High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/569/2016dismissed

Narinder Kaur And ORS v. State Of Punjab & ORS

2016-05-095 pages

!"# $#%&'&()!*

!"# $#%&'&()!* +

!,&($#,-!.,!($"/#,'

00#11!("'

2#,'.'

3"!"# .(4!5!($"/#,'

#'0($#("'

) ) ) ) 6 33 - 6 33 - 6 33 - 6 33 - 6 3 6 3 6 3 6 3 ,#'#(") ,#'#(") ,#'#(") ,#'#(") ,3!("'/3/!,7!+$8%!"#

,"/#!00#11!("' 9/#"/#,#0,"#,' %!10!0#,'7!*5#!11:#$"'##"/#4.$;7#("<*#' *#'

*#'

5#,# #,,#$""/##0,"#,',("<( ( ( ( = 9/#"/#,"/#4.$;7#("'/.1$5#,#0,"#$&("/#&;#'"<( ( ( ( >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> + + + + /#0,#'#("&(",!%.,"!00#!1&'$&,#%"#$!;!&('" "/#4.$;7#("!($,$#,$!"#$ ?

@0!''#$&(9 ?@

5* :/&%/ "/# 1#!,(#$ 3&(;1# .$;# $&'7&''#$"/#'!&$:,&"0#"&"&( &1#$5*"/#!00#11!("'+' !1'"/#,$#,$!"#$

&(,#8&#:0#"&"&( ('.00," "/#!00#!1+1#!,(#$%.('#1 ,"/# !00#11!("' '.57&""#$ "/!"+ & "/# 1#!,(#$ 3&(;1# .$;# %77&""#$ !( #,,, &( /1$&(; "/!" "/# 0,&(%&01#' ,#'

4.$&%!"!:#,#!001&%!51#&(,#1!"&(""/##!,1&#,4.$;7#(" "/#1:#,00#11!"#.,"+:/#(!'!7!""#, !%"+"/# '!&$ .," /!$ ,#'#,8#$ "/# 1&5#,"* &( !8., "/# !00#11!("'",!&'#!%1!&7 ,"/#0.,%/!'# "/#$&'0."#$

1!($!($"'##A!00,0,&!"#,#1&# +&&"/#1#!,(#$3&(;1#

.$;# %77&""#$ !( #,,, &( &;(,&(; "/# !%" "/!" "/# 0,#$#%#'',' "/# !00#11!("' :#,# '/:( &( "/# 0''#''&( "/#'.&"1!($!'"#(!(" ,"/#*#!, @B !($:/#(!001&%!"&("!&5#/'&1$!,:!'7!$#"'.001* A/!',!;&,$!:!,& ,7-/!,& "!5& ?"'/:"/# 0''#''&( "/# !00#11!("'+ "/# !1A! !":!,& /!$ #C0,#''#$/&'&(!5&1&"*"'.001*"/#'!7#("/#;,.($ "/!""/# '!7#:!' ("!8!&1!51#+ &&& "/#1#!,(#$3&(;1#

.$;#.;/""/!8#%('&$#,#$"/#7!"#,&!1!'0#%"(!7#1*+ "/!""/#!001&%!"&(.($#,3#%"&(D "/#.(4!53#%.,&"* !($'#(.,#'%"+ = ,'/,"6%"6:!'!11:#$5* "/#3"!"#(=

5*:/&%/"/#!001&%!("':#,#!'A#$ "$#0'&"E +

0#,!%,#+""!1E+ ?+ FB!($."

:/&%/"/#!00#11!("'&( !%"/!$$#0'&"#$E

+@@ FB/# !00#11!("'!,#'"&11,#!$*!($:&11&(;"$#0'&""/#5!1!(%# !7.(" /# %" = 5#&(; ! 5#(# &%&!1 1#;&'1!"&(+ 0,"#%"&(""/#"#(!(":!',#G.&,#$"5#1&5#,!11*;&8#( #!,(#$%.('#1 ,"/#!00#11!("'+"/#,# ,#+0,!*#$"/!"

"/#9 ?@

5#!11:#$ 9#/!8#/#!,$1#!,(#$%.('#1 ,"/#!00#11!("'

,%('&$#,!51#1#(;"/9#/!8#0#,.'#$"/##("&,#,#%,$ '!1'"/#$%.7#("',# #,,#$".'5*/&79#/!8#!1' 0#,.'#$"/#,#!'(';&8#(5*"/#1#!,(#$3&(;1# .$;# /# !00#11!("' :#,# %1!&7&(; "#(!(%* "/,.;/

= !,(!73&(;/'( &:!(3&(;/+"/#!11#;#$"#(!("&( ,#'0#%" "/#'.&"1!($-/!',!;&,$!:!,&#' ,-/!,& &($&%!"#$ "/# (!7# !,(!7 3&(;/ , "/# &,'" "&7#

# ,#"/!",#%,$&($&%!"#$"/!".0"

+!H!,!

3&(;/ #"% :#,# '/:( &( 0''#''&( !' "#(!("' ($&'0."!51* "/# '.&" 1!($ :!' '1$ " 8#,(7#(" (

@ = D5*!'!1#$##$/#,#&'(,#%,$#!,1&#," -/!,& , !

"#, #C#%."&( '!1# $##$ $!"#$

@ = D'/:&(;0''#''&( !,(!73&(;/7.%/1#''

!'!"#(!("/#.(&("#,,.0"#$!($%("&(..'0''#''&(

,'&C*#!,'&''&(#G.!(( ,%1!&7&(;,&;/""0.,%/!'# '.%/1!($''"!"#$#!,1&#,+!,(!73&(;/6'0''#''&(%!( 5# .($ &( "/# ,#%,$ (1* ,7 -/!,& "&11 "/# 8#,(7#("0.,%/!'#$&"( @ = D!($(""/#,#!

"#,+ &# , ! 0#,&$ ": *#!,' (1* 0!," ,7 "/!" "/# !00#11!("' /!8# (" 7!$# &" %1#!, !' " /:+ &( :/!" %!0!%&"* !($ .($#, :/!" %&,%.7'"!(%#'+ !,(!7 3&(;/ %!7#&(0''#''&( '.54#%"1!($("/# 1&;/" "/#'# !$7&""#$ !%"'+"/#"#(!(%*,&;/" ,"/#0.,%/!'# "/# '.&"0,0#,"*!'"#(!("'%!(("5#/#1$&( !8., "/# !00#11!("'9#"/#,# ,#+ &($"/!""/#%1!&7 ,0.,%/!'#

"/#1!($!'!"#(!(":!',&;/"1*".,(#$$:(5*"/#1#!,(#$ 3&(;1# .$;#/1$&(;/&7"5#&(.(!."/,&H#$0''#''&( /#0,"#%"&(.($#,3#%"&( ,#!$:&"/3#%"&( "/# %":.1$("5#!8!&1!51#

@ /#'.57&''&("/!""/#0,&(%&01#' ,#'4.$&%!"!

:!':,(;1*!001&#$5*"/#1#!,(#$3&(;1# .$;#+!1'7.'"

!&1 /# 1#!,(#$ 3&(;1# .$;# /#1$ "/!" "/# &($&(;'

,#%,$#$&('.77!,*0,%##$&(;'%!(("5#",#!"#$!',#' 4.$&%!"! 5.""/# &($&(;'&("#,B0!,"&#',#%,$#$5*"/#%&8&1 %.,":.1$0#,!"#!',#'4.$&%!"!"&'",.#!'%("#($#$ 5* 1#!,(#$ %.('#1 , "/# !00#11!("' "/!" &( "/# #!,1&#, $#%,##+1:#,00#11!"#.,"/!$/#1$"/!""/#$&'7&''!1

"/# '.&" :.1$ 5# :&"/." 0,#4.$&%# " "/# ,&;/"' "/# 01!&("&

"/#,#&("%1!&7"0.,%/!'#"/#$&'0."#$1!($!($ " '##A !00,0,&!"# ,#1&# ." "/#( "/# !00#11!("' /!$ 01#!$#$"/!""/#*:#,#0,"#%"#$.($#, 3#%"&( ,#!$ :&"/3#%"&( "/#%" !($"/#1:#,00#11!"#.,"

:/&1#!11:&(;"/#!00#!1 &1#$5*"/#3"!"#/#1$!;!&('""/# !00#11!("'8#(& "/'#0,%##$&(;'&("/#%&8&1'.&":#,# '.77!,*(!".,#+&(.,0&(&("/#.,"/!$'"&11"/# 1&7&"#$4.,&'$&%"&(!($:&"/&("/#7#!(&(; 3#%"&( C01!(!"&( 2 &8&1 ,%#$.,# $#+

D+ ! &($&(;

,#%,$#$5*'.%/.," 1&7&"#$4.,&'$&%"&(&("#,B0!,"&#'

:.1$ !1' 0#,!"# !' ,#' 4.$&%!"! &( "/# '.5'#G.#(" 0,%##$&(;' #"/!"!'&"7!*+(7#,&"'+:#%(%.,:&"/ "/# &($&(; !%",#%,$#$5*"/#1#!,(#$3&(;1# .$;#"/!"

"/#!00#11!("'%.1$("%1!&7!(*,&;/"!'!"#(!(" ,:!("

%("&(..'0''#''&( ,'&C*#!,' /# !%""/!""/#!00#11!("'/!$5##(!'A#$5*

"/#3"!"#"0!*"/#0,&%#!""/#,!"# E +

FB0#,!%,# !($"/!"!00#11!("'/!$$#0'&"#$E

+@@ FB:.1$5# ( %('#G.#(%#'&(%#"/#8#,*1#;!1,&;/""0.,%/!'#"/#1!($ %1!&7#$5*"/#7/!'5##((#;!"&8#$5*"/#1#!,(#$3&(;1#

.$;#!':#11!'5*.' /# .0B'/" "/#!58#$&'%.''&(&'"/!""/# !00#!17.'"5#$&'7&''#$ #(%#+:#7!A#"/# 11:&(;,$#,)

&''.77!,&1*$&'7&''#$ I3 -J I3 -J I3 -J I3 -J I J I J I J I J

!* +

7!/!8&,