Govind Lal v. Sher Singh And Others
! "# $$## %&' (& )( (& $
*&
&%+,(#-&!.( &( / -! *&0 +1 #-! &1(!*&$ )(-! &&(/ -!
&&$ 2 - 2 3 2
5( $$## ( )'#& $$# ) (6')7 $80(#& 9&$$##:'& 5($#
#' #7 ( (0 & .
& $ ( ' $&$&0 ( (! &)(-#& & (75('
$# :77-;#.7$# 5( - ( (& ( - #7 ( ( ' $&$&08 )' &77 $'&$ ( ($#
(!
&)(5( ($#((&$) 8 ' &($'&$ $#0 )<< 8'& )< < "& &#:'&7('.(&#& 9& $$## :'& & $$& ) ( ! !#8# ( # &(' #80($#
"& 9&$$##:'&.(# .& )#6')7 ($$&(! !#8# (
# #' )(&! '&& (! '
(($#
.(& #($&7 $&0 & 5(:'&((&(#& &(&$! $&# )( .((&8# ) (&')((6')7 $80(:'&8#. (&& (:'&8#. "& # & ( $$## ( '87 ( ( 6'& (:!#:'&.8&&(#
;( '87 ( ( *'
68 %##) :77 " )'# -
(& &8& &&<(
< $$#8#( ;&0 -8&(6'& (:!#:'& 5(#& 9&$$##:'&()& (&# ($#
80 ($&0&75(:'&( &7 0' ( =' #&.
&($
; -(:'&'# )& 0#& 5(7$#&' .
7 8#(8(
.('# #0 #'
&#& 5($&!'' #807
(8
# -(& &-('#8#877$#&'
&$ . 7 8#($#
& $&!8
((&( -#& &(&$ ( '87 ( ( #& 9& $$## :'& ( $$& ( ! &&7
& ( &!&(6')7 (#& &#:'& 9& &)'7 ( #& # & ( $$## #(')( &8#'(-#+&!-(.!&- # #&' 0 ( $& - ( $&$&0 ' '&8 & 5( '
$#:77-;#$&0 (5($&!
(
.'#(! $$# '&8 &)!& 80 (;&0 '
$#- 3 5( & #0$$#8#
(#
' (!##) (& ## .( (6'& ('
$#:77-(
.'# (! $$# "& (& &&.(
(:'&($&! (;&0 '
$#- 3 ;( '87(((7## # (;&0 '
$# - 3 - (& &- '( # .'# ! .( ( '
$# :77$&
(;&0 '
$#>708
( ( &! ' && $&' # $&! ( ( .
&($#'7 -($#
&(&$&&&&& .
&5(&! '&& &7(0& 3?2?
(8 $&'
#5(678 $&!( ,('## (&&&&( .
& ($&$&0.(((.
8 (.
&
? (678 &(0& 32 23- .+(& '78&(8
) ( # ,('## & && .
& > ( '#! #'7 - (.
&-(.!&-='#0
(# @! (678 &(0&
@A*-($& $#
(&$&&(!8 (.
8 (&.
& '#! #'7 -&&8
(.
&7#&($ (678 &(0& -
3 3 > (678 &(0& 3 -($&$&0 &8 $)@! (678 &(0&
-($#
&&&.
&> ('#! #'7 - (.!&-($)( .8 &&$#0)&'
># $&! #((.
&(7&))(# &(# 9&777-(.
&($ (# (8 & && &7 $&&
($#
5( $$## (
$&' && 0&&$&!(( # . !& &&! &(77 $'&$'($# .(( .#0 )-8 )' & .0 &$#0 )<<& &8'& < <.'# 7+(#
A &)'7 ( #& # ( ( 9& $$##:'&(&& )& )(&# ($#
80 ( $&0&75(' #80($#
$$## (8 & 5($#
&$ ($#((0&.
&
(# 5(:'&( #0&&( ; -(&# )& 80 ($# )5($& . 7$#&' &
2 $&7 5($& (' .' & # &$$& (! -(9&$$##:'&( && )(($#
.(&.
& A&)'7 (#& #((7$#& ' 7 8#5(:'&(#&0
'
(('. 7$#&' ( $#
($#((0&.
& !
8 0 '- 8( ( $& # (& ! 9& $$## :'& & $$& ) ( ! (! '
( ( $#
&.
& (# A&)'7 (#& #(($&!''
#(8 # -(& &-('#8#87 '
&&& '# '8'#6&& '# :*:$&!.( ('#8( $&'#&8 ( $# "& #$ ' 0$&!
(: :!#*&'&.(($&!( #'&#( $&'#&$&!'
&&& '# 6:*:-('#8#8 7>708) ('8'#6. ( *'
68- ;&0 :( )&( ! 7 7
2 "&)'7 (#& #((7$#& ' . 7 8#($#
& 5(:'&(#&0 '
(($#
&.
& > 0-(# ! $
! $ -$ #.0 ##.(# !. ( &' -(& )&'
& &.(( ) &&!80(9&$$##:'& )'#& $$#7 ## ( $ ) 7## ' $$# - 0- & $ - !. (8!6')7
!
"
#$%&$%'()%*+,-./'%*(0-%12 %(/0 #$%&$%''%)0'&*34%2 %(/0