Gurmit Singh Bakshi v. Punjab Water Resources Management And Development Corporation Pvt. Ltd.




   
    

!"#$$ 

!"!%"& !"#'$$


        

     !   "#   #   (#  )*( $ +
(
, (

 $  

%&#  '    (
, ( -$ (

 # *# '  !  + '           # &  ,,-.,,/  '   !  '0 # % *' %1  # #(23-,3,45& 67(38%* +  '    ' '  ' + 7'6  ' +'   

 #9  *' %#   #  +  ' + *  :(,;    7'6  ' +   '    '   

 ! #,33(,3,35& 67-8

### #(/((,3,<5& 67=8%* + +'  

 7'6#1

  +'  +    , ''

%

   ##    % 

    #  '   # 7!    0

   !50 !8 34(3(2=3 #

#'

 '>#  <((3,3(/    #%   

#'#





!  "

  +# #,,(((2=< 32(,(2=<

### #3<(,(22<%* +   ##+ 

  #   # *     #  *  '6  +) #*  * # #'+  ! #3432,3(=* '* # $7 #$ %& '%(&  )

*  )(*  )+ ) *  

 &&

,    -).*/  )( +  ( )   )  )     *     )%  '0  ,        -).*/( ) 1  ' % 

  &  2  &3      4&%(    )(  

)  (     )*    0  )       )        )       *   

  )%            0(      % 0('*5 '%        '#          
6
   7



8  9 (9

,)"   '## #3432,3(= ##  # +' #    %   #  ## #(,3/,3(2%* +## #3<(,(22<%*  * #  '

'  

  #   # *  ## # * ##

  + + # '  

  0

   !0    # ## #(,3/,3(2%     '#+   *

 # #' #(23/,3(2) 

 '# #(23/,3(2 #  #$7 #++ ++ ++ ++ ++ ! )   *  *)

) 7 :7

(& '0( ) *  ' ))* 3 )
*0  ( ' ** )   *  !   )        *       ) 1   '    )

  0   0  '  

 &'* * & &3 0 $ %& '%( )   *  '  ) ) %% * ) ** ( &%( 3'0%% * * ( )

%% ,* 

)(&  ;'0 <           *     )  = ! 1 +%     '    +    '  0

    ! 5 * 8*  # #(4(3,3(25& 6748 '% #,<(3,3(2%   *  # &       !  *'  (=3-(2=4  #  >#   *' 3((3,3(3%     #  +* '6#  +

*   #,33(,3,39    ' +'  # 58  ! #># %

'#!?@@(27!007,3,( !A!?(33@' ,3(2% * % #   * * # * * +



  #+  # * * #3/3,,3,<

 '%   #       

*   + 

#  *      + #  +* '6# #(/((,3,<5& 6 7=8  *  

#  ) '%   '#
 :

7 7     

 >3    ?'  <)9  @,%* 
* !" 

 ' +   ' '    ) #*  * * # * + #3(34,3,4 * +       +'# ' 



 #    * ' # 

' +

     #+   *    #'3(*% 

 ##+     +*    #'

3<   '0    ##%   # #(23-,3,45& 67(38%

  #+   # % * +  '   ' '  '

+

 ' '    58

 # 

 #

   #'  ' !    <((3,3(/ #

  *#  '# # '  '    '># % '%   # '  ' +&

 #

  ##%

'#      < "  # '   

   

  #    !*' (=3-(2=4 # ># *'3((3,3(3% '%   # #  ' +' # 58B

#  

.

#  ' ! 


        

 !

#"



   #$%     & 

 '! 4 0

#  # ' # # 

#*     @ '

     # '

    '

       0

    !    34(3(2=3  #     <((3,3(/B* %    

  #+   

 # >#  #* %    # ## #(23-,3,4%

  #



#   !0   # 

 

'#  !  ?-34(  '  (22@          +    # # ,,(((2=<   32(,(2=<  #  #  # #  3<(,(22<  *  '  +'#    #   +  +7

*' # '       #'### '

  C  0  #*  %

#

#  +   #       

    # %  * +       *  #*    +) #*  * # #'+ ! #3432,3(= '

#   #  (# )&!'  &***    +, 

-     #$%  $% .    / ### ,-32,3(<*  * # #'+ !+  '* # $7 #++ ++ ++ ++ ++ $  *  * &

 **        )        
 )0  &    &

        **     *') 
  ?00   ('0 )   ) '      **    '0     )0  &    %

**) &' )) )& 

)) )&  *')**  
0(  **  ) '') 0  8A> 
 
'

% 40    

.

/<BC27     )%)*;)

')  

** - 0 )

4 -'*
 8  93 ? ./  %D  $    .

/ 

    0  )%)) ' )   &  )3

  0  &    **   )) )&  '0  *')**  6 &( & %

    '     *   &   %    %)   

 ')3          

)     ,% > ?   
  40   %63     7 7.7/ 
   :          ?         4 -' *
   ?'   %8 & E  7 2.

/
 7  A   (  '     *  

    *  )0'))*>'  *

& ( 
)  '%  )( 
*  3 )

& ) ' *) ) 
9

7  )

 
* )   (

/ '   '3 &  () ) 

' % 

)

&* * & )  
*    0 *0  3*

 %& '%'% '0 
3*

 %& & ) & )

0 %3 (' )* E*



%&  ) 

)  *( +) ') )+*0(* '0& *

+    )* ) )*0

$  0) 1 ' '* * (       '  *  &  &     =
"&'#

   7 ##   # !?(,-/'

(222

 ## - '% #(,3/,3(2% ## # 3<(,(22<%* + ''  * #  

   #   # *  ## #* ' ##

  + + # '     '  0

    !  ! 1 +%  '    +    '

0

   !5 * 8* # (4(3,3(20   * %

#'      '     <((3,3(/ # '  %



#    !*'(=3-(2=4 # ># *'3((3,3(3    % #,<(3,3(2

#  +

 '6#  +  *   / A   +'  '&  !

0   # ## ' ! #  *  '#+   * # #' 3432,3(= '  ' #'  +*  # (4(3,3(2 #  1  '%

  #    ! #>#     %    #  ' + # * ) 

* #+ #   #      0# "$. 1  &**! 

 * #*  B D ! * +   #   #$$ 2-3    4   5   &** 

2 *6  
$-7 " 8 7 )  2 7 ) ,

 9:





   &**

' #4   5  
 ;3 -  &**& 

&'

#

*   7 +# '  + *   7#  '     !  #  '  ' C   '      # # %  +

 ' C# #  

 #%  +  #  '

+0  #  %  +   # !'   '

+   ' '### '  )  *

 #+ !% * % *  #+ B D  !) 

  ' ##   #  #$7 # 4%

  '%)   ( 1

F&   *    0G$    &3 0& 0* )) )& < *  0 < ) 

'

*)  )    * 

*  *

 &D  +)  ( * )

'* *  *  ( )    

0& &

&3( 0&  % &3 *

 * *       %  *          

     0 D0( 
 ) ** **    0    )0    )) )  &  <   '0 0  )  '%
  )  ) %    )  ') 

(& **

' * '0 
'0 '%) (  )* )  **  0 )) )& <  )  * & %  '*  *

 &    ))

0    ,)'  ( 

7  $   

 8( 

 ' % 

2C( *  )

 0) %&3 *  )

 ( )( 0 &3%

 )' :


 #$$ 2-3      : 4   5    7 &** 

2 *( )  ) '0 4


 *    '5 *0  &35(( * & '  0*0 & )

* & )  *  

 *( 

 )  ( & %  ***)    %

'  '* 

*& 

)    ? &*4&'  0** ) *0*)%0  ' 

  *0   0    &      
$- : 9:





 7 &**

' * *  2 $(* '04(  4   5  :
 ;3 -7 &**&

 &' 

 952 &**& $.- $ &( 
    &   )' &&

&3'&  ** 0&3    (   *0   0 )&  * &3* *  

*  10 )%*)&*') * )0 ) ) )  )   % * *)

 & ' %( 
   &    0   **)    )  &      )    *      ' )     )) )  &           * '*  

$ **   0**   *  )) )&

 <      '      '%   0  (   1   &3 * *  
 1 0( *0  

0  )(0 *  

  &3  

    *    4


  &(  (& 0  )

*0  

0           4


  ))

0   1 

**))

0&= = )  '' #  'B D  ! 4   5   <8 ;

  '&&

! ### ,4(3,33/

 2 0     %  # +*  #  (4(3,3(2+   #     # # + ! 3432,3(= !?-34('(22@ '  ' # '%



+

#     !*'(=3-(2=4

># *'3((3,3(3     

 '# #     58% '%    #' '  '

+ (3 #  #+  # '   

 +# 

 #    '

'      (( ! 1 +%     % # #'%

+##*  #  1(
, ( '$$     E 0      .  # E.?      E.?