High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4764/2017dismissed

Oriental Insurance Company Ltd v. Ramanjit Kaur And ORS.

2026-03-23Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma28 pages

-1-

FAO-4 XOBJ 4764-2017 (O&M) & JC-88- 2019

! "# '( %

*+%'

# $%&

%) "%&%0&1 2 &( 33

'$ $%&

#0 &$1 & +" 2

#3&$1 +

2! 4 5 67! 5..8 -) 22

- ./ %" " ! +( "9

!" #$

&6< '

()& #"

" 6+ "& :" %!

;) " + *

+"#," $ &-.

..&"( +( ( / + ! "(" & " 4 4

-2-

9 " ! "

4 5 4 55

,6 %"

2! "

" ! + !

! 4 6 5 " ) ( " 9 06.04.2017 p passed by the learned Motor Acc cident Claims Tribunal, (District t Judge), Moh hali (for short, 'the Tribunal') in n the claim petition filed under r Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 19 88 !" %!

&+ " + &("

2! 4 " + =&?

42 (9" @ @ A

+ + " + > " *(" # , "

= ? * " + !"

! + !"

( +" 9

! " %!

& "+&

4 55 ,6 1" (

>+ + + " " =& >" *("& ( (9" 9 (( (#" +" "

& !

!( ( > =2$ $2 ?& 1 ! >" *("9 ( " %" 9 1! &"(" " ( ( ( $ ! .?

& 9" " "

9 -3-

(&3"#" &" &9" 1( " " ( ( 1 "(" & & 9" (! " ++" & "!3 +" & +

"+& >" *(" " + 9 "

(

" # ("" >"*("9

3 1 1 B & " 2 & #" & + + 9"& " 9 + 0 &"( ("&+%"+&"

"9 3#B & & * -&# #" &+!&!

" = C + " & " + +

D " ( + " & " + 9(

9 +!"

2 ! (

!"!"#$

% % & ! '(,-$./, -0 & ! 1

'' "

"!) ! *

* * + ''

-4203

& '4! 253 !

* *

'4! 2$34 !6 $+3( " ( "1 & "

" %!

" 9 " + + =&?

2 (9" @ A

+"+ + >" *("" 2

9 " ! " 1 B &"

+ "

. +" 8

" " ( 9

! " %!

(

! ! ! B + "( "" %!

" " (""

" " ( ( 1(+"++(1" + "

"D 9 9 ( 9" "

" (

<<9

&9" "&

(" &

- -5B+ " "& " 1 ! & & "

" (+ +"++(1" 6

) )

+ "( ( !

! "1 "

"/ + 9&

!("" +" " !

""(" 9"

++ ! B+ + " "" %!

" 9( = A9 + + &9" &" +

+ " & " (" "1!

A " ("+"+

& " " ! 9" ( (9!

! + + " 5

!" %!

" 9 9 1 !"

" B+ " " " %!

" (" " 2

! " " 4 5 %"+&" ""

2 ! ! 9 + ! " 2

+ +

!" 9 ?

"1 " + + "

" 9" +"

-6- >+ (+ "&9 !

" 1 +"92 7)

8! #! 9 &

+ 4

', "* +!'":.

.!9

+!'":.*

, !"!"

"#$!;

& !'(-$,./, - 0* (

! ;

! &

, *< <

* !1

! '

(

* , * *

& =!"!"#$!;

! *

-7-

& ! '(-$,./, -0!>*'

!"*

& (

!( *

!" , +!':(!*

??4 +!':>* & & !

! ! 9 * ,

*& * &

* !) * !1

& !'("0,%, -0*

& &

* &

! "! * & & ,

* * , & !) ) *>)4 &

!%* !*

* ??4*

-8-

!!) * &, & *

!* * & ! 0 ; *

& , & !&*

* >)4 & * & * *

& & ! 1 >)4

!) >)4 &

* ! 9

, & & *

!) *

& !*& * ,

??4

!) ??4 & & !1

@ *

!) * * @ & 1

-9-

?4*& &

!) ) *

* @ & !. ,

*',"4

& ! '(-$,./, -0* &

* & *

& & & *

!% * * * ,+

%* !

&+ & * & !.* &

! 5! )

',"*

-10- *

* & !'(-$,./, -0!

& !1

(

$! * & *+

@ * *

+/ *

& &

! -! > * ! )

* & &

( &

A * !*

B' 1:(*

&= ! & ! 9 * * & *

(

A,"$ *

! * !) *

(/ /.C!/ !%

. / (

-11- &

+!':?*

& & (/. "#$!

( & * @

!/ * * ,

&4!$*###:, !

; *

*& ;& / 4 !4 &

*"#02034/4 4 2/ 3* #* & $#D , * !

9 * *

(

; , *

& &

& &*

(

!. *& ;E&

/* E !

F F! ?

9 / !"##=2034/ ,

4 * 2 / 3* + $#D &

& * + !.

F E 2 3 ,

-12- * &

! &

& ;E&

4 !4 &

"#02034/42/ 3* #* * & @ &

& /* * 4!*##*###:,9*

* (

* G,

! ;.?

3 $#D && /.1/81.9) 4G$*###:, ! 24!$*###H4! $##3 4!""*$## !

3 :" !!2

3& 24!""*$##,*"$#3I

+ 3 /

4!*"$#:, 24!*"$#+"+A3I 4G"5*0#*###:, A

2F3 1 99.1/%' .9) ..4?? A . 4!*##*###:, 4!"$*0#*###, @ * !

% & !'(-$,./,-0. * +!

4* & @

! 9, * &

* * ,

-13- * * * * ,

!. *

!6 = $ + + " 1 "9 " " %!

" ("

+" "( ( 1(+"++(2

! 21+"++( (1" %" %!

" " + F2 *("& & 29

& 9" " ( ! " + "

+ !

( ( " 2 1 5"(

! "

" 1 &" + %" %!

" 3 " + F2 ( 9" " 1 & & 9" "

! "

" + " "& " ( ( 2( + " D " !( " !" % !

9 " (

"#," $ & ((+D @ + ( %" ++

"+ + !! + ! !

!%" -14-

&" &"

"("

. G/ &" %!

(" " ""

+"<<

! (

9"" 9 ( ! 21 " + +& 9" 9 " 1 + " ++( 1 " " !

1( " + + + ! %"

& "

" "9 ! 1 !" - *(+ & 23"1 1*("&!("1+" ++(1 " "! E "

9" "

" "

&+ "

!E 1" ( 1 ( "

&" %!

" (" 91 + (

19+" (

1 !" 2 & !" %!

& 1 ""

" "( (1(+ 23 3"1 *(" 61 + " ++ ( 1" )&

( " "+> "*("%"+( !" %!

+ 1 + + 9&"+&9 + .

4 55

,6 $1( 9 "

2! + ! "

2! 3(" + &"

-15- +3(

" 9 7 B;! * "

+ ! 8- 6/ / 0*" 2 %0"('! !, ,9& & 9"

" 9

+ " 1 + + " 2

!9 &

+ &

9 / *

! ;

&@ / /*

+ * & , 2:03 &

& "0*,2:53 &

& 5-* , 2:$3 &

&+ +!

! ) & *

* * $#D

+ * &

23 &

!> *& *

& ! ) &

-16- * &

& * &

& * *& ! ! 9 &

& *

& &

* $#D &

+ &

$#D &

!; *

& , & * +

& , &

, ! % % % % % % &

& &

/ 253 & & 2

9 J* 9 / / 3*

A 2 $"# ""$ $ 3*& * %, "-0# *%,-0 0$ *%,$0-5#

*%,555$ * %,05-$# * &

* *%,$ $$ *%,=$--# #

*%, --$ %,$-- # ! B;! * "

? " + '( !"# "$8-

/, 59" + " 9 *

& ?2$ . +"#," $ &-..

& "+ 9 9( 2

-172.3 ? +

K 2(3

K 2/3 . &

K 2?3 4 & * * * + *

K 23 > G

&K , +

! %" 1+" (

2 H) . (* * *

+ L! ) 4!"$*###

+ *4*##*###

4 *##*###

! 9 + !9 94

? * ! 9

* & & &

& ! 8

& @ ! . @ & ! 9 &

+* &

& !9

& ! 9 9 & & !

&+ &

-18-

@ *

& &

& !9* + & ! ) & * * * + & 4!$*###* 4!5#*### 4!$*### # !9

!( & , @ , !

& &

@ & & &

! &

M M M M M )+ ! * $#D D

* &

& 5# * & !

9 &0 0#D*

& 5# $# ! )

& $#- -# * & $D!.

+! )+&!)

, 23

* 5#D &

& 5# !. "$D

-19-

& 5#$# #D D

& $# -# #

& !9 & + !

)+)! >

* + * &

& &

0#0"

&! )+,9

& 9 &

F N

5" ! )+-! 9 & &

! )+.!4 & * * * + & 4 $*###* 4 5#*### 4 $*### # !9

B;! * " + '>2' & "'+ + &!0"'&1 %2*'&: ;2;( $ <! '&0

'2 '+;'! =0="0 '2 .

. (= "! 8 ,5-,5/ ,39 + ( '"+' < "2'-!0*"'/

"'&': (= =;-0*"'/" " 9 (( 1 +"

2 7 !./ ( / '

L L

! !)

*O O

-20- O* O

O!9

* * * * *

* +

! "!!'('!

& ,

* * * *

O! "!"! ('

* O

* * *

O! "!0! ('!

!/ * *

! ! /

! % , E +

! %

-21- !9

* *

! ! 9 % F . &

* *

& &

.!. ;

! ; *

! &! 9 &

& &

O O

L!) *

* 4 45#*###

! = $

+ " ( 9 9 1 " " & & >" *("9 - +( "+"

&9" "

1 " (""# #6GEF4>)%"+" %!

" (" "

+. " 9

-22- $ + "

+ " 1 "" 9

((+>$+0 01 (&#" " + "

& "! ! "( " " 9

" / / +

B91& " !

"" +" =

"9" (" /

+ +" " + (

"B;

! "* /*0 0 /1 )

,&23 3 ( , + ) ( !

1 1" (2 9( +( (+ +

+ " ! + " ! + "

" 1+"

75! 9 + !9

(!/

) / ., )

!99

& 4!

0*00=:, &

! 9 ;

/ / . !9;

/ 4!0*0$":,! 9 &

* ;

/ , A

& / (

-23- ) /

1 ! '

* 2"# 3- //-A#! $!99 &

4!A*#0*$":, ,

& ,

& 4!

!9;

/ @

*"5*#0":,

##D &

! 9 ;

4! 5

* *,

+ 4! *""*0$-:,!9

& ;

/ / 4!0"*5-*0AA:,! -! 9 /

, &

/ / . + ! 9 / ) /

* ? & , !

& & @

, ! 9 / &

"##

! &

/ .

-24- +

! 9

& *

, / . * * & . * * & * 4!$*###:, "##* ,

0*0$":,!. 4!$*### #:, *

* & '

* 5#D D & !9 ##D &

&4!$*"*###:, , 24!$*###:,P5#DP" PA3!9 &

4!5

& ;

/ + 4!

*""*0$-:,

4 ! 5#*05*0$-:,! 9

Q=D

& 9 & R ;

/ &

!6 "&B;! "* . 8!! 4/ 5 5/3 4( 63 7 , )3 " 3 " " + " 9" 9

( #$

! ?* -25- * "2%&(=%" 1+ +"

2 2 ! %./9*

& *,

%/. *

& * & 4!

"#*###

"0 * $#

! 9*

SAT 4!0"*5#*###!

! A! 9;

/* *

%./9

* * 4!

A*###

! =! ) &

4!=*55*###! #! 9

;

/ * * &

) /!1!!'

*"# ./U" ##2 /3*

& & , ! ! ) *

& %./9* & 4!"#*###!9

-26- $# & %./9*

& 5#

& !;* +*

& %./9

& ,

;

/!9 4!"#*###

5# ,

, +

&4!5* 5*###!9

0#*"5*###

("+"!1+ - ( &" & " +

" +" %"+&"

" +"

4 .3

9:!& &

! 3( " +"("(

"+ ?

$+ "

+"9 1 "" %!

" (= A+ 9

+ " +"

B91& " 9 &@ ! + + ? $ + "

+ " 9 1 " "("

( " " +

+ " 9

(9 "" +

+ + E %"+& & "9/ / + (

+" ?

19+" 9 9! "B;! * "!1+ + ( &" + + !"

$;!2;!! $ -27- $!(1+ &9"

2! + ! "

2! 4 5 '++%B $ %" 9 06.04.2017 +

( %"

2! 4 5 " " "

"2 2 0 !> # " .

42 @

426

A+.

) ? <

9 I

426=

74)

426=

) = # .

< &&

426

77.) )

+G =&

42 . GE =&

42 -

D + .

E %('+ +%2* &!'(;%&

! 53, ? 2%0 ";A0 0&(B'"$ $A:(= 0&'+

! C3? &='

'&1 $'2%0&( -

!3, ?

! 53, C3/ ?? * + "

& " ! B;! *

/; < = "!/ !

,63

4 !' -

/ C 0*" 2 %0"( '! ! , "

2! 4

-28- (" @-A "" +" ++ (+ "

"+ K ?

%" 2

" " + 9"" %!

9"+9 "

+ "+ + + + " (%"%!

" +

(9" "

2! 4 5 9%"

! 4

5 + ""!3

" %!

?= ( 6 )&+&

+ - /

0 1$ F"" F"" 3(42 3(J 45 ! J