← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4835/2017allowed

The New India Assurance Co Ltd v. Sursati Devi & ORS

2018-12-19Mr. Justice Avneesh Jhingan5 pages

           !" #"$%&%'()  *+

 

 ! 

""! # $!%#!& ' ! ( )  *+   $!%#!& 

""! # %',!& ' ! ,( - ., /0/  1"&"'!( ,11 #""2345 16#7$ !" 1!8" 22"99 '!%'

 '# 11"&2'#"'! %'  :)   ,&;! 8 ;416#7$ !" 1!8" 22"99 '!& %' :)    -..$/0/120(") 8" < 1## !"# 62 &&"#=>!8",!1$$%#"'!

9 %5&1%=4' 968 '#%? 18* 1&81!6-!8"1%=4' 9-+8 &=""' && %9"#=> !8"%'&41"1 7"8%$9"=" 1%'?1"?%&!1 !%',@@@

*8"1"%'

!"1 1"

"11"#! &-!8"

"'#%'?7"8%$9"-+ '#=>!8"$9 %5 '!&="%'? ??1%"7"# A4 '!45 $52"'& !%' < 1#"#4'#"1/"$!%':: !8",!1 0"8%$9"&$!6) * 1&81!6-!8"$!-+ &=!8!8" 22" 9& 1%&" 15!8"& 5" < 1# '# 15& 5"

$$%#"'!6!8"&" 1"="%'?#%&2&"# => $55'1#"1

1%"

$!&'"$"&& 1> 1 #B4#%$ !%' !8"21"&"'! 22" 9& 1"

!8 !' :6!49345 1/8 15 < &?%'?'8%&=%$>$9"68%& 1%"'#@ B%!/8 15 < & 2%99%'1%#"1C8"'!8">1" $8"#'!8"#%7%#%'?1 #

/"$!1& D

6!8"=%$>$9"< &&!14$;=> 1 &89> '#'"?9%?"'!9>#1%7"'

"'#%'?7"8%$9"& 1"&49! !8"%52 $!6!49345 1/8 15 &4

"1"# ?1%"74&%'B41%"&68"< &! ;"'!7"1'5"'!,"#%$ 999"?"E&2%! 96 /"$!1

68 '#%? 186<8"1"8"&4$$45="#!%'B41%"& :# !"#

:< &1"?%&!"1"# $9 %52"!%!%'< & %9"#=>!8"2 1"'!& '#!<&%&!"1& !8"

#"$" &"#8"1%=4' 96 !"1$'&%#"1%'?!8" $!& '# 221"$% !%'?!8"

"7%#"'$" ##4$"#68"9#!8 !!8" $$%#"'!< &$ 4&"##4"!!8"1 &8 '# '"?9%?"'!#1%7%'? !8"

"'#%'?7"8%$9"8"<'"16#1%7"1 '#!8"%'&41"1 !8"

"'#%'?7"8%$9"<"1"8"9#B%'!9> '#&"7"1 99>9% =9"!2 >!8" $52"'& !%'8"1%=4' 9 < 1#"# &45  6D@ 9'?<%!8 %'!"1"&!F G2"1 ''458" 54'! < 1#"#%'$94#%'? 66D@ 1 9&&

"$!%' '#

6D@ 1 4'"1 9"H2"'&"& '!8"$9 %52"!%!%'6%!< &29" #"#!8 !!8"#"$" &"#< & >" 1&  ?" '#< & &!4#"'! ,"$8 '%$ 9'?%'""1%'?*81""" 1

%295  41&"+  %'  8 %  , '%  /%'?8  9>!"$8'%$  99"?"6  > 9241 6

!8%'# $"1!% %$ !"*H+< &21#4$"#8"1%=4' 9 &&"&&"#!8" 5'!89>" 1'%'? !8"#"$" &"# & 6D@6 G 4!41"21&2"$!&<"1"

< 1#"#6I#"#4$!%'< &5 #" @"H2"'&"& '#549!%29%"1  < & 229%"# " 1#9" 1'"#$4'&"9 1!8"2 1!%"&62"14&"#!8"2 2"1=;

'#!8"1"9"7 '!#$45"'!&21#4$"#=>!8"5 8"1"%&'#%&24!"="!<""'!8"2 1!%"&<%!81"? 1#!!8" $!

!8 !  !8"  #"$" &"#   < &    >" 1&  9#6  < &   &!4#"'!    ,"$8 '%$ 9

'?%'""1%'?*81""" 1 %295 41&"+6 1I#"#4$!%'5 #" @ "H2"'&"& '#549!%29%"1 229%"#   ." 1'"#$4'&"9 1!8"%'&41"1$'!"'#&!8 !!8"#"$" &"#< & 5"1"9> &!4#"'! '#< &'!" 1'%'? '>!8%'?6!8" 1%=4' 9"11"#%' &&"&&%'?8%&5'!89>" 1'%'? & 6D@%&?1%"7 '$"%&!8 ! G 4!41"

21&2"$!&8 7"<1'?9>=""' < 1#"#" 41!8"1$'!"'#&!8 !' 54'!

$ '=" < 1#"# 19&&

"$!%'8" 54'! < 1#"# 1

4'"1 9"H2"'&"&%&'!8"8%?8"1&%#" ." 1'"#$4'&"9 1!8"$9 %5 '!&&4=5%!&!8 !!8"#"$" &"# < &241&4%'?8%&'?%'""1%'?68"'$"6!8"1%=4' 9"11"#%' &&"&&%'?8%& 5'!89>  " 1'%'?6  <8%$8  %&  "7"'  9"&&  !8 '  !8"  5%'%545  < ?"&    '

4'&;%99"#9 =41"1"1?1%"7 '$"%&!8 !' 54'!8 &=""' < 1#"# 1 9&& "&! !" 8"#"$" &"#< &>" 1&9# !!8"!%5"  $$%#"'!!< & #49>217"#!8 !8"< &241&4%'?8%&&!4#%"&%' %295 41&"!<49# ="4'

%1!"A4 !"8%5<%!8 '4'&;%99"#9 =41"1"8 # =1%?8! 4!41"

8" #8"4'

1!4' !"2 1"'!&<88 7"9&!!8"%1>4'?$8%9#6' 54'! 5'"! 1>$52"'& !%' < 1#"#!!8"2 1"'!&%&"'4?8 1!8"9&& &4

"1"#=>!8"57"'!8"'!8"41!& 1"#4!>@=4'#! 11%7" !B4&! '# "A4%! =9"$52"'& !%'8"'9>$8"$;!=";"2!%&!8 !%!&849#'!=" <%'# 99 1!8"$9 %5 '!& 3""2%'?%'7%"<!8" $!& !8"$ &"6%!<49#=" 22121% !"! 1"9>42'!8"5%'%545< ?"&21"7 9"'!%'!8"/! !" !!8"!%5"  $$%#"'!

1#"!"15%'%'?!8"%'$5" !8"#"$" &"#3""2%'?%'7%"<!8"' !41"

&!4#%"& !8"#"$" &"#6%!%&#""5"# 22121% !"!8 !8"%&"A4 !"#<%!8 &;%99"#9 =41"18"5%'%545< ?"& 1 &;%99"#9 =41"1 !!8"!%5"

 $$%#"'!< &   6 ) D@1$ 9$49 !%'2412&"&6 5%'%545< ?"& 1" 14'#"#

 & 6)D@2"15'!8 8"$'!"'!%'1 %&"#=>9" 1'"#$4'&"9 1!8"%'&41"1!8 !!8"

1%=4' 9  "11"#  %'  < 1#%'?  G  4!41"  21&2"$!&  #"&"17"&  $$"2! '$"  7%'?#4"1"? 1#!!8"#"$%&%'& !8"/421"5"41!%' !"



 !#3$!&!&6' $   '#/ ',#!"

 !2  ( )3 ' 6 G 4!41"21&2"$!& 1"!=" < 1#"#8"$9 %5 '!& 1""'!%!9"#!  6D@" $8 1 4'"1 9"H2"'&"& '# 19&& "&! !" 54'!%&! =" < 1#"# 19&&

"$!%' '  7%"<    !8"  =7"  #%&$4&&%'6  !8"  $52"'& !%'  %& 1"$ 9$49 !"# &4'#"1( 

     ,'!89>%'$5" !8"#"$" &"# &&"&&"#  6)D@ G 4!41"21&2"$!&  :D@ /4=! 9  6:D@ I#"#4$!%' "H2"'&"& :6 D@ ,49!%29%"1  *:6 H H +  6 6: D@ 4'"1 9"H2"'&"&  6D@ .&& "&! !"

 6D@ ! 9$52"'& !%' < 1#"#  6 6: D@ 8" < 1## !"# %&5#% %"#!!8""H!"'!!8 !!8"

54'! < 1#"#  6D@%&1"#4$"#! 6 6: D@ '!8" 22" 9 %9"#=>!8"%'&41"16 !!8"!%5" '!%$"

5!%'62 >5"'!=">'# 66D@< &&! >"#8"$9 %5 '!&&8 99="

"'!%!9"#!!8"= 9 '$" 54'! 9'?<%!8%'!"1"&!F G2"1 ''45 15 !8"# !" %9%'? !8"$9 %52"!%!%'!%991" 9%& !%' !8" 54'!

!8!8" 22" 9& 1"#%&2&"# %'!8" 1"& %#!"15& (-..$/0/1) 04%1. )  5;

C8"!8"1&2" ;%'?D1" &'"#( "&D C8"!8"11"21! =9"( "&D