← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/599/2016dismissed

Sukhdev Raj And ANR v. State Of Punjab And ORS

2018-07-30Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Arun Monga8 pages





        

 !"

!#!$%&!' ('!'!") *'((+!,!"-.$/01) 2.345(# *6 *"'4(& 77($$*"', 8(&,., 2'*'( ."6*9 '4(&,  (,7"5("',

  ! "#$%&'() $ %$'!#) *  ! "#$%&'() $ )( +  ,,,

&(,("'- &2:*'42*!"!15#+*'( &'4(*77($$*"' & 2*!",15#+*'( &&(,7"5("',) ! ' !!!  ,". *$1(7.'/5#+*'(("(&*$1 ."6*9 ;;;;;

)( + -%

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

(=.$*&2(+"577(*$4*5*&!,(".''4(,.!'!$(59/'4(*77($$*"',' +4*$$("=('4(6.5=:("'*"55(+&((!",.!'!$(5."5(&2(+'!" 27(+!!+

($!(+' &,4&'1'4(+' "*+'1'4(*&=.:("',?(&(4(*&5"$/!"?&!' 7('!'!"*"5"'!"'4( (=.$*&2(+"577(*$1?4!+4?*,5(+!5(5*,* +",(@.("'!*$((+''4(5(+!,!"'4(?&!'7('!'!" '?*,"(B'*&=.(5'4*''4($(*&"(52!"=$(("+4,4.$5"' 4*#(4($5'4*''4(7&!#*'(&(,7"5("',4(&(!"*"5'4(7('!'!"(&,!"?&!' 7('!'!"1?(&(("'!'$(5',.!'7&7(&'/+:7&!,!"=34*,&*  C0"

'4(9*,!,'4('&*",(&&5(&5*'(50)>>1?4!+4!,+"'&*&/''4( 7&(,,"'(5*'(5A>0 ""(B.&( 0C0 1?4!+4,'!7.$*'(5'4*'!* 7(&,"!,++.7/!"=:&('4*""(4.,(*"5:&('4*""(9.!$'<.77$'1 4(,4*$$9(("'!'$(5''&*",(&"$/"('4(,('?7&7(&'!(,*"5'4( ,*!57&!"+!7$(?*,*77$!+*9$(''4(++.7*"',+::(&+!*$7&(:!,(,*, ?($$ &(,,"'(+*&&!(,*$(=*$,*"+'!'/!"#!(?'4(6.5=:("'&("5(&(59/ '4(!#!,!"("+4'4!,.&'!"#./ '. 0/ 1/23 /. ' 4  44..  1/- 56%76 77($$*"',4*5 7$*+(5"&(+&5'4(&(+(!7',5*'(50>  ""(B.&( *$"=?!'4'4(

6

*77$!+*'!" &  *55!'!"*$  (#!5("+( '  7&#(  '4*' '4(7&7(&'/ 9(*&!"= *&(:("'!"(5  34*,&*  ".:9(&  ?*,  '&*",(&&(5  !"  *#.&    !$*3  *6 *=*!",'*,.:0C<*"55(7,!'(5 C<"0> 4(&(+&5 '4(  *&(:("'!"(5  +*,(  +.$5  "'  9(  7$*+(5  "  &(+&51  &1  !'  ?*, :!,7$*+(54(!+!*$&(,7"5("',?(&(5.'/9."5'7&5.+('4(&(+&5 9(&('4($(*&"(52!"=$(.5=( '?*,.&'4(&+"'("5(5'4*''4(&5(&5*'(5A)'4( (4,!$5*& 2*$(, <+.:<*"*=!"= !+(&?*,7*,,(5*'(&,7'!",7(+'!"1 ?4(&(!"!'?*,."5'4*''4(7,,(,,!"'4(,.!'7&7(&'/?*,!$*3

*61'4(&(&(1'4(7&7(&'/+.$5"'4*#(9(("'&*",(&&(5!"*#.&'4( 7('!'!"(&,#!5(&5(&5*'(5) ""(B.&( < =*!",''4(,*!5 &5(&1!$*3 *6!$(5!#!$%&!' ('!'!"AA)'!'$(5*,D!$*3

*68(&,.,4( !"*"+!*$::!,,!"(&1 (#(".(*"5'4(&,E1?4!+4?*, 5!,:!,,(5#!5(&5(&5*'(5) ""(B.&( <0 1?4(&(7('!'!"(& ?*,  "'  7&(+$.5(5  &:  7&(,,!"=  '4(  +$*!:  9(&(  '4(  *.'4&!'!(,  & 5('(&:!"*'!"'4(&!=4','4(7*&'!(,1'4.,1&*$$!"'("',*"57.&7,(,1 '4(&5(&'4($(*&"(52!"=$(("+4!,"',.,'*!"*9$(

(&  +"'&*1  &  2  *!",1  $(*&"(5  +.",($  &(7&(,("'!"= &(,7"5("',) ! ') !!! 1!(1$(=*$4(!&, ,4*"*$1,.9:!''(5'4*'

,4*"*$4*5!$(5!#!$2.!')0)*=*!",'!$*3 *6*"5*, ?($$*,*77($$*"'2.345(# *61?4?*,*&&*/(5*,5(("5*"' 1& 7,,(,,!"'4(*&(:("'!"(5$*"5*,5.&!"='4(7&+((5!"=,7("5!"= 9(&(  '4(  +:7('("'  *.'4&!'/1  7,,(,,!"  ?*,  &+!9$/  '*3("  " A)4(*&(:("'!"(5,.!'?*,5(+&((5*,!'?*,!$(5."5(& 2(+'!" '4(+'*"5&(#!,!"7('!'!"007&((&&(5*=*!",' '4(  ,*:(  ?*,  *$,  5!,:!,,(5  "  )0  #("  9(&(  '4(

8

*&(:("'!"(5,.!'1!"6."+'!",.!'?*,!$(5"0)A?4!+4?*, =&*"'(5!"*#.& ,4*"*$ " 0)A12.345(# *6!$(5!#!$ 2.!' )A&5(+$*&*'!"'4*'4(4*59(+:(?"(&!"7,,(,,!" '4(#*+*"'7$'9(*&!"=34*,&*  C04(,*!5,.!'?*,5!,:!,,(5"

A)A  =*!"  "  >A1  2.345(#  *6  !$(5  *  +!#!$  ,.!'  & 5(+$*&*'!"'4*'4(!,?"(&!"7,,(,,!"'4(,.!'7&7(&'/*$$(=(5' 4*#(9(("7.&+4*,(5&:!$*3 *6 &'4(,*:(#(&/7&7(&'/14(!$(5* +!#!$,.!',((3!"=7(&7('.*$!"6."+'!"*=*!",' ,4*"*$4(,*!5,.!'?*, 5!,:!,,(5!#!$*77(*$!$(5?*,*$,5!,:!,,(5"  (=.$*& 2(+"577(*$A>4*,9(("5!,:!,,(5?4!$(5(+!5!"='4(?&!' 7('!'" '?*,*$,+"'("5(5'4*''4!,.&'4*5*$&(*5/.74($5'4( +"#(/*"+(  5((5  5*'(5  )  ""(B.&(  <0  #!5(  &5(&  5*'(5 )!"!#!$%&!' ('!'"AA)19.'4*5=!#("$!9(&'/ "$/&5('(&:!"*'!"&!=4'9('?(("'4(7*&'!(, "5(&'4(=*&9,.+4 &5(&1 ,4*"*$+.$5"'4*#(!$(5'4(7('!'"9(&('4((4,!$5*& *=*!"

,' '4(&5(&5*'(5) ""(B.&( < 1!"(,,("+(4(?*, (,'77(5 ' .&=('4(!,,.( +$*!:!"= ?"(&,4!7 "'4(9*,!,  '4( +"#(/*"+(5((5*"5'4.,1.&=(5'4!,.&'&.74$5!"='4(&5(&."5(& +4*$$("=( (.&'4(&  9.''&(,,(5 '4*' '4($(*&"(5 2!"=$(("+4  !, "' 7&(+$.5(5'5(+!5('4( (=.$*&2(+"577(*$1*,!$*3 *6*"52.

*6*!$(5'7$*+("&(+&5*"/&5(&C5(+!,!"'4(+:7('("'*.'4&!'/1 !(1  &:  '4(  !+(    (4*9!$!'*'!"1  &(=*&5!"=1  *$$':("'   *&(:("'!"(534*,&*".:9(&?4!+4&(,.$'(5!"'!,,.*"+(+"#(/*"+( 5((5 ("5("+/'4( (=.$*&2(+"577(*$1!"#!(?'4(5(+!,!"



'4($(*&"(52!"=$(("+41?.$54*#(9(("**&+!+*$(B(&+!,( %(4*#(4(*&5'4($(*&"(5+.",($&'4(7*&'!(,*"5*77&*!,(5 '4(7*7(&93 4(:*!"'4&.,'&2:*'42*!"!1$(*&"(5+.",($&'4( *77($$*"',!,'4*''4($(*&"(52!"=$(("+4+.$5"'4*#(*56.5!+*'(5'4(

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

7('!'"4(,*$(5((5!"*#.&2.345(# *6 (B(+.'(59/!$*3 *64*5"'9((",('<*,!5( %(*&(*&*!51'4(*&(:("'!"(5*&=.:("'!,:!,7$*+(51&1 '4(*56.5!+*'!"'4(,.!',((3!"=5(+$*&*'!"?"(&,4!7*"57,,(,,!" '4(,.!'7&7(&'/"'4(9*,!,'4(+"#(/*"+(5((55*'(5))>> ?4!+44*5*$&(*5/9((",('<*,!5(*"5.74($59/'4($(*&"(52!"=$(("+4 77($$*"' 7$*!"'!"'4(,.!' *!$(5'(,'*9$!,4"&(+&5*"/5(+!,!" &(=*&5!"=*$$':("'!"*#.&!$*3 *6 ,  *&  *,  @.(,'!"    7,,(,,!"  !,  +"+(&"(51  7$*!"' :!,(&*9$/  *!$(5  '  7$*+(  "  &(+&5  34*,&*  =!&5*?*&!  '  (,'*9$!



7,,(,,!"19.'"'4(+"'&*&/ ,4*"*$7$*+(5"&(+&56*:*9*"5!(, &:'4(/(*&>')'7&#('4(7,,(,,!" 4(*$$(=(5!",7(+'!"9/'4((4,!$5*&?*,*"(/(?*,41&1 *!9(4,!$5*&")1?4!$(*77&#!"='4('&*",(&7&7(&'/'

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

+*'!"'4($!, ".&#!(?1'4(*&=.:("'&2*!"*"5*,?($$*,'4( 7&!#*'(&(,7"5("',9(&('4(?&!'+.&'*"5!"'4( (=.$*&2(+"577(*$ ?.$54*#(9(("!5("'!+*$'4*'*77($$*"'17$*!"''4(&(!"1?*,5(&!#!"='!'$( "'4(9*,!,'4(+"#(/*"+(5((5&:!$*3 *6'!,,(''$(5$*?'4*'* 7(&,"?45(,"'4*#(*'!'$(1+*""'7*,,"*9(''(&'!'$('!,!"'4!, 9*+35&7'4(:*''(&1$(*&"(5 2!"=$(("+45!,7,(5'4( (=.$*& 2(+"577(*$ 4(&(!,*"'4(&*,7(+''4(:*''(&%(?.$59(+::!''"= **$$*+/!"+*,(?(5"'&(7&5.+('4(&5(&5*'(5)1?4(&(9/ '4(?&!'7('!'"!$(59/!$*3 *67&(5(+(,,&7('!'"(&,?*,5!,:!

5

4(,*:(&(*5,'4.,-< F4(  $(*&"(5  +.",($  &  '4(  7('!'!"(&  +"'("5,  '4*'  '4(

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

&:'4(7(&.,*$'4(*&(:("'!"(5&5(&1!'!,(#!5("''4*' +*"+($$*'!"'4(+"#(/*"+(5((54*5*''*!"(5!"*$!'/4(!:7&''4( &5(&$(*#(,":*""(&5.9''4*'*''4(9(,',:(77&'."!'/?*,'9( =&*"'(5'!$*3 *6'*,,*!$'4(*$$':("'!"*#.& ,4*"*$19.'

."5(&'4(=*&9'4(,*!5&5(&1&*3(5'4(!,,.(?!'4&(=*&5''4('!'$(1 *=*!"1*,5.&!"='4(7("5("+/*$$'4(,(7&+((5!"=,17*,,(5"'!'$(' 2.345(# *6 "+(  '4(  +*"+($$*'!"    ,*$(  5((5  4*,  9(("  .74($5  *,  * "(+(,,*&/+&$$*&/1'4( (=.$*&2(+"577(*$?.$5$,(!',,!="!!+*"+( &."5*'!"*"5?*,&!=4'$/5!,:!,,(5 4(&(!,"5!,7.'(''4(&*'!5(+!5("5!+.$$(5.'!"#./ '. 0/"93 1*,(*+4*"5(#(&/+*,(4*,'9((B*:!"(5"'4( 9*,!,'4(*+',(*+4+*,(

&'4(&(*,",,'*'(5*9#(1?(5"'!"5*"/!"!&:!'/!"'4( &5(&."5(&+4*$$("=(4(,*:(!,.74($5*"5'4((''(&, *'("'77(*$!,

7

5!,:!,,(5",(@.("'$/1'4(*77$!+*'!"&*55!'!"*$(#!5("+(!,*$, 5!,:!,,(5  %$'!#) *    )( +  %&*:$  %&*:$ %3 ;6-7 4/ +// <. 0= 1 >=  +// ?

 >=