High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/5620/2013disposed of

Hsidc (Now Hsiidc) v. Rattan Singh And ORS

2021-10-05Mr. Justice Anil Kshetarpal25 pages

! " #$%$&'( ) # ( "

( ( * *+

, (#- ., / *0 //(1023 #2*4/5* (*1* *-%06 ,

(#6#

76, 6% 8/06 . 2200 9 /

,*5

#+ :'4!&$, #! 4;, !%4 % + %*3,*5,**61 6

(# ,2%8 #61 6

2200 *

<==

2 ?0- *

6 76 6 <6 >

@A *B'&77<>#

> 8,*561 6

2200 * >

2 ?0- *

6 6 6

B'&

*'0.61 6

2200 0- *

6 <= =6<=

6<=

6<= 6<= 6<= 76>

<6>< 6 >< 76>< 6>< 6>< <6>< >6>< =6= 6= >6= = 6=>

76 <=

6 7

7 <>

= 3 61 6

2200 * 7< >=

= ;3061 6

2200 * 6 6 < >

,/@(0061 6 2200 *7

,*1,-26"6 .

! " !

& #

(

( )

( $ $

) (

# ( ( * +#, #-

+ + -

# .#* -)/ 0

1 2 %

* 3 $'

+ 4, 42 15

$4+,2#6(

# !# 8))9:: ( ( )

"#$%" $$$$

&' (" * + : < ' 9

=)# :):9)9::<# $

& #- % )9#:#:::4 , >9 < ' 9

=)# % )9#:#:::4

"#$%" $$$$

&' ("

9):9)9::< > -

=)9:# :9):>)9::< % )9#:#:::4 + -

98 < ' 9

=)# 9:):9)9::< % )9#:#:::4 3

& '(

(

# (

7 !

&)?

;4 ) 3 @ * +# %

&( :8):)9:

' ( A % )##8<4 )

(

A 9:B' (

(

) 9) 3

@ , #%

'(A% )9):#:::4( 9 ):9)9:>) :B

(

) >) 3

( -

+ # %

& ( :<):9)9:9# ))#% )9#:#:::4 ) ) 1(

@ + -

& ( ):)9:# ))#% )9#:#:::4 ) /$ $

( 5 )3

( * +# $ (

)$ $

7C$ ) $

# 9 ):)9::#

:):>)9::)/ $

#6( (

7 # $

' ( ( $

)D 76( $

( 0 ) $

! "

! # $"

# & & '

& !

(

)*+, - .

/.01/2)

3, * 4//.

5 & "

" # 6 !

# ! & "

" 6

$" ! ! !

5 #

! !

6 !

)

5 "

! !

5 # '

$ # (7 '$ "

(&-

# ! !

# "

8 "

5 #

" '! :

- (&- "

:6 & " "

- "

(&-

# "

! 8

5 " # !

- "

(&-

:6 & "

# !

# -

!9 5

; $ $

5 & '

& #

# "

! "

# 6

#6 "

# # "

$ "

'0$"

< /

3,,.

0 3,,.

# "

5 !

# 0 . = 3,,.

3,,.

5 !

# " < # 6( C$ $

9 ):)9:: (

# C$ 7 ( =&%

' & $ C$ 7A% )<#::#:::4 ) $

5 ;4

- 5 ' = (

3,3.

- .

3,,.023//

3,,.

' =

! ' # $" # ! # ,

6 ) % )):: , C$ 7 % =&%

' & $ C$ 7) % )9): ) , C$ 7) % ):):: @5

; $ $

41/29

! # " 6 !

# ,

% )9:):: , C$ 7 4% =&%

' & $ C$ 7) % )<):: ) , C$ 7) % ): ):: )

; $ $

41/2

5 !

# # # !

) 3,,+

! ; $ $

41/2 > /

( * +

$ $

$7C$ '(

A% )##8<4 )

( = & %

$% ) 9#:#:::4 ( % )<#::#:::4 ) 3

( * +#C$ 7/ / *( & C7//*& $

: ):)9::># 9' % )<#::4)C7//*& 5 ,)% (+# (

) /

( , # $

C$ 6( ) 5 & 7 23# C7//*&5 . 7 % # 7 , #C7//*& %3)C7//*&

:):8)9::9 % )#8#:::4) %

& :B'(

(

)

( -

+ # 5 C ? 23# C7//*& 5 . 7 % # 7 , ) $ # C7//*& ):<)9:> 8 % )9#:::4) 5 % )!#<:#:::4 %

& ) 3

( + -

5 %7 # 2 #( 7$ =$ 239) / # $ C7//*& #

& ) /$ ( .

)

( %

& 9:B' (

(

)$$

)$ * +,-. /0, * )$1 "!!

+,-- /,. %

(:B'( 4

(

) / $

# ( , # -

+ + -

'( $%

' $C$ 6( # # ( '( $) 2 #C7//*& $ 9

( , A:B

(

)

(

# .

(

;4 / '(

&# # #

'(E 9 3

(

(# E

'(# $

7 #9> 9

# !#$ 5 ;4 +2 &$ "$ "

" !

+2 " " $ "

5 ! #

& " @# #

# 9 "

" " " "

6 :!

# "

34 &$ "$ 5 "5($

@49

# $

& 6

6 ! A

@49 $"

6 "

# &B 6 "

C !

" @ 9

&B 6 "

" @ 9

&B 6 "

@ 9

$6!

" @ 9 "

# * &B 6 "

@4$9

6 !

! !

! # #! 6 !

@49

# &

6 "

# !

# " #

@39

6 ! ! !

! # A E 6 !

3/ &$ " 5 "5($

F & 6

" " # C

# C !

# C

" #

! 6 #

# # C $6!

# # C

$)!

# &

@49C !!

# < 3

%D =)<>9:8 $7 $"8)(5%()$ !$9# #5

(

;4 2 F "

# ! !

41/2 $

41/2 $ !

# "

& " !

3) 41/2 $

3) 3.

41/2 $

:34 &$ "$

5 "5($ ;+9

# $

& 6

G 6 ! A

@49 "

6 "

# &B 6 "

" @ 9

&B 6 "

! "

C " @ 9

&B 6 "

@ 9

" @ 9 "

# * &B 6 "

A@4 $9

6 !

! !

! # #! 6 ! "

@49

# & 6 "

# !

D "

# " #

@39

6 !

! !

! # A E 6 !

3/&$ " 5 "5($<F & 6

" " # C

# C

" #

# C

! 6 #

# # C

6 # # C !

# & A

@49EC A "

32 5 "5($

" ! ! 5 ! %" < 5 # & # & < .

3) 41/2 $ 6 !

@49 41/2 $

,/ ,* 3,,*

( " ! !

41/2 $

$ 3) 41/2 $ !

# "

6 !

# 43H 6 ! "

@49 41/2 $ # & 6 "

# !

% 3) 41/2 $

6 !

# ),H 6 ! #

41/2 $ ! #

" # "

6 !

41/2 $ !

# #

# # &

# "

6 !

5 &

( "# "# - !

5 6 !

0 ! 6

I "

6 !

# # # # "

# # "

I "

6 !

+ I "

6 !

& # < < !

5 &

# "

& #

! #

"! 6 !

" #

# "!

# " !

# < & 5 '

#$ )

$ $)

# ( ( ) /

( * +# $ $

$7C$ # ( 5 ()

& .

=& '$! !$)$ !$;

>0/2. 3.++ " 4..43.+3 6( ( '( % )9#:#:::4 $9::% )<#::#:::4 99):>)9::8##

>) 9 )/

$ $

# $

& ) ( $#

# !( '( ( 7 #

8))9::) C(#( ( $

( '

( 7

# !#

& :):)9::# $

9 ):)9:: 99):>)9::8 $

:<):)9::8#

% )9#:#:::4 % )<#::#:::4# ($ ) # =5

'$!;$(9 & .

! )/

( * +#%

< $ #

'( $% )#<#8<4( (% )9#:#:::4) C7//*&7C$ ( $ )$(

) + ( #

( , #-

+ + -

( # $ $

( $

7 C$

( ( $ $=&% )

# !# &

'( )/

( 5$ '

)F $# ( ( $

#( # ( $ #

$# $

5 $ ( )

' (

) $ ( ( ' '

) / # C "

7 & !$)$ ? $! !$;3.+09 ,%%/3@#& $

( (( ($

'$(

)& $ (

# !#( # &

' ( #& ( )

$# ' (

( * +#

( $ , #-

+ + -

A% )##8<4 5

(

)& >7 9>

# !# &$ $

(

) / #

( , # C7//*& ( (

) # ( $(

$#( # ( $

)7 $( $ #

) / $ #

( %)/$

( * +#

(

5 9:B '(

(

)7C7//*&( $ ) / #$(

)C7//*&

( , #

$ 2 - :B '(

(

#& 7 23 )C

(

) C(# . 7 %

C7//*&# 7) .# .# * 7 #

+7 #* 7 #%7 #2 7 ,

)(

$)/ #

) $ ' ( ) C

(

#$ ( $(

$)C(# (

( ( 5 :B'(

)D# $ 7 C7//*&

( * +) + ( # $ C7//*&5 ( ,

(

5 9:B'(

(

)C(#15 &

# $ (

)

(

1 "!!;$(9/

( $

(

A:B)

# (

$ ( )/ #

) /

( -

+ + -

# (

(

##$

(

# )

( ( & ) / (

) $C7//*&

, 5

(

$ ( , #-

+ + -

$% )#<#8<4 )/ #'(

( # ))#A##8<4 )

4;, !%4 &$("!

C 28*5? +) ? C2@0 +) ?

, # %.3 ) %D 4<9:49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7% =7/=6C =* ?C1%7 9) G?.-%48!4&/4 9: C)7)/)*)&)@7% =7/=6C =*?C1%7 >) G?.-%4>>49:9: %H = 7 1/=*F7%/

=* /=D% 7%F&F%1*1@1 ?2,1=&?%2?% /?=

*@7% =7/=6C =*?C1%7 ) %D 4<49:> C7/*&@77,).

I?C1%7 ) G?.-%48 4&/4 9: C)7)/)*)&)@7.

=*?C1%7 <) %D 4<>49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7.

% - =*?C1%7 8) %D 4<49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7% ,7/=6C =*?C1%7 ) %D 4<49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7*C %,7/=6C =* ?C1%7 !) %D 4<<49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@77 2

=*?C1%7 :) %D 4<849:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7% =@/%7/=6C =* ?C1%7 ) G?.-%44&/4 9: C)7)/)*)&)@7% =@/%7/=6C =*?C1%7 9) %D 4< 49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@72/%C/ =*?C1%7 >) %D 4<!49:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@77,)*C =2 / =* ?C1%7 ) %D 4<949:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7% =7/=6C =* ?C1%7 ) G?.-%44&/4 9: C)7)/)*)&)@7% =7/=6C =*?C1%7 <) %D 4<<49: % ,7/=6C@77 1?DC %H = =*?C1%7 8) %D 4<<<49: .

% -@77 1?DC %H = =*?C1%7 ) %D 4<<849: 2

=*?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = I ?C1%7 !) %D 4<< 49: *C % ,7/=6C =*?C1%7@77 1?D %H = =*?C1%7 9:) %D 48!:!49: % ,*C %/@77 1?DC %H = I?C1%7 9) %D 48!:49: =7% -@77 1?DC %H = I?C1%7 99) %D 48!49: 7,)7 %-?@77 1?DC %H = I?C1%7 9>) %D 48!949: % =*C/%@77 1?DC %H = I?C1%7 9) %D 48!>49: 7C) 1+C% ,@77 1?DC %H = I?C1%7 9) %D 48!49: %* %1I?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = I ?C1%7 9<) %D 4 :849: % ,&C =*1%I?C1%7@77 1?D

%H = I =?C1% 98) %D 4 8:>49: ./%, /I?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = I ?C1%7 9 ) %D 4 8:49: * %7C =7/=6C@77 1?DC %H = I ?C1%7 9!) %D 4 8:49: % ,2C

I =?C1%@77 1?DC %H = I ?C1%7 >:) %D 4 8:<49: C1, =@77 1?DC %H = I?C1%7 >) %D 4 8:849: , =-117/=6C@77 1?DC %H = I ?C1%7 >9) %D 4 8: 49: 7,)+ 7F%/I?C1%7@77 1?DC %H =

I =?C1% >>) %D 4 8:!49: ?,2 %+ 7CI =?C1%@77 1?D %H = I =?C1% >) %D 4!::49: % +17CI?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = I

=?C1% >) %D 4!<< 49: 1C7/=6C =*?C1%7@77 1?D %H = I?C1%7 ><) %D 4!<!:49: 7F% 7/=6CI?C1%7@77 1?DC %H =

I =?C1% >8) %D 4! :49: .

./%7/=6C@77 1?DC %H = I

=?C1% > ) %D 4>8!49: %* %7/=6C*1&1 71*C%?F6C %7@7 7 1?DC %H = I =?C1% >!) %D 4>>49:< 7C%/+%/7C = =*?C1%7@77 1?D %H = =*?C1%7 :) %D 4>>:49: 2%1,7/=6C =*?7@77 1?DC %H = =* ?C1%7 ) %D 4::49:! %/ &C =* =* ?C1%7 @7 7 1 ?D %H = =*?C1%7 9) %D 49849: .C %1 @7

=* &JF/7//?= &?

1&?%4 &F,4*/7%/&%1@1=F1?DD/&1% =*?C1%7 >) %D 4>: !49: %, = =* =* =?C1% @7

&JF/7//?=&?

1&?% =*?C1%7 ) %D 4>::49: ,F=7C/@77 1?DC %H = =*?C1%7 ) %D 49<49: % @/=*1% +F, % =* ?C1%7 @7 7 1 ?D %H = =*?C1%7 <) %D 49849: 7,)/7C %/ *1@/ =* ?C1%7 @7 7 1 ?D %H = =*?C1%7 8) %D 49!49: 7F%-1 =*?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = =* ?C1%7 ) %D 499:49: % =./% 7/=6C @7 7 1 ?D C %H = =* ?C1%7 !) %D 499949: ,1C %7/=6C 7/=&1*1&1 71*C%?F6CC/7

% =*?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = =* ?C1%7 :) %D 49>>>49: 7,)2H %/7/=&1*1&1 71*C%?F6C % =* ?C1%7@77 1?DC %H = =*?C1%7

) %D 498!!49: % -1=*1% 7/=6C =* ?C1%7 @7 7 1 ?D %H = =* =?C1% 9) %D 49:<49:!

K *7/=6C=?3*1&1 71*C%?F6CC/7 %7

=* ?C1%7 @7 7 1 ?D C %H = =* ?C1%7 >) %D 48 >49:! % 2 7/=6C =* =?C1% @7 7 1 ?D %H = ) %D 4<949:> C7/*& =?3 C7//*& @7 7,) *C =2 / =* ?C1%7 ) G?.-%4<!4&/4 9:

C7/*&@7*C =2 / =*?C1%7 <) %D 4<9949:> C7/*&=?3C7//*&@7- /7/=6C =*?C1%7 8) G?.-%4884&/4 9: C)7)/)*)&)@7- /7/=6C =*?C1%7