← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRFA/1493/2015dismissed

Supriya Batta And ORS v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2015-09-28Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain5 pages

 

 

  

 

  

    

    !"#$ %"

!!&&

'

(% )"#  %"

 ! 

!"#$ %&'()! *+,-.) "/)+0 -%1"( *" +"#, -'- "%!!&& 

"/)+0 -%1"(  (%!"  !!& % . & /

 % 0"

  -0%".#%&"

 ".&0

%.2

.#%& 0 "

 &# $" &#-%  "%&   "'  

'&&/  $% %%! "-  (% &      "  3 "/ -  0  /%    . 4 ".#% )"#  "" " "

56-3 "/ - '       5 -

  "      %   4  - " %"-8%9:;0 &&0.#  

5 %(% 4  &&"7 " %"-8% &&"9:'0" 

%1"<'&  4 "& =6-->?!""//"'/

%0" &&"-%& 0 "

&.2

-0%%0"" ""% &"

 & ", /-0%<! / '0%1"&!& "".#%!" -

%.2

&.#%& 0 "

. /1.""'0"   ; % 0"0%%

1! /  %!" !!& "



& "%!!&& .1%%%"

& 0 "

-0% & 0 4 "' 1   -%'.

 0"  %/%"  1!

 -  0%"   &#  %  !!&&  %'  .

 "1 (%#% &.2

   %. "%&&" "1< /" %&"

 " .&0 "

1 "1!

 (%&"

 ".&0' 0"   -

% 1. /1."";0

.1%%  "".#%&"

 ".&0%% "  &.#%& 0 "

0 1.""-"&&#""  )

.1% "1 %!"'

 %-% .2

 &. &0% @0<  "1% 0" %& 0 "

"!" %1 !" 1 %0";

%" -0 &.0% 50< %"!  "1% &&" %"0% @1 % "1% %&&"9 0"-0%%'"!"@!" "

(%.2

.#%!!&& % &.

"0% &1  )"&"



& "%!!&& !"

%!!"?

.< (%   -  0%%  "  '   "1  %  ""  "  %

    % 0

  5 (% &&"  

  %  0"        ;        .#  % !!&& %%#% "'%1!

 %4 "& "%%#0"  %< 0&/ %0".#%&&" !!&&   "'%1 1!

 65   !!&&   "'%1!

 65  %" - 0%%  ! - %%.2

0" &.#%!!&&

   %      &  1"@-  %  

  0%%  " "



" .#%  " - 0%%"%.2

&.#% !!&& "."0% 1.#

" /%&1 "1 %%!!&& &1%%#%'"' %1

1!

  "  "1 %    %# 1&# %  %  < 0&/  



1 %0"(%1  %!!&& %%#

&  %  .2

         %#  %  %  < 0&/    % 

1 %0".#%&&"  

   % @".&0

A2 ))!)%.),*!,37: #!"

" 0%%

  !  % 0" 1#-  .# 0"  !!&   % &&"-"4 "%%1"." "".#%&&"

"%"1  % "-0%%"% .2 . %1 "1 %& -%1 1!

 -% !"

0%1 !#.&-"%!!" 1 1!

 1 /%!"

"  :(%!!& %&& %/" 0%%.2

%0" <

*"'%'"# %!!& %&&.1-?

7: %!"

1< /0 !" ""!" . &&"%10% %1% 0"-0% @ 0< "1% %&&"9 0"B 7.:  %" -0% @0< %"! 

"1%&&" - .?

 :-"

0% @1 % "1% %&&"9 0"- 0%%'"!" %&& "

@!"C (%       !"'  %        #  !"

"  !%0"-%1#.#0" !!& % &&""4 "%%1"." ""% "(%.2

."/" /1 "1 %& -%1 1!

 -% !"

   0%1     !#.&  "  %  !!" 1     1!



1 %!"

" (%!!& % &  %/"

0%%%0" .2*"'  .?

  %!"' "%!" 0%%%.2

 &. & & 7:%" !"' % !"

!" ""!"  . "  %  &&"    %  1    

1     %  0"-  % .2

. &0% @1 % "1% %&&"9

0"& 7.:!"' % %" -%.2

. 0% @0< %"!  "1%&&"

 %"0% @1 % "1% &&"9 0"- 0%%'"!"@!" "



  D

" !& #7 4  :  %"' %1  + &&  %  &&     %"

-  7

5:

    -  ) 9.&  %  !"1 "

"%

 0%%"&1 !"' "

7 % " & /.2

.@   0

0" /'*"/"!% 6 %" "@" .&0

A6    ; ."11."%% 4 

71 1 :75  :0  !" ". /% &1 @" %!0"

 -5  & @& %1 !  #/" .#%  "   (< /  / E     %  &1  !" ".  

!"'  .?

 -%!"'

1 0" @!"

&#@ (% /%

%1  '&.&- %&1

!"'  .?

 1#.".

!&&0- %.

 % !!& .# 4   71 1 :    75      :-  %  

! &&#1 

  .0 %&&" % " %&&">D!"

"1 &#  "# 

"%- &  / 0%&1< /"  "

 ;

 &

" %%&&">D 0%&1< /"  -  "# %"#

&&         "  "  %  ! "!           % 1      (% /%%"1#.- '0 !  &1 !"' "!"'  7 %- 0" %

"'0% .?



 

 . !!&  % !"'    .?

  7 : 

 (%&&">D-%" "-  "0%

%   "# %"# 7:(%" "-   %1 

.!!& "@

%!" &1 !" ". "!"'  .?

 (%)/% "-%" "-0 

 "/%   /%%&&"  "  %1 C71!% !!&: (%  1  '0  0 &&0       F"

< ' @ 1 -7 :6 .#%  "  

G  



   - 5?

    

    - 5  ?   

       

?

 !"# $ "  -  6  '0 % 

 &0-%&# & .2

/

%0" %&&"

.  ;

  % -%!!&& 0"0&&0" %4  !" !!&&  % &%' &%.2

. "%&&"

. "6 -0%" !!&&   - % &%' &% 1 . "6 -0%%%#%' & -0%%0"&"&# .# %!"!" ". "% 

" /%   &1"@-;  % # &&/&#% . 11.#%&"

  "

%.2

&.#%!!&& 1.""" /&#-% !!&



  72 %$ &:

'

, /