Anshiv Berry v. Panjab University And Others
!
"# $
%&'
() *'+,-,(.!/ 0
0
1&
%
3 # 4 4
6 4 3"" 7 4 $ " % 43""
5
4 88888
9 "5
"
!
"# "$%
&#''()*+
(
,
-./. 0 ! "
# 4 : " "
" " "#"
(* :
# 6 . (*
"
#
(*
; ../. " $ $ 5
(
&) * " 5
' ! " #
$
% & ' ( )*+ ( "
) ! "# ,
- & . " /((0+ +)1 #. .-- & % $
"$ & 29 0 --# 0
* - 0 '-- $ '
' &# ' &# 3 +
3 +
3 -
4
/ (
/ 3 -
4
% & -# ' )*+ ( "
) ! 3 -
3 -
$ $ # 3 3 +
/ 5 (*
" $ $%
#
" # .+./. 9
"# " -./.5 5 5 5 "
:
" (*
" # "
5
5
(* ;/./.
""5 6 ) 7&'8.'$ . - & -
$ # -# -# '
" .
. -
$ # - - -$ # - - "
/ :' :! 00: 46 ; #
" + +
# )*+ &
- &# #- " -
$ # --# ,
# 3 -
$ # $
0 3 -
8&
$ #+
"
<. - & # - #" # - '8 5 (* 9
... ""5 5
- &# ! . *8 = =. 3 .
$ # + 0 " . 8&
$ #> 3 - - . 3 +
. 8&
$ #. ! ". -
! 6 $ . & : & " <. # <
-
+
$ - # -
- . :'0 00: :!46 00:;#
" & < - $
. - & -
-$ #- -
5 " (* 9
<..< ""5 #
? $ -
? $ - - &# ! 0< " " -- ,
- &#
$ # - $ &#@'@3 -
@:@3 - -
-
- -- - ,-# . -9 $ & --
( . - & " "$ $ -- . " " % .
. - & -$ #
8&
$ # 0 ( # !- -. ! ". :'00: :!46 0 00: ;#
" #& < - $
. # #& " $
0 AAB5
6
"
A 5
# ,1%2 34 45,--,(.-
< '
" B" 43 # 4 B
: C "
# # # $% &= $ "
"" ././.
& ) 9
5 5 "
! "
$%
"
.+./. 5 ""
"5 # :"# "
:
5 5 :
"
" '
"
5
"
#
""
" # # (* /./.
.
..
..
<.. < 5
""
#
" "
# " #
"
> ! ; #
5
? #
" @ @ #
"
5 " " 9 "
"
" "
0 % #
3 ( "
3 +
!- +C 4' 4 2 31') ) /( (/*1+ ) % 31)%.
8&
$ #! C 9+4-- -D # - -$ * " - " -
)B " & -- -
- !-# "
'))1E *12*9 9D % ) D .'))1E *12 F &# 3+ + -
$ # $
" --
#$
)*+ "#5 % # #5 " B4 4
& ) 5
"
" "
$
& :3
$% &=
$ "
#
#
5 # " # '
"
5 5 5 $<(D
"4
*
" "
#
" '
"
" A
$% ! C ; # # " 5
+ @ "
"
7,5'
-- -3'
# # 5 5 5 $% ! & #
5 &
) 5
5 "
# # # $% &=
$ "
5 C ""././. .%28-,- E "
# "
&
" & ) 5
$< (D
" 4
* C "
# # # $ $% &= $ "
"" ././.
& 3
E "
& )
" 5 C
" # # # 5 5 "
" $% &=
$ "
9 "
# #
C
"
# "
" "
5 "": "
# "
#
## 5 # " C C E 9 " : & ) 5 (
$< : D " 4
* "
A ! #
" ; ##
# "
#
# B # D
(
$< D " 4
*B
"
" # "
> > " "
5 " # 4 #
(*
C " "
#
# 5 A "
# C
5 "
"F5 5 #
""
" F F
#
9
# : 5 5 5
"
"
5"
5 & # "
5
4 5" 5""
"
" $
" 6
#
" "
#
C 5 5" ## #
5 "
"
" " $% ! 1"> "
"
"
"
"# " -./. - 9
#
# /./. ...
.
"
5
#
""
" 0
<..<
#
""
'
5= "
- 5"
#
!
"
#
$ %!! $
&
'() " 5
B ? - < - "
#. "
$ - - # -
7::%
. 8 .
&
$
4 -
# -
-
- & $
' G" :
6
& - !
%** +,
* - -
./0 12%033 420-
7 2 F ,,,,,,,,,,,,,( & 8 -- #$ $
& "&
- "+ & - 8- " & 8" ,
"- " # - - - -
8 - + . "
-
"
" .&" "
#
& .
& & < & & $
# - # #8 & " - - . - -$
-# $ . $ - &
8 99&8
. . &
"4 8 )
- #
- < -
! + " - . - , .&
- -
" 8
* " -
" . $ $ --
& #? -- < " " # &# - # 8 " "# #
. . # . < "
H $
$ -
&
- "- $ & -#& # ,,,,,,,,,,, ,,,,5 ( .($ G" :
6
& - ! 6 ./0
2%03 33 420-" "
"
-
. 2 B * -
8 # D;9 9DI ' ;# $ - &# ? #-
9
#& - " + $
&#@&
' 6"
-
- - )& . %& - -$ 8 " &#
"$ -
+ # < " -
. # -$ " $ # -& # #& -
,,,,,,,,,,,,,5 F ' &$ . - - # - 7:: " . " &
- &# # ! % " #
"- $ "& < &# -
% -
).
- $ "& "
. - &# ! !? 9D DDA9I K - &#
$ 4 -
) -
9 #'
8 . # 4 # -
# # #+ & $ # - -
-
& $ "- 7:: " > $ # & -$ $ 4 -&9 $ & H + & ". . #
> $ # - . < - & + & & " " $ . -
)> - - + . & - $ # " # - & - 5 - = # "
9 :* 6 %*8 #
$%!! $
" + "
> 1 #
. - # $ 9 " /& #
8 ( ' . # . $ " $ # % J1 #J" * J J."" "
#. &. -- % 8 6" ! . ' I A !
& + . "
" 8
!
,
#.
" 8 -
% . , " ,
# 8 . #
& " - - &
8 .&" - $
8 . $ . " #-- $
- % #. $ -
" # . 8
$
- $
& 1 #. - " < . - " -$ $ &
-.-- .--
% -- "
- . & -- - # &
8 ? - #.& # "& . " #
. $ "-&
$ # . #
$ & &8 -- - # & - ( . "- - & --
"
&8
$ 8 % ! . " 8 .
"-
" #. & $ $ " " " - %. "
. " . < "
& & ,- -" . # & -- -
&
$ 8 $ " #--
G
$
"
" " -
- % , "$& 4 - 8 -- - $"
". " # - -
- & -#
&
$ 8 '"--
& - - 8 %
-- #.
8 $ .
$ - - - & " "
& &8 $ " # <1". ,
& 8 . ! 4
- $
"
. - # . -
.
& & "
% ! < "#- 9 $ &$ $ &
$ 8 + . --. " #
!!
" - $. & " "& 8
% 8 . . &
8 ,& 8 # .& &# -
" 5 -< C
A5" # /./. ..
.. <..< "
"
" # 0 " "
" "
# 5
5 5" # "
" ! "
" " " # "
9
" ! 0 5 "
0 5" "
"
5
2
G # 5
#
"
# C
(*9 # !
# # " #
# "
# 9 "
"
5#"
"
!
""
5 !
"
"
! " "
5
#
#
1 ". "
"
"# C C
C ! "
# #
""5
# "
!
" #
" " '+,-,(.
/
5
5 ""5 # (*
"# "
-./.! C
" "
0
" "
/./. -.. "
#
<..<
"
> 9
#
A 5
! ! " (*
" (*
"" "
(*
" " #"
" ##
"
< '8#
$
"
$
.+ @
A &
H @
" H