Rajat Agarwal v. Sonal Agarwal























1



   
 !

"


#   $% &&


'
()*
)'+)
#,-(

,./
0
)-1
(


#)0'+-)


0

0

2


-3




 














 






















 
 











 










 
 

#-*44

5




 






















 
 











 










 
 



 





 


!"
#
 

#-24
)6/7*
-
.,8('#*
,+,8('*
+*-+*
8')


)6/7*
-
.,8('#*

8)9
9,-
"*-
8)9
9,-
"*-:
.
$
% 


 
#
&
'()()
#
*+$,

-.
'/
#
*+$0

"11
2  
#


#"
 ! 
3

" 
&
'()()
#
*+$,
 

#

1 
 /+)*+$,
 
3

1


-

1
 3


 
 
,

*)
#

 

4
"
$05+
#

6"
#
$05+7

 

 
8
#

9 
  
























2
 

"
$5)8
#

6"
#
$5)87
#


3
 




 


:# 
 3


"
#
 


1

;

 

 :

1 
%
-


-.
'/
#
*+$0
 



" 
#


3


<# :
 
#
1
"
#


"


3
-
#

 
;

 "
=

1


-
1
 "

#  

 
-
#1
 1


-
!

 
 
)(*+$0
 
3
 
-

%
'0)$
#
*+$,

*

%
# 
#




1 
1 !

 
#


 




 
3 ">

"" 
%

"


#
 


"


#
# 




?

1

# 
3

 
!

1
1
# 


 "

 
@

#



# 
1
# 

""
#

 1

1   <1 ""



 
##
1

 " 




 

%



" "





 "
#

1 

3



## 
%
1 
 "
1 
 " 
"





 



1 #
#


"  "



 " "



"

<"

 


% 


1>

 



1> 1




/

3

#



#"


"

!




1 #
 
#"
 
## 
% 



1



$,(*++8

1


#

 ">

#

1

;

 

3

$)$*++0
# 
1

#

1 

 




 



 
%























3
:


 

@
 
*$$+*+$8
 
 
(50:



(+8
@-
 
 
3

 
% :


#



"1



1
#
 3
*+$,
 


!


#

 
#
41 
#1
;1  "


" *++)
% 
#


 
 
,

*)
#

$05+
"
 

 
8
#


"
#
$5)8
3
1

-
1
#

"
#
 
#








:# 


> 
" 


# "



"


#
 

# "
1


 
#


1


-
#1 

#

 :

    

            

    

    

 

    !

 "   

# $# % ( @



#
 
"
3
1


- B1 
  #

4$

 
#
1





4*

"



"1 
 "

.B$
" #



"
#
1 
 
;

 
  
.B*
" 
#
 
#
"
" 
.B/
" 
#


 
;
"
" 

.B(




" 
#
"



@
'
8*)
#
*+$8 )
&

 


:# B1 
 1 #

4:$

 
#
1


>
 

4*
9 "



"1 

 "

.B$

.B*
-

#
C>
 























4
8
%
1


-
# 
 
3
 





#

1 
!


1 
 
/+)*+$,

!

"
#
 
 :
;

 

 
1 
9

:

# 

#


 


 
 
$5$
#

1

-
"
$50(
,
%




 1 #

"



 


31  




3


 # 


 


 

"

1

"
#
  :;

 
9

!


"  


1


-


#




 "







#





.

3 
#


"  
 

" 

"
>
"
#
 
 



# 
31  


 
3 

3

1



#

1 
 #
 




 
 "
#
 
9

31  

 


"
#
 

*$)*+$,

@



#

31  


"




"



& '() 

*+ ,#'

-,"$+.

'. */012  

.** 1314  0) & ') 86

9    ",#*$ :'

,"';<"

 =.:

#4>?;: "

 ;:*1;$,#+33  @ 7 ' @ 7  2A AA :*3$;  422 <+B 4 C

 .7  4  ' ?

 ?



 4  , 4  9      .7  4  :*3+;  422 /B (  ?   '# & A "

 ***:;422<9 '@  ' 2  #  :BB+;  422 1<< C  C

  ( 























5
'@ (  :BB<;342213$4   '@ 9       :B<; B 422 //   CD    E

')C B<"#:42;$<
0
&

 


 
"
#

 :

1 
 


31  



 
1


-
#


#


 "

 





#

3
 

!

"
#
 


 
 "



 :"



 
"
#

 

!


 




 
 1

 
"
 



 




" 


" 3

#

!


2


" 

 
 

!


3  

# 1
#
 
 "



#
 
 
@



#
 
31  

 
"

"




"




2  AC

    '

C

   @.**$:; 42 *  C   9  #   9  C   #  :4, :2; ) *<0*< BB* 

1+BB; 27  4  ?     B/:;#2#:2

;+$:

E?;&     

F ) $1 B+ 

*B/'

A4

  

4

"#B3:42;** #7

 9  (  4

 F ) 31B B+ 

1B<:

E?; 5

!

 

#
"  

 31  
#









 
" #
 


 
 "
#

"
3  
4




1
31  
#


























6
$+
%
1
2  
 "
 
#
"  
3 -

1 
 

# 


1 
 !

"
#

 1

$/

 
#

E
@


 


# 
#
 
 


 


"
#

1 



"1




#
# 


 


3 

1 



 
#
"



 -
"1 


""

 


# 
# 

!

"




#
 


# 
 
3



"

 
 
 


#
" 

$$

%


#


 


"
#

1 
"




 


@





 1 

2  


"


"

"
#

"


 
3
"11  

 1
"  




#
 "




 
#
 
 

 
?3

!


#


 


"
#

"


"





"
#
$05+




"
#
$5)8
 
 





1 
"  
@
#"





3
"



"

3


!


#"
#
 
@


3


# 1 
3

 

3
3  
 
>
# 

#

"

3


1

> 

 
#

#1

"
"
-




1






 1 

2  
#
 


"

@




 !


"


-

"



 " 
 
3">
#




!























7
#"

"

"1"

3 
1 






1
"  
$*
"


#


>

!





"


3




 
3
1

-
1


  

 
 
## !


.B4$<

%

"
 

3




 1

 
#1
 
 
 

4$





 

1


6"



  :  ;

 2  "



  7 

        2    ?

 2     

 "7 

7  $7 0"

!

00 "         4

0 

    

  C   

8

**<" 

       .

     

@  BBB00'

  7 



 

        7

/BB< 4  7

 (  0      7     "



 G 70"

    0" 

 A 4

     

00         

       0"   7 7        



     A  5 

     

 

 7 "

  

@  B/ 7  7 

@  B1 74



        

  

  500  



 4

  G7"       4

  G700"

A

   























8

 

    

00"         4

 !

       7 

"  " 

 





    

" 

  7  

'

   

7  G C   

   

" 



  *$B      7A 7 $BB H A  +BB H A       

7    7A7  4 7A  7/ C"    7"

A

     0"   

 

     0"  

   H7   

 7 

   

00 "  



7A ? "  

 4

   

 "  4

    

   G 7% $/
1

3!



 
1
3



3 
" 








!


 

 


#




  
 1 #
#1

"

"

"


#




 

# 
 











3 



#
" 
#



 



3
% "


 

"


:








#

1
3


  
 3





#
>




 

3




# 
# 
@

"1

 "



 

 

3
#
" 
%




"





 1























9


 



"1 
#
 
1  
 

 





3 

3   

>
# 

 

!

 
2


" 

 

1  





"
1 


$(



>
 


# 
#








4:*

  
 
## !


.B4*<

3>
 
.B$

.B*
9


 
 
 
":

B1  


C

  

 

3+BB1"   

  

  

 04

 .       

       7   

   

    ! 

     C 

          

 0. 

       



 

 ( 

.     

  

  

" 7      !

        

  C 

   

70(  

  

      00 " 

A

7   

7    00"



 4

    G 7"

A





> 4

  7

A   74

   

   

 ( 

00 #G   



   

   "

A

    A   7A%

$)

%
":

B1  
#

# 
#



1>


3 
"





# 

# 
# 

"1



 
# 
4*


3


# 
#




























10
>


3


 
3



 
"
 



3  

" 
3

# 


 


1  




>







 


!

#
>





"1 
3">


 
1"


#
 
#



 :


%


"" 



"

 
 

>
# 
 
 
'
"
!

 

3


3
4*
%
 
#
4:*

!


3

 ## 
@
 



1 

 


#
  
 "
#
: 
%


"
  
""

 


:# 
3  

!



#



#1





 1



 

 

 
#!


3 "


 
#!
2

"
#
 




$8
%
#1


 " 
1


"





" 


"
#


 

 

 
1 
 
 B1  


  


1  

 
1 " 3

#
!


2


" 

 
 



:

# 
 "


1
 


#


3  1 




 
#
 
 
% 

"" 



"

 

3
 
"
#


"





:# 
1  "

 

"1

 "



:
# 



"



3
#


"

 
 
 1


 :"



 
3

1

1  
3

"

"




"
1 


























11

 :"



 
 
1
 
 3

9F3


-


#  @ 7  @ 7   2A AA:*3$;422<+B

  

 =0
6%

 


1
" G



:

#



3  
#

!


 






#



"



1 
" 
"

" 




"  
#


1
3




 
1

 
1
3 "


1 

3
 #
1 
#
 "

7
$,


!




#
#"

"

"1"


#

"


" 








3 



"

3 

 
1 
 



## 
>
"
#
 


%


1
 
#

"

I




"
 
3
3 

 


"

F
 
#1

"

3
"> 
 


" 
 
"




 "

"1 
#

1 
1 ! 3



 

#







"1



 3



"


 

3



#

"1 
#
 1 



$0
 
#1

 



 #


  

 
 # 
#

"


#

 

#


#
$/

 "

 
""


#

3



1
 #

> 
3  "


 "
1


 

 
1

## 



#
 
1 


 
""






 "


1 
 
#
 
 

 
 
























12
 >
#
1 <
#

"1  

1

"
 
 "
"

  
"1#3 
%
 
3

1
 
"

 
" 

 "

 
# 


"
1 

3
3 



>
"
#
 
 

 
 
 
$5
@

!


  

""








 
#
;

 


 
1 
@



 #
 

 3


 3

"
#




 
1 
 
 

 "



 #







#

1 : 
1


 
 
 
*80*+$5
 
3
 - 




;

 

3


3
3

-:  "
#
 
-
3
 
1 


-: 
;


C "
#

-
" 
 
#
3
$+
1  



 -

 
 
# 

- 

 
 

"


9


 
 
 ""


""1 

 # 

1

*+

9!


 


#  
 " 
# 






!

 

 


 1 
#

1


-
% 


"
 
-
"

# 

#  
 " 
3

1


-
 "
 3 
#  
#
#"


2  
#

! 




*$
@
!

3!

# 

1 


 "


 3
 1  
% 




#

3 



 
"























13
**
  

 
#
!

 
 



1
3




 
"





 

1 
# 


3 
-
3
>


!

#"


"





 !


## 
#
3

# 

 1 




  "







1
 !



3 

#


3





# :


 




 
#



:# 
  
 
#
1


 

 

#
  




3 



!




:;

 


1
3 

*

(




"



1





3









3 "

 1
1















1



#  
"
!" 





"" 


*/
- 2 
 

 1 
#
 



 
 2 

3  
-.:/:*+$0
-
'*++)8:),-@@ *+*)$:-@@
#
*+$0

$+*+(:-@@
#
*+$5


" 
#

1< 
"
"

-!


 
'$,/$8(
#
*+$,
"



  
#
""  



8)9
9,-
"*-







,+,8('*
+*-+*
8')

















.,0+*














.,0+*

9
  A

D 

 I
 #

7 I