High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3184/2012dismissed

Jagtar Singh v. Narinder Singh And Others

2017-07-26Mrs. Justice Anita Chaudhry5 pages

!"# "$ %%&& '# (

# # "$ $#

#*! +, #- $./$ +#,0$ # $$#*+, ## %

2$%&

%%&& &$ "(&# %%& "

$3("* %

4.$&# & #!("

% "$%%& &4.$# % 2$%&

$ & #%

4.0. %# &&

0$# %$ & * (# "

- & #& &

# + +670

&&" $ +6 0 % # * . #" # 8( &0 "# 2$%&

(#$#&&"$ $ &$& * (# " - &

4.#" # & ,(#

5 0$#

- & & 0 & ,(# *

2$#&9(#$ #$ &4.$%&

# %%& &4.$ +$&# 9(# ( $8( && (4 (&2$:# 9(# ( $$ *%%%# 0$$"#* &&$ 4

8( $0 $ #$ * $4- *%%%# #$ &$ 4 %( *%%%#7 $ (#$#4 ( $ $4- # *%%%#+$#

# * $

58;7*

$$#0# 8&,

5 $ <0,#+ $ "#* && %#( $ 9(#

" &.0&, 8%& $ 4 ", 0$ $ $%% #* " 2$&# =# %%&&9(# $4$$

# % 0

)> *#- "$

#&4#$# !"# "$%&

0$# :-$0 # "$ 4#$# &0 ?0& "$ 2$ =# %%&& 9(# (#$# ( $ 0

(& &&$ $.% 0$.%$ "#* &&2$0

( 4($%& 8(

$"#* &&!"# "$)> $ % $$"#*

#4!& $# $$( :-$0 # "$0$#

*#- "$% $"#* 0 #4$%& .% !& $# >$$ #

+&# =# %%&&9(# # ,#( $# #% $ , $ " 0

%$%%& &4.$ $&$"#*

&& ( %(

:# (

(4*$

*%%%#*"$$,4 #(# $ 0# #@(# :# (

(4*$ > (-$, "$$ %%#<

(4*$8( &&

0 - 0

&&$,&&"# +$# #+$

&* $* &, 44 %(#$ # :# (

(4*$* #

* $0

# (&

& &4.$%&

# %# && $$#$ +&# (

#$# % $

0$ && ,$* (4* $ $ #

## 4. $ =# %%&&9(##" 4# ( #*$##2$# ### $3("* %

4.$&# =# %%&&9(#+$# #+$ %%& &4&4

7$,

#$#"(* # 4.&# (

# $%# 2$# %($ &.0&, ( $, 4 ( +$# #+$ *%%%# *%&8%& $

* ## $0 0$*

# *% %%#$, %%#4#&-$"#* 0(&%#,$

*%%%# $#4#$ ##$ & 2$%&

$ 4&8%& $0 *%%%#0

( 0$($ ##$ & 3(& *% %%# #

(4.$#2# (#.#4.$: *%' #( #

$# & "

(# 2$: *%' #(&.* #" #*- " #. $ *%%%#

(2$.#& #@(# *- #. $4- # %" *%%%#4.* "$

$%(#$ #2$%(#% #0$$$ *%%%# 4 %(#$ & &&.* $4- *%%%#+ &. &$ 4 %( $# $ #$ 4 * #$ &$ 4

%(2$#"(* &# (

$ *.

$,4 #(# (%%#%& #, 8%&

$ 4 ", #*0$#$ *%%%#0 %(#$ 0$#$

$," *

" #"(* &# (

& $ "#*

- 0 ,#. $,&&" 4.(-$, "$

+$# #+$

4$&4 4 %(#$ # 7 *.% + ($ "

#.4( $"#* && & 4 "$&4(4 (& $## :# (

(4*$ #

* $0

4( .$ %# && 7$,# (&&.

#$#"(* 7$,& " $#("$ $ 3("* %

4. $ =# %%&& 9(# 2$

# * #/$$

&&#& &.#&+$, # , 4#$# $ %&

4#$# &0 A, $ .% 0$.%$"#* & ">

5 # ( & "$%&0$#$"#*

8(2$# #+ 4 &.$&$%&

$ #

%#. $#"$ ' # 2- "

# &&$

$=# %%&&9(#+7 .#

# #0$$

##,4.$=# %%&&9(# 9(

4&% ( .

(4 &@(

&0# " $%# %%& #*

9)99(

& 4&% ( ."#( 4& "$ 9(# # # $"(&# %%&

# 0$

$)( 349(# + # "&.+$%# "(&# %%&

"#$%#$&'($)*+,-.&$)'/,$01 $'./ "#$%#$&&$(/&%)23$1 $'./