Commissioner Of Income Tax-I Ludhiana v. M/S Verdhman Textiles Ltd. Ludhiana


 

   

   

 !"#"$%&%'() 

**%&&%'"+'$*" ,
-./#0% '

122"33 '!

4&

5&4"+#0* '",!%3"&.!#-./#0% '

"&2'#"'!

 


  


   +"&"'!(

+4 %60 7 /2! -#7$ !"- +!0" 22"33 '!

& #0%8 9/+%-9"'%+#7$ !"- :%!0 +&0 ';; +: 3-#7$ !"- +!0"+"&2'#"'! <<<<

%!/ 0+%- + 3 0"%'&! '! 22" 3/'#"+9"$!%'=!0"'$*" ,$!- >=-0 &6""'%3"# ; %'&!!0"+#"+# !"#2 &&"#6?!0" '$*" ,22"33 !"+%6/' 3- 0 '#%; +0-:0"+"6? 22" 3%3"#6?!0"

&&"&&""
5&4"+#0* '",!%3"&.!#0 &6""' $$"2!"# '#+#"+# !"# =2 &&"#6?!0" **%&&%'"+'$*" , 22" 3-./#0% '

+"3 !%';!!0" &&"&&*"'!?" +@
A0 &6""'&"! &%#" +%" $!&!0"$ &" +"!0 !!0" &&"&&""0 #%3"#%!&+%;%' 3 +"!/+'%'$*"+!0" &&"&&*"'!?" +@
A'@#"$3 +%'; !! 3%'$*" &-=-A-=-@5
. !"+'-!0" &&"&&""%3"#%!&+"7%&"# +"!/+''>#"$3 +%';%'$*" &-@---)5
&&"&&*"'!

/'#"+9"$!%') !0"'$*" ,$!: &$*23"!"#7%#"+#"+# !"#


>:"7"+-!0"&&"&&%'; %$"+- !"++"$+#%';!0"+" &'&+ +"2"'%';!0" &&"&&*"'!/'#"+9"$!%')@!0"'$*" ,$!-%&&/"# '!%$"!!0" &&"&&""/'#"+9"$!%')A!0"$!/+%';!0"$/+&" +" &&"&&*"'!2+$""#%';&-!0"+" &'&+"$+#"#++"2"'%';:"+"&"+7"# /2'  !0"  &&"&&""   4%#"  3"!!"+  # !"#  -  !0"  &&"&&""  + %&"# 6B"$!%' 33";%';%!!6" +"7%":!0"" +3%"+#"$%&%'!0"&&"&&%';

%$"+  0"  &"$'#  6B"$!%'    !0"  &&"&&""  : &  !0 !  !0"+"  : &  ' /'# !%'++*%';!0"6"3%" '#%'!0" 6&"'$"&/$0+" &'&-!0" &&"&&%';  %$"+  : &  #"7%#    '?  B/+%&#%$!%'  +  +"2"'%';  !0" &&"&&*"'!/'#"+9"$!%')@5)A!0"$!0" &&"&&""0 #$3 %*"# ' ",2"'#%!/+" &=$++"& & */'!2 %#! #0? + #"&03"$!+%$%!?

 +#

+!0"3%'"56 ?$0 +;"&%'' '!92%''%'; '#4 +#0* '  +'-9 !3 2/+-6!0/'%!&3$ !"#%' #0? + #"&00"&&"&&%'; %$"+ : &!0"7%":!0 !!0"",2"'#%!/+"%'$/++"#: &+!0"$+" !%'$ 2%! 3 &&"!&-:0%$0:"+"!6"/&"#&3"3?+6/&%'"&&!0" &&"&&"" '# &!0" &&"&&""$/3#!+ '&"+&/$0 +%;0!%'$ &"!+ '&"+ &&"!&-!0"& %# ",2"'#%!/+": &0"3#!6" $ 2%! 3",2"'#%!/+" '#: &#%& 33:"# '# ##"#6 $8!!0"%'$*"!0" &&"&&"" ' 22" 3-!0" /20"3#!0"+"2"'%';!0" &&"&&*"'!

'#2%'"#!0 !!0"$3 %*$ 2%! 3",2"'#%!/+" & "7"'/"",2"'#%!/+"- :0%$00 #6""' 33:"#6?!0"&&"&&%'; %$"+-: &!0"7 3%#+" &'! +"2"'!0" &&"&&*"'!!6+%';!! ,!0"$ 2%! 3",2"'#%!/+" 33:"# &

"7"'/"",2"'#%!/+"0" 6&"+7"#!0 !!0"&&"&&%'; %$"+0 # +"2"'"# !0"  &&"&&*"'! :%!0%'  2"+%#   /+  ?" +&   !0"  +%;%' 3 &&"&&*"'! '#0"'$"-!0"& *": &/20"3#0"  3&/20"3#!0"

+#"+!0"&&"&&%'; %$"+%'03#%';!0"",2"'#%!/+"!6" $ 2%! 3


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
>>-  !0" ",2"'&"& 2 %# ! !0"

#0? + #"&03"$!+%$%!? +#

+!0"3%'"56 ?$0 +;"&%'' '!

92%''%'; '#4 +#0* ' +'-9 !3 2/+-:"+"! 8"' &$ 2%! 3",2"'&"&0" & %#23" : & 33:"#6?!0"  '# ; %'&!!0"& %#+#"+-' 22" 3 : &%3"#6?!0"+"7"'/"0" &&"&&""0 #/+!0"+%'+*"#!0"+%6/' 3 !0 !&%*%3 +",2"'#%!/+": & 33:"#+!0" &&"&&*"'!?" +)
 '!%$"/'#"+9"$!%')A!0"$!: &%&&/"#6?!0"&&"&&%'; %$"+'

=6?+""++%';! B/#;*"'!2 &&"#6?!0%& /+!%'
 



 !"

#  >  -:0"+"%'%!: &0"3#!0 !

&/$0",2"'#%!/+":"+"!6"!+" !"# &$ 2%! 3%'' !/+"0" +"& %# B/#;*"'!2 &&"#6?!0%& /+!: &3 !"+'-&"! &%#"6?'C63"!0"

9/2+"*" /+!'>A'!0%&6 $8#+2-%!: & +;/"#!0 !'!%$" /'#"+9"$!%')A!0"$!: &%33"; 3 '#%!$/3#'!0 7"6""'%&&/"# !"+!0"#"3 ?/+%';!0"2"+%#/'#"+$'&%#"+ !%'-!0" &&"&&""0 # $3 %*"#",2"'#%!/+" &=--=>-AA5
2 %#! ' $$/'!6 ?

)
3%'"&0"& %#2 ?*"'!: &&3"3?/!$**"+$% 3",2"#%"'$?:%!0 *!%7" /;*"'!%';!0"6/&%'"&& $!%7%!?!0" &&"&&""$*2 '?0" &&"&&%';  %$"+-  7%#"  +#"+  # !"#  >-  :0%3"  + *%';  !0" &&"&&*"'!/'#"+9"$!%') !0"$!-0 # 33:"#!0"$3 %*!0"

&&"&&"" :"7"+-!0"+" &'++"2"'%';!0" &&"&&*"'!7%#"+#"+ # !"#  >A-  %&  !0 !  !0%&  ",2"'#%!/+"  %&  $ 2%! 3  %'  ' !/+"  '#  !0" 2 ?*"'!: &! 8"'!6" &%'$*"-:0%$00 #"&$ 2"#!0" &&"&&*"'! 0"+%6/' 3 /+!0"+ 6&"+7"# !0 ! + !0" &&"&&*"'! ?" + >>
>>-  !0%&  2 ?*"'!  * #"  !  #0?  + #"&0  3"$!+%$%!?   +#

: & 33:"#6?!0"  '# ; %'&!!0"& %#+#"+-' 22" 3 0 #6""'%3"#6?!0" "7"'/" 7"':%!0+"&2"$!!!0" &&"&&*"'!?" +)
- 22" 3 !0" &&"&&"":%!0+"&2"$!!!0"&%*%3 +$3 %*: & 33:"#0%&%'$*"0 # 6""'#%&$3&"#6?!0" &&"&&"":0%3"%3%';!0"+"!/+' '#"7"'%'+"&2"$! !0"2 &!!: &&"&&*"'!?" +&-&%*%3 +6"'"%!0 #6""' 33:"#6?!+" !%'; !0"2 ?*"'!* #"! #0? + #"&03"$!+%$%!? +#

+!0"

3%'"56 ?$0 +;"&%'' '!92%''%'; '#4 +#0* ' +'-9 !3 2/+- &+"7"'/" ",2"'#%!/+"!: &'! $ &"-:0"+" '?%'+* !%'0 #6""'$'$" 3"#6? !0" &&"&&"" !!0"!%*"2 &&%';!0" &&"&&*"'!+#"+/'#"+9"$!%')

!0"$!0"+": &'+"&0* !"+% 32%'!"#/!6?!0"&&"&&%';

%$"+++"2"'%';!0" &&"&&*"'! 0"+%6/' 3/+!0"+6&"+7"#!0 ! !0"+": &'*"+%!%'!0"+" &'&+"$+#"#++"2"'%';!0" &&"&&*"'!6? !0"&&"&&%'; %$"+6?23 $%';+"3% '$"'!0"+ !%3 %##:'6?!0" /'B 6 '# +? ' %;0 /+!%' 

$

 !"

% $ &"

&/2+ !: &/+!0"+6&"+7"#!0 !!0" &&"&&""0 #+""++"#!!0"+"3"7 '! ",!+ $!+*!0"





 !"##$%& &2"+:0%$0


$&!",!"'&%'#%&!+%6/!%'* #"%&!6"2 %#6?!0"$'&/*"+%'%!% 33? :"7"+-!0"$ &!2 %#6?!0"$'&/*"+&0 336"!0"2+2"+!?!0" 3%$"'&""D%!0!0"&"6&"+7 !%'&- 22" 3%3"#6?!0" &&"&&"": & 33:"# " +#-3" +'"#$/'&"3+!0"2 +!%"& !"+;%';!0+/;0!0"%*2/;'"#B/#;*"'!-!0%& /+!%&!0"

7%":!0 !!0" */'!2 %#6?!0" &&"&&""!!0" #0? + #"&03"$!+%$%!?

 +#+6 ?3%'"&0 &6""'+%;0!3?! 8"'!6"!0"'()*+( ) 9%*%3 +6"'"%!0 #6""'",!"'#"#!!0" &&"&&""+!0" &&"&&*"'!?" + >>
>> '#)
0%&",2"'#%!/+"0 &6""'+%;0!3?$3 %*"#6? !0" &&"&&"" &2"+!0"2+7%&%'&!0"'$*" ,$! 0"+": &' +" &'++"
2"'%'; '#%'%!% !%';2+$""#%';&/'#"+9"$!%')@5)A !0"$!0"+%6/' 30 &+%;0!3? 33:"#!0" 22" 3!0" &&"&&""6? 22+"$% !%';!0" $!&%'!0"+%;0!2"+&2"$!%7" +"7"+-!0" "7"'/"0 & '!3"# '?"7%#"'$"!&0:!0 ! '?%'$*"0 #"&$ 2"# &&"&&*"'! !!0" !%*"2 &&%';!0" &&"&&*"'!+#"+&/6&! '!% 3E/"&!%'3 : +%&"& +$'&%#"+ !%'%'!0%& 22" 3

"&/3! '!3?-%'#%';'*"+%!&-!0"2+"&"'! 22" 3%&#%&*%&&"# 

      

9     ) B2


   ("&5
  ("&5