High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/723/2016dismissed

Joginder Pal Singh And ORS v. State Of Haryana And ORS

2018-07-05Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

# $ %&''(!)!"*+,-./$ 0!"1'2 %,3!"04 &4'2) 55',,%"&) 6'2)+) 3&%&'%2-%"% &4'2) ')5"1'"&)

! "#$%&'() $ %$'!#) * ! "#$%&'() $ )( + ,,,

2')'"&* 2 2%&''7+5&%/18(%&'/ 2&4'%55',,%"&) 2"7+2!&&%,/11,%2-%"%/ 2&4'3&%&' 99999

)( + -% 4'52')'"&"&2%+2&55'%,4%):''"52''22'1%0%!")&&4' ;+10<'"&1%&'1==.2'"1'2'1:-&4','%2"'13!"0,'+10'/>4'2':- #2!& '&!&!"52''22'1%0%!")&&4'%>%211%&'1$5%))'1:-&4' "1+)&2!%,2!:+"%,/4%"1!0%24 2)42&/&4'2!:+"%, 4%8!"0%")>'2'1!"

%8+2&4''<5,-'')?%55',,%"&):'!"0'%2"'2!"1'2):-<'%") !"87!"0&4'52!"(!5,'@'A+%,5%-2'A+%,>27B:2!"0!"0&4'<%&5%2 >!&4 2'))%&2!)>' /4%):''"%,,>'1 ,"0 >!&4 &4' %55'%,/ !8!, !)(55,!(%&!" C== +"1'2 21'2 +,' 4%):''"!,'1)''7!"05'2<!))!"&4!) +2&2!,!"0&4'%55'%,":'4%,&4''<5,-'')/>4>'2'5%2&- :'2'&4'2!:+"%,/:+&3&%&'%2-%"%>!&4+&!<5,'%1!"0&4'</!,'1&4'

>2!&5'&!&!"",-%0%!")&0!"1'2 %,3!"04 4!)+2&/8!1'21'21%&'1 />4!,'!))+!"0"&!('

<&!"!"<%!"%55'%,%)>',,%)"&4'%55,!(%&!")''7!"0("1"%&!" 1',%-/4%1%,,>'1!8!,!)(C==? 4')%<'2'%1)%) +"1'2*?

2')'"&*2 2%&''7+5&%/18(%&'

2%55',,%"&) C==?

,,>'1%)52%-'12

#'1"&!"1%"-!"!2<!&-!"&4','0%,525)!&!")'& +&!"&4'!<5+0"'1;+10<'"&+)&&)'&&,''A+!&!')/!))+' "&!('<&!"2 &!('2'*("1"%&!"1',%-%,)

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

02!'8%"('+"1'22&!(,' &4'")&!&+&!""1!%4'5'2%&!8'5%2& &4'21'22'%1)&4+)*?

DC= "2'8!'>!"0&4!)<%&&'2%&&4')&%0'&4'%>%21/!& >+,1:'%55252!%&'2&4!)+2&&)&'5+&;+2!)1!(&!" >4!,'2'8!'>!"0&4'%>%21&4'%:+2+2&%"1'F'2(!)'!&) 5>'2)+"1'22&!(,' &4'")&!&+&!"&2'A+')&&4'

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

&)',%"1&%7'%"!"2<'11'(!)""&4'1!)5+&'4' 1'<%"1<%-:'0'"+!"'%"1;+)&!!'1:+&&4'2',!'<%-:' !"(%5%:,' :'!"0 02%"&'1 :- &4' %:+2 +2& 4!) 1!(4&<- 2'A+!2') %&&'"&!" !" %55252!%&' A+%2&'2) & :' (")!1'2'122'12'))%,!"%"%55252!%&'2+</!"&4'!2)& !")&%"(':-&4'5'&!&!"!"01'5%2&<'"&%<!"(,!"'1&&4!"7 &4%&&("('1'5>'2&&4',%:+2(+2&2&2!:+"%,&!

%"11'5%2&2<2+,'))'28!('08'2"!"05%-%"15)&!"% 1'5%2&<'"&08'2"<'"&%"1&2'%1;+2!)1!(&!"'F%'A+'& :"!"&4',%:+2(+2&%)%55,!(%:,'&%2:!&2%&!")>+,1"& :'&4'525'2&4!"0&1&>+,1:'("('1!"0&<+(4 %+&42!&-!"&4'&2!:+"%,>4'2'""''F!)&)!"(1!!'12< "&2%(&))'28!('!&<%-(4%"0'2%,&'2!"!&);+1!(!+) 1!)(2'&!":+&"&&4'2+,')2%<'1+"1'2528!)&2&!(,'= &4' ")&!&+&!" "1!% 4%& 5>'2 8')&) !" &4' (")&!&+&!"%,(+2&)&:''F'2(!)'1!"%55252!%&'(%)')& 52'8'"&!"2%(&!")0+%2%"&'')!" %2&%"1&4'!2'(&!8'

2!"(!5,')3&%&' ,!(-%)4%8':''"2'%1!"& %2&&4'

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

2&4'2'%)"))&%&'1%:8'/"02+"12!"&'2'2'"('!"&4' !<5+0"'121'2!) <%1'+& ')+,&%"&,-/&4''&&'2) %&'"& 55'%, !) 1!)<!))'1")'A+'"&,-/&4'%55,!(%&!"2("1"%&!"1',%-!"!,!"0 &4'%55'%,!)%,)1!)<!))'1

%$'!#) * )( + %&*0$ %&*0$ %1 2/-3 45 +55 67 89 :

;9 +55 < ;9