High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/10339/2014dismissed

Sat Parkash And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2022-09-30Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal25 pages

$% &

(

)%* + $", !

* -,

#* "#$ %

% & "' % % " ( $ % % " '(% % & ")

% %* "" % % "'

+#% % ",#% % "'! % % "

+#)(% % ""+-!% % " & % % " +#+))% % " (.

% % "

$ % % "(

$ % % ",+$ % % " #

#% % "( .

% % "

/% % "

/% % " !,

% %

0 12 & "(!3 % % " & % % ",

% % "" (+#-!% "

$ % % "+ % % " #% % "'! % % "'

+#% %

" #

% % "4

% %

" . ! % % 553 * -,

#*.

+ /0 123/( 6

/# #

)! 3 0

7 381%

& &

! 5 5

# 3 0

7 55381 #

)

(/# 1 )

& &

)!3- 9 :4 ;

%<90

7<9 81 &

)! 4 ;

74381 ## %&%3)!& & %

# ;

/ #

)

! )

)! ##

(/# 5 %3%

&) &

/ # (/#

/ -

;

,+ & #0/4 =:

' 9<9 &

)

/ ;

5 ?

% +

:== :& )

& :43%+

! @%%A2

#$-&

/ &

)! # $- &

%%A2 /& # B # B

# 9 =<9 -3

# 9%%<<9A2 @ @ &

)! 3% &

< <9 %3

## (

! ;

& #/ ;

& )

/ /

)

% ##

& ! /'

%> ;

) - ;

(

'&$

" $-%+ - ! ;

/ /%

/ + %&

# ;

& 9%43 ! 9A2 ; ! /&

!) -

## )

! ;

- & ! &

/# ;

# + % &

9 % 553&

! 43

% ;# ;

/ # @ -3 #

& ;

(

# ;

4 &/56 70( % & >#

/ &

6 $

6 #+#% #

69 (

/ 6@ (%3 %3D 6:

(!+#% / 6= (

6< , &

/ 6

/ 6 (!+# 6 $

6 (!//&

6 #

69 #

/ # ! % & % #

/ # ! ?> 3

?> 3 !&= ?>?>@ /

?>@ 3 ?>@

/ ?>@ # -5:9

?>6A.

?>@9%@@

> 5 55 ?>@:*@= # -5 ?>@<

>01 ?>@ 3 ! 53 ?>:

>55 ?>:*: 3

?>: 3 ! ?>:9::

(#)

?>:= 3 ! ?>:< 4-5 ?>:*= 3

?>= 3 ! & !

?>=9=:

?>== 3A # ?><< 3A

?><<@ 3A

"E 3A

" 3A(#)

" 3A "9 3A&9 % 553 >#

/ &

6 .

/%+

/ 6 +#%

" /% 53 9 # ! % 553 # %

/ #

?> 3A&

)!43 ?> 3A > ?> 3 !

?> 3A F

3G & @% &

%>#

%62. )

/%62+#)

/%62+

4 : # ! %! ?>= ?>9

!# @<=:@?>@

(#) !92@ ?>:

=@?>=

!# = ::?>%

& #

) /

= = D % 553>#

62. )

/% +

< # ! % 3G

(/# =<9 ?> !

9<9 %?> # ?> + &0/0 !/(

/% & )

!>#

(/#

)!3 <9 - ?>=%<

9<9 -

?>%%%9% %%%%9 @&

& ?>@%:%=%<% :&

=%&

&!# ;

- %3 #

)! &

# )

/ # -%&

/ % )! 553#?>% ) )

)

;

)!?>% ) & &

) %)

/) & # )!43%

)

-%3 >#

)!3

/# # !

&=&

# )

9=@A2 ;!

=@-3

# )

) %% H B ! # =@ =: / 9%%<<9A2 .

/ % & )

)!3-3&

)

/ ?>%%9 @&

! #

%% # ) I%

/ !

?>=?>

&%3

)

?>%9%%% &

5 %3 ?>

:) / %&

) ) #

9) / @)

& %&

;

-3&

/ )

?>@%:%=%<%% :&

=%&

&!# ;

)

/ 553 &

)! 5 %3 !

?> )!

553%&

3G D ?>2 !

;

)

& &

/ )

- / ?>:0:1

&!# ;

? ?> @

&!# ;

- ?>9

&!# ;

- %3 &

)

)& ;

)! 553 ) 9 #

!%&

& / !

/ @<9 %3

?> / #

) &# # )!435 %

! ) ! )

)! %

& # )!43D

/ @<9 %

! ) #&

# )!43 <9 -

&(/#

)! # 3

*4 ! 7+ "

8 ,!!

:9+ @ 5#!) %

?>:=%:%=%=%=%=9%=@% =:%<%<9 <@-3 !

)!) : -3

& =

)!3

# ;

;

/3 (/# @9

,5+ - &70 7+ , <

60I :91 = . !F

/ /#

/ %

# # !F

) #

> ,4 =5>4 >/ 4? ' ?> )

' -

/ ?>A ?>@ =: @: ;!

:%A2 %9@%%A2 "

/% +

?> << @ @@;K 9%%A2 :%:%A2 +

?> :@=: : :@@=:

;! =%%A2 @%=%A2 +

9 ?> :@ <@ .

/2 .

& :%@%9A2 %9@%@%A2 +

@ ?>A ?> <= <9 =.

/2 <.

& @%<%A2 %:%A2 +

: ?> <: =@ @ ;! %@%A2 %<<%A2 +

= ?>9A ?> ?>2 : @= <@ @== ;! 9%%A2 %:%@%=A2 +

< ?>@A ?> @9 @9@ :=.2.

9%%@9%::A2 @%=%9<9A2 +

?>:A ?> 9 9@ 99.

/2 .

& %@@%<@%9:A2 <%%=A2 +

?>= :< 9@ .

/2 .

& %<%%:=A2 <%=%=@A2 +

?>< < 9@ 9.

/2 .

& %%=%A2 <%%A2 +

?> @ 9@ :.

/2 .

& 9%:%@A2 %:%::A2 +

?> 9 @ <.

/2 =.

& %%9=%<A2 9%%=9A2 +

9 ?> :

@ ;!

=@%A2 %9@%%A2 +

@ ?> ?>= = :

/2 .

& @%:%A2 %@%%9@=A2 +#) : ?> = :

/2 @.

& %:%9<%A2 %@9%@%=A2 +#) = ?>9 ?>= :

< ;!

%@%A2 %@%<%@=A2 +

< ?>9 = @ =.

/2 <.

& @:%%A2 =%%A2 +#) ?>@ @ ::

@ ;!

=@%A2 %9@%%A2 +

?>: 9:

/2 @.

& %<<%<%<A2 @%%9A2 +

?>:

?>: @ == =9 ;! %%A2 @%<<%@A2 +

?>= @@ :

/2 9.

& :@%%A2 %<%<%=9=A2 +#) ?>= ?>:9 @ == =9 ;! %%A2 @%<<%@A2 +

9 ?>< @@ :

/2 9.

& :@%%A2 %<%<%=9=A2 +#) @ ?>< : <@ ;!

@%A2 =%%A2 +

: ?> ?>< == 9:

/2 .

& %=9%:%:::A2 <%%9A2 +

= ?> =: 9= 9 ;! 9%%A2 9:%<=%:@A2 +

< ?>9 <9 ::

# @%@%9%@A2 %:%%A2 . ?>@ @9 =@:

/2 =.

& %:%%A2 <9%9:%=@A2 +

?>: =@9 ::

/2 9.

& %%=%@A2 :@%%<A2 +

?>= =@@ ::

/2 9.

& %@%=%@ ::%%A2 +

?> :@=: : :@@ ;! =%%A2 @%=%@A2 +

?>< 9:

==@

%:@%A2 %=:%<9A2 +

9 ?>2 : @ :@

%A2 :%%<:A2 +

@ ?>2 : 9< <.

& %%A2 =%@%<<A2 +

: ?>2 : : @:

: ;! %:%A2 9<%9% +

= ?>2 :@ @:= : %9

<# 9%<9%=% =9%%A2 .( ,

< ?>2 := <== <@ .

/2 9.

& 9%%A2 @%%A2 +

?>2 = :@9 :

<: ;! %%A2 =%:%A2 +

9 ?>2 =9 @9< =@9 := ;! %:%A2 %%=9A2 +

9 ?>2 =@ <@ = ;!

<%A2 %9@%%A2 +

9 ?>2 =:

@9= =@9 @ ;! %%A2 %@%<:A2 +

9 ?>2 < < @9:

9 " %=%%@A2 <@%%A2 L 99 ?>2 <9 < =@:

%:%<=%@A2 <@%%A2 L 9@ ?>2 <@ =@:

% + " %:%:@%:@A2 <@%%A2 L ,4 =5>4 >/

,&!

' ?> )

/ ?> @9 @@ @.

/ .

& :%<%@A2 :%%A2 +

?>9 :9= @ 9.

/ :.

& @%=%@A2 @%%A2 +

?>@ @9 @@ .

/ :.

& 9%=@%A2 @%%A2 +

9 ?>:

:@ :

/ .

& %:%9A2 @%%<A2 +

@ ?>= <: =: 9.

/ .

& @%%A2 :%%A2 +

: ?>< < :9: .

/ .

& %:@%A2 <%9%<<A2 +

= ?> 9=@= : .

/ <.

& %%A2 @%%@A2 +

< ?> @ ==@ 9.

/ :.

& :%%A2 @%%@A2 +

?> :9::

:<@ 9.

/ :.

& :%%A2 @%%@A2 +

?>2 @ = @.

/ =.

& 9%=%A2 %@%@=A2 +

?>2 @9 : 9.

/ =.

& %9%A2 %9%@<A2 +

?>2 @< = @.

/ <.

& 9%%A2 %@%:9A2 +

?>29 < =< 9.

/ :.

& <%%A2 %@%A2 +

9 ?>2@ =9:

/ .

& %%A2 %:@%@99A2 +

/ @ # 0@>@ 9<9 ;! 0

:@ ;! 0

" " @ ;!

/ ;!

& .

& @9:@ ;! <

/ / & )

(/#

)!3 & 38 %& & ;

& 3 & / !/ B

#& ) # H @B !-! )#

; ) ;

! 5 -! )# # 3

# )

/ < +99+ @ > A/ 6 -! )# % =@% # @@ & ;

'&%)!

=:%# : ) ;

-! ;

# % # )

/ #

#-!

& )#

# /# %&

)>#

(/# %

/ 553&

/?> 3

/ # ;

9%%<<9A2 # !

) )

# % /& !

?>6A. )!

& %

?>%@%:%=%<% %%=%< &

$- ' /&!' # & #) ' 29915 % ;

' /&!& >#

# ;

#$- 5

;

% ;

$-5 %

% 553 ;

)

/' /&!5 !%

& ;

/ 2- % %5

' /&!I%/

/& 6 % )

/ -%

/& /

/.( -

;

.( & 6

# ;

)

# #

$- - 553 = ?

' /&!- ?>%%&

$-- ?>%

)

/' /&!

= = # %& ?

"/ 3 % : ) :

#' /&! -

?>@%:%=%<%%%= <&

:- ?>: &

%& &! -

& ?

' /&! !

?>9%%% 9 @

& 6

' /&! &% ! #) %

?>@

:& ?

& 6

' /&! - ?>

/@ ;! .( #

8 ?>9

< ;! .( %&

/ %

# ) %

) ) # ) # % &

?>:=%:%=%=%=%=9%=@%=:%<%<:%<9 <@%&% # )

)3)

?><%<9 <@&

/L %&

/ '

)

/L 5 ) #

/ % & )

! #%

!%& ?>:%=%=%=%=9%=@%=:

! #

9<9 ;! 5 >/

% &G / G @

) / )

& &

& ? ()

/ 03

I/# 1 % @

/ 553 ;

# ) /

/ 2 .

/M<;K 0.

&1 .

&M@9;K 0.

9 ?>

)! 553 - ;

/ & / )!

553&

& -

?>%@%:&

# ;

?>9

@ &!# ;

?>%% 9%@&

# )

5 !@% # ) & ;

)

# )!43-

?>%9%@

:%%A2 &

?>: ) @%@:%:A2 D # !

)! & 553%

)! 553

! ;

& )%

# ;

/% & )

!>#

(/# 3

=%& )

# -3&

/# @@ ;

=@ -3&

# #

(/# <+99+ @ > A/ 6%

# ;

=@% )!

/ #

# ! - %3& / 9=@A2 ;!-(/# = !

)

)! /3 @9

,5+ - &70 7+ , <

6 0I2:921?

) (/# @9% &

(/# =%

# ;

)

B # -#

/ % #

/ %

/! %&

%5 &

)

)! 553

?>< /

<%%A2 &

)

/ :%%A2 5

# / (/# %3 / B

9=@A2 ;! # 9!

# ;

<=: ; !0 9%%<<9A2 1-3%

) % # # %

!@! -

) - 8) #3

7+ $? %0 #4

;

,!!

8 *4

;

/> ( %# %)

29! @ '&% >#

.( -43 & @%%A2 # $- % &% ##

! )

/.( )

- & &

?>9 & ! #

# ) & ;

D !

?>%

) ;

)

/.( # ) # ##

& %&

%?>9 >

.( %

@%%A2 :

5#!) &

& 3 ! & &

3 #

)! 6

.( & )

/ )

=:%

)! #.(

) /

# ) &

%5 $

/) " :%+

= " /#

/ & !) !F%&% #!) #

! )!

/ &

# )

! )

+&00( 9 3

; !%&

)!3

# - #

)!3

)& =<9 @

# )!

43 )! #.(

6 % .(

@%%A2 6 )

)( %

)! 553

&% & %

9 4

/ & & 3 !

# #

)!3 %

)

% !%

* -,

$"& 6

/A K A' 6 ) K A'

' 3 '

#-,

B,+ ,

' &

I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "- DD4D?

*D I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "-?+ 5'5 *D I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5'D+L"* D @ I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "K?

5*D :

I2:2@ 6'+L" --?DI K''D = I29@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ''+L"* D < I29=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,'5'D I29<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5+",5-5'$ H 5+"'D I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 .4.55'$ ' D I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 -3 ' '$4'D I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "-L 54 "'D I2@92@ ?'5D"'$? 553 K 4 0?3??1- 4'D 9 I2@:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 6'+L"* D @ I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,5'? *D :

I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,+L"*D = I2@=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5+",5-5'$ H 5+"*D < I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L '5*D I2@92@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,L'5'$ H ??'+L"*D I2@:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 +5 '+L" 'D I2@=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 I-? 5'$ * D I22@ '?? --?DI K''D I2=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "-"D'5+* D 9 I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L "45+*D @ I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "-"54' D :

I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 " ? 3 '? $D5'*D = I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 $D ? ' 'D < I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 6' 5*D I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "??''D I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,K+L"* D I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 '??4"'D I2@92@ ?'5D"'$? 553 +L'-4?

'D I2@:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ',??

+L"* D

9 I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,5'?+L" 'D @ I2@<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 '??4"*D :

I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 43 "53 ' *D = I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ' '??-5'$ * D < I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L5'?5'$ * D I2@@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 -4*D 9 I2@<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "? +L" 'D 9 I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 3 --5'$ 0?3??1- 4'D 9 I29:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,D$5'?5'$ * D 9 I2@=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "L'5'$ *D I2@<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 -+ * D 9@ I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "K?

5*D 9:

I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5'?5'$ * D 9= I2@@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ".54' D 9< I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 - D?

?3??- 4'D 9 I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ??'+L" *D @ I2==2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ," 5'D @ I2=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "- .-5 ?

5'D @ I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L 543 '' D @ I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "? +L" 'D @9 I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "- "5 $$64*D @@ I2=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ??''5' D @:

I2=<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 6'+L" 'D @= I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 +5 '+L" 'D @< I2=:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5+",5-5'$ H 5+"'D @ I22:

-3 ''$4 --?DI K' 'D : I2992:

L?'?5'$ --?DI K'*D : I2@<2@ L "45+'' --?DI K' 'D : I2@2@ "- .-5?

5 --?DI K'' D : I2:2@ ?"'- --?DI K''D :9 I2:2@ ' '??-5'$ --?DI K'' D :@ I2<29 6' 5*' --?DI K'*D

I2@2@ "L'5'$ *' --?DI K' *D := I2@2@ '??4"*D --?DI K'*D :< I2@2@ L 543 ' --?DI K'*D : I29==29

5'D+L" --?DI K'*D = I29:29 6'+L" --?DI K'*D = I2<2@ ??'+L" --?DI K'' D = I2=<:2:

.4.55'$ 'D --?DI K' 'D = I2@<2@ L'54+L"05'3??3??1- 4 ??'

--?DI K''D =9 I2992@ 3 5'5'$4 --?DI K'*D =@ I2:2@ ,L'5'$ H ??'+L"'D --?DI K''D =:

I22@ -4'' --?DI K'' D == I29@9:2= "'5"0?3??1- 4 --?DI K''D =< I2@@@2= DD45'$ 'D --?DI K' 'D = I2@@:2= DD45'$ 'D --?DI K' 'D < I29@992= $'$?

5'D --?DI K' 'D < I29@9@2= "45'D --?DI K'' D < I29@9=2= L ?

5'D --?DI K' 'D < I29@2= K" --?DI K''D <9 I292< "? 65?

50?3??1- 4' D --?DI K''D <@ I2:9<2@

5+",5-5'$ 45 5+" --?DI K'*D <:

I292:

L 54 "0?3??1- ?4' ' --?DI K''D <= I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5+ * D << I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,"?5'$ * D < I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "'- *D I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,$"45'$ * D I292@ ,K+L"- $ --?DI K' 'D I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,5 'D I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 .4.55'$ * D 9 I2992@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "

5 5'$ *D @ I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "??' D :

I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5+",5-5'$ H 5+"'D = I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 3 --5'$ 05'3??3??1- 4'D < I2<=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ??+L"

'D I2<<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 .4?

5' D I2:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 '??+L" 'D I2:2@ 5'?5'$ --?DI K'' D I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 +545'$ ' D I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L5'?$D?4* D 9 I2@=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5 "5'$ * D @ I2@<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "

5*D :

I2:2@ 43 "53 ''' --?DI K''D = I22@ "-D '5?

5 --?DI K'*D < I2<92@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L. 3 ' 'D I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 3 5'5'$4 'D I2=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5'6-5' D I2=@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "-L'? 5 'D I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 D '5?

5' D I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ",5-+L 'D 9 I2@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 $'? $$' D @ I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "5'$ *D :

I2<@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "-D"--5' D = I2<:2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ?"'-'D < I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 L'54+L"' D I22@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ?"4-' D I2@2@ ".54- $ --?DI K'' D I2:@2@ "D'5+ --?DI K'*D I2<2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 '??'D I2=92@ ?'5D"'$? 553 -6'-5?

'D 9 I2@<@2@ "-- D?

5- ?4?$4 ?5 --?DI K''D @ I292@ "44'D --?DI K'' D :

I292@ $D ? ' --?DI K'' D = I2:2@ 5 "5'$ --?DI K''D < I2=<2@ "''D --?DI K'*D I2@2@ "-D"--5 --?DI K'*D I2@992= 553 ?+ 05'3??3??1 - 4'D I2=<@2:

.4.55'$ 'D --?DI K'

'D I2@@2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 5+",5-5'$ H 5+"'D I2=2@ ?'5D"'$? 553 "44'D 9 I2::29 .4.55'$ 'D --?DI K' 'D @ I29=@29 +5 '+L" --?DI K'*D :

I29=:29 "-"54 --?DI K'*D = I2<@2:

"-3 "?45?

505'3??3??1- 4 'D --?DI K''D < I2@9<2= 5534- .4.55'$ *D I2@9=2= 5534- "D 5'?5'$ *D- ? 9 I2@:2 "5'$ ?3??%- DL$ 54 - ?--?DI K''D- ? 9 I2@9@2= 5534- $'$?

5*D 9 I2@@2= 5534- "'5"05'3??3??1 - 4*D 9 I2@@2= 5534- "? +L"'D 99 I2@2= "5'$ --?DI K''D 9@ I2@92= 5534- 5+ 'D 9:

I2@92= 5534- L ?

5*D- ? 9= I2@9:2= 5534- K"*D- ? 9< I2@2= 5534- +".5*D 9 I2@<2= 5534- "5'$ *D @ I2@@2= 5534- "45*D- ? @ I22= ,5'? 'D --?DI K''D @ I2@@2= 5534- +5 '44*D- ? @ I2@:2= 5534- "-3 "?45?

5?3?? - 4*D- ? @9 I2@=2= 5534- +'6. '*D- ? @@ I2@2= 5534- L5?

*D- ? @:

I2@92= 5534- DD4D*D- ? @= I2@92= 5534- "+L"*D @< I2@@2= 5534- "? 65?

5*D- ? @ I2@92= 5534- "'*D- ? : I2@92= 5534- '??4"'D : I292@ ?'5D"'$? 553 ,56'5'$ ' D : I2=2@ "-5'6-5'D --?DI K''D : I299@2@ "D 5'?5'$ --?DI K'*D :9 I292< "-.4?

5 --?DI K''D :@ I292< ,5 '' --?DI K''D ::

I22@ "- "5$$64- ?$ --?

DI K''D := I2@@2@ "

55'$ *' --?DI K'*D :< I2:2@ ,56'5'$ '' --?DI K' 'D : I2:92@ ,$"45'$ --?DI K''D = I2@:2@ ,'5'' --?DI K'' D = I2<92@ I-? 5'$ --?DI K''D = I2:2@ $'? $$ --?DI K''D = I292@ 6'+L"*' --?DI K'*

D =9 I2@2@ "- DD4D?

5*D --?DI K' *D =@ I2:9@2@

5+",5-5'$ 45 5+" --?DI K'*D =:

I2:9:2@

5+",5-5'$ H 5+" --?DI K'*D == I2:92@

5+",5-5'$ 45 5+" --?DI K'*D =< I2:@2@

5+",5-5'$ 45 5+" --?DI K'*D = I2@92@ ''+L" --?DI K'*D < I2@@2@ ',??

+L" --?DI K'' D < I2:9=2@

5+",5-5'$ H 5+" --?DI K'*D < I2:@2@ "? +L"*D --?DI K'* D < I2<2@ '??+L"'D --?DI K''D <9 I22@ L5'?$D?4*' --?DI K'* D <@ I2<@2@ "-L'? 5'D --?DI K' 'D <:

I2@2@ L '5*D --?DI K'*D <= I2@=2@ -6'-5?

5'D --?DI K' 'D << I2:2@ "-",5-+L --?DI K'' D < I2@2@ ?'5D"'$?% 553 5+",5-5'$ H 5+"'D ED.,2:<2352 @ ?'5D"'$?% 553 ??+L" 'D

* -,

$"&