← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/958/2015dismissed

Institute Of Hotel Management v. Presiding Officer & ANR

2015-07-06Mr. Justice Surinder Singh Grewal,Mrs Justice Daya Chaudhary4 pages



     

 !"#"$%&'  $#  )* +,$ -

/ 00)) 1.#(#

.#" "$+ "!.- $ (# ) ."/($ )2!(,2 /(. (.

-

/

$ 44 #0$ $  *%2  5*  6666   7*  6 * 

.#$ %*. (.

86"$+3 - 8!

. 

* - 3 $#  )* +,$ -

/ 9:$# 7 ;.#3.

</"$+($#(!!##()/. .$ 6"$+)( +-3 ## ")  =( +,$

 >> .$ . "$?

 @

 

#0$ $   2 A.B, $ A 00"$ # ?

!3, $C 3AB"

./D (."$+3"##.8"!-3A ##.8 A"

!3 .+ #3  $ '  9$$E(. < ($ . () '  3  .D  "8") 6.8"!# 9 ($"#3,$ $  00 )< ()#- ' $ A !($ #- " 9"< 3 A /"

)  ., "$"$+ /#$  ., ( "# A"

3( $D 0.". "$.,

"$C 0.,"##"$A #"##( )

.@

 & 8" A3"!33A

#B  E0) "$3"#0#"

"$A"

3"$@3(.#., 3.!"0 

.

A3D3#3() $ / "#,"## .,3"##.8"!-A3"!33 ")  .0)D 9""<3.0.

 . ( D

@ ,- 3# "0()

", 

$"+3 $' $ -(.

3.3" ) A"

",#) /D8.A."

 $"+3 8.."+"$ )$ .D@ ,

 3.0)D9$$E(. 2<") /D $$' A ($  "##

"# !

.D/D $#F($ )D-63."

=G(, . ., - 8!

A 00"$ $$F(".D "!. !$ (!

3 ,# "! $F(".D .#0$ $ 2A.B, $ .!$ (!

!,0.3$#"8 $F(".D-

 &  9$$E(. 2><A ##(/,"

 0.8"$+/

3 !3 .+# $   #3A !

(# $ "!

  

 9$$E(. 2@< A # #.8  (0$ 3", ,$ "$"$+

."$!"0 ) 

A #0.8"#"$ ))D 30"$"$

0$ ) D.,8 )., #.8"! #3()  / ",0#  (0$ 3", $ 00. ($"

D A # +"8$ .#0$ $ 2A.B, $ ") .0.#$

"$-" $D-A"

3"$" $ D#

3.!"0  3!,,($"!

"$3.#0$ $ 2A.B, $-3A8.- ") $.0)D 3#3A!

(#$ "!9$$E(. 2@<3 ."$!"0 )

 2 $#  . !$#" .

"$  3 ,

. A #  3 0"$"$

$ #=(# "!A() /, " 30.0# 0($"#3,$ .,8 ).,#.8"! # !$".,    # . .  !!. "$+)D 8"  . .

  &  9$$E(. 2< 3 # "  . .  .,8 ) ., #.8"!  .#0$ $   A !3 ))$+ /D3",/. 3$ (# )."/($ )2!(,2 2-

/ 9: 7;.#3.

<9.#0$ $  < $ 00.!"

"$8" $!/D

##  $ . 

  

9$$E(. 2&<"$  8(. $3) 3) 

3 ,# "!$F(".D !$ (!

 /D ;$# A  ". $ 0.0.3. .

.,"$

"$A #3)  /"))+ )3..$!A $#A. "$ 8(. A.B, $ 3A.B, #3)  / )  /."$#

 "$#.8"! )$+A"

3H/ +#.,

 , $ $ "! 3# "  . 

  

9$$E(. 2&<A #!3 ))$+ /D

/. 3"#(.

/DA D?

 @

3

 ) .$ 6"$+)( +8" ",0(+$ . .

 >>  "#0#  3# "  A."

 0 "$ A"

3 , ""!

"$  . 

   

   /#.8 

#"$! $3 /!,0 .

)D "!-"

A() $ / . .."$#

,$ -/#" #-B0"$+"$8"A$"$D .##.8"!.$ . /D3",

.

"$+ 3", "$ #.8"! A"

3 H / !B A +# $  !,0$#

"$- "

,  00.0."

+.

3", !$#)"

,($ 3E 'H  3/ +#/D .

"$+3", /"$!$ "$((##.8"!3 .  ) A #, ""  .# " E 3A."

"$ # "#,"##  A 3 #!3 ))$+  3=( +,$

>> 0 ## /D .$ 6"$+)( + .$  !($#) .  2 $#  #(/,"

) .$  6"$+) ( + "  $ 00.

"# 3 8" $! "$  !..!

 0.#0!

"8- "$ #,(!3 3$F(".DA #!$ (!

 # ."!

)D"$!$#$ $!A"

30.8"#"$# ) A .$ !($#)(.

3.#(/,"

)) 3!3 .+#A. ()D0.8 

$  $#

  !!0 3 !) ",  3 $#  - ) .$ 6"$+)( +3 #A.$+)D $ "))+ ))D "#,"## "

#A."

"$ ? 3 8 +"8$ (. 3(+3 () !$#" .

"$ 3 !$ "$# .

"# /D .$ !($#).  3 ) .$  6"$+) ( +-  . 0.(#"$+ 3 "#,"## ) . .- /#.8 

I"

"#8" $

"

A 0.8 

3.A #" )"$+

$!.+"# .- 3(+3"

A #,$ "$ 

$3  . D

 @ ,- 3..- !3 .+  3  $  /$ 0.8   3 , +,$  3 )#  ")   0.8 !3 .+  # "

 "  $  E ,"$ $D  3.!2A.B. 3$# -.

3#0!""!!

#

3 A # A.B"$+ & 3(.# ")D $  A # , $ "$+ 00.0."

+#  3 /#.8 

!3 .+" )"$+A ) A"

3/D 3$F(".D "!.8$ 3$F(".D "!. " $

B"$ !$#" .

"$ 3"$ "$+#

 0.8"(#!3 .+#3 -A3./D #E$.

$ -3$!- $F(".DA !$ (!

 "$  "., $$.J 3) )#$ "! 

3!3 .+#3 #.8  (0$ $ A # 8 +( ,/"+((#

  /#$! "# !$#0"!((#)D /#$  3 /8 "$ "$+#  ) .$   /(. (.

$  ) .$  6"$+) ( + ./ # $ !

#,

)A3

#8.3 #/$#3A$  "#) +

3"$ "$+#.

!3 

/D .$ 6"$+)( + E!0 ..0

3!$ "$#

3 8 ).

D/$!$#" .  $ A"

A3"!3A"$ $/ #"#  ".? )#$ "! 

.$ 6"$+)( +- !$#" . 

.

)D "!0

"$ -/#.8 

"

A() $ /"$ 3"

$## 3"$+# ."$#

3","$#.8"!A8.-B0"$+"$8"A 3"# !$ "$((# #.8"!  $"$ D .#- "

# . . 

 3 / +.

!$#)"

,($ !,0$#

"$ 3E 'H 3/ +#- A3"!3 #$ "$ $D, $$.#, / "#0.0.

"$

.$ 33"+3.#"  $ 8"A  .# "  "#!(##"$- A "$  $ ,."

 "$ !$ "$#.

"# /D) .$ !($#).  !!. "$+)D- 3 0.#$ ) /"$+ 8"   $D ,."

 "# "#,"##  * <   ()D&-  9666 < G C ,"

   %?3 /...  3.0.

.%#C