High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/2439/2018dismissed

Sapna Devi v. Vinod Kumar

2019-02-07Mr Justice Rakesh Kumar Jain,Mr. Justice Harnaresh Singh Gill5 pages

!"!#$% & '# (! )''** +,"-" +!#./-0 , ) "'#.# 1$ 231 & /&/ 1 231 & &&33

,"# $ 1,

,0!#.,&!#456.(

6, 1,& ,44 ,7 *6.(

5 " !*. 5 ',"# ''

**#4!#4 5 9-.40# .

. % '

"". :;

0!*; -, 6 / ,# *6 (!. 75! 5 !# -#., & !# 5- ,.!

#" #.< ,." 6 6!*.:; #.6 5 " :# **7. #. -"

.; 0!#, 5!*. 4. :- %8=;

,"64!(# #. 0 ;:0# !#.5,

75# 50

, 0 -' , 5 ,!#4 :, 5!" -, # %> 6 75!* !""-!#4 ! 0 !#6 50

,7 ",,,. 51.!

# !*!

!## 5!"-, # :*!#4 ,,!(

# 0!

:* "

*0# ,4 ,.!#4 5 (!"!

!# ,!45 " .-,!#4 5'#.# ; ''

*7(,6 0.!

!# 5 . !*.6 5 0

, 7 " ,.,. : *!"

. ,

,4-0# "#%

?@ < 5 ( 5 ,. ,#. -#"* ,

#. 7!

5!, :* ""!"

# 4# 5,-45 9-.40# ',-"

* '

"".:; 7-*. "57

75!* . !.!#4 !# !*. :; #.6 5 (, ** 7* , 5 5!*.6 5 " :# .*!:,

.-'#!#A #" #.7**

B#!# #"!.,

!#:;

5* 75!*A 0!#!#4

5 0'

!( ,"-, " ( !* :*

5 #." !"6 " -#.

. ',(

"5 "7,B!#4 ,#!#4 5,:; '

:*4!(!#4 4. *! 50!#, 5!*.675, #.:!#4 .,!(,:;',""!# #.67 "-#. :0,"-!

:* , !"

5 5!*. -, 5,6 !

7 " -#.

5 0

,# 4, #.0 5, 5 0!#,6 75 !" *!(!#4 7!

5-":

#.6 #

B 50!#, 5!*. 5* 65 "5 #!#

!#7!

50!#, 5!*. #.# ! .

."'!

:!#4%8=;

,"*.6 5 7 " -# :* , !

#4*!"5 , !#.! *'5 :

" , :

"! -# !#4 & !** -, 5,6 !

" :# # ! . :; !# !

" ,.,

87! *#4 7!

50!#, 5,-( 5,"# 87!6# 0*;6(C 4. ;

,"D ,0 5, !,"

4 7!

''!6 75 5 . .!. :,5,0 47!

#.6!"*!(!#47!

5,0 5,!# 5-44!5 (!#4#*;#,0'

87! -*. # ',.- #; (!.# :, "57,"

:*!"5

50!#,!"4!#4

#;" 5* 7 "!# 5!"(!7 50

?@ , ,..6 !# '

" % #. !

" 9-.40# -#.,$8 E% ,0

!.6 !" (!.#

!" # ',(!.!#4 4. .-

0!#, 5,-( #. 5, *., "# !" # 4!#4 " 5*

** 5,!"#

0"'5,"

-.!"!# 5#,05-" 5 0 5, 75 5 .0!

#. (,; 00:, 5, 0!*; !" !**!

.-:

!#,!" *"# 0- 5.-

.657(,6 75!*!#

!#47!

!"6!

0:(!-"

!#,!" *!( 5( *-4..-

57 "'

!#. "

5!""#7 "# 4

!#4 #; #(!7 ,"

!.:",(

!#" 5

#. !, -0"

# " "6 5!" -, !" #"!.,. '!#!#

5 7* , 0!#, 5,-( .0 #."

5!" -"

.;:4!(# !#,675

#',(!.:

,.-

#.:

,*! 5 5!*. 5'

!#,!"6 5,,65*.# *. 5 -"

.; 0!#, 5,-( 7(,6 !# :"# "!0-*

#-"

"" !

!# 7!

5 : "6 5 5!*. 7!** 0!"" 0'* #"" 5!" ,*

!#"5!' 5,,6

!":!#44, .(!"!

!#,!45 "))F ,#. -#"* , !#, 5 " (50# *;

,4-.

B !# #"!.,

5 0!#, 5!*. !# 5!" !#

!# 7!

65 .A',"".5!"."!, *!(7!

55!"0 5,5 -, ,4-.

.'* .#, ,.

5 . -0#

,; (!.# ',(

"5 !" 0'*;. !#

,; 5-"6 "5 !" 7** 7!

5!# 5, ,"-, " , !" 0!#, 5!*. 7(,67.# !#. #;0,!

!# ,4-0# !".:; ,#. -#"*, ""

:(6

B#!# #"!.,

5(, **

?@ 7* , 5 0!#, 5!*.6 , 5 (!#4 A 0!#. '

***= 0'

!( ,"-, "

5#." : !" "!."6 "!",( *.,0 5',-"

* 87! !" 5 (!#4 5, 5!*.6 0*;6 (6 4. ;

,"6 ,0 5, !,"

4 5-"6

B!#4 !# #"!.,

5 0!#, 5!*. !" # 4!#4 " 5* #. -,

B!#4 !# #"!.,

5 !" *!(!#4

*#47!

55!"0 #.'

*4, #.0 *" "# 87! !# 5-44! 5 (!#4 #*; # ,06 !

## :"

5,.,'

"".:; "-,",0 #;!**4 *!

; " 0 # , ,.

87! !" "-,!#4 ,0 + C-0 # 00-#.! !# ; +!,-"D '"!

#.# '

!#!*.:; #.-#.,& CDC(D 5!#.-1 4 6>>6 . ,.!(, 5 :#4, .# 5"

!.(,;4,-#. !"# "75, "# :#4!(# #;,!45 ",4 ,."5, "" 50!#, 5!*. 5 * " 4!(# (!"!

!# ,!45

5,6 " .

4 6 '

9-.40# ',-"

5,7-*."57

87! " :# 4!(# (!"!

!# ,!45 " # (,; " #. #. -, &-#.

; 5 0# 5 :"!." # 5 "!#" !7 *!6 -""5, #. *! "

!( *" &5 5 " -, 5, :# 4!(# ,!45

*B 5 0!#, # *'5# , , "# :* !06 75# 5 5!*. " ."!," , 75# 87! **" "!."6 87!5 *":#',0!

##- *="', " -# !#" !# 5 " 5* 5 5!*. , #;

?>@ 5,-# !#!# 5" 5*675# 5 5!*.',,0" #.!"5 " ."!," 5 ,"'#.# *" :# 4!(# ,!45 (!"!

5 5!*. !# " #; 0.!

* #.!

!# 5 5!*. ,G-!,!#45"'!

*!H

!#=0.!

*', .-, # (!7 :(6 7 !#.

4!(#

7** "#. 9-.40#

"* #"!.,

!#:!#4 57* 5 5!*."0# !#. :(6

":#4!(# 5(!"!

!#,!45 "6"

,0 !#!# # !#--" - 57!

50!#,50!#, 5!*. !"

4,7!#4 4 #.7!

4 !0657-*.* ,#

*!( 7!

5 ',

! !, -0"

# " & !** -, 5,6 . !'5,. ,0 5 9-.40#

87!6 :"!." 0!#, 5,-(6 !" *" 5 (!#4 5!*. (6 4. ;

,"6 ,0 5, !,"

4 5-"6 ,0

'!# (!7 *"6!

#7**:"

5-":

#. !" 0, "-!

:* '

',(!. 5 0!#, 5!*. 7!

G- *!

;.-

!#6,!45 -':,!#4!#4 #. 5,# ""!

*! #"G-# *;6 7 . # !#. #; !#!,0!

; , !**4 *!

;!# 675! 50 ; ,, #;!# ,,# :; 5!"-, !# 5',"# ''

* # 6 5',"# ''

*!".!"0!"".

% ." <5 5,&'

B!#4=

"#.$ "= <5 ',

:*$ "=