High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/2168/2016dismissed

St Of Hry Thr Fc & Sectt Deptt Of Industrial Training & Vocational Edu Hry & Others v. Jagbir Singh

2018-01-19Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice B.S. Walia8 pages

! "

#$% &'(() * !+, -'&'(&./&!&&!0'1(.* 22(33&!'* 4(.*5* &67 .- !61 (*2!0(!'

.(*(!'+

*&! *1& (*1&8&. &99&./&!&

. &!:;&<<&.90=)&'(.'1(.(*2!0(!' >>>

*9 %? &!0 $ 9 1&=( 7((! 3(0 &6& !*')@@!.0(.0&'(0$0() 0 !6" *#$9#$% &!0%!'1(6.5!0'1&'* @ 3&. **5(*&)'&!03&88(.( !=3=(08(=(.9&*85307((= 0(!'.@'1(*5))((0 !62&.&6.&21* '1 *:506@(!'9'1(2* ' ! *'1(.8 *(1(.(.(8(2.2*('0(&38 '1 '1( &)'* (&)1 )&*( * &))@2&! (0 8 '1 &! &223 )&' !*((< !6)!0!&' !$?0&/*0(3&/ ! 3 !6&!0$0&/* 0(3&/ ! .( 33 !6 %? * &))@2&! (0 8 '1 &! &223 )&' !*((< !6)!0!&' !,0&/*0(3&/ ! 3 !6&!0?0&/* 0(3&/ !.( 33 !6'1( 81 3( $ *&))@2&! (0 8 '1 &! &223 )&' ! *((< !6 )!0!&' ! 0&/* 0(3&/ ! 3 !6 '1(

-: 2 :-

*#$%9#$%% % 8(.( 0 *2*(0 7/ 130 !6 '1( .(*2()' =( .(*2!0(!'A8. ' 2(' ' !(. (!' '3(0 . &0:5*'@(!' ! '1( 2*' @25'(. !*'.5)'.9 )( -().('&./*1 2!*'.5)'. !0 &!0 )(-().('&./*1 2!*'.5)'. !0

-- !'(.@*.0(.0&'(0?92&**(07/!B73('1(-52.(@( 5.' ! - ,?C? ,9 - ?,C%$ ,9 - #%&!0,%,&3!68 '1&33)!*(D5(!' &37(!( '*&*1&0 7((! &338(0 ' '1(. * @ 3&.3/ * '5&'(0 (@23/((* &0:5*'(0 &* 2(. '1( .0(.*!B73('1(-52.(@(5.' ?

! " !#$!%!&#'('!)*+# +%), -. ! " !#$!%!!%/!% ,"#('+0*!) +%),!%/ 1 ! " !#$!%! !%/!% ,"#(' !%/""2345!# @256!(0.0(.1&*7((!)1&33(!6(0 !'(.&3 &!'1(6.5!0 '1&''1(&)'*1&07((!'&<(!!3/.@"

#$%81(.(&* &)'*"

*#$9#$%&!0%%8(.(''&33/ 0 (.(!'9'1&'*(.= )(*'1(.(*2!0(!'A8. '2(' ' !(. !" *#$% &!0 % 1&0 7((! '(.@ !&'(0 ! &))5!' 7( !6 *5.235* ! &)).0&!)( 8 '1 .0(.* 0&'(0 % ! " $,A#9 81 3( *(.= )(8. '2(' ' !(. !"

#$1&07((!0 *2(!*(08 '1! %05('!!C*&' *&)'./8.<&!02(..@&!)(9!'(@2'5.' = 0( '*.0(.0&'(0 ! ??$1&02. @&&) ( 5!0'1&''1('(.@ !&' !.(*2!0(!'C&67 .- !618&* !'(.@*.0(. 0&'(0 % ! "

$, # &!0 81 3( &7*3= !6 '1( .(*2!0(!'* '1(.( ! .@ )!'(@2' 2.)((0 !6* 1&0 1(30 '1&' '1(

-: 3 :-

.(*2!0(!'A8. ' 2(' ' !(. )530 !' 7( 0(2. =(0 3 7(.'/ ' )@2('( &.(*1 &* &!0 81(! 2*'* 8(.( &0=(.' *(09 !&@( '1( .(*2!0(!'A8. ' 2(' ' !(.*0 0!' 65.(&@!6*''1(3 *')!'.&)'5&3*'&53 33 !6'1( .(D5 * '(D5&3 )&' !*&* 2(. .53(* &!0&*2(.*'&!07(.( '1( -52.(@( 5.' =(.!@(!' 8&* &6.((0 ' &))@@0&'( !3/ (3 6 73( (@23/((* 818(.( !*(.= )(9'1&''1(8. '2(' ' !1&07((!&338(07/.(3/ !6 52! 0)5@(!'* 3(0 8 '1 ?C"

C$ 75' ! .0(.* 1&0 7((!2&**(0 !.(*2()'*& 0 9'1(.(7/0(2. = !6'1(&22(33&!'.@ )!'.=(.' !6 '1( &)'* *'&'(0 '1(.( ! ! '1( 3 61' *57@ ** !* @&0(9 )5!*(3.'1(&22(33&!'2.&/*.*('' !6&* 0('1( @256!(0.0(.&!0 .0 *@ **&3'1(8. '2(' ' ! % "(1&=()!* 0(.(0'1(*57@ ** !*3(&.!(0)5!*(3.'1( 2&.' (*&!0&.('1(= (8'1&'.'1(.(&*!*.().0(01(.(5!0(.9 *7(.('@(. '&!0 *3 &73('7(0 *@ **(081 3( %?&!0 $&.(3 &73('7(&338(0 $ 1(2(' ' !(.B* !"

#$9#$%&!0% .(*2()' =(3/8(.(&22 !'(0&*@25'(.!*'.5)'.9 )(-().('&./*1 29 !*'.5)'. !0 &!0 )( -().('&./*1 2 !*'.5)'. !0 -- ! )!'.&)'7&* * !=(@7(."

$%#9"

$%% #&3!68 '1'1(.)!!()'(08. '2(' ' !* !)350 !6" $, #9 ' '3(0 &* E*1< ;5@&. &!0 '1(.* =* -'&'( &./&!& &!0 '1(.*B8(.( 3(0 !'(.&3 &7/.(*2!0(!'&67 .- !61&!0 37&6- !61 &!0'1(*&@(8(.(0 *2*(07/& = * !(!)1'1 *5.'= 0(.0(. 0&'(0 % 7/ &338 !6 '1( &.(@(!' !(0 '8 .(*2!0(!'* &!0 '1(.* @ 3&.3/* '5&'(0)!'.&)'5&3(@23/((A2(' ' !(.*'1(.( !')!' !5(

-: 4 :-

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

$% # &!0 )!!()'(0 "

$,81(.( !81 3('&< !6!'(9 !'(.&3 &.(*2!0(!' &67 . - !61 7( !6 D5&3 (0 &!0 1 * 1&= !6 7((! &22 !'(0 ! =(@7(.9 # 7/ & 053/ )!*' '5'(0 *(3()' ! )@@ ''((9 '1( 8. '

-: 5 :-

2(' ' !* 8(.( 0 *2*(0 7/ 2(.@ '' !6 '1( 8. ' 2(' ' !(.* '1(.( !

!)350 !6.(*2!0(!'&67 .- !61')!' !5( !*(.= )(' 33'1(: ! !6 )&!0 0&'(**(3()'(0!.(653&.7&* * (&.!(0 )5!*(3 5.'1(. )!'(!0(0 '1&' *(.= )(* '1( 8. ' 2(' ' !(. (&67 .- !618(.('(.@ !&'(0!%!&))5!' 5!*&' *&)'./8.<75'*& 0.0(.'(.@ !&' !8&**('&* 0(= 0(.0(. 0&'(0 % ! "

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

%%B 81(.( ! '1( 3(&.!(0 * !63( :506( 1(30 '1&' '1( *'&!0 '1( -'&'( &./&!& '1&' !3/ (3 6 73( 2(.*!* ! *(.= )( 8(.( ' 7( @&0( .(653&.8&*!'7.!(5'.@'1(.().0)).0 !63/9 '8&*1(30'1&' !!)!* 0(.&' !'1()3& @'1(2(' ' !(.'1(.( !.&0:5*'@(!' ! '(.@*& 0&= '0&'(0?# 3(0!7(1&3'1(-'&'(&./&!& 7(.(!B73('1(-52.(@(5.'!3/!'1(6.5!0'1&'*(.= )(**5)1 .(*2!0(!'* 7(.( '1( -52.(@( 5.' 1&0 7((! '(.@ !&'(0 &'(. '1( 0 *2*&3 '1( 8. ' 2(' ' ! 2.((..(0 7/ *5)1 (@23/(( 8&* !

-: 6 :-

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

= 0( .0(. 0&'(0 %!'1(6.5!0'1(*&@(7( !6 != 3&' !'1(2. !) 23(* !&'5.&3 5*' )(9 ! '1( '1(. 1&!09 !( '1(. .(*2!0(!' 37&6 - !61 !.

-: 7 :-

.(*2!0(!' -&!0((2 ;5@&. )1&33(!6(0 '1( . .0(. '(.@ !&' ! 0&'(0 #, (*2!0(!'&67 .- !61)!' !5(0@&< !6(.'*.7( !6 '&<(! 7&)< ! *(.= )( ! '(.@* .0(.* 0&'(0 % ! " A '1561 1( 8&* !' *5))(**53 ' * ! '1( &.(@(!' !(0 ) .)5@*'&!)(*'1&'.(*2!0(!'&67 .- !61 !=<(0'1(:5. *0 )' !'1(

8. ')5.'7/8&/"

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

'1&' @&''(.'1( '1(..(*2!0(!'*7(.(!B73('1( -52.(@(5.'( '1(.1&0'1(/25' !%G$/(&.**(.= )(&*8&*'&<(! !'(7/!B73('1(-52.(@(5.'.0 .()' !6'1(&0:5*'@(!'*5)1 (@23/((* !. 0 0 '1(/ )1&33(!6( '1( . .0(. '(.@ !&' ! 0&'(0 #,&!

#$%%&!0"

%!*'565*'%&!0$'1-(2'(@7(.%.(*2()' =(3/*((< !6 &0:5*'@(!' !'(.@*.0(.*!B73(-52.(@(5.'0&'(0? 8 '15')1&33(!6 !6.0(.'(.@ !&' !0&'(0#,!'1(3 61'

-: 8 :-

'1(2* ' !&*!'(0&7=(9 *0 *@ **(081 3( %? &!0 $ &.( &338(0 @256!(0 :506@(!' !"

*#$%%&!0"

%&.(*(' &* 0( &!0 '1( &.(*& 0 8. ' 2(' ' !* &.( 0 *@ **(0 8(=(.9 . '1( .(&*!*&*&.(@(!' !(0 !'1(&223 )&' !*90(3&/ ! 3 !6&!0.( 33 !6 ! (&)1'1( B* *)!0!(0

-" &!5&./,9 .&:(*1<<15.&!& "1('1(.*2(&< !6A.(&*!(0 +(*A "1('1(..(2.'&73( +(*A