High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/39119/2025allowed

Balraj Kaur Alias Mahi Gill v. State Of Punjab

2025-09-16Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel7 pages

/ >

> > $%&2$1!*!%') $%&2$1!*!%') $%&2$1!*!%') $%&2$1!*!%')"$0#$9($4 "$0#$9($4 "$0#$9($4 "$0#$9($4. / > . / > . / > . / > #$ #$ #$ #$ !! E8$#!#!%'$ ?$* * ( "##$%& '

E$*0%'2$'# # ) ) ) ) $*$'#) $*$'#) $*$'#) $*$'#)

7+8"

" + + + + 8% !#"!',.2;%1#$&%# $0$#!#!%'$8 8:0$$#"!', . '

( (8 @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ @@@@@ + + + +.85+A .85+A .85+A .85+A " " " " $*$'#0$#!#!%' *($$'&!$2 '

'2$"$1#!%'C3%&# $ #!:

,!-"

-* "' !#. / 5&%* %#6

""7A&%,'#%&$, (!#% % # $0$#!#!%'$ !'1*$($!', %8//B 2# #$28/8 / C.$,!*#$$2&%# $ $ %&&$'1$*0 '!

!* ($ '2$"$1#!%'*C/4.C /. /%&# $ '2!'$'%2$.

. 34/5&%* % %#6 7A'2"$1#!%' C%&# $ 99!,#!%'1#.#%!1$"##!%'

' # .""

,8 8

$,;9$'%&# $$,#!%'* ,!'*## $0$#!#!%'$!*# ## $ $ 1%90!''#. '9$:. *!( "!', . $,$2 2 # # $ !'#$'2$2 #% *$'2 !* * 2 , #$ ;

;'$$# #%'2'2.&%# !*0 0%*$.1%'#1#$2?!*+'2 2 2'9% '#%&₹ .33.>//D#%# $ !98 $0!2 $*!2&!98 %<$;$.2$*0!#$# $ $ 0*$%&# $$ $:$*.'$!# $<*# $;!*!**

$2'%<*# $9% '#$# '$28 8 ;$' # $ 1 $= $* !** $2 #%<2* $0:9$ $'#F%'$ 2#$2 /8 8 / &%

₹ .33.>//D '2 '%# $ 2#$2 8/8 / CF<$$ 2!* %'% $2

0%' 0$*$'##!%'8 "!9!:. '%# $ 1%90!'# <* &!$2 (: *0 "!', . < % $,$2 # # $ 2 0!2 ₹.>.///D #% # $ 11 *$2 &% *$1 !', ;!* #% '28 $*0!#$ # !* 0:9$'#. '% ;!* <* !** $2. '% <* # $ 9% '# $& '2$28& # $1%90!'#<*%2,$2(:'

!#"!', .< %$,$2# #%' 38/C8 / . $0!2₹>.///D*&!$1 ,$*'2# $$&#$.'22!#!%'* 9 %& ₹>.3/.///D # % , 1 $= $ #% # $ 11 *$28 %<$;$. '$!# $ <* ;!* ',$2 &% !9. '% <* # $ 9%'$: $# '$28 ' # $ (*!* %& # $ (%;$ 1%90!'#*. ' !'= !: <* 1%'2 1#$28 # <* &% '2 # # # $ 0$#!#!%'$ 2 1 $#$2# $1%90!''#*%&#%#9% '#%&₹ .3.>//D '2$# $0$#$G#%& *$'2!',# $9(%28%'*$= $'#:.' <*$,!*#$$2,!'*## $%<'$* '2 **%1!#$* %& # $ &!9. '9$: !* ' "!', . 0$$# "!', . *0$$#

. ! 50$#!#!%'$ $$!'A. $$#. 9'. !:. %# . '2 "!9 "'2 8 8 +$'$21% '*$&%# $0$#!#!%'$ *, $2# ## $0$#!#!%'$!* !' 1 *#%2: *!'1$ 88 / C8 +$'$2 1% '*$ * & # $ , $2 # # # $ 0$#!#!%'$ *($$'&*$:!90!1#$2!'#%# $ !'= $*#!%'8+$'$21% '*$ *& # $!#$#$2# #.!'&1#.!#!*# $1%11 *$2.'9$:. !* '"!', '2 # $0$#!#!%'$<*%':<%-!',!'# $&!9%<'$2(:# $*!211 *$28+$'$2 1% '*$ *& # $* (9!##$2# ## $0$#!#!%'$!*2:,$2(% #:$*8

*.$, (!!*0:$2&%8 C8 +$'$2"##$1% '*$ *%00%*$2# $0$*$'#0$#!#!%'(:, !', # ## $$,#!%'*!*$2$*$!% *!''# $'2# *.# $0$#!#!%'$2%$*'%# 2$*$;$# $1%'1$**!%'%&# $$, (!8+$'$2"##$1% '*$*$$-*#%01$ %' $1%2 1 *#%2: 1$#!&!1#$ 2#$2 C8/8 / > !' % #. < !1 !* #-$' %' $1%28

;$ $2 1% '*$ &% # $0#!$* '2 ;$ ,%'$ # % , # $ ;!($$1%2*%&# $1*$8 $&%$ 2$;!', !'#% # $ 9##$ & # $. !# <% 2 ($ ,$9'$ #% $&$ $$!'# $1*$<,%;$'!',# $!** $!' '2) H>8 2!-'#! *!9 '2 %# $* ;*8 (!1 %*$1 #%. !, 2!-'#! *!9 '2 %# $* ;*8 (!1 %*$1 #%. !, 2!-'#! *!9 '2 %# $* ;*8 (!1 %*$1 #%. !, 2!-'#! *!9 '2 %# $* ;*8 (!1 %*$1 #%. !, % # %& '2 2$* B3 " C . % # %& '2 2$* B3 " C . % # %& '2 2$* B3 " C . % # %& '2 2$* B3 " C . $$;'# < $$%&$2** '2$) H/8

$ *!,'!&!1'1$ '2 *<$$0 %&#!1$ 9-$ # $ 2$0!;#!%' %& !($#: 9##$ %& ,;$ 1%'1$' '2 0$9!**!($ %':< $'# $< # %!*!',!#!*$*%'($. $;$' '2$2'2 ,$$2#%# $,%*%&1%99 '!#:,%%2'2"##$'$1$**!#:*0$# % # !'#!1$ 8 '2$$2. # $ 1%'*!2$#!%'* ;$ *$# % # * 1!#$! $ ,$9'$ #% # $ 1%'*#!# #!%' 0%0%*!#!%' ;$ 2$2 1$28$*%'($'$**0%*# #$*!'#$!,$'#1$'20$2!1#$* # #2$0!;#!%'%&&$$2%9(:$& *%&(!!*'%#&%0 '!#!;$ 0%*$ ( # &% # $ (!&%1 !'#$$*#* %&

*#!1$#% # $ !'2!;!2 !';%;$2'2*%1!$#:&&$1#$28 8 I$9 *#<$!, # $1%'#:&1#%*#%'*<$# $#$*#%& $*%'($'$**. * ( $1# #% # $ '$$2 &% *$1 !', # $ 0$*$'1$. %& # $(!00!1'#8 #9-$**$'*$#%** 9$# #9'%'(! * ($##$1 '1$#%0$0$%0$*$'# !*1*$# '%'$$9'2$2!' *#%2:8 '2 !& 0 (!1

*#!1$ !* #% ($ 0%9%#$2. 9$1 '!1 2$#$'#!%'* % 2($1%*$#%% *.# $& '1#!%'%&(!!*!9!#$2. J1%99 '!#:%%#*J%&# $.00!1'#$*#$**$2'2.&#$# $?$ % '2#!%'J*' ##'!% $1#.9%'$#:* $#:* !0!*%*!', ,% '28 $ 1%'*!2$($ 0 (!1 $G0$'*$ !' -$$0!', !' 1 *#%2: < $$'%2',$%&2!*00$'1$%2!*# ('1$1'!*$.!*'%# '$,!,!($ 1%'*!2$#!%'8 = : !90%#'# !* # $ 2$0%($ 1%'2!#!%'. ;$,!', %'8 # $ !'

9'. %& % * ( !*. # # # $

'$<2!', 1 $#: '2 $G0$'*!;$ 1 *#%2: %& ;%!2($ !'11$#!%' 9-$* $& * %& (! '$*%'($ '2 %!1: &;% !',$$*$

*#:*$'*!($8 8 &$< %# $ <$!, #: &1#%* 2$*$;$ $&$$'1$8 2$0!;#!%'%&!($#:!*;!2#$2(:*%1!2$&$'1$'2!'2!;!2 1%$1#!%'%',''#!1!9!'2!$1#!%'8 (!1

*#!1$!*1$'# #%# $< %$*1 $9$%&(!<8$$!',

*#!1$9 *#($&%(!22$' ( #0 '!#!;$ * '$*** % 2($9!'!9!*$28$*#%#!;$2$;!1$*#% $2$$9 # $ 9'. $;$'. # % , 1%99 '!#: *$;!1$. 9$2!##!;$ 2!. *# 2: 1**$* % %# $ $*% 1$* * % 2 ($ !''%;#$2. '2 0:!', &% <!# 0 (!1 0$1$ (:#90$!', <!# $;!2$'1$. !'#!9!2#!', <!#'$**$* % 1%99!##!', %&&$'1$ < !$ %'

2!1!: *'1#!%'$2J&$$$'#$0!*$.J* % 2($0%;!2$2,!'*#8 %*$$-$ %&

*#!1$* 0:1%'&!2$'1$#!1-*%'# $1% #%1%99 '!#:8

*.1%'2!#!%'*9:($ ',% '2(!%2$*.'%##%1!00$( # #% 0%#$1#8 "

1 !* # $ %!*#!1

!*2!1#!%' '2 9'!*#!1 %!$'##!%' !';%-$2 (: # $

2!1! 2!*1$#!%' 1%$#$2 #% # $ ; $*%&% 1%'*#!# #!%'8K >8 8 # $. # $ %'7($ "

0$9$ % # !'

2,9$'# #!#$2 * 1 '"!', ;*8"##$5 %&$ !AB35A"3. 1 '"!', ;*8"##$5 %&$ !AB35A"3. 1 '"!', ;*8"##$5 %&$ !AB35A"3. 1 '"!', ;*8"##$5 %&$ !AB35A"3. * $2*

'2$)

C HI $$# $,'#!',%&(!!$*<!# !'# $2!*1$#!%'%&# $1% #.

1% #.

1% #. # $,'#!',%2$'!!*$, #$2.#%,$$G#$'#.(:# $&1#* '21!1 9*#'1$*%&$1 0#!1 1*$8"!'1$# $%( $1#%&# $ 2$#$'#!%' % !90!*%'9$'# %& # $ 11 *$2 !* #% *$1 $ !* 00$'1$'2* (9!**!%'#%# $

!*2!1#!%''2# $

2,9$'#%& # $1% #.

1% #.

1% #.# $0!9:!'= !:!*< $# $$1%,'!L'1$%(%'2 <% 2$&&$1## #$'28K >8 # $9%$. # $ %'7($ "

0$9$ % # !'

2,9$'# #!$2 * "'

: '2;*8 5 / A"C/. "'

: '2;*8 5 / A"C/. * $2* '2$) H 8

'(!00!1#!%'*.,$'$:.!# *($$'!22%<'&%9 # $$!$*##!9$*# ## $%( $1#%&(!!*#%*$1 $# $00$'1$ %&# $11 *$20$*%'# !*#!(:$*%'($9% '#%&(!8 $ %( $1#%&(!!*'$!# $0 '!#!;$'%0$;$'##!;$8$0!;#!%'%& !($#:9 *#($1%'*!2$$20 '!* 9$'#. '$**!#1'($$= !$2 #%$'* $# #'11 *$20$*%'<!*#'2 !*#!< $'1$2

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

$ 0$#!#!%'$ <* $*#$2 %' 88 / C < $$!'&#$ !';$*#!,#!%' <* 1!$2 % # '2 1 ' <* 0$*$'#$2 !' # $ 1*$ %' /8/8 / >8 ,$*!'# $1*$!' '2<$$&9$2%'>8/ 8 / >8 %#B 0%*$1 #!%'<!#'$**$* ;$($$'1!#$2.( #%':/ *($$'$G9!'$2#!2#$8

#!*.# *!'2 (!#($# #1%'1 *!%'%&# $#!<!#-$!#*%<'#!9$8 $ !; 1%'#$'#!%' !*$2 # ,!;$ !*$ #% 2$(#($ !** $*. < !1 * $**$'#!:($#!%1!'#$2 0%'2 !',# $1% *$%&#!8 !*% #2%$*'%# 2$$9!#00%0!#$#%2$;$2$$0!'#%# $*$!;1%'#$'#!%'*.## !**#,$.$*# !# 9: 0$

2!1$ # $ #!8 %# !', #',!($ * ($$' (% , # &%<2 #% !'2!1#$# $!-$! %%2%&# $0$#!#!%'$(*1%'2!',&%9# $0%1$**%&

*#!1$ %!'#$&$!',<!# # $0%*$1 #!%'$;!2$'1$8

> 488

$ 0$#!#!%'$ !* 2: ,$2 (% # :$* 5* 0$ 9$9% %& 0#!$*00$'2$2<!# # $0$#!#!%'A. $'1$.(!0$#!#!%'% , ##%($1%'*!2$$2 !';!$<%&0%;!*%#%"$1#!%'C3/5 A ""8 #!*0$#!'$'##%9$'#!%' $$!' # ## $0%;!*%#%"$1#!%'C3/ "". / .!*0!9#$!<!# 0%;!*%#% "$1#!%'CB888.B8 '# !*$,2.!#<% 2($00%*!#$#%$&$ $$!'#%

2,9$'#0**$2(:# !*% #%'C8/8 / C!' >/ >/ >/ >/ / C / C / C / C#!#$2 *6;!'2$ ?*8"##$%& '

( 6;!'2$ ?*8"##$%& '

(752$!',<!# 0%;!*%#%"$1#!%'CB 888A.$$;'## $$%&$2** '2$) # <% 2 ($ 00%*!#$ #% $&$ $$!' #% # $ 2!1# %&

2,9$'# %& # $

%'J($"

0$9$% #!'1*$%&6"#$'2$

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

*0%;!

4 48 8 *0$1 *#%2:1$#!&!1#$2#$2C8/8 / >&!$2(:$'$2"##$ 1% '*$.# $0$#!#!%'$ *$2:* &&$$2!'11$#!%'&%0$!%2%&(% # / 9%'# *8 * 0$ # $ *!2 1 *#%2: 1$#!&!1#$. # $ 0$#!#!%'$ !* *##$2 #% ($ !';%;$2!'%# $ 5*A8 '2 (!#(:.# $'#$1$2$'#*%&0$*%'$$= !$2 #%($11% '#$2&%< !$1%'*!2$!',$, (!0$#!#!%'0$&$$2(: !98

%<$;$. # !* &1# 9 1''%# ($ ,% '2 * &&!1!$'# (: !#*$&. #% 2$1!'$ # $ 1%'1$**!%'%&$, (!#%# $0$#!#!%'$!'# $ !'= $*#!%'< $'1*$!* 92$% #&%,'#%&$, (!= # $ !'= $*#!%'(:#!%1!'#!', 0%' # $&1#*D1!1 9*#'1$*%&# $*!2 8$!'1$!'# !*$,21'($01$2

0%' # $

2,9$'# %& # $ %'7($ "

0$9$ % # !' ' % 28 9! ' % 28 9! ' % 28 9! ' % 28 9! * 2!;8"##$%&88'2 * 2!;8"##$%&88'2 * 2!;8"##$%&88'2 * 2!;8"##$%&88'2'%# $. / 5A5!9!'A>34 '%# $. / 5A5!9!'A>34 '%# $. / 5A5!9!'A>34 '%# $. / 5A5!9!'A>34N!;!*!%' $'1

2,9$'#%&# $ %'7($1 ## !, % #!'1*$%&"!2 *;8 "!2 *;8 "!2 *;8 "!2 *;8 "##$. 3 5 A 5!9!'A CBB "##$. 3 5 A 5!9!'A CBB "##$. 3 5 A 5!9!'A CBB "##$. 3 5 A 5!9!'A CBB M

2,9$'#* %& # !* % # !'

%833

%833 / / / / #!#$2 * - !$* "!', ;8 "##$ %& :'.

- !$* "!', ;8 "##$ %& :'.

- !$* "!', ;8 "##$ %& :'. 2$1!2$2 %' 88 / .'2 ;8"##$%& :'.35A5!9!'A8 ;8"##$%& :'.35A5!9!'A8 ;8"##$%& :'.35A5!9!'A8 ;8"##$%& :'.35A5!9!'A8 "

&&!1$#%*:.& # $2$#$'#!%'%&# $0$#!#!%'$*' '2$#!!* '%#<'#$2!'# $&1#*'21!1 9*#'1$*%&# $1*$8 B8

' ;!$< %& (%;$. # $ 0$*$'# 0$#!#!%' !* %<$28 $#!#!%'$ !* %2$$2#%($$$*$2%'$, (!%' $& '!* !',(!D* $#:(%'2*#%# $ *#!*&1#!%'%&# $+281%'1$'$2D #:,!*##$8 %<$;$.!'22!#!%' #%1%'2!#!%'*# #9:($!90%*$2(:# $1%'1$'$2D #:,!*##$.# $ 0$#!#!%'$* $9!'(% '2(:# $&%%<!',1%'2!#!%'*) 5!A

$0$#!#!%'$* '%#9!* *$# $!($#:,'#$28 5!!A

$0$#!#!%'$* '%##90$<!# ':$;!2$'1$.%% 2%1 9$'#:.2 !',# $#!8 5!!!A $0$#!#!%'$* '%#(*$'# $*$&%'':2#$($&%$ # $#!8 5!;A $0$#!#!%'$* '%#1%99!#':%&&$'1$< !$%'(!8

B 5;A

$0$#!#!%'$ * 2$0%*!# $0**0%#. !& ':. <!# # $ #!% #8 5;!A

$ 0$#!#!%'$ * ,!;$ $ 1$0 %'$ ' 9($ #% # $

';$*#!,#!',&&!1$D"

%&1%'1$'$2%!1$"##!%''2 * '%# 1 ',$ $ 1$0 %'$ '

9($ <!# % # 0!% 0$9!**!%'%&# $#!% #D =,!*##$8 5;!!A $0$#!#!%'$* '%#!'':9''$#:#%2$:# $#!8 38

' 1*$ %& ($1 %& ': %& # $ &%$*!2 1%'2!#!%'* '2 # %*$ < !1 9: ($ !90%*$2 (: 1%'1$'$2 D #: ,!*##$ * 2!$1#$2 $$!'(%;$% 0%'* %<!',':%# $* &&!1!$'#1 *$.# $"##$D1%90!''# * ($#!($#:#%9%;$1'1$#!%'%&(!%&# $0$#!#!%'$8 8 2$$211%2!',:8 /8

%# !',*!2 $$!'(%;$* ($1%'*# $2*'$G0$**!%'%& %0!'!%'%'# $9$!#*%&# $1*$8 8 "!'1$ # $ 9!' 1*$ * ($$' 2$1!2$2. 0$'2!', 9!*1$'$% * 00!1#!%'.!&':.* *%*#'2*2!*0%*$2%&&8 5" + " + " + " +A "$0#$9($4 "$0#$9($4 "$0#$9($4 "$0#$9($4. / > . / > . / > . / > 9 ;! I $# $*0$-!',D$*%'$2) $*D % I $# $$0%#($) $*D %