1 0!0#-' 5!= ,# !11>#$ " '##".#?3$65#("@

,#-# #--#$"".#-#0-"#-'-("@ <.#".#- ".# ?3$65#(" '.31$ ,# -#0-"#$ &( ".# $&6#'"@ ;;; 88 -!1 3&" &1#$,=".#01!&("&

'>!'$&'5&''#$,=".#"-&!1 %3-" :&$# ?3$65#(" !($ $#%-## $!"#$

00#!1 0-# #--#$!6!&('"".#'!&$$#%-## !&1#$!($>!'$&'5&''#$:&$# ?3$65#("$!"#$ A

.&'&'.>901!&("&

'!-#,# -# ".&' %3-" &( ".&' -#631!- '#%($ !00#!1 !-"&#' " ".# 1&'9 .#-#&(!

"#-9>31$,#-# #--#$",=".#&--&6&(!10'&"&('&( ".#'3&" ('.-"9&(!'3&" &1#$,=".#01!&("&

'9".#=0-!=#$

-!$#%1!-!"&(".!"".#6& "$##$$!"#$

953"!"&( &(.#-&"!(%# 9 &( !:3- 8!%.5& #:& >&$> !6&(!9!($".#'3,'#C3#("'!1#$##$',=8!%.5&#:&9>#-#

>.11=&11#6!1!($(311!($:&$ =>!= %('#C3#("&!1-#1&# 9 !$#%-## -0''#''&(>!'!1'0-!=#$ -">!'5!&("!&(#$ ".!".#"!5'( !('!.!00#(#$",#".#>(#- !( !6-&%31"3-!1 1!($ 5#!'3-&(6 * ,&6.!' ,&'>!'9 '&"3!"#$ !" :&11!6# .!(?.!-&9 #.'&1 &14.#-&9 &'"-&%" D!-(!1 1!&("&

' %1!&5#$ ".#5'#1:#' " ,# ".# -#:#-'&(#-' .#" !59 !' $#0&%"#$&(".#0#$&6-##"!,1#,#&(6$-!>(,#1>)

" # $!% # $!& 2&$# 6& " $##$ $!"#$

9 .#" !5 ,#C3#!".#$.!1 ".#'3&"0-0#-"=&( !:3- 8!%.5&#:& (> $#%#!'#$ >&$> !6&(! ' ".# '!&$ 6& " $##$ >!' #E#%3"#$>&".3"%(%3--#(%# ".# !".#-!($6-!($ !".#- ".# 01!&("&

'9 >. .!00#(#$ " ,# ".# %11!"#-!1 !($ -#:#-'&(#-' .#" !59 ".# '!5# >!' ( %('#C3#(%# 3-".#-9".#'3&"0-0#-"=>!'!(%#'"-!1&((!"3-#!($!'0#-

".# %3'"5 0-#:!1#(" &( ".# !-#! ( 5!1# 0-0-&#"- %31$ !1&#(!"#-6& "".#!(%#'"-!10-0#-"="".#$#"-&5#(" ".# %11!"#-!1!($-#:#-'&(#-'.#"!5$&#$&''3#1#''!,3"A =#!-' !6 !($ 0'" .&' $#!". #:#( ".# -#'" .!1 ".# '3&" 0-0#-"=>!'53"!"#$&( !:3- 8!%.5&#:&,=".#-#:#(3# !6#(%= !' '.# >!' !%%#0"#$ " ,# .&' >&$> " >!' ( ".# ,!'&' ".# 6& " $##$ $!"#$

!($ ".# 53"!"&( 98!%.5&#:&'1$".#'3&"1!($&( !:3- $# #($!("' " ($ ".#-#!

"#-9 ".# '!&$ -#'0($#("' 3-".#- !1&#(!"#$".#'!&$0-0#-"=.!"&'.>901!&("&

'.!$!''!&1#$ ".# 6& " $##$ $!"#$

9 53"!"&( !($ ".# '3,'#C3#("!1&#(!"&(' ($# #(%#9&">!'01#!$#$9&("#-!1&!9,=$# #($!("' " " A9:&$#'#0!-!"#>-&""#('"!"#5#("'9".!" ".#'3&"&('"&"3"#$,=".#01!&("&

'>!',!--#$,=".#0-&(%&01# -#' ?3$&%!"! !(6!19 6-!($ !".#- ".# 01!&("&

'9 .!$ #!-1&#- &1#$ ! '3&" !6!&('" 8!%.5& >& # .#" !5 C3! 6& " $##$ $!"#$

!($ ".# '!5# >!' $&'5&''#$ ,= ".# #(&- 3, 3$6#9 D!-(!19 :&$# $#%-## $!"#$ B +F &(%#9!(6!1$&#$$3-&(6".#0#($#(%= ".#'3&"9.&''(' '.5!!($ &-,!10-'#%3"#$".#'!&$'3&"(.&',#.!1 ($ =#"!(".#-'3&",#!-&(6 GB+ >!' &1#$,= 3(.#-&#:& >&$> !(6!19 31!, &(6.9 '.!5 &(6. !($ &-,!1 !6!&('"8!%.5&:#(".#'!&$'3&">!'$&'5&''#$,=".#3,

3$6#9 &-'" 1!''9 D!-(!19 ( +

.# !00#!1

A 0-# #--#$ !6!&('" ".# '!&$ $#%-## >!' !1' $&'5&''#$ ( + !($'>!'".# !"# ".#-#631!-'#%($!00#!1 0-# #--#$ ,= ".# 0-#$#%#''-'&(&("#-#'" ".# 01!&("&

' ,# -#".&'%3-"9(

A8!%.5&#:&>!'>& # .#" !59!'.#0#- -5#$D!-#:!5!--&!6#>&"..#-.&'&'.>9 .!1 ".#'3&"0-0#-"=>!',#C3#!".#$,=.#"!5&(.#-

!:3-9 03-'3!(" " ! 6& " $##$ !($ ".# -#5!&(&(6 .!1 $#:1:#$30(.#-,='3%%#''&(!

"#-".#$#!". .#"!5 ( ! $3# !($ ".36."

31 %('&$#-!"&( ".# 5!""#- &( &''3#9 !($ ".# #:&$#(%# ( ".# -#%-$9 ".# %3-"' ,#1> %50-#.#('&:#1= %(%13$#$ ".!" ".# '3&" &('"&"3"#$ ,= ".# 01!&("&

' >!' ,!--#$ ,= 0-&(%&01# -#' ?3$&%!"! !($ 03-'3!(" " ".# &($&(6 -#%-$#$ !' -#6!-$' &''3# 9 ".# '3&" &1#$ ,= ".# 01!&("&

' >!' $&'5&''#$ .# %(%13'&( !--&:#$!"&(".&'-#6!-$,=".#"-&!1%3-"!($!

&-5#$,=".# !00#11!"#%3-"-#!$'!'".3') '() * # # +#"

+# ,

) * - " +

# , ) , #+ #, . &/)%%)%(01) 2 34)4%)%(14

. 34)%%)%(1% + - ##, 2$5

. 34)4%)%(14) # ,# ,

# , # . 43)43)&446 + - #

# ++

8#)004#,%(1&

. 34)%%)%(1%)

# # +#

* , " ") $ &4463$ 69!:) %4) +

#, . &/)%%)%(01

34)4%)%(14"

. #

+ ) # -$ + +

# ##,

+ +

++ - +

,, ,)* + ,

#)%#%4

+# # , "# )

;

#)&/4%=%

&/&%=% %9)4/)%(/6

%0)4/)%(/6 +" -) ,

#)%%

%15 > %( -

;

< 8#)%63&=% &6)%4)&449 ? - ,

#)(

%4 , "#)

-$,

#)%3

%6 + ,#,

#)%% "

41)41)&44/

%%)46)&441 +" -)* +

+ # + # - #

- #,

) .

34)4%)%(14)*

#, #)&$1$(

%4 ,#

# @ '& A +#+-

+#+-B +

,,CD!!) 1) A

, , "# #, ,

D # .#CD!!) () A ) # #, CD!) %4) , #)( +#"$ #

# .# C D!!)

F * #+# #+ - #)%, + )E %%) * + -

. +# -

- # #, , ++

- - #

! .

: -

# ++

) %&) ";) + $ #

## ") ) *

) ) ) "

# #, ) ) * , 41)4/)%(9&

# #)&64 # #,

) %3) * +

,, +

,# # +# + , #

- " ,

# +# )*

# # " #

, #, +

,, # - ,

- !

. #, #

#) %6) * $ . 43)43)&446 +

- #

# ,

#,. +"

,, ,# <

+ #"

) *

#, + + #,. #+ - # #

# %% #,!)#

-$ , "# #, ,

,,)E .!:#.#!-$1#!-(#$%3('#1 -".#!00#11!("'!($ 0#-3'#$".#0!0#-,4

B 8#!-(#$%3('#1 -".#!00#11!("''&501='##4'" -#&"#-!"# ".# '3,5&''&(' ".!" >#-# !$:!(%#$ ,# -# ".# %3-"' ,#1> !($ -#?#%"#$ !

"#- ! $3# !($ %50-#.#('&:# %('&$#-!"&(".#-!-635#(">!'!$:!(%#$ (%#$#$1=9 0-&- " ".# &('"&"3"&( ".# 0-#'#(" '3&"9!'&5&1!-'3&">!' &1#$,=".#6-!($ !".#- ".#01!&("&

' '##4&(6".#'!5#-#1&# 0''#''&(!($$#%1!-!"&(9".!"".# 6& " $##$ $!"#$

>!' >.11= &11#6!1 !($ ".# '3&" 0-0#-"= &( ".# .!($' .#" !5 >!' !(%#'"-!1 &( (!"3-# !($0'".&'$#!".&">31$.!:#%5#"".#01!&("&

',#&(6 %11!"#-!1 .#"!5(%#$#$1=901!&("&

'!-#("%1!&5&(6 !(= &($#0#($#(" -&6." &( ".# '3&" 0-0#-"= ,3" %1!&5 !( &("#-#'" &( ".# '3&" 0-0#-"= ".-36. ".#&- 6-!($ !".#- .# 0-#:&3' '3&" &1#$ ,= ".# 0-#$#%#''-'&(&("#-#'" ".# 01!&("&

'>!'C3!".#'!5#0-0#-"=!($!6!&('"8!%.5&E

!%&#9".#C3#'"&(".!">!'$&-#%"1=!($'3,'"!("&!11=&(&''3# &(".#0-#:&3''3&"&'!1'$&-#%"1=!($'3,'"!("&!11=&(:1:#$

-$#"#-5&(!"&(&(".#0-#'#("1&'.3'9!00!-#("1=".#'3&"

&1#$,=".#01!&("&

'>!',!--#$,=0-&(%&01# -#'?3$&%!"! 8#!-(#$%3('#1 -".#!00#11!("'%31$("0&(" 3" !' " .> ".# %(%13'&(' ".!" .!:# %(%3--#("1= ,##( !--&:#$ !" ,= ".# %3-"' ,#1> >#-# #&".#- %("-!-= " ".# 0'&"&((-#%-$-'3

#-#$ -5!(=5!"#-&!1&11#6!1&"= (".#>!4# ".#0'&"&(9!''4#"%.#$3"!,:#9 ".#-# .!-$1= #E&'"' !(= 6-3($9 1#!'" 01!3'&,1# &( 1!>9 "

&("#- #-# >&". ".# $#%-## ,#&(6 !''!&1#$ C3#'"&( 1!>9 53%. 1#'' !(= '3,'"!("&!1 C3#'"&(' 1!>9 !-&'#' - %('&$#-!"&( 00#!1 ,#&(6 $#:&$ 5#-&" &' !%%-$&(61= $&'5&''#$ #0"#5,#- *9

* !?!( -3( !11& 3$6#