High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3590/2012dismissed

Karnail Singh v. Hari Singh

2015-09-10Mr. Justice Arun Monga3 pages

!"##$%&%'(#)"#*+#, - .!,'!%/%'01 ))#//!'"

2#,&3& !,%%'01 #&)'4#'"

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%,'(-.&

51#"1#, #),"#,&/$!/)!)#,&*!6+#!//7#4"&##"1#8340*#'"9 +#,##,,#4""1# #),"#,&,'"9 51#"1#,"1#8340*#'"&13/4+#,#),"#4%'"1#%0#&"9

,#&#'"( ,&1:1!,47!8-4;$!"#- ,"1#!))#//!'" ,!'4!'%'4!/-4;$!"#- ,"1#,#&)'4#'" <<<<< *)+%,'

1#$1!//#'0#%'"1#),#&#'" #03/!,#$'4))#!/%&""1# %*)30'#48340*#'"&!'44#$,##&"1#3,"&+#/7-71#,#+6"1#&3%", ,#$;#,6!'!*3'" --

=>%'$/3&%;#%'"#,#&"? @)#, !''3*,*"1#4!"#),'"#!'4,#$#%)""%//"1#4!"#4#$,##!'4?A@ )#,!''3*"%//"1#4!"#,#!/%&!"%'-1!&+##'4#$,##4 ,&1:1!,47!8-/#!,'#4$3'&#/!))#!,%'0'+#1!/ "1#!))#//!'">4##'4!'"&3+*%"&"1!"+"1"1#3,"&+#/71!;#$**%""#4 !'%//#0!/%"6!'4)#,;#,&%"6-%'!&*3$1!&+"1"1#!""#&"%'07%"'#&&#&""1# ),'"#7#,#'"!7!,#"1!""1#$'&%4#,!"%'"1#!//#0#4),'"#!*3'"

1!4'"+##')!&&#4'""1#!))#//!'">4##'4!'"#3,"1#,&3+*%"&"1!" "1# ,#&)'4#'">)/!%'"%- %' $,&&>#B!*%'!"%'- !4*%""#4 "1!" "1#,# 7!& '"1%'043#-71#'"1#+3&%'#&&7!&$/&#4%'A>C!'4-"1#,#,#-%' ;%#7&3$1!4*%&&%'-"1#3,"&+#/7301"'""1!;#4#$,##4"1#&3%" !'4"13&-!&3+&"!'"%!/D3#&"%'/!7!,%&#&,!4834%$!"%'+6"1%&3," ,!'4!/%'4!/-/#!,'#4$3'&#/!))#!,%'0'+#1!/"1# ,#&)'4#'">)/!%'"%&3+*%"&"1!" +"1"1#!""#&"%'07%"'#&&#&-%#- 5>

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

&)!&&#4'".!,'!%/%'01 4##'4!'"=8340*#'"4#+",=!))#//!'"1#&",6$%'#4+6"1#!))#//!'"> 4##'4!'" "1!" 1# '#;#, $'43$"#4 !'6 +3&%'#&& 7%"1 "1# ,#&)'4#'"> )/!%'"%1!&+##'3'4"+#!+,%$!"#4'#-%'!&*3$1!&-'*!"#,%!/ #;%4#'$#1!&+##'+,301"',#$,47#;#,-,"1#%,&""%*#-!/'07%"1 "1#!))/%$!"%'3'4#, ,4#,E 3/#C -$#,"!%'4$3*#'"&1!

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

0#41%*#"1!"!&%" *!6-"1##B#$3"%'"1#),'"#1!&+##'),;#4"1,301"1#"#&"%*'%#& "1#!,#*#'"%'#47%"'#&&#&-"1#,#,#-"1#,#),"73/4+#%**!"#,%!/ ,"1#!4834%$!"%'"1#/%&+#"7##'"1#)!,"%#& ';%#771!"1!&+##'+&#,;#4!+;#-"1#,#%&'%//#0!/%"6 !'4)#,;#,&%"6%'"1#8340*#'"&!'44#$,##&+"1"1#3,"&+#/7-*3$1 /#&&-'&3+&"!'"%!/D3#&"%'/!7!,%&#&,4#"#,*%'!"%'+6"1%&3," 1#!))#!/%&!

023 '(-.&