← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaFAO/5139/2017allowed

United India Insurance Co Ltd v. Sukhwinder Kaur & ORS

2019-03-08Mr. Justice B.S. Walia5 pages

  



         !"#$#$#%& 

 ! !

! '(!

$) $ *$++,,! -( '  .'/01!

(2'(!

0( $ *$$ +!

! 

 .3$.'/01!

(2'(4.'/01!

(!

0( $  *$++,,! -( '  -562'3(!

0( $  *$$ +!

!   ("

!78,9($'  $.$:,$ ( !" 9($( + 6,; <  (0++,,!! $=%& #%>!

( +!

!$! $>#& #%>$ 9($!

(5.0(3; <  (0++,,! ! $>#& #%>!

( +!

! $%!$=%& #%>$ 9($-+',; <  (( +!

! $?!

=! $=%& #%>!

( +!

! $%!

!$>#& #%>$ @@@    %  $=%&   #%> 0  8!  86 0 ! '(!

3+!6 /!A( !  %%;;###BC1(  0( +!

! B ,3! ;10,$>#& #%>0 8! 86

 0++,,! B ,3!  /!A!0!

3! 0 3+! !1( 03$  0 ,(!  9( 

!  ,3  (8'!,; .. A(; 90,D0(! (( ((  E0 (8'!,7F/!

'!0A 0 , ?6( ;

'+! A( ','( ;   0  !

3  G;###BC+(3!0;/!

'!=#H 0 8, 0 !

( 0 +'(+    1(/!A ' ''( +( +   +68,; 3 ! %B(    0 !

 1(  0  +( !,I+!  ;++, 3',+,( %?; '(0(861( !A%;##;###BC ! 

'!   ,   ! ('3 !

  =;###BC ! 

'!  '!(, I+!  ; 1(  , 3+! !   %%;;###BC  0 1 1 !

1 0, (! 0 $  )(! '! , (0++,,!B! '(!

3+!6 !!

0 !

;0 1  , C3+,6 !

1 81!0A ?# =#6( ;0( (;=H 0 8, 0 !

3 0  ,8, 8/!!

'!1( ''(+( +   A! =#H/!! 

'! 86 0 ,(!  (8'!,$  . !

,6;  ?#;###BC   +68,  0 1   ! 

'!   ,   ! ('3   A!   %;##;###BC1( 860,(!  (8'!,$  ;=;###BC1( ! 

'! '!(,I+!   ,8,8 , 1!%=;###BC$ ? ( !(;,(! '! , (0++,,! B ,3! ! $>#& #%> !!

0!

3 0 0 8!/!!0 ,1(  !

 +(0!

! ' 860 <(!3! (6!

(0(,<!+( '!

(09!3'3:A  ;3!0,61A   #>#BC +( 3!0 1( +68,  ! '! /,,  ,8'(( !AA ( 0 +'(+  A( ','(1(/$0 +6 0!

! (0(,<! +( ( !A!

3 !'! /,, A( ','(,,8'(( #>#BC+(

 3!0 ',6 A!  86 0 ,(! '! , ( 0 ++,,! B ,3!    /! ! ( (    9(/ E7 !

+6 0(  0!

 <(  ,(!

'! , (0! '(!

3+!610!+(' ,0(  !  +' 1A +68,!'! /,, ,8'(( #>#BC+(3!0$

( !A,6; 0 !

   (   #>#BC+( 3!0   A!   G###BC /! ! 

'! 86 0 ,(!  (8'!, (   !A 0

3+! !+68,$ =  +(01(  0,(!  (8'!,;0 1 ? 6(    A !

 1  , C3+,6   0 3   0  0$    +( +(A(+0 $G% D<F   !  !78, 0 .'+(3 '( !   !"

#$%&'()& $*+!, ($ -* -$ ! ./%/%+ =H 0 8, 0 !

3 0 3!'  0I 3+!! 8/!!

'!!<1 0 8!A , C3+,6  !

 81! 0 A A('+   ?#  =# 6( $ ! 0

( '3 !

 ; A! =#H1( 860,(!  (8'!,;=H 0  8, 0 !

33!' I 3+!! 0,,8/!!

'!1(

''(+( +  10, 3+'!A0 3+! !$ G )/1 ;   +( +(A(+0 $G% D<F   ! 

!78,0.'+(3 '(!(!6.07   D.'+(F; %;##;###BC1( !

'! ,  ! ('3  , 1! ?#;###BC !

  =;###BC 1(  ! 

'!  '!(, I+!     , 

, 1!%=;###BC10,%=;###BC 1( !

'! ,   $ > ! 0 ,A0 0 + !   ! 8<; 0 ++,,! B ,3!  !  $>#&   #%>  ( 0,  !,   0

,,1!A 3+! !"C

?   0$*! &"

!!$!!$* &"

 !!$!!$* 1(  1( -$2 1"

-$%"

%$ !

3 G###BC #>#BC $ ''(( +   =#H G###BCJ =H #>#BC ###BC  #%>$=BC  D('!

#%BCF G###BCK###BJ #>#BCK#%BCJ $ , !

3 &###BC %#;#BC    ?$ 9',+,(++,  %? %? %B(  &###BCJ %B(  %#;#BCJ =$  ! D1( +( !, I+!    ###BC G$GBCD('!



GBCF

F G$ +!

!

6D!!',F D&###BCC###BCF D%#;#BCCGBCF J  G###BC D+( J  G>=BC D+( 3!0F!

G###BC 3!0F!

D G>=BC  I %F J  I % J  >;###BC #;>##BCD!!',,6F D!!',,6F >;###BCI%?J #;>##BCI%?J >$

3+! ! %%;&;##BC 1(  86 ++,6!A %#;#;###BC 3',+,( $ )  ! ('3 %;##;###BC ?#;###BC &$ '!(, I+!   =;###BC %=;###BC %#$ )   ) %=;###BC %%$  !(  GH+(!!'3 &H+(!!'3 , %%;;###BC %%;&&;##BC

= & 

( !A,6; A!  %%;;###BC1( 860,(!  (8'!,;0++,,! B ,3! !$>#& #%> (0, !,  %%;&&;##BC,!A10!( 4&H +(!!'310

 (30  ,3+!,,  +63!; , +63!; !6;3 (,($ %#  !0,A0 0+ ! ! 8<;,0'A00 ''( +( +   (  8 , ',  4 =H   0  8, 0  !

;6!0!( ',;0 3+! !+68, !

!0!

$ %%  

( !A,6;  $=%&   #%>  86 0 ! '(!

3+!6    +     10,  $>#&   #%>   ,,1  86 3

6!A 1(   #%$#=$#%> +   86 0 ,(!  (8'!,  0 I! ! 8<$ D$.$:,F '

A #$#$#%& 3 %$ :00( +/!AB( ! "  B$ $ :00((+(8, "  B$