High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/647/2016dismissed

Ganesh Dass v. Amina & ORS

2017-09-26Mr. Justice P.B. Bajanthri,Mr. Justice Karamjit Singh14 pages

!!"# $ " %%% &'$()'*+,($-. /0&,(), ) $'1,$ )'*+,($-. /0&,$- ),2)$//$0 %%%

!!!

$- ),2)$//$03-

!" # $#%%&'

#() # )& * +, - . $-!, $#) )&

( #(

#,#

, #0

#! $#) )&1 # (#

#2 #( 3 4 5 #2 #(3 6# !"

# $#%%&' #( )74

# 2 #( 3 4

6 #(# # #%

!" # $#%%&'#(

" )7#2 #(3 (# # # #(*'&-%-30 1 ! #(*8-%-30!9

# 6

2 0 7#

)& 1 ! #( *&-&%-30 # )&

2 #, #( # 6

2 0 7 ( !# #( :

9# #! #, #( # 2 ,, $#) ))& *

$ # ! ;

2 0 7 , (# * - <

# & : ! ( , # #( #, #( #

$#8& )& #((#( * <

- . /# 6=

7> # # - * # #, #( # $#8&#(& #

#((#( * -<

#( # -*

#( $#) )&!# )&# #

# #( (#

( #, #( # $#8& )& 5 ! # #(

-,##(!

5 ( !" # $#%%&'#()(# # )& # # * # # #

#(( ! # #!

## # # # , !# ! - !# #(

=# #- # $##'6(# , # 7 ! # , # # # - - #! :

1 !(#

( #, #( #

# #( - !2 > # * +, # ! ( ( # *

-. /# #( #, #( #

, # # , * -$- (#

( # 4 * +, #

, - #, -

- /

7 #!

#(( ! # :

1 #, #( # - (# - (

( #, #( # # # # # -

# (

( #

*# $#0/

## , # #

# - - ! # #! :

#, #( # - (# - #! -

* +,

9 #, !" # $#%%&'#( )

# )& * +, # #(

# #

" !

# (#

!# # #

# (#

! #

#! #, #( # , ## # # (# #( '

''#(* -8) 6

( # ( #@ #(8)A74 * #

# #

(# #, #( # $#8& )& , (#

( # 4 , ! 2

$ /

# , ! , #(( #( *

# #- * # #!# #( )#( #(8)#

9 ( # (

, # #,, # > # #(# -

# (##, ,B0

!" "#-67 * *6 !7&) " $ " # $! %#" - 6'7 %% '

&''(" $!) # "

#-688&7 ' $ '

* "(+",-* # +",-* #" #-6887 % $ %* " # .(*

## /0( /

# 1( " #-67 *%

"$ # +.(*

## ,1 -'-88867 * *6 !7 & ')''#2 3 # ('$*

3 #1& 6%7* *6 !7 8 ) *" # # - >*8%%+

% 8 (## '

$ $ " '

$" #1 >*8'' # &) " !! # #(# ## (#

!# # ##:

&#( #(8) ,# , ; ## # #(# ( #

&6767>

( #! $#) )& * - +,

## , # #(8)- :

( #( # - :# #

# ##( 0* 3*

-# # #2 #!#

#(8),#, * # #(

# ( , # , # (#

# # * ( #, #

! > #(

2 #!# (- ## # * ,## #

#(# ;# 1#,! - 0 - * #, ##

, #B0

' # #( # #

# # B0 C' ##. #"0( #! # 0D2 E# '-))

)8F-! # - , ## # ##

- #

#((0 7 # # 2 # -# - #( # #( # # - #

& # -# 67 !# #( # -# 67 #( # - !# -

# #, 0#(0 # 2

( C - (2

#( #! #!# :

'# # * ?(( # ( ( # , # ( ,

#( # 6 7#67#(#

' # G* ?(( ## (# #(

#, # (

# #( # # , B0 4567( *-! # -* # !!

0 /67

# #!# #

-'- %- 8-&%-&&-))

)8- ##

- # 2 # - # !- # # G (# -

(# #(( , #,(#

'--%

#! - ( #, # #

# # ## -* - ,

# #2(# # -

#( ( #2 # #( # (- # #( -(

%-#

0# 67

((

' 6'7 #(( # ; , # ## , 2

# ,# # # ! 24 67 ( ( # #( # (#

!2# 4

67 #(

# !-

# - ( (#( #( # # # 67

(# # #!##0 # 67

#, 0* -,# (# , (# , #* #,##

6%7$# # ###( # # H >(,# # #! ( #!# -

# 2 # # !# (# * -# , * #, # (

#(2

2 (( #!# #!

0# 6'7#( '6 7 # * ?(( # ( ( #, # # 2 , ( # > # ; , :

# #(# (# # - # ( (, # ( #( # (# (# ##( #( -, # # #

!- # * ?(( # ( , # # # (# ;

(

# # # 0

* ?(( # ##, ##

( #(

0# 6'7#( '% # * ?(( # ( ##( #

# -

B0 7 >(

# ,## # # 2 2# -# 67(

# # #(( #

# -

-# 67(

# ,## # #2 -

!# 2# >(

#( !

- #(( ( # # # # #

- # - #!# #( &- #(( # #

# (# ( # # 2 # # # > # (# #, #( #

# # G #!# #( ''#( #(8) # # #

''#(

#(8) ##, #( # # G , B0 455 2 /!/ * 0 8-'! .( .##!$0 59/67 5# # #( '- (##, #, 0#( # # # G-

( #(2 #, 0#(0 #

#(E> F , (# (# -

#, 0#(0 # 2 (#

) * # 0* , ,# # 0 4 67 ( (# E

#(>

, # (# F- #, 0# 0 # 2(#

+ 4 67 ( (# # # E> F-

#, 0#(0 # 2(#

# --+ E>

F # # I0 # -# !EJJJF#( /#! B

#! (##, # # ; #

0#((# # (# ##(2

#, 0#(0 # 6 7

67#( -

0 67 # ,# # #(# (

,# :# # # ! ## B 67 # ,# !#

67 # 2 ,( # #

# 67> #(! # * # 0* # + -

-( ( #, 0#(0 # !# 2 # # # -

,# ; #

#((# # (# 6'7## ! #!#

#(2# - * # 0* # +

(## ##( # # # -# # , # ( -

2 -# ## (# 2

#, 0#(0 # #

* ## #(,#( ##(, # # ( #( # ! 2(#

# # # (# (H

#( #!;# #!# :

''#( #(8) , ( # , # 2

#(> , #( 8)(# (#

# , #

#(> , # (# 4

-, # #

# > # # ,(

#!#

( 2

#(2# #(#, #( #

#(> , #(8)(# (# - #, #( # 2(#

# * , ,# # 0 >

- #( #, #( # 6

2 7 :

- /

## 9;# # !

#, #( #

* #( #( $#) )&

2 7

# ,

(

(# !# -( ## #(!

# #!# #( #( 8)- * ?((

(# #

# - -( # (,# # #

'#'%6 71#,! - # # # # (# ( - ! ( #, # (

(# * #!# #( & * ?(( ( #, # # ## (# # # #(( )

# #!# #( B0 K:9 '*! & !'## #"'

!'#0.

# #' #1!'#. # 1"- /"#! 0

( -, # # # #-

, # # #-(#

#((

2# #( -

# # 4# 67

! # #((

8# - ( # #

#( - # ( # #( #

4# 67 ( #

# -

-# :

# # -#

# # ## #-# #

# # 4# 67

4 , # (# ,

2 #! - # ,( -# ,# 45 # !!

0 *0

0. #0( #067 ##

#(( # #:

#,#( #((

#((

# # , # #(> # / -EJJJF* # 0* - ,# # - # 0 -

-#(( # 67?((

# # #(( 2 #, #

##( + #( # H 1#,! -

- # ## #

* # * > # (# (

! 0 #

, !

6 # 7 (#

( #, #( # 6

2 7#

# ! (

* -<

* -/# # # # # # #!

# #(

,# ( * ! #

# , # #

2 ( 00 ! ( * - <

- . /# %8&, :

#, #( # $#8& )& 2 /

( !# #( 1

#(( ( , # ; #( * - $! $# )&9#

#-* -+, # ! ( # ! * - <

! $# )&

$# ')& !, # #, #( # , # , * -<

> !,#( #((# #(

# # ! ( # - # #(# #

(# !#

# (#

( * -+, #

, , ( # #, #( # , , * -<

-# #

#(#, #( # 6

2 7" !# # ,# (# * # # ##

( #(

# * #, #,# *

!1 # # #

# # 9- # * ( ;# (# 59 #(

1 # - #( ')''#2 ;#0#+#(. , , #,

( 2

, * ?(( : . *

3# 0*

# /#! # # ( ,

( ( #

)#( #(8) ((-* ?(( # # # * ?((

# # 8#-'

'% -# # - ## #* ?(( #

! ( ! # # # #(# # !, #(59 , ( # ! D2 .# - #: # ( ! #

" # # #

( #-!, : 59 #(

1 # ')''#2 ;#0#+#(. ,

#! 1# A

;#0#+#(. , > (

1 # -,(##, # #, 5 9 ' )''#2 ;# 0# +#(. ,1 " #

$#)%)#( # /

2!/#! #(

# , # ( ! (# # ,, #,

1 # #

$ 2A , > !,#( -!, # 59

#! 2 # #( , #, " $ ;#0#+#(. ,

&''(" ;#0#+#(. ,

# #!

# #(

1#,! -( #( %* ;#0#+#(. ,1 "$ ;#0#+#(. ,1*" # ;#0#+#(. ,

(## '

$;# 0#+#(. ,

- !##(

-, ## ##1#,! -

! - ! -,# # : ( # #( -8 ' +)$ < , + $= , $. - 9>19?@A *

+ ,