High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3348/2012dismissed

Imami v. Hanif And Others

2015-10-12Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih5 pages

"#$ %$&'(')*

+ ,",' -..$//")# 0$1(2( ")'

")%#3$1( -$(.)%$)#( * 45 55

1$($)#* 1$/6%7&"#$6 1#3$"..$//")# 888 93$#3$1 1$.1#$1( /&"/ .".$1( ,": ;$ "//<$% # ($$#3$=2%>,$)#?

;$1$ $11$%##3$1$.1#$1(1)#? 93$#3$1 #3$ =2%>,$)# (32/% ;$ 1$.1#$% ') #3$ %'>$(#? 888 55 1"/ 2'#

<"(%'(,'(($%;:#3$#1'"/ &21#7'%$=2%>,$)#")%%$&1$$%"#$%@

($7$)#3$ "..$"/ .1$ $11$% ">"')(# #3$ ("'% %$&1$$ "'/$% ")% <"( %'(,'(($%7'%$=2%>,$)#%"#$%

6./"')#'

'(;$ 1$ #3'( &21# 7'%$ #3'( 1$>2/"1 ($&)% "..$"/ "1#'$( # #3$ /'(6 3$1$')"

#$16<2/%;$1$ $11$%#;:#3$'11'>')"/.('#')(') #3$(2'# ) " (2'#

6 3$ &/"',$% #3"# 3$ "/)> <'#3 %$

<$1$ &<)$1(A &(3"1$1( ') .(($((') #3$ (2'# /")% # #3$ $B#$)# C (3"1$6 .21(2")# # #3$ =2%>,$)# ")% %$&1$$

@+D#<"(,"')#"')$%#3"##3$=2%>,$)#")%%$&1$$

@+D <"( /$>"/ ")% ;')%')> ) #3$ ."1#'$( ")%

3"% (')&$ "##"')$% ')"/'#: 3$1$ 1$6 #3$ ("/$ %$$%6 %"#$%

E6 $B$&2#$% ;: (";6 "#3$1 %$ $)%")#( +6 ') "721 %$ $)%")#( E # @6 ")% "// (2;($F2$)# ("/$%$$%(6"("/(#3$$)#1'$(1$&1%$%')#3$1$7$)2$1$&1%6 <$1$<3//:)2//")%7'%(#3$.1.$1#:#3"#<"("/'$)"#$% ;:(";6 "#3$1 %$ $)%")#( +6<"(,1$#3")3'( (3"1$6#32(6#3$("'%("/$%$$%6<"(2)(2(#"')";/$ ) %$ $)&$6 &)#$(#')> %$ @ # ")% D # + ./$"%$%6 ')#$1 "/'"6 #3"# #3$: <$1$ ;)" '%$ .21&3"($1( 1 " 7"/2";/$ &)('%$1"#') )%6 #3$ ,"##$1 ') '((2$3"%(')&$"/1$"%:;$$)1$(/7$%;:"&'7'/&21#')"(2'#

")% #3$1( ">"')(# #3$ %$ $)%")#(6 <3$1$')#3$("/$%$$%%"#$%

E<"(3$/%#;$7"/'%

21#3$16 %$ $)%")#( <$1$ "/( 3$/% # ;$ #3$ ;)" '%$ .21&3"($1( 1 &)('%$1"#') <'#32# )#'&$ ) (2..1# #3$'1%$ $)&$6%$ $)%")#(1$/'$%2.)#3$=2%>,$)#")%%$&1$$ E@@D "( "/( #3$ =2%>,$)# 1$)%$1$% ;: #3$ "..$//"#$&21#)@

) " %2$ ")% #32>3# 2/ &)('%$1"#') #3$ ,"##$1')'((2$6")%#3$$7'%$)&$)1$&1%6#3$&21#(;$/< &)&211$)#/:&)&/2%$%#3"##3$1$<"()%'(.2#$"(1$>"1%( #3$/$>"/'#: #3$%$&1$$%"#$%

@+D<$7$16#3$1$/'$ &/"',$% ;: #3$ ./"')#'

&2/% )# ;$ "<"1%$% <'#32# $B",')')>#3$7"/'%'#: #3$("/$%$$%(')F2$(#')3$ '1(# ("/$ %$$% ') .')# #',$ <"( $B$&2#$% ;: (";6 "#3$1

%$ $)%")#( +6 )

E6 ') "721 %$ $)%")#(E#@3$#3$1("/$%$$%($B&$.#("/$%$$%

@6.$1#"')$%##3$(",$/")%#3"#<"((/%7'%$("/$ %$$% %"#$%

E ) ")"/:('( #3$ =2%>,$)# ")% %$&1$$ %"#$% E@@D 1$7$"/$% #3"# #3$ ("/$ %$$% %"#$%

E")%"//(2;($F2$)#"/'$)"#')(<$1$F2$(#')$%;: #3$./"')#'

') #3$("'%(2'#6"(#3$:<$1$"//$>$%#;$)2//6 7'%")%))$(#<$7$16#3$("'%(2'#6

6 <"( %'(,'(($% )% ( <"( #3$ "#$ #3$ "..$"/6 .1$ $11$% ">"')(##3$("'%%$&1$$ 21#3$16')#3$("'%.1&$$%')>(6#3$ "..$//"#$ &21# ;($17$% #3"# #3$ 7$)%$$( &2/% )# ;$ .1$(2,$% # 3"7$ "): G)</$%>$ F2" #3$ %$&1$$ %"#$%

@+D6 "( #3"# <"(6 &)&$%$%/:6 )# 1$ /$&#$% ') #3$ 1$&1% 1'>3#( #'// #3$ ("/$ %$$%( <$1$ $B$&2#$% ) #3$1 <1%(6#3$1$7$)2$1$&1%&)#')2$%#1$ /$&#%$ $)%")#D # ;$ #3$ <)$1 A1% (3"1$ ') #3$ (2'# /")% 3$1$ 1$6 #3$1$ &2/% 3"1%/: ;$ "): .1$(2,.#') G)</$%>$ ) #3$ ."1# #3$%$ $)%")#("(1$>"1%(#3$%$&1$$%"#$%

@+D $$%/$(( # "(($1#6 #3$ ("'% %$&1$$ <"( )/: " =2%>,$)# ') .$1()", ")% #32( %$ # &2/% )# ;$ .1$(2,$% # 3"7$ "): )#'&$ #3$1$ 32(6 &2/% )# ;$ %$.1'7$% #3$7"/2";/$1'>3#(#3$:3"%"&F2'1$%.21(2")## #3$ ("/$ %$$%( $B$&2#$% ') #3$'1 "721 )&$%$%/:6 #3$ =2%>,$)# ")% %$&1$$ %"#$% E@@D 3"% (')&$ "##"')$%

')"/'#: ( #3$ &)#$(#')> %$ $)%")#( <$1$ 2)% # ;$ ')

.(($((') #3$ (2'# /")%6 $7$1 (')&$ #3$: "&F2'1$% #'#/$ #3$1$')6#3$(2'#

<"(3$/%#;$%$7'% "):&"2($ "&#')#3')><"(;12>3#)1$&1%$'#3$1# (3<#3"#./"')#'

<"($7$1').(($((') #3$(2'#.1.$1#: #'// 21#3$16#3$'((2$<3$#3$1#3$(2'#')F2$(#')<"(;"11$% ;:#',$6'#<"(1$&1%$%#3"##3$./"')#'

3"%"(("'/$%#3$("/$ %$$%($B$&2#$%%21')>#3$.$1'%<$ @ E#@@//#3$ ("/$ %$$%( <$1$ 1$>'(#$1$% ')(#12,$)#( ")% #3$ .$1'% /','#"#')#"(("'/#3$(",$<"(#31$$:$"1(3$.1$($)#(2'# <"(

) D

6"(("'/')>#3$("/$%$$%

E6 #3"# <"( $B$&2#$% '1(# ') .')# #',$ 32(6')(#'#2#') #3$.1$($)#(2'#"

#$1$B$&2#') #3$("/$ %$$% %"#$%

E6 <"( ".."1$)#/: ;"11$% ;: #',$ )( "1"(#3$'((2$H<3$#3$1#3$(2'#')3")%<"(;"11$%;: #3$.1')&'./$ 1$(=2%'&"#"6'#<"(&)&/2%$%#3"#"($7$)') ") $"1/'$1 (2'#6

6 "( 1$>"1%( #3$ (2'# .1.$1#: ">"')(# #3$ %$ $)%")#(6 #3$ ("/$ %$$%( ') F2$(#')6 <$1$"/(')%'(.2#$6#3$1$ 1$6#3$.1$($)#(2'#<"(;"11$%;: #3$.1')&'./$ 1$(=2%'&"#" 5$"1)$% &2)($/ 1 #3$ "..$//")# &2/% )# .')# 2# "( # 3< #3$ &)&/2(')( #3"# 3"% &)&211$)#/: ;$$) "11'7$%"#;:;#3#3$&21#(;$/<<$1$$'#3$1&)#1"1:##3$ .('#'))1$&1%1(2

$1$% 1,"):,"#$1'"/'//$>"/'#:3$ )/: (2;,'((') #3"# 3"( ;$$) "%7")&$% ;: #3$ /$"1)$% &2)($/H#3"##3$7"/'%'#: #3$("/$%$$%(')F2$(#')<"()#

+ %'1$&#/:")%(2;(#")#'"//:')'((2$')#3$.1$7'2((2'# '/$%;: #3$./"')#'

6$B "&'$6&"))#;$&2)#$)")&$%)&$%$%/:6') " .1$7'2( (2'#

6 3$ 3"% (.$&'

'&"//: F2$(#')$% #3$ 7"/'%'#: ")% 7$1"&'#: #3$ ("/$ %$$%( ') F2$(#')2#<3$#3$1#3$'17"/'%'#:<"($B",')$%1)#H<"( ) &)($F2$)&$ "( ;#3 #3$ &21#( &)&/2%$% #3"# ') #3$ <"G$ B./")"#') 0 # $&#') #3$ %$ '7'/

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

+ "=") 12) "//' 2%>$