High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/414/2012allowed

Barjesh Grover v. M/S Bathinda Cold Drinks And ORS

2022-11-16Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan9 pages

##$$ % &

' ($ )

# *

&#+,$-" ##$$

. ! ,-" #/

$1- #$ !

" 2 &, &, ($ )- "$$, 23$- - , -3+$+ / - 1 & # .&+ - ), " 1 -4-5' 4-6'# #$+&&&# 2$$'# ,&##$'$ -7' 8 59# &+$$$, & 7

# " #$- 2,2& &##$1,2$*#: & +1$ '

;

&##$ -! - 2,$# - " &&+ # *&2< #$ 2 +, & 2) 2$$ 2)- # 2)- ,

#'$" 1# ,&$ & 2&-3 # & 2 =+>?# +#$ +?

< 3 $$,2&: < / 3 # ($ )- 3 / @ , / 73+$+ / 3 +#$1/ 3 ),& &< / 1 & 3 $ , -3 / 6#.&+ 3+#1 # "*#+#1

< / &, # , ## #$ #& 2$*#:

3 A&&##$1 2$/ 62 $ / , 3&$) $" 1 &, *# +#1 # " & $ , +#1 *# # "$& # " 3&$) $" 13 / < + 3 $! < / #$ 3 #$ &##$12$*#< 3 &, / " $2 ,/ * 7(B44",#/ 62$$/ 6B<4 , + #$C ! ), &##$1*#: < , +#$1 / 7*#: 3," +-3

" $/ * 7D7"2$$/ 65<,6 *# (+#1 # " / 6 #$ A& &##$1*#: / <

7 #$ ,$1+ &##$1</ +$ " " $/ * 7D7<&##$13+",#/ 2$$/ 5B</ 6 #& ,& 2$$,#< +$ $17 / + #$ A&, &##$1*#: / < ) $" 13 3+"2$$/ B</ +$ "" $ / * 7D7< 31 2#& ,*# : + #$ +++# A& + +),# #1+-, ,#+ + 2),#-3 3 3 ,+ *#: ) # + $< 2$$3 $ < 31 &, 2 -&+ -6'3&#$ + 3 &##$1*#: - +#1- # +&2 6-' +#12$ 6' , #$-, 23 # - 3$+859# &+ > #$$$&# +) #1+2&-& $ & 2 ("$;&,

/ & 3 ," $1 / ## &-3 / 6 $#&## # "-& 3 # , ?#

= 3 +$21/ -" & $,$23 ) &3+2$-&

#$$ &< #$$)$& $ &< &2,2 1# < #$2,##21 3& +$, # &< #$+#$1,3 # "

4 &$4(*( - &32

21$+ + -& 3#$21 3 , 3 #$ &##$1 3 + 21 #$ & - -#1+ +& 3& #$</ 73 +#$1 3 , 3 ,2 & $2$1#11+& #$3 $# 1,

+$ &

+ #$, # - $$3, & 3 +

"#$$ %

"#$& '

(

"#$& ) ( *

"#$& +

(

"#$& ,

# -$-"#$&

6 ( (

"#$&

+./'+0-$-"#$& 1

> # 3 ## & $

& , & "- #$, 3 + *:# &, "E?

*:'$, 3 &+E?

*E?

*B > #$& ?+&$ .&+ *:- 3 " " E?

*:'

> - " #$$

= 2&$ , - # / ## :- , "E?

:' > - ",/ 3$

, ,&+- $(& &/ "& #$, =&/ 53 , &$,&- & #$3 3 , #$$

" &+& -4-5'$,3 859#

&+ + $, &$$ $F

D$, ,, " 21 &,+ - / $ ##$ (& ;&,-

-3 3,$ ;&, D> ) (& - - 3 " &,+ # ##$- &$$1 &,+ #21 $(& 3

& " 12 &, 21 #$3+

> #$$,3 &,+

21$ ;&, D> )(& - )) (& 2131$, ,&$ ##$# 1, +2#- +#&,&,+ #21$ ;&, D> )(& - 2

/ ##$3," #/ -3 #& ## &, &$

= " $ &$ # 2,, &, = &,+#21 $(&

&$# # ## $"

# $3

> $(& 3& , & #$ = # # $1$1## "&21 #

$1 # $33 $ , & #$

> ## D ##$$(& 33 ,

& : & , &+ # # $1$1,"&21 # ## + -3+ &$21 #$ = # 1# $## &, #$ +#$

4&$4(*( > # "# & $& 2 # ? &+ " 1

3 +

G &$ ##$$

&,+

4 ,$;&, (& 3 &," &&,+21 #?(& -32 " # & + + -$&2 - + & #$2## &1# #, & $12& ,$2 3 # &$,3 #$ =3& 2 " 21# & ,$2 - , 2 ,3 &$ # & & &$# & $31&2 " &<21 2& "-2 &2& & =3, $$12 " &2" , #$ " +&& 3 $3-2 2# & -3 # 2$1" &&

> D ##$$(& 1 )- 3 & ,#&"$& -3 1 # # # 22$ = ?+ & # # # 22$ +& + "& #$ > #$$&##$1 2$*#:

> &$ " 1+$$+& -4-5' > #$3&$ "&$,1 , 1

2 & +& ),, +$$

#&2& $- $$, , 13 = & 2?#$21 3 1 #$ &$ $ + # &$ $1 & &, ##&$ & > #$ ," 1$ &##$1*#

5 : / &, > &##$1- +-3 +$$ ,+- " $&+2 3 3

$,3 2$$&+2 , #&+2 "2+

- / 6##& ## # "3 # ,?# -3 + 1 ,1 + 13 & $$,, + #$ $1/ #&## 2)21 $,$& 2$$ $+21#$-3 +2", > #$ &&, $3$$ &+ 1"# " > #$ !"

,, 3+ *: ," "E?

*:'

, H 2 &, ,$&2)- #2)-,#-$" 1# $, -# # 2,E?

*E?

*B *: &$ .&+ "E?

*:'

= 2&$- + : , - # ($ ) > " $ #$) 3 + = ?+- 1 #& + $ + #$ -3 37- 31- +2& $,23 # = ?+- , +2,$,

> #$ # " 212 ,,&, ,

B "," $(& 3& , & #$-3 &,+$" 21D ##$$(& " , &,+ #21 $ (& +, &&2$&$ &1 $2"

& - ##$3 ,+ # > &,+ #21$ ;&, D> ) (& - 21 - 3 &,+ #21 $(& > ##$ $$33 &, &

!"#$ %&"'

!()$* "&#

'# !+,

"&#