Zile Singh & ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS
!""# $$ % &#'"# $ !" #$%&' ()*+,' -').+#/ & (# )#"#"*%+%+ #" ,# )##-., +$-'%/# +&#'
-').+#/ &0 0"##" $ + +
12
+#!- 34-
0" ,# # $$ 5 # " -# 6!
"3 3$ #"4-# 2 .# '+" "#"" &#'% 12
--# "4- +7
#"#+8"8-!"4-# -,"" #%- 9 ! $-#+&5 +0" #&#+
##- :"$-#; 6#
",-21
0"4- # "#+8" #8%,# 1"3#6% - "4-# < + + =;$## ,"",#
" #+" ,# 5>?# #+" # -# 5 , #3 " 3#6 % - " 4-# <
+ + =;$##!!#%!",# #-#5 ,+ " ,##$$ 5 #"-#
# - # " ,# -53 " " $#",# " #,- 1 "5$ '"3$-!,# " #-# 5 , " #3 " $ ' 1 #- 5' " /%#3 &#'33-3# #4- ,# @ <7+ + =;$##+",%#+ " ,#"$# "%5,# ' + + =;$##3$0"$ '
1, #- 5- "#3" #",#, -5'" # 1"$#A#3
$ '#- 1+"33-3# #"4-# ,
@ 7+ + =;$##"3$$ 5 " 4-,"#,#5'" #"%5-# #
1##$% " 0" # # '5 """/%#3"$" $$# $#-#!"##!-3&$#'"",# "$#,- 1+#5 -5 $$ "% - " $#%"$ '#-
10"$#'# #"3 3$6$!%, "$ ' " , " #$ -5'"
?""#"+ #- #" -53" " #-#5 ,,"-"#5!'%$#- ##5'" ,#",!"% - " +" 3$ #"4-# < + + =;$##A, -#"# -53""#,##! "#0"% - ,#35'"-#5 , '-"$ ' " /%#3"#,% - " "#,4- , 0" -53"-
3- 3$"5,#5'
" #+,"" #'"3
&# #- #"$#$#-"# % # #### 1 A$-5'" #- #" "" /%#3 &#'"-$ #333,"#5'"
2 33-3#,# @ #$'33$ #"4-# " 0"$ '- 7
+$#%" " ,#,"",# " #,$# #
##$% "+" 5 33-33- 3$< + + =;$## 0"# %@# " #$ '-#;
B -5>; @ ## #4- $-5 $-#$" &#' #+ A3## #"-5> "" /%#3"54-#! $-5 $-#$ #%#-$#3, "# !C#"$#'33$$ " ,#5"# @5'"33 - -# " "#3"$ % 33# % " $#3 # 2 1 ;;
;
=7
2+
0" 33 " 5 #33! # 5 " 4- '+ !#' " -#4-
A"5"!# @$#""#
3$ @ #4-#4- ,3$# "3#6#$#% "#4- '+" ,#"%$$#""-# #"!" 3$$"3"$# !6 -5 3 !#- -# %# " " 53%#'% -5 3#"#!-##-! "0" #3#,"$#% " ' % " # 3$ 5 " 3#6 # $#% "# 2 0"4- 5#!!5-3$#%3 "'35' @!33-3 ##"#5'-# $'3 #3$" #3#5" 3#6#+"5-#"%#
/%#30"'3 4- ,5'" "3#, 5'"?A$#!" " 5-
A",55'"/%#3" " 5% ,! #"$-#$
@! ## 4-;
0" -#55 # ", " /-#!% $3( " -5;#! &#' -! ("6- $#$"#'
"!#" #3!$# &#' " -&#'-5;#!
#-#+" -#"#5
@" ,! ## #"5%"# 4- #$-5 $-#$ 0"-#55 # /-#!, "% 33-3 ## $## " &#' -5;#! -!("6- # "!#"
$#$"#' " &#' , "% 33-3 ## $## #"# " 33-3 ## , 5 $## % 0"# -" -3 # $'5 -# " $#% " 4-
0" 33 " 5' " % 33#, -$# #3-," @!
"# 3$ #%#-!# -# 4-5" ##A, -6 - "$#3# #,#6!-" 4- # 5! , $# ,"
33-! " # " 4-#! $#3= !" D 7 0"# #+ /%#3 &#'+ - #
# '!5-$$ 5 ' " ##-=$ '
7
,"#!# @ #$# 4-# $-5 $-#$" 0"# %@#"# -#;
B ## - #+"5 ",# #4- 5- = # ")#"
" 5# ,#"" # #+33-'-%"$#3 #
7;
;
0""#$#% "33-
7;
;
, #3-"!D
$#"$ ' 7
+33-3#"# 4-,- 5< + + =;$##0"##$$ 5 "4-,"#,#"5-# #
##$% " 0" #$ '-5'"/%#3,#%
1+#!"33-3#" @"'#
0"# %@# $ '+ 1+-#;
E -5 @ ## #"4- $-5 $-#$" &#' 0"$#3)3
;;
;
=
+ 7
9"$#3)3-## #+ 33-3 ## #4-#! #$-5 $-#$
#%#-$#3, "# ! ,# @5'"&#'/%#3 , )3-3 ## #-#55 # /-#! $## )3-3 # # # # " &#' -5;! -!
("6- # "!#"
$#$"#'"&#' $## )3-3 ## #"# &#' $## 0" # # - " -3
# $'5 -# " $#% " 4-+7
,"55#%",""$!
33#6# " "%#-5 ' 0"# #+ &#' /%#3 " #;# " 3#"#;
@" ## , )3-3 ## #-#55 # /-#! $## )3-3 # # # # " &#' -5;! -!
("6- # "!#"
$#$"#'"&#' $## )3-3 ## #"# &#' 7 $## 2 0" ## -" -3 # $'5 -# " $#% " 4-+7
0"#%#, 5$$ 5 " 4-,"#,#"%5-# #
1 ##$% " -# "4-+7
E 0"$ ' 1+",""33-3 ##
#"# "&#' ,##%7+ + =;$## #3
+ + =;$##"##$$ 5 "4- ,"#,#5'" #"%5-# #
##$% " A"$#+",#,-5'" # 1 ,"# $# # $ 7
1+" $$ 5 '#
1+#$% ' 0" &#' "#"% - " #3"'#
15' F"#4- #3 + + =; 7+ + =;$##$#- " #$ "," # !$ # ','#+"33-33$$'5 #4- ,"<2 F$#-3#"$#",
21 F ""$#","'# 10"% #!
$# ,"""# $#-##35-
1 3 #-#5G"# ##--# 0"$#
#3##%$ '#% "# 63 2 0" #$ ' #+3'$+5# $ %",!"% - " #!" "",#"$#,- 1" "" "!##<2 F$#-3 #"3!$ , '# " $ + # ## 5%+ " 3 # " ,#"$##%5!#$#$## 06!-" # +",#"$#, -5'" # 1+" ,#"$# #% 5 !# 3$ < 1+ + =; $# # #! '+"% - "4-# #3<1+ + =;
$##0" ,#" 5 "-#'5 % 5 -#"
-').+#/ &
% (/1'