High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/695/2016disposed of

Yog Raj v. State Of Haryana & ORS

2018-02-22Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Mahabir Singh Sindhu4 pages

!" # $ %&'(')!*!"+ , -.%/ 011'22%"& 3'.*4* 5&%&'%.6%"%%"( &7'.* 0 '*1"('"&* + 8 5 5 8 55#

.'*'"&+ .54.'*794:%. '(74;(<)%&'.&7'%11'22%"& *%"!*7% '*7%=%.!%;;%.6%"% >>> ?

@ "&.%A)4.&%11'%27%*B''"!2'(%-%!"*&.('.(%&'( (!*:!**!"- &7' =.!& 1'&!&!" )7%22'"-!"- "C4!.6

'1.& (%&'(

$ ;.('.(!*:!**%2(%&'( $

A ;.('.(!*:!**%2%11'%2(%&'( , AE %*%2* .('. (%&'( E$, AF .'/')&!"- &7' '<!*!" '&!&!" %-%!"*&.('.(!*:!**%2%11'%2 ?@ '%."'()4"*'2.&7'%11'22%"&)"&'"('(&7%&"%))4"& !22"'** %"( B'!"-4"('.&.'%&:'"& )42("& %&&'"((4&6 . . &7%& :%&&'. ('1%.&:'"&%21.)''(!"-*;&7'.'=%*"B%.&&7'%11'22%"&&%G!"-&.'%&:'"& .:%"%221%&7!)H%64.<'(!)()&.;11.&4"!&67%("&B''"-!<'"&&7' %11'22%"&!"&7'(!*)!12!"%.61.)''(!"-*;%11'22%"&7%(*'"&%112!)%&!". 2'%<'&7.4-77!*=!'=7!)7=%*"&%))'1&'(".=%*&7'%112!)%&!".

(%6* )%*4%2 2'%<' *'"& &7.4-7

" . . :"&7*8

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

'.4*%2&7'.').(.'<'%2*&7%&&7'%11'22%"&8*=!'*4B:!&&'( %112!)%&!" A$ (%&'( $ & &7' 541'.!"&'"('"&

2!)'; %!2=%6*;:B%2%%"&&;.'C4'*&!"-.G''1!"-&7''"C4!.6!"!&!%&'( %-%!"*&7'.74*B%"(!"%B'6%")'"&7'-.4"(&7%&7'=%**4'.!"-.: ('1.'**!" %"( =%* &%G!"- &.'%&:'"& .: 57!< !<(%6% %"&% *1!&%2 .'-42%.26%"(&7'()&.*7%(.')::'"('(7!:):12'&'.'*&='<'.; 1'.4*%2 :'(!)%2 )'.&!!)%&'* ""'D4.'* A$ & !**4'( B6 57!< !<(%6%%"&%*1!&%2;%.'2%;'27!%*%2*:'(!)%2)'.&!!)%&'*""'D4.'

E& !**4'(B6)7%.6%6%"4"!7%.!&%B2'*1!&%2;'='27! . &7' .'2'<%"& 1'.!( .'<'%2 &7' %11'22%"& *4'.!"- .: %!2:'"&* &7'. &7%" ('1.'**!" 74*; =7'" <!'='( !" &7' )"&'D& %112!)%&!"

A$ (%&'($!&!*'<!('"&&7%&&7':'(!)%2)'.&!!)%&'*

""'D4.'* A$& %.'B-4*.&7'.'%*"*)!&'(!"&7'%112!)%&!"

A$ .(''..!"-'"C4!.6!*"%))4"&&7'%11'22%"&*4'.!"- .: ('1.'**!" =7'.'%* &7' :'(!)%2 )'.&!!)%&'* ""'D4.'* A$ &

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

!"# $%%#& )"&'"('(&7%&&7'.('.(!*:!**%2=%*!"('.-%&!" 42' &7' 4"/%B 2!)' 42'*; EF%*&7'%B*'")'. (%6* )42("&B'.'-%.('(%*-.%<'*&%)&:!*)"(4)&B'*!('*&7'%11'22%"&7%( *'.<'(.6'%.*%"(!"&7')!.)4:*&%")'*;7')42(7%<'B''"%=%.('( 2'**'.14"!*7:'"&):142*.6.'&!.':'"& ?@

'.4*%2 .('. AE 1%**'( !" %11'%2 B6 &7' "*1')&.'"'.%2 2!)':'"&!"*&7%&")4"&2'**))%*!"*;%B*'")' &7'%11'22%"&=%*.'-42%.!I'(B6*%")&!"!"-7!:2'%<'<%.!4*G!"(*B6 (!'.'"&%4&7.!&!'*"&7'%)&*&7')%*';&7'%11'22%"&;B'!"-%:':B'. %(!*)!12!"'(.)')42("&B'1'.:!&&'(&.':%!"%B*'"&=!&74&2'%<' %"(&7%&&.*4)7%2"-1'.!(7'.'.';7'=%*.!-7&26"&%22='(& B'.'&%!"'(!"*'.<!)' ?

@ ='<'.; &%G!"- !"& %))4"& &7' (')!*!" "8B2' &7' 541.':'4.&!"7!"('.5!"-78*)%*' *41.% ;='(!*1*'&7!*%11'%2 B6-.%"&!"-2!B'.&6&&7'%11'22%"&&:%G'%.'1.'*'"&%&!"&&7'):1'&'"& %4&7.!&6.!:1*!&!"14"!*7:'"&&7'.&7%"&7%&(!*:!**%2")%*' .')'!1& %"6 *4)7 .'1.'*'"&%&!"; &7' ):1'&'"& %4&7.!&6 =42( )"*!('. &7' *%:' *6:1%&7'&!)%226 !" %)).(%")' =!&7 2%= %"( &7' .42'* %112!)%B2' %"( 1%** .('.* !" .'*1')& &7'.'& %* :%6 B' =%..%"&'( !" %)).(%")'=!&72%='&&'.* %&'"&11'%2(!*1*'(!"&7'%B<'&'.:*

%/'*7!"(%2 5#%2!% 4(-' 4(-' , %:!& #7'&7'.*1'%G!"-H.'%*"'( + '*H #7'&7'..'1.&%B2' + '*H