Parvez Khan And ANR v. National Insurance Co. Ltd And ORS
!"
#$%&'%()*)+,-.
#/%012#+#+'#+$2% 33%44#+$* 5 #$)+#4+*6#+(%7$'#+'$2%* %*3+'%+$* !, 87!
17
%*%+$, !!6+)*2 6)9'/(#$%9&$2%#33%44#+$* ! #'%%316:#9'/(#$%9&%*3+'%+$ !#(2)+ 2)9'/(#$%9&%*3+'%+$*#+'; <<<<<<< 179 7"
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
DE 2% )=6+#4 #&$% =*%/)+B $2#$ #33%44#+$ ')/%8* 4)(%+(% 3%:)$$%' 2): $ +4>')/% #:$(>(4% ?)$2 B%#* #+' ++ $#+*3$/%2)(4%*B#+$%'%*3+'%+$+*6#+(%:3#+>$2%)B2$$ %(/%$2%(:3%+*#$)+&:$2%#33%44#+$*#&$%')*=6*)+B$2%*#:%$ %*3+'%+$*#+';A(4#):#+$* &$%3%6*)+BC ")%#33%44#+$')/%8*')/)+B 4)(%+(%)$)*&6+'$2#$2%?#*#6$2)*%'$')/%+$+4>#:$(>(4%?)$2 B%#F#4)B2$:$/%2)(4%++$#+*3$"=6$#4*#$#+*3$/%2)(4% 26*9$2%&)+')+B*&$2%)=6+#4)+$2)*%B#'#%&6+'$=%#B#)+*$$2% %(' 6$2%9#(%$)&)(#$%2#*#4*=%%+3'6(%'=>#33%44#+$ A')/%=%&%$2)*6$#*#+#'')$)+#4%/)'%+(%$26B2?
2)(2)$)* (%$)&)%'=>$2%7)(%+*)+B6$2)$>9 %B)+#4#+*3$ &&)(%9#::6$2#$ #$$2%$):%&$2%#(()'%+$2%?#*#4*#6$2)*%'$')/%#'#+B%6*#+' 2#0#'6*/%2)(4% +/)%?&$2%#=/%=6$?)$26$%(')+B#+>&)+')+B+$2% B%+6)+%+%**#+'%/)'%+$)#>?$2&$2%')/)+B4)(%+(%C "#*#4*$2% #'')$)+#4%/)'%+(%3'6(%'=%&%$2)*6$9$2%):36B+%'#?#')**%$ #*)'%+4>$$2%%C$%+$*&##*)$B#+$*$2%)B2$$%*3+'%+$ +*6#+(% :3#+> $ %(/% $2% #?
=>$2%:=%&%$2)*6$)+#(('#+(%?)$24#? %%'4%**$*#>$2#$ %*3+'%+$+*6#+(%:3#+>*2#44#4*=%B#+$%'#'%G6#$%
D;E 33$6+)$>$%=6$*6(2%/)'%+(% &)+#4'%()*)+=%$#@%+=>$2%)=6+#4?)$2)+*)C:+$2* &:$2%'#$%&%(%)3$&#(%$)&)%'(3>&$2)*'% 2%#33%#4)*#44?%')+$2%#=/%$%:* -. D 17E *2#:*2% H2%$2%*3%#@)+BA%#*+%'
, %*A H2%$2%%3$#=4% ,%*A