High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3541/2012dismissed

Krishna Devi And ORS. v. Yashpaul And ORS.

2019-07-26Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!"#$#"

%%&& '"( )#%(&#"

% "*(+, "

-#&."$/# "

!(&(&/.$ "#%%&&

1"&,.#"#2 !"#$3 //.# (+##-#"# 453# 6&!"# #+"(*#("&"*# )#%(& # 7"#!(2".+## 6&!"#2%&*# 1#" . #" # 6& !"# 82. #2.

!$. (#23(*#"# 6&!"#%""2

%"##%&.#"%""" # 6&!"##

9&$*+##%&

# &*& "%"$: # # 6& !"# / +&(/"%#(&:##/"*7/ &#%"2&,#($$&&*#(#/&.;#& ""<(:##)#%(&7"#!(2"# %"("#2%(*5(*2

%-$&( 7 &=)#%& #"'"(6&!"#> %+,##(+?(*@-&.""*"*A#"#( &#"$("

"*#%&.#5(*2 ""(&&$+*"(&"(.(#+*(% #""*#"&+&+:###2 $&(7 ##,(54(2&,.#( #%&%""2/"",%"# (+(#,/"2%&:#2"(#2&, &2#$"B%&+/# 6&!"# 7 %&/&&$"#2+, # 6&!"#:#"## 6&!"#

9.# %&&*/#&&##$+25/" %#(&#CD #"# 7 "%A#"#(&:## #&+(#2%(*5(*2" ("*&2# 6&!"#:#%&2B/+( #2%(*5(*2"/##,$#4&<8/" "#%("%**2(/#"*"#" %"%"# 6&!"##+("&(:# #%&"<(#7 2#"&2+(

$.(##,&#$&(<(

. 7 # %%" #"(*# (&&5/"2*#(.#/$" "&#%+/#%""/## 6&!"#/ 2 / # # 6& !"#

9 & 2 "*#.54(2&,/$" (+,#%"#(5/#"/#"*" #(&:#2"&&#.(*#"/ # 6& !"# # + /#* &B* " #" $(&D%"&":##%&%""2 7 /""(."(.#"*"+&%"/" +# 6&!"#:##,(2&".#(2& +(%#"#"# 6&!"#(**"&#"2 "%(%"%"#2&,:#%&7 2 !"# $./##%%+/# 6&!"#/(&"( %"%" " # 6& !"

#: # (" # "(2# 6&!"#("*#&2#(# (+##-#"45.%&7 ."%$&,. /&&1#"3%""27 "2#$*,#" #%"%":#%(+&#"*"/*%(+&#+, # 6& !"# # /%%" * # # /(& + "%+&",."&+&,#%&7 %""27 :##/"*("$ # 6&!"#&&"%.

#"$(":"(&&,#

/"*+2/"%A#"#( &<(&&,:##2%(*5(*2"

/"%#+2&,&2#2"&*& $&: # # 6& !"# # * # -(" ** # E$"#E,&.$./#"#/"2 2(""(# 6&!"#./##* $"#2:#2# 6&!"#/&"" # -("

. /## # 2 # (2 2&, &2:##(%"%",/&<("%"%",# 6& !"#.(##/$",2(#2%("":#%"" #2&,&2.#/"*/"% #(&#,(2*#"(#(&(" #(%"$#"#":##/"*"(& %#,&%#"&2("* B& 2"& +&(/":("#"# 6&!"##C(F&&# &2./##/*"*""&7 #(+ *"".&# $/####+<(# &&# 2$+& 22$+& %"%" $(" # /"* <(&#"&(*"2*A#"#(&

(# # B (% $"( &*& +5. &(*. #&&**#&(#%&+"*#(&# #(/#%&&,2+"" @#.(#%","

2&#(

# %&* # %". &&/* ( /" "2

F##"#5(*2"

/"((& +#(&+&+G

F##"#7 "/"%# "(&+,$"("

F&&

G 8

F##"#(/#2G

F##"#(&+&+2%&& 2"&G 8

& 1##%"/""<(%%"(& #"$

"#"*&"(&"#%".#"&-(" 2#(#%&/#"" ;#/ $5(*2"

H&* **"$ +, # 5(*2 ". # %&#&%%&#-(""?(*."./## /*&"?(* H;"B-("."./# $5(*2"

2#%%&. /##5(*2"%+,# -("+&/.#%&#$BB#"#-("+,/, &*"*(&"%%&%",*##2+%.# 2%(*5(*2"%+,#-("+&/+ #(&+,#2+" 7 # %%& / ( # "%

%7 #&&,%%"#"(*#(&+((+<(&, # +. /#" "2* "% %%" % "$

@#$#"&"(&"#%%&&+** #"(*##""@,2"#%%&

%"(&#5(*2%+,#-("+&/* #/#(#-("#"5#&2#%& ;#"& -("(##(&/&<("%"%",# 6& !"#. /## / && #2 # / +"#": # # &&2/#2# 6&!"###"

;# #%&#$&(#2%(*5(*2 "/""(&"(/"5+"$*##* #C2# E$"#.$F./# #"%"# 6&!"##$&( 4### #"#/"22*#&2#%& +#& # 6& !"# # 6& !"# # & 2 2 # -(". /## / IC#+ F D- 1# # (2+"*("# 6&!"#J"( 7(&"

2%"/%"$#$+22 ;#2+*&*& $&(2.7 #+2/"# (&#CA#"/#""2*A#"#( &#+*$#2+,/,F&& ./### +#&&*+,#%&-$&-("7/&# ;#"& -("#+"$##""$","*"*#F&&# %"./##/(&++,#-$&-("7/&#: ##%&##&&*#"*"F&&"*"*A #"#(&.#""./"(+/" %#"(&#+5(*2"

F&& ;#%%&&#$#&&*(#**## ( %"%", #%% + 4( ($ 2&, "& %"",%"%",&<("%"%",#++"$ +,#"&-(" 4/$".$#B+"" ##&%#%&2(#7 +* 22+"4(($2&,(#%"""B #$%"C*"*#(#& ;#"".# 6&!"#(& $",/&&#$"2&,&2/##2*$*# ./##%%+#A#"#(&+,/, " ;#%&#(./#"7 &*/##( #"#"# 6&!"

# (54(2&,("4(&/ ;#/2 +,# 6&!"##/"2 @+*.#%* "/5("*%"C*"*#%&#( /"*#/"".#"".#""<(" 2%(&","*" " +5 " +, &" (& " # %%&&##"#&"# 6&!"##/#$ +5#&&*2&,&2"#$&(.

*# #$2(##2&,&2 &&#B#&" 2,+5#2+"2%&,"# " ;# / # %" %& # # ( & #%% + 5 4( 2&, "& %"", %"%",.

9 &*.(&+(/##2%(*5(*2" ("*" ;#*#$((&&, %"$## 6&!"##**(&&/" 22*#&2%&#*#2 "" # "& -(" # : "(&&, # ( # %&#"/" ;#%"%&#$+(+& %"$ # # 2%(* 5(*2 " " "(& "(. 2%" # 6& !"# ("* # & 2 # #&&*#" (#.#"#%&#$&%"$ "","./##2*##$%"(#-(""* 2%(*5(*2"

#"*"(#%%&&##(&+,#2 /#&+2+"".&#(*##%&/"/"# %*2%(*5(*2" 2(#+ #5(*2"#+*+,7 "2#"$(&#,2B/+(&," # # 6& !"# ;#"". ( & +, #2 /# &2.&2&(&"2#*B/&*

6"(&"#%%&&#"""5(*2 +,-"1##"*"

! .

/#"/+"$###%&#&&**#"/ %",#2#(#+&/#&2"2 #B/&*.#(+#&++""+,&2

;#&"(&"#%%&&2

#$" ;#((&+#&+2+"" 4/$". 2"#%&#$,#"" &"#2%(*5(*2"+&&*&.(&&$

6"(&"#%%&&#("#"""" 5(*2 "

# $

!% &' +, -" 1# # -(". /## %%&+&#/"2&,&2#2&, B%&./##2*##$"<("2%(&","*" ;# %& # "&" $& ( # &&* "& 2&, &2 +/#2#"#"# 6&!"#("/###,# +*$A#"#(&./##/2+,# 6& !"# (#.#"/% &",+"$# %&#%"C*"*##&.#"".#" "<(","*"/"*##+"

"*" # 5(*2 #( )

)

$ !&$*+ "%,% +,$ 1# # -(". /#" / +"$ # & && %&%"&("&&&F8B/&&+ 2"& 4/$".#5(*2#&%## %%&&2(#(""(2

F#"*"5(*2 ) " " -

$ ,

+,-"1# #-("/#"/+"$#/#"++,%&,* "(2(##/"$#(:("* (#"+""+,&2&/#2"2

#B/&*#"(+,#**"$%", ;#(#", %%&#%"(" "(2#C/##(#+"$#+2

7"(#%"$#$+%"+,# *7 ./#/"%&#$&( 7 .(%#%&D%%&&./##" /% ;#5(*2-.)

$ , +,-"1##-(" %%&+&$/#+"$+$.#+(# %&#$&(./##%%+# 6&!"# #%"C*"*##%"%",%( @##5(*2""+,#("+&/" &/&&".+(%%"%"%%"&$ """%"&/ ;#"&&*&,""2,#". /##2*##$&&"""+,#-("/#&#"* %%&

7(+&<(&/"#%%&

;#"".@,2"#%"%%& , " ("+# &*&.$& /&& " 5(*2%+,#-("+&/

;#%%&2"*&,

1"5

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#