High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/402/2016allowed

Siri Bhagwan And ORS. v. State Of Haryana And ORS.

2024-05-27Mr. Justice Sanjeev Prakash Sharma,Mrs. Justice Sudeepti Sharma18 pages

!" #$$%% &' ( ) #$

*+ #$$%% &' ,'%$

! -". '! #$ / !

)0!$%

! # &'

*+ #$ !

"#$"

& ,'1 # &'

*+ #$ % &

''(

)''

' ''

2 ' 0 3+%4 $'+3%4 *+4 22 5

! 4 5+ 2 ' %, 422 5'4 23'2 '42&,'14

$ 67

2 "% 4 5+ 23'44 $$%%

$/4

2 '5 8

! 3 %%4 2, 9 144 $

67/:;

< =' +) %%+ 9'!1 :

4 "

%5+,'%$

! - ." %%"5+

!% " $ '5)$"

1 9' 5$1 611% ><

9'!1

1 1

!% < 1" %%!5+ " ?,'%$

! 5 '$16'6 %$$%/ /

" 5+ '$16'5 ! 11' % "

%%! 1 ) $ 1 !

!%0'!" 7 4 4 %'% %!

< % $ %%"

!='

! "# $

#%& ' (

)

# $

### $ # $

/ $

+, / '% %+ ' " 611( $!'%='

' 1 " % 611% > $' $%! < + 611 $$$%+ 1 611% >"!5+ !@;

;:: ' 5+ 1 % $1 1 *+% 611>< !@ " ' !1 43%1 4< ! @$ 6116+ 5+*+31 11 :

) ' 1 $1 1 $%+< '4"

"1='

' $,'%$

! A$ A$ 4 "! 5

$5+ %

!%0'!)

1 '5

%%+9' % "

% 1'591"

$ !" '% $$$% <

!% 6' %%" " %+ !9'!1$5+ >'%% 6' ;;;- . 6< 9'!1 '$1 6'

- /. 66/ <

!% %'

,'%$

! ' "'%

+ =' %5

"'% '5 %5% 1 $ <

!% % 111 !

%" ,'%$

! %5$1 '5)$ $41%+4 611% >

$$%"

5 " ,'%$

! -$

."$$ 65% *+% 611 % > ;;

!"8 1 +4

" %!"

%$% $ 8'%*" ' $1 *65%"

1 @

4 9' -$:

: :.

611 % > " $1 8 '5 )$*"

1 $ *65%"

1/ :

, %" ' $1

'5)$

% ! , %

< $$%% $$%5 !

"$1*65%"

1 ; ;; 611% >$" B,'%$

! 4 " $ /-$$%% 5' +"$1 % '5)$ 611(

% " B,'%$

! "$1

/ "

%"8 ! , %

: )67

/4$+ $ =' ! 1$'!

/ "

% 1 +%%=' %5

$ 611 !$"

9' "9>' $+ $

$5 $1 1 '5)$?

)$ 1 9' 5$1 ; )67/:;

4$ & ,'1% 18 % $+ < $ " %% 65% 6117 ! / ;::*$$ $ " %6' + ;;*"5'! $1 % 6

/ ;;*"$1*65% : / ;;@

; ;;:4 % 611 7 ! " 5 < 4 $ " 5%+ 16117 ! % < ! $ $9'

14" ! / + 1 51

5% 6117 !4! '$1 '$ 8 )$< +"$ % '% $ " "8' 9' '5)$

< " ?,'%$

! % !!! '51 $$%

! 1 $% 6116 $1 ! 8 '5)$ 5' "8 $$% < 4 1 $$% @54

5 ! $ 611 ( 5' 9' $:

5$1 8

'5)$*%!A1$% $ 4"

% 5 8'%%!"

15' 5 58611( $1 '5 )$

< =' " $ B ,'%$

! "4 "49

! + 5 ' ! " !@;?

;:: $ $1$ ! 6117 !< " 4 4$+ =' !

" 5+ " $%%$+ $1 1 '5)$"

1 9' 5$15+ ! 1 $% 1 +$1

$%+"

%5 % $$ $+ )"'51 " "!5+ !@ ;?

;::"

5 ' 1 *+% 611>)" ' % '! $ 5 % < 6117 ! %

5$''!" %6'*+% 1+4 2 '5! %%6117 !5' !

$ 6'4 "58 % 8'% ! / +/

$ !@4%% 65%4" ! / +4 5 "

! *+% 6 '15

% 5 1 !@ % 1 1 '

+4"

%'$ /

/ ) " ' / 65% %% 5 % 1) " "'% % 6117 ! $1 %

'% $$%%? $ '51 " %%! < 4 5$1*65% %"

! $% * $ $1 '5)$ %"

$% +

/ 5 %%" ' ' %%! $1 " $$%%< $

!@ %5 %%!5+ " 5%%"

81%+5' ' !5 !

! " $1 " ! $$%%

) * 65% " %% 65% 611>4% $'"

%6' %%611>+ ' ?< + 611>! 5

%' !$1 '$ 8 '5)$ 611> % ) % $ " $ 41%+4$ /$$ $1 %'

1611>!%% ' $1 %5

1 611>$:4 4

1 611( 4"

%$;

" ' 5'"% 1 611>

: "%%$ 5 %"

! 8'%5' 1=' '

! 611 ! 3%$ 1586117 ! $1 5 ; 54 4 $1

< $ 6%' % ! ?

> ! 1 !5%" 1 / + !) % ' ! + /4 ;65%" '

611>' ! $ 1

:4 %/ :65%4" "'

+ /4" $% 5'" 1$+'+ 611 > @' 1 65% " % $ 1 < 4 ;

65% 1 $% 5 8 $' 611>4 "4 % 5 "

$% 65% 5% 611 > +

/4 4 " 55'! $' 1 $% 4 %%5$ '

1 ' ) % " 9'!1$ !" #$%&'(&&)* + 4

4 $4 " " "

' =' !4 58$ 5+"

' :

% !

! +'$ 8 '5 )$"

1+4 45' %% )? ) " 5 1!

; $1 ?

1 ='

A +%+

) % 1 A $" ' %/ ; 6 ' ) "

;

- . *+%

4 '% 5 1

< 1%+" +'%

: < %

!%0'! 4 "4 ! $ ' >'%% 6' C -'$. "=' D

# #

# #' -#

# # +,

; < %

!%0'!%% E -'$.4" " %' .%+ $

#'/ '

# #

) $

# + 0 )$

$ # 0 ) #(" " )

#+' 1#

)

1 ) $

23+4%5.5*6617*""" .&+8+6&.&+,

< 1%%'$ '$16'< $A6' ! '$45'

#) #

# ) #/

9 ##

) #: ) ; # # 9 + <

) $ #) 9 #

# +( $

/#: ) ;

: ) ;

)

+" #: ) ;

: ) ; # 9 +,

) 58!'4"

%%"

! '"

5 -.

7 611% > $

" "'%5 ='% ! + $1 " %+ '

611( F -5. 7 $ " "! '%%+ 58611% >

F -. 7 " " %5 $1 $ '5)$ " $:

"$1

-. 7 " %5 $1 611 % > $

'5)$ 1 9' " $1"

-. 7 ! @ ; ;:: "

%% ! ! " "'% 5

9'!1$5+ >'%% 6' C-'$.9'!1 '$16'

=-'$.

51 5% 1$'%

%5+

%$4 $$ %"+5 ! 611% >$H% $ !@; ;::" ' 611% > "

! 1 1 65%"8 ! 611% >' ! $+

$$%4 *+% -3I 8. '%4

- 4C % '%

E.41 "

% 611% > $4

1 3% %% !43% 31 %"+% *+1% '%

% '%

' .6+ ++ ,+- - .

> # # $ *

# #

)

# @)

' !

0 (' !

) ' -+ 6

> #

$ #

A ## *"

)

## + %

;$ $:$7 -

# # #

' 0 +

)

+ 4

# * * 9

.B ) ' 0 + 5 #

) A !

# #

# 9 + C A

* 5 ) "

+ D 3

)0 9

# +

/ 9 # (

" +

)

* * # + 8 3# #

)# )

+ E ( ## # 9

) $: @

#' :

) +7 # :

## 9# : "

# ' # 9#(

#' # 9#0 +:

< #

9 #

@)# + :

$* / ) #

# )

) #

! #

+ #

# ) $

# #

)

# )

# +

# ) # 9 !

# # )

@)# !

.&") )

# ##

) )

)

$: @

# ' $

)

#@)

) #

## #A

/ < '41$%+$$ 611% 7 !"'% $ +$1 $ '% 1 ! % '%

4 " !"

! 1 1 $$ 1 $% $% 611 % > ) 1

% 5+ ' -'$.4"

$ "% $$ 611% > %$% 8'%" "=') " 4$ 9'!1 '$16' C '$.4" $ B,'%$

! " %5 '5!5+

611 % > '% !'% < 14 54 '

%$ % " $ 5 115 611% >*"" %'115 611% >5'" ! "

%$% " "$11' % 9' < 9' $4" " 5+

%$4 5$1

% 4"

% 1 " B,'%$

! " 4% '! "

%$ " B ,'%$

! " %!"

4" 1$%/ + '%5%%" ' 611% 4 '51 <

%4" " 5+

4"%$1"

%" B,'%$

! " %$%

1$%+1+ ! $1 5' !

%"+ %5% 1

$9' 1 $1 4 % 1 $5 1%+ 5' 5 ' 1 A ! "

!$)' '14 " $ %5 % 5 ! $1 1 9' 5$1

< % '% " %%! $$ % !

$1 611% >4 '5"

$5 "

! 4

%%! 1 7%

" ='*4 45 $% 5%"='

9 ' " 8 ) $ '% ! 1"

%8$ !9' 6114 " $ 5%%"'

< / + ! 611

$% '% 15+ $

< '4%1 5 %"+5

%" 611"

% '') " 4 $$%%

) " 5 ! %"% "5+

'$16' .-'$.5+>'%% 6' .-'$." % + !" ,'%$

! E% 1 5 ! 58611% >

5 %"% %%!% 7 ' " B,'%$

! %%55 ' 611% >"

! % 1 + 611% > $'$ $1 $

'5)$<

%$"'%" $1 1 $9' 1"$1

%%=' %5

" ,'%$

! A$ 4 %5

%%5%'%'% %+ % 5

%% 5 % ' %!% $ 4 "

: ) " 5 *+,*+-*++., "

%5+,'%$

! - . %%"< $"' A "

$ 1

; 67

//:;

5!! %!"

$+15+ " $ %" B,'%$

! ) " '

!% !" B,'%$

! - .4" %%" "" % " %5 115 611% > "

!"'%

+ $ 611< +"'%5 %%% 5

%5% //0,*12345!

+" 61, "#$ "60.6337.,< 9 ! $+ 5 !5'! 58 6117 !

/ =' < +"'% 5 %$1 $ '5)$?)$ 1 9' "$1 / ,$ ! " 5

!4"$ 5+ $$%%

4" " 1 %+$$ 1' %" B,'%$

! < $$%% $1 %%1 $< +"

%%59' " B,'%$

611 ' $1 5

//0,*12345 *+8609346337., / %%$ !$$% %% $

: / <'1'$

*+,*+-*++., "

%5+,'%$

! - . %%"< $"' A "

$ 1

+ " 61, "#$ " 60. 6337., < 9 ! $+ 5 !

5'! 58 6117 !

=' < +"'% 5 % $1 $ '5)$?)$ 1 9' "$1 611 % >"

%%=' %5

*+8609346337., < $$%%< $1 %%1 $< +"

%%59' " $ B ,'%$

611 ' $1 5

)''

:" '

7 $8 !? J? 7 $5% J?