High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4283/2017allowed

Karamjit Singh v. Amandeep Singh And ANR

2023-05-24Mrs. Justice Sukhvinder Kaur16 pages

! "

#$%$&'$ ( ! "

)( *")

!"" #$%& '!!

' ! %!) ( )

), -)

+ '!!

!"" #$%&

' ! %!) ( ) *** .

/0.

1 11 23 2

4%567 +,) -( . '/(0! 1( 2# 3!

". '/(0!

1( 1( !) ( 4( ( 5. '/(0! 1( ) (6 5. '/(0!

1( 1( !) ( 4( 0 . '/(0! 1( !) ( 4(7 ), 0! 8( 888 1%9:;$52%< ) ('! ) "" ') ()! (1 )( *")

+=2'>;1;$4:

3 '$5# 1;$4:$5$:? ), -)

+ ='$5# 1;$4:32'>;1;$4:$5$:? ) :( ! !") /! )!

1( 0(( ;' '!'

) !" 1"!' :9 0" 1( ('10( (1 ;' '!' ))!' :9 ! (( 00'!

8") 2:, ". %, . ;

!!:9 ! 0" !( 1"!' :9 0" /(6

! (/)( ) (1 !0(

< (1 (( #!

0"!) 0. 1( ) (. = ! 0 (1 > ;) "9 ""(;!'

! ;) ;'!' 0( !

(1 %) ..?< ' !@( !

!) ( 4(7 ), 0! 8( 9 ( 9 ! 0( !

(, .

!) ( 4( '/!(;

! (1 (11!

0"! ;) '!0!' ( 9 ! (, (1 0( !

()/!"9 ; ;( ( ) 1( ! '! (1 ))

! ;'. 1"

;

;) !"' ( :! !

"!' ( ! !!) A B !

, 1( ! '! (1 1"

(1 ! 0" !(

"" ! '! (1 !"C( . ( 00(, (1 ,!) ),) !' :9 ! 0" (( /!

0," 00'!

((6 "0! (

) !" 1"!' :9 '/!(;

! (1 (11!

0"! )!!6

( :)("/!

) ":"9 :9 )!

)'! ! ;' D, ! !"!/ 10) ! (

. !"" <0"

;

) 1 !+" !!

;) (

1( /"" " - " (;') /"" ! E ," ( ((090"! ;

;) :!

'/!

:9 . ;

!!) ) 1 ! ;) ""( '! :(,

F. ;

!9 !0 !'

! /"" ! 8 , E ( %( E!" ('. G( ' 2;)! ((090"! :!

)( 4(FE%2??. :!

'/!

:9 ) '/!0,(;

! '!!

!"" . ) "

!. 0! 1( ;(

)'!

((090"! !"" 0" +,! ( ! )' 0("")( . 0" ) 1 ! 1!"" '(;

( ! (' "(

; ! ((090"! !"" 0" ),) !' ," "!

!/(,) ,!) (

)

' ( !) ) (1 :('9 G! ;) 6!

( 8/" G() ". %( .

1( ;

! ;) !1!!' ( F57. 8 ! ! !' '!'

!! 1(

( +,

! ;) ( !!'

, ( !!1! ")( ! ;) !

,""9 (

( F57. 8 1( 1(""(; , !!

G! ")( ( !!

G() ". %( .

;

! ! !' '!' 1( ? ( ' ;)

( !!' , ( ""9.

)

;) ,!' ( ) )"" , '! !!

2 (,

(

("0! (110") /)!'

F57. 8 ' (: !'

) )

,!) ( :" 6 !). :, "! (

! 0! ( 6 (; ( 7% ' :!!

)!!' :9 ! ("0! 2 !!1!.

! "('

!' 0( " !!1! 7% 4(. '!'

. , '! !0( ) . . ' 7F8 ;) !

)!!' F("0! ( .

6, :. ) '!!

'/! (1 ! (11!

0"!

7 /!!' :9 !"" 0"

) 0" !(

) :!0(! ! "9 '):"!' ' ) 0( 1 !' ( :!' :!0(! , ! "(9!' G!

' ) !

%).

< (

) !'0" !!

!@0",'

! !

' 0 !) F( ( ! 00'!

! ;) "!

!9 ' ;) ! )("! :!' ! ! (1 ) 1"9 G! ;) ;(6

) 0 !

! ' ;) !

%)?.

< F +,! ( ! 00'!

D,!)( .

) :!0(! '):"!'

9)0""9 ) ")( ),11!!'

! 1 0" "()) %!) ( 4( '!!

'/!(;

! ) ;!"" )

778 27 5!

!" 7 ), 0! 8( 3' ;!! "!'!' ) !) ( ) ! 0" !( %!) ( 4( 0( !)!' ! !( :9 )

!" 9 (:!0( ) !

) :"9 ' "(0,) ) '

!) ;) "!'!' 0" !(

1"!' ,) ( )) ! 10, (1 '/

! (11!

0"! :9 !) ( 4( 00'!

D,!)( ;) '!

!' ' ;) "!'!' ( ),0 00'!

' 6!

"0! ;

) ((090"!. ;

!!) 1")! 7% ' :!!

)!!' ) %!) ( 4(7 ), 0! 8( 9 ")( )!' !" 9 (:!0( ) ' 1"!' ) )! ! ;!

)!!

!" 9 (:!0( 0",'

:"9 (1 ! !( !! ;) '!"9 (1 (! ( ! ( !

)( (1 7% 7 ;) "!'!' ) ;)

' , 0)! ( 00'!

' 6!

"0! ; ! (11!

0"!

( ),0 1(( ;) (/'!' :9 (;

! (1 ! (11!

0"!

%!) ( 4( ;) /

/"' ' !11!0/! '/

"0!

0! ! (1 ! ""!

!' 00'!

. ;

) 0"! 0, /("( (1 !) 0( '( ) (1 ), 0! ("09 !). 10, (1 00'!

;) '!

' ;) ")( '!

!' 0" ' ),) !' 9 ,!) ! :)) (1 ! "!'

) (1 ! !). )),!) ;!! )!"!'

E( ! !) '',0!' ! !) !0/! !/'!

0! ( ')0 ! ! ( ,) :!

! )),!) , ( ! 1! 0( )'!

! !/'!

0! /":"! ( !0(' ),:))( ) '! ( :!

"1 (1 ! !). "! !' 2:, " "9 ""(;!'

! 0" !( ' ;'!' ), (1 %) ..?< ) 0( !

(

? 0" ' !@( !!' !) ( 4(7 ), 0! 8( ( 9 ! 0( !

(, ' !) ( 4( '/!(;

! (1 (11!

0"! ;) '!0!' ( 9 ! (, (1 0( !

()/!"9 ; ;( ( ) 1( ! '! (1 ))

! ;'. 1"

;

;) !"' ( :! !

"!' ( ! !!) A B !

, 1( ! '! (1 1"

(1 ! 0" !( "" ! '! (1 !"C(

!!"

')))1!' ; ! ;' '!' . !"" 0" ) !1!!' ! !" !) ( 4( '/!(;

! ) 1"!' !" /!

!' "! !' 0(, )!" 1( ! !) /! ")( !,)!' ! !"!/ !0('

3! !' 0(, )!" 1( ! !"" 0" ) 0( !

'!' ! 00'!

D,!)(

' 6!

"0! ',! ( ) " '/

(1 !) ( 4(. '/! ' (;

! (1 (11!

G( ' 2;)! ((090"! :!

)( 4(FE%2 ?? 2 0" ' ),) !' ," "!

!/(,) ,!) (

)

' ( ! ) (1 :('9 G!

) 0( !

'!' !"" ;) 9!) (1 ! ! ! (1 00'!

' ;) !

%)?.

< F :9 '(

! ;(6 (1 0 !

! 2 !)! ,!) /!

!),"!' ( B '):"9 ' ! ,!'<0" ) :!0(!

'0 !' ' ) , :"! ( '( ! (: (1 0 !

! 7 ),:!'

( !0!' 0! /" ) !0) (1 ! !

) '!D,!"9 ))!))!' ! 0( !

;

) ":"! ( :! !

0!'

) ,!' ! !"" 0" ! !' '!' F57 1(

, ( ' ;) ( !!' , ( !/!

!!1!.

' :!!

,""9 (

( F57. 8 1( 1(""(;, !!

2 !!1!.

' ")( 6!

G() ". %( ' ! !' '!' !! 1( ? ( ;

! ;) ( !!' , ( ' 1 ""9 )

;) ,!' ( ! ) )"" , '! !!

) 0( !

'!'

!"" ) ) !

(! %).

< 1( ) !!

. :, 0(,"'

( (/! "" ! !'0" :"") ( !0('. ) !/! !

'!' ( 6!!

! )! 1( 0"

0( !

"! ( ! ), (1 %)?.

!' :9 " 1( ! !'0" !!

) ( /!9 "(;! )'! 7 ) ")( :!!

,!' "

) !( !(,)"9 6!

0(! (1 ,!' ) %)?.

< F. ;

!!) (/!' ( !0('

! ;) !

%)?.

< F 1! ),11!

! ! '):"9. ! ,!'

) :!0(! '"! ' ) , :"! ( '( 9 ;(6 ( ) !

"!' ( !0!/! 0( !

1( ! 1,,! "()) (1 0(! 2 2:, "

) !!'

( ''

B (1 (( " 0!)! 0(!

' ! (, (1 0( !

"9 '!D,! G!

) ")( 0( !

'!' "

!' !!) A B F ;

")( ( ! "(;! )'! ' ) ":"! ( :! !

0!' A B F 9!' !)!

!" 9 :! 00! !' ! ;' ))!' :9 2:, " 9 :! ('1!' 00('

"9 ! ( ! '. "! !' 0(, )!" 1( !"" <'/!0, (;

! ) 0( !

'!' ) :!!

1")!"9

"0!' ! 0 " 0)! ) 7% ;) "('

!' 1! '!"9 (1 (!

( ! ( 4( ()/! !/'!

0! ;) "!' :9 ,!'<0" !@0! )!"1 )!/

)!!

( (/! /("/!!

(1 <'/!0, (;

! ! ""!

!' 00'!

4( !9!; !)) ( ! ""!

!' 00'!

:!!

!@ !' 7 ,!'<0" ;

"! !

) FH ) '!'

) 0())!@ ( ! ''

( 6 (; <'/!0,(;

! ( ( ! 00'!

' ) ),0 '!

9 (1 <'/!0,(;

! ;) ( !):") !' G!

' ")( , !' 0" ( ')0 !' 1( () " ) ! !'0" '/)! ! !'0"

" 0! ;) ")( ! !)( 1( ,( (1

(1 ,!'<0" E!)'!) .

) ")( :!!

,!' ! !) ( < ), 0! 0( 9 0(,"'

(/! ! '/

"0!

0! (1 ;) 16! 2 " !"!'

, ( ! /!10( ! ( $@F ;

;) )(,

:9 ), 0!

0( 9 ' ;) ,) "0!' ( !0('. (,

! )! ;) ( ( !"9 (/!' ) ! "; 4( (110" 1( ! 0( 0! !' +2 110! ;) 0""!'

( (/! ! +/

30!

)! (1 ;) ( )),!' :9 ! ( ), 0! 0( 9 0

( !/'! ) ":"9. 1( ( 1," ( ! (1 G!

) 0( !

'!' (, ;'!' ) ")( (

! )'! ' 0(! (1 ! 0" ;) 6!

) %)?.

<F ;

;) ( (/!' ( !0(' G!

) 9!' ) !" :! ""(;!'

' !"" :! :)("/!' (1 ! ":"9 :9 )!

)'! ! ;' D,

2( (/! ! 10, (1 ! 00'!

. ',! ( " 0! (1 !) ( 4(. ! 0"

)!"1 )! !' (

; !)) :(@ ) FH 7

) 11'/ $@FH<. !

'!!'

!@ ( !1.

) '! ()!' '!" "" ! /!!

) '! 0" !(

2( !:, ! )!. !) ( 4( ) ")( !!' ) (;

; !)) ) %H '

) 11'/.

) '! ()!' 1")! 7% ;) !

)!!' ) 2 ! 00'!

""!

!'"9 ((6 "0! (

;

!!) ! 7% ;) !

)!!' (

1! 0( )'!:"! '!"9 E,

) 0())!@ (

) '!' ( :!

0(!0 ! ;) !)!' 1( 0,)

! 00'!

'!'

;) !"!)!' ( :" "! ( G!

) 1, ! 0!

(0""9 '!' ''

( (0 ! F. %( ( 9 ( !

! ("0! (110"

) 1")! "0( 7% 4(. '!'

. , '! !0( ) . . ' 7F8 F("0! ( . 8 6, :

) 1, ! '!' ! ;) 10

" :!1(! ! 8(, (1 -,'0"

)! 7) 8")). %(

(. ( "9 :!0,)! (1 '!"9 ! !

)( (1 7%. 0

:! !),!' !) ( 4( 1")!"9 "0!'. ;

:!!

) !010""9 '!' :9 !) ( 4( ;

"! !

) %H

( 1"!' 9 0( " :!1(!

! ("0! , (!) !

) 1")! "0( (!(/!. ) ")( ( :! 6!

(! (1. '!'"9 ! ( , '! !0( 8F8 ;) !)!

!' ! 8(, ) !) ( 4( ! ;) 10

" ! 8(, 2 (0!!'

) :!1(! " ! (1 ),9 ,! ' )0 ((1 !

(1 ! 00'!

:!9( ! !)( :"! '(,: )

!D,!' ) !D,!' ! 0 " (0!!'

) "

)

"9 (:)!/!' ! '!"9

:!!

0,)!' ) ,!' ;) !

!'0" !!

' ;) '!' F57. 8 !!1! ! !' '!' /!

() " ;0!

' ( , '! ( ! ), !9 , !(!. !

( !'

! 7% )!"1 ;

(',0!' ( !0(' ) $@F. !"! "6 1( 0( ()! ;) (

( . :, ! )! 0(,"'

( !")! ( ")(

:! ! !)( 1( ! '!"9 ! !

)( (1 7% FH + -F

) '! ()!' 0"

)( (1 E ) +) ;) '!'

() " ( ' ;) 0)!

(1 (')'! 00'!

) 0())!@ (

) ) !010""9 )!' !"! !

;) 6!

( F57. 8 1( !!

( 1( !)! 10). ) ') !):") !' 0" ' ),) !' ,!) (

)

) !)," (1 00'!

D,!)( ;

' 6!

"0! ',!

( ) " '/

(1 ! (11!

((090"! :9 !) ( 4( 7 ")( '( ( 1!!" 0" !' ( 00! ) 0( !

( (1 "! !'

0(, )!" 1( !"" <'/!0,(;

! !

(1 ! 0" ;) ,!' ) ',! ( " 0! ( ! (1 ! 0" )!"1.

1!0( '!/!"( !'

)

7 0( !

'!' :9 "! !'

0(, )!" 1( <'/!0,(;

! ! 0" )!"1 '!' /!

() " :9 "!/

F57. 8 ',! ( ;

' ),11!!' ,( 7

"9 (:)!/!' :9 " 0" ;) '/)!' ( ! )

,!' ( 00(, (1 )!/!!

1!0( ' 1 ' !1!!' /!

() " 1( ! )' ( !( .

'(!) ( ! ! ;) "

! !'0" !!

)( *")

7 ""!

!' :9 ! 0" < !"" 0(! (1 0" 6!

) %)?.

<F ) ( ! "(;! )'!. ;

!!) ,!' :9 ! 0(, )!" 1( <'/!0,(;

! ) (

! )'!

! !,)" (1 ! !/'!

0! ( !0(' !/!") ( ) !010 !/'!

(',0!' :9 ! 0" !

) (00, ( 0(! ( ! :)!

0! (1 9 !/'!

0! !

! (00, ( 0(! (1 ,!'.

"9 0( )'!!' ) '"9 ; ! :9 " (( " 0(!

"9 6!

) %)?.

< F 0)! "!' )

8/" !" 4(?? (1 )

(, (1 3F 8/" 4( (1 . '!0'!' (

. !

(1 ' ( :! ,!' 9)0" '):"9 ),11!!' :9 !"" (1 ! "!1 "(;! ": ;) ))!))!' ) B. ;

;) :(, ?B (1 ! ;

("! :('9 7 ;) !"' :9 ! G( I:"! !@ 8(, 0)!

), = ! !

0 09 (1 !"" ) ( ! '! (1 ! 00'!

) ') 0( "!!"9 !' !',0!' G!

'!!' ! "9 0 :"! (1 ;(6

) ! ( '( 9 ," ;(6 8( !

1( "()) (1 1,,! !

!!1(!

) ( :! ( ! ' ,) ( !

:"!

( "/! "1! (1 '

( 0( !

;

) !",)/! 71 ! ?B 9)0" '):"9 !

'!!' ! !"" ! "9 '):"!' 1( ,),

/(0( ( 9 )" ;(6. ) '110," ( 0( !

(1 0( !

( ( ( ! '):"9 ( ! ;

("! :('9 2 !"" ) !!1(!

!"' !

"!' ( 0( !

1( "()) (1 1,,!

:)!' (

) ?B ! 9)0" 1, 0( " '):"9 !0"0,"!' ; ! )"9 (1 %)?.?

< ; ," "! (1 II %) .

<> ) 0)! ")( !/!

1 ) 6!

( :! '"9 ; !. ! 10 )

,!'. ;"" )!/!!"9 11!0

) :"9 ( !1( 9 ," ;(6 7 ) ( :! 6!

(! (1 !"" ) ( '( ," ;(6 1( ! !) (1 ) "1!. ; (, ,)! (1

) ) :(, ' ( 11!0 ! D,"9 (1 ) ;(6 ' ")( :"9 ( 1 ' ;(6 0( )'!

) '):"9 ( "

)

"9 6!

! 1, 0( " '):"9 ) B 2 ,) !

," "()) (1 0(!

0(!) ( %).

< %)

@ ) 10 ) ( ') ,!' ;) !' :(, 9!) ! ! (1 ),)

,!) 00'!

D,!)( !!

/!; ! ! (1 ! 0" ;) 9!). ," "! (1 II

"9 "!' :9 " (. :9 "9

," "! (1 II. ),0

0( !

) ))!))!' ) %) ..

< %).

@ E!)'!) . 2:, "

!"' 0" ) ")( !

"!' 1( !'0" !@ !

)!) (1 %)?.

< E, ) 10 ( :!!

0( )'!!' :9 " ) ( ()):"! ( 6!! "" ! :"") (',0!

)! ( !0(' ( 0" ! !'0" !@ !

)!) (. 6!!

/!;. 0() (1 !'0 !) ' !!

) !

0!' ( %)

< ! !,)" (1 ! ;' 1, ! !/!") ! 0( !

, '! ( !0, 9 !') '

( :!!

'!D,!"9 !'

00(, (1 ' ),11!

( "9 %) .

< /! :!!

!' ;

( '!D,! 2 ! 0" ! !' '!' F57. 8 1(

( !!1!.

! ")( ! !' '!'

G() ". %( 1( ? ( ' ;) ( !!'

, ( ;0! ' ,"!"9 )

;) ,!'. )( ! ,) /!

, '! ( ! !

)! ' ),11!

) ),0 . ! 0( !

' ),11!

) !

0!' ( %)

< ) ! 0" ! !' '!' /(,) () ") 1 ""9 )

;) ,!'. )( (:/(,)"9 ! ,) /! ! !'

(, (1 ;(6 1( "!) !! ( ) 2 !!1(!. "()) (1 0(! 1( !!

( ) ) ))!))!' ) %)?.

< ! 10 :!

! 0" ! !' '!' /(,)

() " )

;) ,!'. )( ! ,) :!

!!' (1 !

' ! ' 1!;') ( %)?.

< !

!' ( 00(, (1 !

' 0 !) ! 0" ,) /! :!!

'/)!' :9 ! '(0() ( 6!

) !0" '! 1( ) ( ! !0(/!9. )( %) .

< !

!' 1( ) !0"

'! ,)

) ! 0" ! !' '!' /(,) () ") !!1! ")( 6!! ( /)

() ". 1( 1(""(;, !!

. )(

),0 0( '( . ;(,"'

/! :!!

()):"! 1( ! 0" ( /!" ! ,:"0 ) (. )( %)?.

< !

!' ( 00(, (1 ! ) ( 0 !) ?

! 0" "() )

' ' ( :! ,!' ( )/!

) "1!. )( %) .

< !

!' ( 1( "()) (1 !

!) 2 ,) 0( !

) ( :!

!' ( ! 0" ) !;(6!' ) , '! 3()) (1 1,,! !

) %) ..

< 3()) (1 !

!) %) .

< 2!!

' !'0 !) 0 !) %)

< 2 ) (( !) %)?.

< ?

F ' ),11!

< !0" '! ,)

!) %) .

< !

' 0 !) %)?.

< 3()) (1 0(! ',

%)?.

< 2("

%). .

G(;!/!. ! ! (1 !!)

!' :9 2:, " ) ,) ' '(!) ( 0"" 1( 9 !1!!

0! 2 ,). !"" <0" ) !" ) !"' !

"!' ( ! 0( !

(1 %). .

< "(

; !!) A B !

, 1( ! '! (1 1"

(1 ! 0" !( "" ! !"C( 00('

"9 ! !" ! ) "9 ""(;!'

"0( ). 1

9. ) "" ")( ) ' ') ()!' (1

), -)

+ ! 1(!() 0( !

( (1 !"" <'/!0,(;

! !" ) ), 0! 0( '

( :"! ( (/! ! '/

"0!

0! (1 ;) 16! 2 ! /!10( ! ( $@%. (

:)) (1 ;

! '/

"0!

!"' ( :! 16!

( :!!

( !"9 (/!' ( !0('. ) ! "; 4( (110" 1( ! 0( 0! !'

+2 110!

0""!' ( (/! ! '/

"0!

0! (1 !"" ;) ( )),!' :9 ! (110!. )( ), 0! 0( 9 0

:! :)("/!' (1 ) !) ( ):"9 ( '! 19 ),!' 7

!"'

:9 " !) ( 4(7 ), 0! 8( ' )!

! 0( 9 (1 ! '/

"0!

)! (1 !) ( 4( 1( /!10( :9 (/

"0( , '! %27 2 ! "0(

(/!' ) $@%. ()"

!0! ) $@% ' !

/!"( !0!/!' 1( +2 110!. 2, !)

4 " ' ) $@%? 2 ! 0( !

( (1 ! ), 0! 0( 9 ) !) ( 4( ! '/! (1 ! (11!

((090"! ;) '/

; 16! '/

"0!

0!. ;

) /("( (1 ! !) ' 0( '( ) (1 ), 0! ("09. )( ), 0! 0( 9 ) ( !) ( ):"! ( '! 19 ),!'

) !"!' , (

!"#$%&'(

)

%*+)'!$$ (:)!/!' ) ! '/

"0!

/!1!' (,

%27 :!

,:"0 '(0,!

. !D,!) ( 1, ! 0((:(( 1, ! !"' ) !) ( 4( ;) "9

! ((090"! ; (,

9 /"' ' !11!0/! '/

"0!

0!. )( !) ( 4( ) ":"!

( 9 0( !

' ) !) ( 4( ) 0(!' /("( (1 !) ' 0( '( ) (1 ), 0! 0( 9 :9 '/

! (11!

((090"! ; 16! '/

"0!

0! ' !) ( 4( ), 0!

0( 9 0

( :!

!"' ":"! ( 9 ! 0( !

E,. ! 0(, )!" 1( <'/!0,(;

! ) "0!'

!" 0! , ( , - .

( /

!"#$%!'*(01234 - .

(

. ?

(1 . '!0'!' (

' .4 - .

( !"!#%5'##62 ) /!

"9 0( !

'!' :9 ,) 6

'(0,!

) $@ : '(!) ( ') !

)! ; !D,!!

(1 (/

)! ' ) ),0 ! /!10( ! ( $@% 0

( :!

!"' ( :!

( !"9 (/!' ! !)!

0)!

!"' , - .

( ? (1 '!0'!' (

. =2 ! 1) ,!

)!' :9 ! "! !' 0(, )!" ) ' !@ :!' %27 (0!!'

) ;

!!:9 ! 0( 0! !' ) ( , (9 ' /!1!' ! '/

"0!

)! ;) 16! ) ! ! ! "9 !0!/!' ,), ( "0(

, '! ! %27 0 ;(,"' :! 0!1!' 0( 9 (1 ! ,:"0 '(0,!

, '! !0( (1 ! $/'!

0! 0 ,) ' ( :! 6!

"0!

;) 16! 7 ) 0(

!0( .

) !"!' , ( ! ,'

(1 ) 8(, ))!' ! ! (1 =, ) % ' ! ), ;

!! ) 8(,

!"' !) ( )! (1 %27 "0( ;(,"' :! 0(/!!' , '! !0(

(1 ! $/'!

0! 0 7 9 ( ( . !! ) ( D,!" ; ( ()( !) ( )! !"0!' , '! ! %27 0 0(,"' :! 0!1!'

0( 9 (1 ,:"0 '(0,!

1 ! '(0,!

) 0(/!!' , '! !0( (1 $/'!

0! 0 E, ! )),! ! !)!

0)! ) !)! '(0,!

) ;!!

!!"9 "0!' ( !0(' ( (" !/'!

0! ;) "!' G' :!!

0)!

;

!! ! "(9!! (1 ! !"" ' !!' ( (/! ! %27 "0( ! ! "9. 0(,"'

/! :!!

!"' ! '/

"0!

;) 16! E, ! :)!

0! (1 9 !)( ;

( !!' ( !)19 ( !11!0. ' ;) 0())!@ !'. ;(,"'

( :! ()):"! ( 0(! ( 0( 0",)( ! '(0,!

"0!' ( !0(' ;) 0,""9 ,:"0 '(0,!

7 ! 00,) 0!). ! ,!

! '/

"0!

)! ;) (/!' ( :! 16!

) ( :! !!0!'> 4(;. '/!

( ! !)!

0)!. ) 0)! ")( ;

( "9 ! /!10( ! ( (: !' (,

%27 "0!' (

!0(' :, ( (" !/'!

"!' ( (/! ! )!. )( ( ! :)) (1 ! )' /!10( ! ( 0

( :!

!"' ! '/

"0!

)! (1 !) ( 4( (/!' ( :! 16! 2 ,). 0

( :! )' !) ' 0( '( ) (1 ), 0! ("09 ;!! /("!' :9 !) ( 4( ( ! 1

(1 " ;

!!:9 ! 7 ), 0! 8( :!!

!@( !!' ) )! )'! ' ":"9 (1 :( ! !) ( ) ( 9 0( !

) "" :! ( ' )!/!" 00('

"9 ! !" !

) "9 ""(;!'

"0( ). 1

9. ) "" ")( ) ' ') ()!' (1 =1 23 2

( ! "

! ! ) !6

<!)( !'J K!)< 4( ! ! ! (:"!J K!)< 4(