M/S Crompton Greaves Ltd. v. State Of Punjab And ANR.
!" # $% && !$%$'%( # $% &&
) & !$*+,$% ! -" .,#& &&&&++ //-%, ) & 0,-, $1 '%2-3 -%# -%$,4 !
&&&&& +$%# %,
5.6 0& 06
5.6 0& 06 0
7,' -4!78 & 9 ! ! " #$%# &
! $( $$ )%%(*+&$%,# -''
! ! . / '
0 1! 2 3 - 45% -6 #3+ "
! 0 1 2#"
2 7 8 ! " 0
. 39 ! !
"8 .
! 0
!!
"
$ . 7 :)5)$ %;
)%%< 44=%%%0&*+ &$,
) . 7 :)<)$ %;
)%%< :)(%%%0&*+ &), . 7 :);)$ %;
)%%< :)(%%%0&*+ &4,
" ! # 7
4:4:4=4:4:4(4:4::%)$ %;
)%%<!7 8! 0 1 2 +&:&< " 0
> '
8 12
"
"!! " 0 )$ %;
)%%<%=:5 #! + # '
0 8 1 2
-')%%5"
'.77
%4;($%5)$$;
7 "! .
'
7 /&$:&) &=$=4 "
#
.11 ! *.!,%$ %= )%%<
"
!& $,. 7 %:)5)$ ;
)%%< # 01 2# "
2 &$% .?1!7 8 44=%%%0&"
7 4:4:4= )$ ;
)%%< # 0 1 8 !7 8
!
),. 7 %:)<)$ ;
)%%< # 01 2# "
2 &$% .?1!7 8 :)(%%%0&"
7 4:4:4( )$ ;
)%%< # 0 1 8 !7 8 ! @ 4,. 7 %:);)$ ;
)%%< # 01 2# "
2 &$% .?1!7 8 :)(%%%0&"
7 4:4::% )$ ;
)%%< # 0 1 8 !7 8 !
3'6# " 0 > '
8 1 2
"
'
#" 0
1! 2 "
# ! #2
'
!" " 6
A #"
" 0 82
! " ! 1! A !" "!+ '
#
45==%%0&" ! 5$*;,*, -' $$ %= )%%<# *+&;,
6 $$ %= )%%< ! " !
# ?3'1&!&/ ?
*. , ?
$( %= )%%= *+ &=, '
$$ %= )%%< *+ &;, $( %= )%%= *+ &=, ' - $( $$ )%%(*+&$%, ' !
"
& $
7 A &55&>&54)(
A" ! .11"
7 /$:&) &=$=4
) "+ "
" !7 8! "# 0 1
2#"
2 1! 2
" 0
39 !! :
"B 0 8 ! 1B"" '.77 " %;:<%)5<%%="8 '.77 %44;($%5)$$;
"!
.
!"> 8""
"2
: < " 0
! " !# 0 8 ;
"!! ! " &
# ' ! 0
> 8" "!+ 2 ! #AB !1
! " # $ $$ $) )%%= "
& & +!
4 1'+ $(5< !
+9 "
A ?
> !#
1 $%& !'( '&
)* +
,--.
/
, 0 1 (
"
" " ! # " & + !"
!! 3+ '+ 6 &!&6 & & 8 " " " & " "8+
A ?
> !#
1
$%&23 !&
!# )* 4 /
, 0 1 !5 #
!# "
" ?
! 78? C #!
; #" " 8"
.11 ! ! 5$ - '+ )%%5 " '
" " #- 8# 1!# '
?
> "
" #- 8# 1!# " # !# 78?C # "
& 5%%%%0&" ! !
2 ! "#"
0
!! ! 0
> 8 A " '.7! !
"
.11" 7 /$:&) &=$=4"
"
7 A &55&>&54)( A "
"!# 0
! 0 8"
# " # !" "!+ A # # !# 3'1 0
. 39 ! ! $$ = )%%< *+&;, 0 1! 2
!#
"
0
!! "
! 0 8 '
" 1! 2
"! 0
!! ' !# 0
! 0 8 " " 0
! # 0
. ! 0 8"
!
> " '
" ! " " # 0
39 ! 0 8 &
" ! ! ! "
" & " +
' # ! 5$*;,*, -'# . !7 8 ! "
" "
# # 0 1
2# "
2 '
9 8 # 0
. !> 8 8 & +D . )* +
,--.
/ 6
,- 1 " ! '
"
9 9 "# & " "8+ " " " # !#
! " + # # !+ . !! )* 4 /
,- " "!# 78? C #! ! "
" ?
-'+ " " - 8# 1!#!
78?C #!
"! & E
?
> " #- 8# 1!# " !?
" " &
#!#
78?C #! ! !
. & A" ""
. " " ! 0 1! 2 " 0
. !! "
! 0
1! 2 " 0 8 2
!
< "
" "
0
. 39 ! # ! 0 8 A "#9 ! " & "
"!
7 8! A " ! " $( $$ )%%(*+&$%,
6 &&
0 7"=-% 47
6 >4 ,4 ! + -?7%@)! - $% #
) $ >4 ,4 ! ! +$!,-3/
) $