High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/929/2015dismissed

Sharad Kumar v. Pandit Bhagwat Dayal Sharma University Of Health Science & ORS

2015-06-29Mr. Justice S.S. Saron,Mr. Justice Satpal4 pages

!" #"$%&%'( )

*+ , #-./ , 00"11 '!

2",&.& '#%! + 34 ! 5 1*+ ,/ 6'%7",&%!5 " 1!+*$%"'$"6+! 8 '# !+",& "&0'#"'!&

,"&"'!( ,.8.15 16#7$ !"

,!+" 00"11 '! ! +" 0,"&"'! 1"!!",& 0 !"'! 00" 1 + & :""' %1"# 4%!+.!

0,#.$%'3$05 !+"%/0.3'"#,#"," ,'"#$.'&"1 ,!+" 00"11 '!

0%'!&.!!+ ! *, ;,# 5" ,"< /%' !%'%&!$//"'$" ,/ ;

)

'#6!+","

,"6%'!","&! !+" 00"11 '! 4.1# :"&",%.&15 0,"=.#%$"#6% +"%&'!0",/%!!"#! 00" ,%'!+"+%,#, "&&%' 15" , "< /%' !%'4%!+.!0,#.$%'3!+"$05 !+",#",%/0.3'"#%' 00" 1 !",+" ,%'3 ,3./"'!& ,&/"!%/"64" %'#!+ !'$ &" , %'!", ","'$"%&/ #"%'!+"0,"&"'! 00" 1

*, &!5" ,"< /%' !%'$'&%&!& &%<&.:="$!&+"

00"11 '!$.1#'!>. 1% 5&.:="$! ?

;%"!+"&.:="$! # ,!+2%35 '%'

&%< !!"/0!&&0",,"3.1 !%'@%%%6 $ '#%# !"4+ %1&%''",/,"

&.:="$!&%& 114"#!8""0!",/%'*"$'#, "&&%' 1$.,&":.! 114"# !! 8"*"$'#, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%''15% +"0 &&"& 11!+"&.:="$!

%,&!, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'+","3.1 !%' .,!+",$'!"/01 !"&!+ ! &!.#"'!&+ 11:" 114"# !$1" , 11!+"&.:="$!& %,&!, "&&%' 1 "< /%' !%'%'&%<$'&"$.!%7" !!"/0!&%'$1.#%'3!+" %,&! !!"/0!6 %1%'3 4+%$+ $ '#%# !" &+ 11 + 7" ! 00" , %' 11 !+" &.:="$!& %,&!

, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'+","1"7 '!,"3.1 !%'," #& &.'#",(? $ '#%# !"4+ %1&%''",/,"&.:="$!& %,&!

, "&&%' 1 "< /%' !%' / 5 :" 114"# ! 8""0 !",/ %' *"$'#, "&&%' 1$.,&"'15!+&"&!.#"'!&4+0 &&%' 11&.:="$!& &!0, *"< /%' !%'&+ 11:" 114"#! ! 8"*"$'#, "&&%' 1< /%' !%' +"&!.#"'!&+ 11:" 114"#!$1" , 11!+"&.:="$!&

%,&! , "&&%' 1 * "< /%' !%' %' &%< $'&"$.!%7"

!!"/0!&%'$1.#%'3!+" %,&! !!"/0!%'4+%$+!+"54",""1%3%:1"

! 00" ,6 %1%'34+%$+!+"5&+ 11+ 7"! 00" ,%' 11!+" &.:="$!& !+"%,&!, "&&%' 1 *< /%' !%'&B *.$+,"3.1 !%'4 & /"'#"#' C

7%#"%!"/

%'!+"/""!%'3 $ #"/%$.'$%1*.$+,"&1.!%'," #& &.'#",(? ! 4 & ,"&17"# !+ ! % !+" 0,"&$,%:"# ',/& !+"

$'$",'"#,"3.1 !,5:#5D$.'$%1 ,"'!,"&!,%$!%7"6!+"& /" 0,$"#.," 4%11 :" 001%"# %' 11 !+" $.,&"& ,.' :5 !+" '%7",&%!5 ,"3 ,#%'3 './:", !!"/0!& '# 1%/%! !%'

0",%#& !+" $.,&" '# &.:="$!& 1," #5 0 &&"# :5 !+" $ '#%# !"4+","+"D&+"4%11'!:",">.%,"#! 00" , 3 %'B ,3./"'! 1" ,'"#$.'&"1 ,!+" 00"11 '!%&!+ !$'#%!%'

&%< !!"/0!&6 &/"'!%'"#%',"3.1 !%'@%%%6&! '#&&.0",&"#"#:5!+" ,"&1.!%'# !"# C

'#!+ !!+" 00"11 '!'""#'! 00" ,%' 11!+"

;

&.:="$!& %,&! , "&&%' 1 "< /%' !%' 3 %' '&">."'!156 +" %& "'!%!1"#! 00" ,%'!+"*"$'#D+%,#, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'E"#'!

%'# '5/",%!%'!+" ,3./"'!, %&"# "&1.!%'# !"# C

%&%'!40 ,!&%,&!156!3%7"

0,"

","'$"!!+"',/& !+"$'$",'"#,"3.1 !,5:#5+","3.1 !,5 :#5%'!+"$ &" $+"1, 5.,7"#%$"#%$%'" '#*$%"'$"&6%&"'!, 1 .'$%1 '#% '"#%$%'"$'&!%!.!"#.'#",!+"'#% '"#%$ 1.'$%1 $!6 F +" 00"11 '! + & '! 0,#.$"# !+" ',/& $'#.$!

"< /%' !%':5!+".'$%16!+","3.1 !,5:#5 &&./%'3!+"& /"%&'!,"&!,%$!%7"%'!+"/ !!", './:",

!!"/0!& 7 %1 :1"! $ '#%# !"!>. 1% 5 0, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'!+"'

!+"&"$'#0 ,! !+","3.1 !%'4.1#:" 001%$ :1"4+%$+&! !"&!+ !& /" 0,$"#.,"&+ 11:" 001%"#%' 11!+"$.,&"&,.':5!+"'%7",&%!5,"3 ,#%'3 './:", !!"/0!& '#1%/%! !%' 0",%#& !+"$.,&" 1," #50 &&"#:5 !+"$ '#%# !"&!/" '&!+ !0 ,%!54.1#:"/ %'! %'"#%'&%/%1 ,$.,&"& %',"&0"$! './:", !!"/0!& 7 %1 :1"! $ '#%# !" *$.,&"& !$.1#'!:"0%'!"#.!!+ !%' '5!+",, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'&+ 7"

0 ,%!54%!+ *$.,&"64+","!+"'./:", !!"/0!& ,".'?,"&!,%$!"# ' !+" :&"'$" .',"&!,%$!"# !!"/0!& %' '5 !+", 0, "&&%' 1 "< /%' !%' &%/%1 ,' !.,"6!+" 00"11 '!$.1#'!&""8.'?,"&!,%$!"# !!"/0!& ! >. 1% 5 %,&! , "&&%' 1 "< /%' !%' * $.,&" +","

,"6,"&1.!%'# !"# C

#"&'!0,7%#" '5 &&%&! '$"! !+" ,3./"'!&, %&"#:51" ,'"#$.'&"1 ,!+" 00"11 '! E" %'# !+ ! .',"&!,%$!"# !!"/0!& ! $1" , 0, "&&%' 1 "< /%' !%'4.1#:"'!$'#.$%7" ,/ %'! %'%'3&! '# ,#& /"#%$ 1

"#.$ !%' &4"11+.&64"#'! %'#!+ !!+" 00"11 '!%&"'!%!1"#! 00" ,%'!+"'"<!, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'4%!+.!>. 1% 5%'3!+"%,&!

, "&&%' 1"< /%' !%'%'&%< !!"/0!&'7%"4!+"," 64"#'! %'# '5/",%! %' !+"0,"&"'! 1"!!",&0 !"'! 00" 1+"," ,"6!+"& /"%& #%&/%&&"# "#$%& '(&$ ')*"

+,$ +--

.'" 6

')*"

,!&