High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/3872/2012allowed

Ajit Singh v. Gajraj Singh & ORS

2018-01-17Mr. Justice Arun Monga11 pages

!"##$%&%'(!')!*+ , -%"%'./ 00#11!'"

2#*&)& !-*!-%'./ "/#*& #&0'3#'"& !

"#$%& '( )* & *)+%

*#&#'"( *4!*.!*5!'!,36$!"#5%"/ &#/!#5!',36$!"#, *"/#!00#11!'" *4)16%*!*5!1,36$!"#, *"/#*#&0'3#'"& 77777 *)+%,' 89: /#0*#&#'"!00#!1/!&;##'0*##**#3!.!%'&""/#-)3.<#'"& !'3 3#$*##& ;"/ "/# )*"& ;#15, 5/#*#;+ "/# &)%" %1#3 ;+ "/# *#&0'3#'":01!%'"%&$1!%<%'."/#115%'.*#1%#,/!3;##'3#$*##3;+ ;"/"/#)*"&;#15(:

#*#!33*#&&%'.!*.)<#'"&'!00#!1,!';-#$"%'/!&;##'

"!>#';+*4)16%*!*5!1,1#!*'#3$)'&#1*"/#*#&0'3#'":01!%'"%& 5%"/*#.!*3""/#<!%'"!%'!;%1%"+"/#!00#!1'"/#0*#<%&#"/!"-%" %'.//!33%#3'

,5/#*#!&"/#!00#!1,!&0#*"/#<#< 0!*"%#&,5!&%1#3)'3#*"/#'!<#-%"%'./!'3,"/#*#*#,!'+!00#!1 %1#3 ;+ ! 3#!3 0#*&' 5)13 '" ;# <!%'"!%'!;1# ' &)00*" /%& $'"#'"%',/#/!&*#1%#3)0'"/#3#$%&%'*#'3#*#3;+"/#%6%&%'#'$/ "/%&)*"%'-.

/01211 0 3 0

/01, 45*6 78 9"$'"#'3"/!""/#0*6%&%'& *3#* )1# *#!35%"/#$"%'& ?

!'3 ?!'3 *3#* )1#&!'3

"/#%6%1

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

6%"!'3 "/#2!>!1!"'<!*%.%'!11+%1#3!1'.5%"/"/#!00#!1"&/5"/!""/# &%.'")*#&!*#-!+4)<!*!'3'"-%"%'.//#5*3=-%"%'./@ )'3#*"/#&%.'")*#%&'";+"/#!00#11!'",;)"0*;!;1+;+"/#$1#*>)'3#* "/#%<0*#&&%'"/!"2!>!1!"'<!;*#"/#&%.'")*#-%"%'./5*"#%';*!$>#" #!"/$#*"%%$!"#-%"%'.

/!&;##' !''#A#3!&

''#A)*#:

!'3,"/)&,&);<%""#3"/!""/#!00#!15)13;#<!%'"!%'!;1# /#!$"&!&#<!'!"#3*<"/#-)3.<#'"$%"#3;+*4)16%* !*5!1,%#,-.#1 11 ,5!&"3#"#*<%'#!B)#&"%'!&" 5/#"/#*"/#!00#!1%1#3%'"/#'!<#!0#*&',5/5!&3#!3'"/#3!+ "/#!00#!15!&%'&"%")"#3,$)13$'"%')#;+0#*<%""%'./%&C &";# &);&"%")"#3*'"!'3;+*##**%'."!11"/#-)3.<#'"&*#1%#3)0';+"/# *#&0#$"%6#$)'&#1%' !*!& 8!'3 ?*#'3#*#3"/#%'3%'.&!&)'3#*(:

!"#$

"%&'('

)

' ,-./0 "'('

' ,

' 4 555

0 .

"%&'('

: "%9

/ )

8 ":5;5":%

0 .

8 '

1 2<

= =

2 7

= 2=

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

)1# =0 &>;?1 @

5 >"?

)

< A

;%5 ;5"::;( ///>.$?;%&5'

< A

;"5;5"::;B (":C $5 >&? 0 # !@

5 >"?

) DE <$0&:F'%F":G F$";;% ""5#5":

%H >

5 >#?>%?

>C? 0 #,--//1 !>#? /

)

!>%? 9

5 >#? '

0*%<! !$%# "/!" /!3 "/# 1#.!1 *#0*#&#'"!"%6#;##''"/#*#$*3!3%#*#'"*#&)1"<%./"/!6# ;##'*#!$/#3%'"/#&)%"@ = /#0*6%&%'&#$"%'?"/#'3%!'C%<%"!"%'$"

D 9D &/!11!001+"!001%$!"%'&)'3#*&);:*)1# 8 @

*!11%'"#'"&!'30)*0&#&,%"1#!6#&'<!''#*3);""/!" !& 0#* "/# !<#'3<#'" $!)&#3 %' "/# !*#&!%3 0*6%&%'& "/#%6%1

*$#3)*#3#,#6#'"/)./'!001%$!"%'*;*%'.%'.'*#$*3"/#C & !3#!30#*&''*#$*3%&%1#3,"/#&)%"&/!11'"!;!"#!'3"/#-)3.<#'"

5 $!';#0*')'$#3'"5%"/&"!'3%'./%&3#!"/5/%$/&/!11/!6#"/#&!<# ##$"!&%%"/!&;##'0*')'$#3;#*#"/#3#!"/">01!$#!'3"/# $'"*!$";#"5##'"/#3#$#!&#3!'3"/#01#!3#*%'"/!"#6#'"&/!11$'"%')# "&);&%&"/)&,"/#;-#$"%',%'<+6%#5,%&5%"/)"!'+;!&%&!'3&!'& <#*%"!'3"/#&!<#%&/#*#;+*#-#$"#3/#!001%$!"%';#!*%'.89: 8%&!115#3/#C &!*#!1&;*)./"'*#$*3/#!00#!1%&,"/)&, /#13<!%'"!%'!;1#

C#!*'#3 #'%* )'&#1 * !00#11!'":3##'3!'" &);<%""#3 "/!" "/# *#&0'3#'"& %'&"%")"#3 "/# &)%" * $1!%<%'. "/# !*#<#'"%'#3*#1%#'"/#0*#<%&#"/!""/#+!*#&);&#B)#'"0)*$/!&#*&;+ 6%*")#!<*".!.#3##3 ?8 9 A :9 '#<"##"!E!"%!/!3 <*".!.#3"/#0*0#*"+%'3%&0)"#6%3#<*".!.#3##33!"#3

A : "/)''%C!1&'!/!; !<!'3"/#"%<#0*#&$*%;#3"/#*#%'

**#3#<0"%'5!&%A#3!&9+#!*&!%3/)''%C!13%#3!'3/%&C & /!3!1&#A#$)"#3<*".!.#3##33!"#3 ?8 9 A :9 %'!6)*"/# *#&0'3#'":01!%'"%&/#!*#<#'"%'#3<*".!.#3##33!"#3 ?8 9 3%3 '" 0*#&$*%;# !'+ 0#*%3 * *#3#<0"%' ' "/%& *#.!*3, /# 3*#5 !""#'"%'"/%&)*"""/#"*)#"*!'&1!"#3$0+"/#!*#<#'"%'#3 <*".!.#3##3"&);<%""/!""/#&)%"&##>%'.3#$1!*!"%'<*".!.#*%./"& %'6%#5"/#-)3.<#'"*#'3#*#3;+"/#'F;1#)0*#<#)*"%' 3 0 -;

/0 01 //3<1211 0 -

/01, :

4 - / 11 9 5)13 '" ;# <!%'"!%'!;1# !'3, "/#*#*#,"/#&);&"!'"%!1B)#&"%'1!55)13!*%&#!&"5/#"/#*"/#&)%" &##>%'.3#$1!*!"%'"/!""/#<*".!.##&%'0)*&)!'$#""/#&);&#B)#'" <*".!.#3##3/!3;#$<#5'#*&5%'.""/##1)A"%<#!'3,"/)&,

)*.#&"/!""/#115%'.&);&"!'"%!1B)#&"%'&1!5!*%&#*3#"#*<%'!"%' ;+"/%&)*"(:

I ;?

I &?

I #?

I %?

@ '

"%#"

:& >B(;:?

I C?

/0 ;GG ( 4

>3 9 ?

0 J

E$0 I

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

"/#0!0#*;> /# "#*<& !'3 $'3%"%'& "/# <*".!.# 3##3 3!"#3

9 A : #'6%&!.%'."/#*#3#<0"%'"/#<*".!.#5%"/%'! 0#*%39+#!*&!*#'"%'3%&0)"#,;)"*!3-)3%$!"%'"/#$'"*6#*&+ %'/!'3,%"5)13;#%'"/#%"'#&&"/%'.&"#A"*!$""/#<*".!.#3##3 3!"#3 ?8 9 A :9 ,"/#*#1#6!'"0*"%'5/%$/*#!3&"/)&(: =';

"%#"

:& @$

@F'

K =

0FE

J 7 ) (

(

8 == 7

"F#

"%:% "" )

J 7 )

(

$ 8

F$ $

0 = 0F J 7 ) (

L M

(

' J ))

$ 8

";"

> )?

"%"

0 GGF5

6 0#GGF5

$ $

$ = $

10 = F

J 7 ) (

( 8 ==

E 0;GGF5' ==0 0;GGF5 K =

"%:%9 ""9 )

M L

;#G ;#&5;#% ;# 5;%G5":C5":

"::5;GG5;G#5;G%5;"5;"5;"

5;;G5;#C5;;"5;;;5;;& ;;C5 ;%%5;C&5;C#5;C% ;

"5;"%5;"C5;"#5;# 5K=

5;%&5;;G K=

5;# 5;#:5":

#G 1 ) )

;% 1< 0

"% "

0 #;

$ $

> )?

K) $

9 ' K F

K =

1 9 $

FK $

0 =

J))

K $

$0 8 == /#$'"#'"&"/#!.*##<#'")'#B)%6$!11+*#6#!1"/!"%'$!&# "/#*%.%'!15'#*,*#B)%*#&"/#1!'3.%6#'%'<*".!.#,%"$!';#*#3##<#3 '0!+<#'""/#<*".!.#<'#+,"/#*#*#,"/#!*.)<#'"*!*5!1 "/!""/#!*#<#'"%'#33$)<#'"$!''";#*#!3!&!<*".!.#3##3;)"! &!1#3##3%&5/11+<%&01!$#3!'3%&/#*#;+*#-#$"#3 *".!.# 3##3 A :9 3#& '" &0#$%+ !'+ "%<# * *#3#<0"%'"/#<*".!.#3##3/#'F;1#)0*#<#)*"%' 3 0 -#1 11 ,/#13!&)'3#*(:

!;" @

0 =

N $

C; 7(

&G ;;@

C; 7(

C" $ .

;&,

) ( =

4 '

) 4 ( 4 '

0 >?7.00

$)0 > ?

5 7 '$#'"%<#/!&;##'0*#&$*%;#3%'"/#<*".!.#3##3,%'<+ 6%#5,"/#<*".!.*%&'"0*#6#'"#3*<&##>%'."/#*#3#<0"%'!&"/#*# %&'1%<%"!"%'*&##>%'.*#3#<0"%'&0#*"/#%'3%'.&<%'#,"/# !*#<#'"%'#3!$"*&/!6#'";##'"!>#'%'"$'&%3#*!"%';+"/#)*"&

;#15!'3,"/#*#*#,"/#*#%& %11#.!1%"+!'3 0#*6#*&%"+ #&)1"!'"1+,"/# B)#&"%'1!5*!<#3, %&!'&5#*#3%'!6)*!00#11!'":3##'3!'" !'3 !.!%'&" "/#*#&0'3#'":01!%'"%&/#!00#!1%&!115#3/# -)3.<#'"&!'33#$*##&"/#)*"&;#15!*#/#*#;+&#":!&%3#,%#,"/#&)%" "/#*#&0'3#'":01!%'"%&&"!'3&3%&<%&&#3 ' =, *)+%

-10 '(;>& +0/01?3 @1

A1@

+0/0 /8!

A1@