← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaITA/407/2011allowed

M/S Beekons Industries Limited v. Commissioner Of Income Tax And ANR

2023-02-16Ms. Justice Ritu Bahri,Mrs. Justice Manisha Batra9 pages

   





    ! "#  $ %&&

'

$( )"$$*+ , '- %&&

.!&

/$!

*!'"0 !

10,0' 

&&&&)) 22'

3.!& $,,0!!0$ "

$( +$, 4 $'5 "

&&&& !)$ '!



.!&

+/$!

*!'"0 !

10,0'  &&&&)) 22'

3.!& $,,0!!0$ "

$( +$, 4 $'5 "

&&&& !)$ '

- 6 8&

87 

 6 8&

87 8

  



   

     



  

 

 !

"#$%&#'%((

"#))#'%('

 *  

  ,

+ "

- . + //// 0'*

5"09

& :: % 0  +

  +

)'

1

 

 " 



 + -

 

"  $%&

'%((

"  ))

'%('











0 

1



 - 

"#$%&#'%((

+ 

 

() %2 '%(( - #$!

+ "

- 

,  

 3"

3!

+ 1 '%%4#%&

- +

. +

 



, " !

)% %$ '%(%

  # 5( 6



+ 



, " !







 



'

6



+ 



, " !







 ()4($2%7#

6

 

 .

  )

1

, " !



6 

$

 

+











  





+  



+ 9# ': (( '%%4  

+

 ((%)%4$7#

 

1

. 

1





+

 )(('';447#











   .

 

  

+ 

#+

1











6  











 



 

+

 ()4($2%7# 

 



 6  

#

 





+  

. 

+   

+

 )(('';447#

.



.

  .  

   



1













+

-





+

 ()4($2%7#

#



"

 

 ()4($2%7# 

- +



1  7 '&( (! !

 



7

+

+

    8 

6



, " !

, " !





+



   5:

    



 



 -

+ 



-8

 <   4()'$7#

 

 ()'4%%27#

 +

 (;;%%7#

  (;4$27#

  

 $4)':7#

 

 

"

($4:(%)7# (% 6    

 

 +

7     ((



 )(('';447#

 

  

 :%2%%%%7#    

 1  

 2((24%%%7#



 

 ((%();'27# 

 &('(:;'2 #

 )(('';447#!

)( ) '%%4 ('

 



+

 )(('';447#    



 $'%(((27#



 



 '2)%)%4$7#

 $:);:)%7# 

 



   < 

= +

 '(:;';'(7#

  < 1 

.

<   1 8 

, " !  



+

 $:);:)%7#

# 

   <  



;   .

#+

+

 '(:;';'(7#



= < 1 

>

 

#+

     <  



#+ 



+   +

+

 

#+

 

= 



 



 # 

   < 



 

+ 

   < 

1 

  

   < 



+  +

   < 



+ 

++

- 1

#+



   < 

#   1 

#

 

- 

 



<1 

 ,

   



 





+

 $:);:)%7# 



#+





   < 

? 

+  +

= < 1 

> 



#+

+

= 

   

1



 +

 +

= < 1 

>





% - 1

@

 





#  

+

'% %& '%('

 

  

A

# 5?



+ 

""



1 

 @3 ,

  

!  





   <  B8 >  



@3 + , "#$$#%& '(&)**#

&  +#  

    &,,&  &)  &,  -   #  

 @3 + ,

- +

7 .

#+

7 

+

 (2 

 )$

  .

(%D

 

 @ ,1 

  

" 

 1

   

   





  





  

-  

  - 

#  ? 

.

+





@3 + , ?    @3 + ,



@ , &,,&  &)  &,  -.

  "  /      ,    

  %& */**'&*( * **

#

 

+    

  - +

     +1  #= < 1 

>

 

1

& +#0 $

@ 

   <     @3 + ,

& +#0 $

 )$

 .  

 (2 



+

    

 

A

 1





+ ,

& +#0$



1 E $



@ ,1 3  !

 



 ,

$# &,,&&) &, -" &#+2 &#



%& 3&)*3&( *3 *3



 )4 (! !

 ,

 & ; :

(% 

# 5& 0

1 E  !

   

  @E + ,

& +# 

4536

5(37







5-----------

< 



 

)$

 ,+

7  

(2 

 



  F 





 8

;

0

 +

 



1

4  

 )4 (! !





!

G, "#( >

H

 *

"  )&#'%($

' %& '%(2

!

G, "

H 6+ - < >+

"  (%;27, 7'%()

%4 %; '%(2

:

?



,

  



1    ,4  $

18! 9$  "  ,  $

  

 +

  @E ,



 

(%





  

+





  A

 

  )4 (! !

  1  

 )4 (! !

    

:

, " !

=   +



"

I 

  

#+ 

6

() %2 '%(( - # $!





)% %$ '%(%

, " !





 

 +

 & +#0 $  &#+2 &#

 0$





7 %&&

8



0#=!50

7 >5 '5 "

!) /0?." !$ -  !.$ >5 '5 "

" )$"'@2 -  !.$