Vinod Kumar Makkar v. Jagdish Pahuja & ANR
!" "#$%$&' (#) *
,,"-- &!
"%,&."&!% '/0 12 2 23
!!""
# $
!%
&&&&
23* ( - '( !
) * + " "" ,-',,.'/!
+0"
"$
)
1 +0+ "+0
-2
3 " '44/1 !
!
+0
% !5, '2'',.'-1 , 6 "0
! %
1
!
0" 7 " %!"
1 .'.2,..'( ! ! 89 ...7% 1 " ! " !
! +!
1 "
9.:
!
" + 1"" ;1 +
"" ! " ! ""+
! 01""+
<',:! ! "
+ +
1 ""
0<,...7%!
+!
" ; " "
"
1 ! !
!
!
! 1 1
!
=!
+ ; "!"1 !!" >$ )
>$ "" !" 0 1 = !
! 7 " !"
+!
,.'',..-; !
"
,..9 !+
!
! 0
! ! """ " ( !
?! +/.
...7% 0" 0+""
'
,.
...7% !1 "0,..91 !
0 ? "
!
1 1
" ( ! 1 ""!" @'',..9 1
+"
! 1 "
/."
!
A ! "
B ) B !"
+1!
"
!
! "" " '
,.
...7%1 !
! %
-( +
"
1!> 3 >3 !! 6 "
'9,..4 !!
! % " "
"
" /."
!
2 ( " !"0 "
! "
1 0
0+!
'2,..' 7 " !"
!
! 1
,..' ! "0 99 ...7% !
+1!
" B!
B1
.@'',..9 1 ! 1 !
'
,.
...7% "" "" " +"1
+0 ! + ! % "
+ !
9(
""1 ! +1!
%
!
" # $ % %&' ()*
"
) )
"
# ) $
= "+0!
5'
, 2C9
! %
A
5-
"" " +"
1
! !
0 /
'2'',.'-
! 7 "
"D
!
! 0!"52/,
98 )
;1 " " +"
1 1 !
!
;1 " 1 1 " 1 !
+0 !
" 0+0(
"
! + 0
,..2%,..9
! " ! %
1 !
42-97% " "1 <',:
! .'.2,..9""!
0 A +
"
1 '2'',.'- !+ 1 " +"
""!
0 @
" !!" -2
3 "
'44/
'2'',.'-!
+0
> 1 "
)
.@'',..9 ! !
'
,.
...7%! %
"" "" "" " +"1
+0 >
!
!
! !
"
0 "+0 1 !
! "0 !!
!
0
(! "
!"0 !!" +
!
+0
1""% "
> + "!
1 + " +0
!
0 !!" 0+ 8 ( "$ = !"
"+0!
,-',,.'/"
!
+1!
1 ! "0 " ""0
+0 0" "=!
!
+
+0
+ +"> "
" +" !
!
+ / '9 ...7%1
" 0 1
6 >0
1 !!
+0
1"
; 1 " +" " B!
B 0"" "0
+1 !
!
1 +
"
"0 1 11"" 1 0
A"" '
,.
...7%! %
%! $ )
""1+ !
!
+0
! %
+0 !
+"0
1 4 (!
!! " + " "" ,-',,.'/!
+0 "$ )
'.;
" !
1
! !" "
1 ;
"! " $ 1 !
"!
+"0 1 (!
-2 !
"
-2 1 % % +!% ,
"
- .
$
#
# #
"
/ . / .! .,
#
#$ # - .
#
"
- .
#
#) .
"
1 )
" #
)
" 2 .
#
"
"
"
2 .
# "
)
#
3
)
)#
#
2 .
"
)
"
"
))
"
" )
2 .$ - .
1 /
#
" ) .
# 4
5
+
! " !
+ 1"1 !
1 !
"
0+ +03 "0 EF
01 0
EF
" "
11
+
" 0 "
1
+ G EF!
0
!!" 1 !
! !!
1 1 +"!
G E F
"1 ! !"
+0 ""1 +
+0 ! +
G E F !
" + "
"!
1
1 !
" 1 " 1
1 !
" 1 1
G 3 %EF+ % ! +" " +0
"
1 + EF
"
" 1!+" !" 0 ; '' ; 1"""+0!
3
1"
=
!!""
3 1"= !1
3 %
!!
"" " ! !
1
"
? "
+ (!1 3
! ""0"
1 -2 '44/ 0+ $- &.
!4( - %(,( !$&1!.52 6$,"%1!.*
72
+'
%%#$ !" 4$-."(%5 "-)$ "5"-,8"&!4!)($!92
:72
+ 59 . 9 %%&!"(! $&8"&!1!.;% 8<$&"%
:+ 2 +=1
+ "" 1
+ 1 ',;!
"
"0
)
!!
( )
"
+" =%$''1 + ! ;1 " +
# *
"
# #
" )
))6/
0
7
# *
) 0# ,,
0 # 7
# *
7 )
"
07
#
0 7
# *
))6/
8 )
# "
" ))6/
5 '- (
" " 1 !
.@'',..9 1 1 +0 "
+ ) (" " '
,.
...7% 1 !
! % !"
(""0+
"
!"1 !
! !
! ,''',..-; ) 1 "
"0 "
!"1 +
! 1
1
" '
/.
...7%(
" ! 1" "0 '
,.
...7%" 1 1
+" !
! 0
" - ,.
...7% +
" ; 1 " 1
"
+" ! !
" 1
!"?
0 " " "" " +" 1 1 ! 1"
!
'2( "$ 1" ""1+
!!""
0 % !!
( 1 !
-2
3 " '44/
3 !! " % !!
(
"$
1"+ !
'' ! (3 + 1
"
+
" " + "
E,FE F -2
3 " '44/
+ "
'9; "$ 1" ""1 + !! "1 ! +"
1" "
!!
B ) B "! +0 ! ! 1 1 " $
%
!!
0 '/ ( ,-',,.'/ +0 $ + ! % !!
'@
"0 !! " ""1 23 (#) *
A !
7 # A ! +" #75