Rakesh Kumar Goyal v. Gurtej Singh Sahota & ORS
!
" #$
%&
'() "*+, ---..
,, / )
*)" 012'1'3'
" ---%
! "#$%&'
()*+,& -&).+"/ % "#$%&'
()*+,& +"/& 0+"1.0+/.( "
"41)"$35 "'
..
,, " ' ''."$35 ""
"("12'13')$35
""
3 "'
..
,,
6 00 2
8' 0)32 ',, 3 .
9 ..
, !
"2
63
!'"
) 0)32 :"3 . ,
..
, $'
"
!
2& "
8' ;"-)"..
,)3 ",)
< ' !
, 32 '
0)32 3 3
6 , " 312,
4)32 $9'
!+5,"
, 3!+*)" 012'
1'="
,,9 3 8'
.. %&
'
() "*+,=..
,,
>2
">,
" ,'
1 29,; >2
"238
',2+$29, " '" ?'
@ 9
3 3 "
9 "3 3 !
.. 3 ) '9',,
A) ,!
B"
,+$'
"
'53 35
3 3
$ '
""
""
3 ?'
"
35
@$'
5 .., " ,,2).5") . ,)32 .
>2
">,
" ,8'
A), "'
3. 9 .
3 35
$ .
"'
C 2%),
)3 " -
! "# $% & '
( # ( )
* %
.., 3"
.
'
335
D9 "$
9 3 .)"
)'
; 3$'
) 3'
"35
3 3 6
'
""
""
3 ?'
335
@$52 .., "5") . ,)32 .
>2
">,
" ,8'
, 3 ""
.
..,
;9 .
3'
35
' , A), 3'
""
A)"
"'
. 9 5,!,
'
9 !
999 , 8'
..
,, 9 ,,
.., 3"
.
'
335
8'
..
,,9
3$9'
$"
.,
31" ", %
, 3 '
9" .
',, 22 '
.. ..
,, '
2")3 ' '
,2!, "
3 " ' 33)"
'
33'5 A)
E "&
A)"
3)3 "'
%),
"
9 , )2' "..
'
. '
9 "") ,2!,
3
33 6
''
A),
."
"!
3 '
"
35
9 '2 3 '
3 35
5 9 3 '
%),
F% 2),
3 12, 4)32 " C 2 '
"
"3 '
,) '' 3
!" ) " "
"3 ; $ '
3 '
%),
9 " ,
3 8')2'$.". ,'3!
3 $!) "'
.
2 93 ', + "
"$ 3 9 "" 3)8'
3
,
3 ""+'
"3
"32,+$ 9 '
,3''
.. ..
,,9 2 '
A),
."
"!
3'
%),
$9' ' C 3'
'
3 .. G " 41 )"$ 3 )
, " '
..
,, "2) 3 ' 3 3,+'
", "%),
9' '."
"!
3 )
E "& B>F B8
' 2"
>,
" , >2
"2 9 "3 3 !
& . !
+
.
"'
3
B"3 2
'
23 3
8'
312, 4)32 '3 ,+ ,)3 3''
.".
3%),
9' '."
"!
3 ) 66E "& B>FB8
'>,
" ,>2
"2'3!
,H 3$!) 312, 4)32 '3"
)" 3+ 32 9' '%),
9
.., !, ; '
!
.
32 9' ' "),
9
.., !, '
$ ),3'5 !
'
,3''
..
,, 9 ,2!,
3,+$ '
"2) 3 ' !
) 3 ' '
.".
3 %),
'5 ,,+!
3. 3$'
9),3!
4 9'
9 %),
25 "2 '
. $'
", "%),
'52 !
& .!
+
;'
!
+%),
$'
A),
."
"!
3'
35
9),325 " ..
,, ), ,, 3'
3A), ' .. ),3!
'
,3!
5,3 # 8'"3,+$'
"2) 3'3"
.."
),3 '5 !
) 3 '
33 '5 5 + " C.
"
*5 " ." F )!, I3 "&2F ") 2 +
,"
.) !
,9'
"& 4)">2
"" A)5,
.), 3 '
35
3 3 6
8'
C.
"
"
,,
$9' '9 , 3
)!
.., ,++ "
$ 2'3', '
D
"2)
''
.
"3 "
G 6
"
),3!
3 3 C.
"
"' .)".
D "2) 3'&2'
C.
"
!
5 + "
3 )" '
$." 9"
, ") (',$ % 2 "" 1;>8 '
' ""
3 '
" )2'
C.
"
,,'
, 3
. .., "' &
)' C.
"
"
>'
"9+'
1
' ""
3
1' ' ''."$3)
, ""
"2) ''
A), 9 .
3'
335
:"
&92'
A), 33 A)"
35 '
9 !
9'
A), 9 '
"
35
>5 "
.,+ .., )3 " '
%2' ; " $'
"
3''
A), "'
.
>2
">,
" ,'
)
3 35
9 '
25 '
"
35
D
5 ') )! 3''
A), "'
3. "
3'
'
'
"
35
$ ,
E "& '
A), +2 C $9' ''
..
,,33.
D )"'
"2) 3' .
"'
2 3;
6 )
2
B"3 2
'
,3 #
'
.".
3%),
."
"!
66E "& '
A), +2 C 9', + "
C.
"
9'
$'
A), ."
"!
3!+'
'
3 35
"
A)"
3 , 6 + "
C.
"
'
35
),3!
, 39''
.". , " 3 $'
312, 4)32 "2',+ ,)3 3''
3 .".
39
" "" 3)
)"'
""2) 3'!
"
312, 4)32 2"
3
''
%),
'3!
3 3 .
.". ,$ !) 9 '
33,
35 3 3 G #
'
' & 3''
%),
'5 !
3 3D
A)
3'
35 "2 3 & !+'
+"
'
"2) 3''
33,
3553 3' .
)"'
" 3' .
"2 3
.."5 3
'
2 '
B"3 2
'
%
") %),
'),3!
"32I*F;8>FD%9' '
!
"A),+D
''
) A), ."
"!
!+ '
I*
E "& D )"'
" , ' '
3 '
''
%),
'3!
& .!
+
""
!
)
'
'
" . 35
3 '
"
35
,+:
"$)33
)
"3+ % 2 ""9 3 $9' '9),3'5 !
.
!, "),
'3
!
3 3
)"'
"
''
,+2" 5
2 '
0)32 312, 4)32 "
3!+'
'
2")3
..
,
6 2 '
3"
..
8'
' '
'
32
312, 4)32 '
.' .".
3 3 9
"" 3)'
A), ,339'
335
9
""+'
%),
;' 2"3'
,+2" 5
; '
335
'52!
'
,3!
.".
"$
),3'5 !
3"
3!
.. 3; 3'
312,
4)32 '),3'5 3"
3'
."
'!+
)2
'35
'
! , 2,,+5,3 3.".
"A),
3 .) 3'
"2) 3)
, "'
..
,, ''
33'5 A) 5 + "
C.
"
'
, 3
)!
.., D "2) 3''
.
"3 >C
)5 8"
9 ,!, !
) 39"3 C.
"
6 '5 '
"33)
, "'
."
3.
")
3'
"3
3 .) '
."
..
,
"
")3'
A)
9'
"'
335
9
"3
9' "),
C 2$'
% 2 ""
; 3"
3 ,
35 "
2"3 '
%),
.., !, " '
. A)
"32,+$
353 3 G#
' !
, 3!+'
% 2 ""
; 8'5 ". )"
%),
$
"+"
"'
353 ,
6
G ;'
35$' !
3'"
) ) !3+$ ),,+ )3 3!+'
*5 " ;3;
2 3)3 "'
1
% 2 " $
3 25 " 3!+'
"3)
3 %),
'
; .
" '
"3) 3 %),
$ '
B"3 2
'
" ., >C
)5 B3+ 3' .9 " 3 "5 $ ",3'
". 3"
,339"'
"9
3 & .. ),9''
:
:)"'
"$ '
B"3 2
' .9 " 2 ,, '
3 "5
"
8'
5 .., 53 "
35
"
- '2. ,)32
.
>2
" >,
" , .
" '
%
") %),
.."5 3!+'
B"3 2
'
2'
,3
3) ,A), 3 ,2!,+ 3 3'
35
"'
. 9 )3 " + , , ( " - ( %
'
.
/
!
"# $% & '
(
# ( )
2 3; ) !
"
" 3 "2 2 '
$'
)
%
") %),
"32I*F;8>FD%9' '
"
!
"A),+$3 "-8 '2. .
"'
>,2!,+" " ."
5, '
"*5 " ;
9 .,
3 ".." ,3 " B"3 2
'
2 '
,3
-8'
5 C" " '
2 3 )3 0 1 ((2 3 ( $!& ! % &&+ 4 1 ,5 +((2 3 ( &&+ .4"/ 4 ( !632 " +2 % +
&% ( +73
% & ! 3 ( (%% # & ! , ( ( ! ( 3% #
% ( ( % ( % ( (% # 3 8
( ( ( 3 2 "
4 % 1 ( &&+ 4 9 !1 4 ( & ! # (% +73 4 + 4 4 % $!&'3&:;4 (( # # (% +
# (% ,5 ,5
# &
! 3 :
% ( '
% 4 ( # % ( : * B"3 2
'
23
3 3 )3 " - 0
!
" #$%
& !
"%' &
&''
()
"*"+,-,./+001- 2 ,0/../+001 *".3-.4/+005- 2 04/01/+0.0"
6 / %$/)
&''
7"
* -% '
'
$
'
" << ( 42 # (% 3 2 = # %% ( % =
'
% ,<> #
% ( :;4 2 ,
% , ??@531 %% ?> % : 2 ?<? ( :;4 %% #A #$% # &
% '
'
'
'
#$%# &"%'
'
'
"%'
'
' &''
'
' '
8( '( % # % (
7 :;4 2 % % %% ( &&+2 !142 +"42 ;'42 # & ! &
( ( 3 % (
% +73 # # << ( %%
( % # ! % % # % ' % ( % 5 (( % 2 % ( $!&'3&:;4 (( # # (% # 3 *
%
") %),
'3)3 "2 '2
"
35
'52 !
) 3$ '
3 35
3
6
'52"
5
3 ,2!,+ 3 $9
) 3;9 3 35
'3 , A), 3'
""
A)"
"
. "
5,!, '
9 !- 999 ,
# /3 2 3;
6 "'
'
2 B"3
2
'
,3 #
$'
3 3%
") %),
"- '2
$'
! 9' '35
3 3 6
9
) 39 .,
3!
"
".."5,8'
3 , %
") %),
.."5 3'
'
2'
,3
3'
.".
3 "
'
2 B"3'
,3 #
9 )3 " -
1' 8 )
)
'
+9"."+0..
..' 8 )
)
'
+."3"+0.+ % %
( ( ( '
.
/ % %
( ( ( '
.
/
?
! "# $% & '
( # ( )
!
"# $% & '
(
# ( )
3 %
% B
(
! 3 "# + $% ' #% 2 ( #
( )
B"3 2
3 3'
2 3;
6
2 '
,3 #
8'
"
5 C" '
3
."3)
3!
,9 - 3: ,6<<
* - % '
: ;
2 % % % 2 ( % # 2
% %% % %
(
% %% # #( ; # &
2 6: 6:
C &
( ( 9', $ '
"+ D) %
)"
,.
53 ) 3 3#
"9"3 3'
"
"
.+ 1"2
% ."%
") %),
: ),+3- ),+ " 3 "33.!+'
B"3 *5 ""
; 8'
""
2"32 3. 1"2
.,
3 2 3; "
'
2 B"3 2
; '
3
2$'
B"33
3 3." ., 3.'
1"2
3 ,%
") %),
;9 , 3
3 3'
9),3!
3 " ' .,
'
."5 '
3 '
1"2
% ."+
") 3 5
" '
)""
"
9,,!
& '
B"3 2
'
.."." 8'
5 C" )
'
2
B )3 " - %$)*(".+"9
)
6: % % +
%
( :;4 2 ,
2 ( ( % 5(
: "%D + 2 $% +
:;4 2 , %
% +73 % +
& 4 ( ( % 5( ' # % (
(
(
% '
%
(
# 6:
.)).!
"
'" B"3 2
8'
.
"5 ." 2 )3 " - 03
( # 2
% &
% ( ( 5 ( +73 % 6:
% ?<@?<? %
( % "& # % (
# %' &
'
)
" 3 % 2 ( % ( % ( +
& :% 4 4 ( 5( (( #
% % # #( 6: (
% * '" 25 ' .'
.". ,
,,9 - 0:
% ( (( ( 3 2 % # ( 9 ! " ( +
& ( ( * 2 3;
'
)!0
%
") %),
" - ),+ . 3 3) '
3 ." ,
2 ."
."
3 " 3 " B"3 '
2
G
-
: ;)
"
**$<6 $=>? ..+@ ( 5( # ( +73 # %
( % (
(
5(
% % % #( 6:
% ?<@?<? %
C% &
% ( ( #
( ( (( E
( # % ( 2 &
%
% # # % #( % % # #( % % <??<> 3 2 :;4 % ( %% +
& 4 ( ( % 5( # ,3 ( % ( %
+73 3 6: % <??<>2 % % %%
% +
& :% 4 4 3 ( % %% # % ( (
( % '
%
(
# 6:
# % 3 # ( % 2 # % +73 ( 5( (( 5( #
% #
% ( ! (
# +
& :% 4 4
55
+73 +
& 4 4 # +73 %
( % (( 1 +
& :% 4 42
(
#% % %
% ( % (
% (( #
#% 3 !
2
( %
(
:
% %
% +
& % ( % ( 2 ( :;4
3 #
% ( " + ( 3 ,3 (
% % +
& :% 4 4 3
( # 2 &
% % ( ( 5( +73 % 6: % ?<@?<?
%
( % "& # % (
# &
2 % ( : % 4 4 ( 5( % # &
2 % ( : # ( % # % ( : + &
%
% #
% ( #( %2 % ( : % 4 4 ( 5 "& # % 3 % :
( 1 2 ! ( 3% 2 % # % ( % ( 3 +732
% ( % % 5 ( C ( 4 4 ,2 ( % ( : ( 4 4
# ( %
3
B"3 2
."3)
!
,9 - ? % # &
2 6: ( %
"& # ( 4 4 ( % ; 2 &
2 6: % 2 +
& 4 # % ( 5(
2 # '( 2 %
# ( +
4 # %2 % # % ( : * ;
"
3 '
35 ' " ' ' 3
3
G
B"3 2
..,
,+." ,.
3) $9' '' "
5
3"
"
") "252'
3 , $' !
"
3'
35 ' '
"
") %),
.."5 3 !+ '
B"3 2
4
,) 3 3
"
,2 '
.
>2
>,
" , 9
,5 3!
& .!
+
!+'
3
B"3 2
3 3
8'
. ' '2 3
"'
. A)"
3!
,, 3!+3"
"
") 8') $ " '
35$ " ' '
3 '
''
") "),
.."5 3
$ ! 9' ' "
35
9
) 39 & .!
+
53
,)3 3
B"3 2
8')2''
3 3"),
9 .".
3$'
+'5 !
" ,,+.."5 3 " A)
9'
"'
.)"
)'
3 35
9''
3)
3 ) .
2 !
3 3 !
5,3'
"
)
J 6 "
.'
!
3 '53
,)
B"3 2
'
", ""
") %),
9 ,+& . !
+
8'
"),
9 '
""
.
, 3"'5 +!
"
.,
3!+ '
"
"),
8'
3 3"),
9 .,
3 ".."5,!
"
B"3 2
$9' ')'"
3'
'" & 3
B) "3
.."5 & 9"3K!
+
K K8 .""+ 5+L ) .
K MB, &K 9 "+'>3N8' '!+'
3
&
.'
", "%),
!
+
+'5 !
"
3)
C
8'
+"
." '
) !&$,+'
".
"9
"
) .
3 33'
+9 !
"
3.
32.."5,
9"),
$9' '.."5,' "!
"3 3 G 9' ," )9 3 3!+'
1)."
)"A"A " %"*" '
:.33B;B9133
5 9 '
,3' ,+!
)
'
*5 " '33 3 3'
5"),
33 ''
)"+"),
3 !, " 38,,'
"), 3 3'
C 2"),
9,,..,+ 8'
)"!
"5 3 )3 8," %
# (
! % % % %
2 % ( % % # % #
#
%2 ( 2 % % # % E ( % ( # % 2 % %2 ( % %
'
>@ ( &
+
#
%% #
%
: # ! % % % % % # % %%2 % % # ((% ' % ((% %
% #
#
(% #
# 2 ( 2
* .".
3"),
9 ".."5 3$ 3'
", "),
9 "
.
, 3!),+& .!
+
$)"5 9$'
3 12, 4)32 "2',+! 2' 3
'
", ""),
$ '
,3'
.. ..
,,!
2 '
A), ."
"!
3 "),
C 3'
' .. 3
#
335
),3,+ ) 3 .".
3'3 !
.."5 3 3'
35
9
9' ;' !
9 ,, 3',& )"
$9!'"
5 )) C ' $ 8 "#D #.33.:+; 5,.
A8 " )' ':+0.9;.11+,;"
B"3 2
&
.2 '
C 2"),
!
+
3 " "
.
,2'
"2'9+
),3'5 !
53;'
""
2) $,,'
.."5,
9"),
$ '
"!
)
3'
,)
B"3 2
$"
+" ,9$ ,, $'
", ""),
9),3'5 !
'
,3!
.., !, ."
5 )) $ . +'5 !
3
9 "),
,, !
29' ; ' $'
A), .), 3'
35
!+'
.
)'"+9),325 "'
B)
) ' '
'
8') 9 3 "'
"2) ")" ''
!
"),
$'
3 '
35
9),3 25 " '
""2) ")"''
312, 4)32 33 .
+9' '"),
9 .., !, $, ) !, "'
312, 4)32 ."
3 '
", ""),
!
2 .., !, B)9 3 "' "2) "
2"32'
3"
.. "
9'
" '
3 '
..
,, 9
.. 39',,
A) ,!
)"2"2) 3)
"'
..
,,' "
3
")
) 9'
"'
' '
"
A) C.
"
'
, 3 )!
.., 6 A)
C.
"
) '
9".
3' !
"
3,+"2) $!""2 .
2"
." 9"
'
- 9 3.".
. ' A)
.,+
6 "
, 3, 2,. ''
!
+'
"3
.
3 '
"),
F35
'
"
5 3 " "
&2
C.
"
9),3!
, 3
. ..,
,''52 )3'
..
,,!
,2!, 3'
.. '52!
3 $'
.."." 3"
9),3'5
!
3"
'
3 "'
'
9".
" ".. )!0
' ), ,,2'
3 C.
"
3'
" " ,5 " G 8') $9',
" 2'
3
312, 4)32 A)
2 3
..
,,$9 3 +'
3"
'
.."
9'
" '
3 9'
..
,,9 .. 39',,
A) ,!
; 3$'
3"
3 3 "'
"
".. )!0
' ), ,,2'
3
C.
"
3'
" " ,5 " 8'
3
!
"" 3) 9' ' 3
. ' "3 " ;
'
), ,,
A) 3$' .. 9),3!
9'
" '
3
9'
'
..
,,9 .. 3D 9),3!
, 3,,
A) , !
.""
"
.+3,,9
..
, 33 .
3
"32,+ 90 : 9 00 :
&,& $& 72
2 '
" .
&2F"
O
F '
"% ."!,
O