← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/4947/2017allowed

Paras Feeds v. Oriental Insurance Co & ORS

2019-12-09Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages



    



 



  ! "  #"

$%&' ( 

)      



* "(+ ,-  ( 

&. ("

,-

(. ("

,- 

 

 

1

 ( %( ,(%  2 & & +( 

  !

  " #$   "    " +  3"

      %  -(" 

,2((. 4

 45"6  % (  - +$(%%"7 , &" (+ + -+ $ 5 + + / 1)689:6 (  



 (  +  -(   5&    /

 ;  (.  7"% ,  < %  #(2  $( (  5 "+(    %  "

= ::(  !( , 88+  

(.7"% ; - , ,7  ;2 *(  #"

$%&' "

 (+-( , %+ %

  5+  "    ,    (  (     "          2   %  + (  % 

&+ %

#"% 2  %( 2   >" " -

 "  , ( + +"%   

$ %* 5" ,7"

".(  (  

( * 5" -2 6

  2( % 2   %    ) , ,66<    (   %  &5   5&

/

3 &-  & # ?@ "% %( +( %   A2  +  12- , 6;"

%&2   &(%%"( %( - ( % % /

5&B"(2 *(   +  - & +(2( -+ 

2.+",2((%"-  %  ("

 & *(  ,(-( >" 25+ -5&

(-+ + -  -+ (%, 6;"

%&

6  5 %&( ;"

2( +  5 &&(%( %" (2

="(2  ( ;2 (+ -( ++ -((..( ($"

5& + ( ,2((2"( ;"

 %&,2((" ( "+("

#(-(   "  ( 5++ ( "+((  *( + +  - & +(("

 %& / 64 ,2(( &    5+  ""      

    

         

          

  

   ! "

# 

$   $     "     %

"$

$    

&'"

 $  (   

$  $ &  ))*)

 

 $$ $ 

 +&&

 "

,&-./    $

   $$  

$    $     

     1       

&             &       

  '  

    $

$ 

    &  

  2  &00

 $23 4,&  &  

& 

 

 $ 556 " , #  

 & 

$    &  



  23 4,&         4 7 $ ( 8-.$ 5 9   3 "8**

  

1 $  &   :$ $ 

   & 

 $  

 &$      6   -.1    

 

 

" -.

1  

   &  $



$ & 1  

 

   &

      /  

  

  

    & 



& 

   

   $  $    $ "

 

 1       

 $ & 7 $  



 $7 8$ 5 9   3 "

8**   * ;  "6    4 $ $  < &   $    

   $   +0 =5+=))/-%0. ))*) 7 8-.- .$ 5 9   3 "8** :  

$             &     $  ))  1 &  $

        &

$

4 $4  



  7 1  

 

   $  

&  3&  " 

 

   

  $$ $  

 $> 

 $    &  $ &23 4,&

   &  $ 

 (%  $ & 

/ 



 1    

    &  $ & $    $    $ 

  $4      1   $ 

 

    $     

 

&  $ & 8 ;3 (0)- ?5.    



          



1    " $, "

&4  

1    &  & 

            

  

   &    

& & $

 $ 

 $    "   1   $4  $ $ 

  &  

   : 6 

  $ 

   $ $  

  ')  ! "       #  $

%&' !( )*)&+# ,$(  (-

' -   

    + $  

 

: ?.   &   &&  $ &  

 3  

    1

        

             1         1    & 

 

 

 3 

      &   1        $ &   $

&  $ $ 

     $$   

 " $ , 4   "       " &  & "

        4 $ " 

  !

 "       #    

%&' !( )*)&+# , (  (- '



   $ $ 

  $

   

   ' $1 $ &   

 

    $$     & $

  

  && 

$  &

    $      

      $$  4 

 11   $$     $ " 

 

  $ &    &$  

  12- ,#((2(  ((* 5" 2 % % 

*(" -+"/ 6@2  

   $$     & $

 "$ 1 $$ A %0B 2"("



 %& % &, ( "

 %& (  B%  &   %( * C"5,/+  -((  "5&

(5"5&(

"

( % , (5" 2 5(  /

 ( 

(5 &+ ( ". ++ /+ ,(  ( -+ 2" %( *( * 5" ( 2-  .+-2(( )D  (.  7"%

  /

  "     "  & "% &  + +(&/+ " (2 ((" & "./+  *( ((* 5" ( 5(& (  &5 -("

%&( "%%   %("+(22(( ( (5"5& * C"5,/+    

 " (-5"+( %(( + 

 %  ,("

%&( - "-+  ="( -+  "   (-  +      *  C"5, /+ ,  %-   (+  2 +2( +  +"( >"5"(+( 2

*(* 5"   &+"(5 >" % " -+  (( "( " (-5" %/+ "( "- =(

 !( , 88 + -  #

(

"

   5&+-+ 2 +  "  , ("  (- 5

"+- " -  !( "

2( 5" "( . ,%&-2,( " 

8 5   %    5   +    -   =%  &  (2    "  2(  "% " 5"( %=% $ 

(5 5 5  & ' "  ( ((( "

%&( "- & % ("

 &

' "  ( ( 

- " 3"+%" ((" ("

" 5+  &+ +2( % &+ - ,("

%& %"2( ( %("

  &(5-  #.        /0

&'1 1& 2'*35&(B$"

2( 2(  + 2(( 5 &"

  %2( -+ ( - (-( 2"5.,25 -(5 (  5&2 "

-( %"55 (5&("

 %&   -   5 & 2( +    (  &  %  *( #"

$%& -  %(2  & -( (-( 2.2+ & &(-  -  ( +&-   -"(-( ( ( 5& ( - %5- (,(2 B %. -+>" &"- &(2(" -+ .2 +(2 ,5 ( & 5 5"("



#     !

- 

 0

"

4 2( 2 +>",2(( "

 %&  - 5 &2 "

( -( ("

2+" &+ + B  5   (% "  +( & + + -+ -( 5&" &  -  2(2>"  -   (   -  %,     %-,    (  5  5 -  (  %  5,  .    -       >"     (   -  

-+,         (% -    - 5     (  "  %&

# +  1   5              0

&'1 1& 2'* ,2( 25 - (2("5& - ,2(. -+ ,("

%& 5 &%( 2 (-( 

 (( (,   "   ( ;

"

%&( +"(( 5&( - 2 -5 + - ,( % ("

 &(("

-( (" 5 -5& 

-  2   -   5 -+  (  "

  %&  5     & % *(  ,( - & +(2  +( &+ ( "

%&5&(* 5"

  ( +  (     "    (   ,  ++ ( "+((3"+% 

5&  "  (   "+(  ,#((* 5" 23"+ +

- & +(("

%&

*(" -+("/ 62(( (  /

2( +-  -+ (%2 ("

%& *( " -( ;

2 (-( (.2+ & &(- ( -( 

( +&-   -"( -( %+ *( 5&

( %5- (2 " (-&"

+ +(%2 2 %%%5&- " ( +"( & *(  ,5.5 (( %("

 &  -+( "

  %&    &  5 &   &  %  )(  ( 5 &"

%&(  +&

- & +( %("



*(  ,(  5&(2  *( %"+  2     %  )"  &,  (  5 &    &  ( %%"  53-   (( 

( 5 &+ ("

%& -

(%" %("

( 5&2( 2

  "$ 3   %&'(&'))'*+,-'./+0'*12-3  '+/, %&'(&'))'0,)(*45'

 '+/,