High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRR/1592/2021disposed of

Ramesh Chand v. State Of Haryana And Another

2023-03-03Mr. Justice Jasjit Singh Bedi23 pages

-1-

#$%$%$ &'

%% "( )(!*!

%%%!, "

-. &% '

Mr. Namit Khurana, Advocate for respondent No.2.

/ %

!" # $%&%$&$'()"*'+ , , *- ". /'%00"-- # 1 2 1-($+ " , - $ , - ."-0(- ",!"+ #3$4$%&5$&$&," &3/& # # -6 .

# ."1 -4 (- + # , #6 .

# ." , # -

# (- 7+ ,- (."-0*- + 8# "" # #

-2- 1$&&&9*, #, "" (- 7+

#1 - (- 7+ "- .

#- 6 .

# ."# , # -(- +

"- .

- (- +-" "## " :- -61&&% &'&;$&$&-,# . < 61 ))"*' / .",!"."-0(- + - 0#.*/$0 #- " " ", - ) '/&;$&$& - 61 &&% &'&;$&$& =>1'%3'/&;$&$&# ". /&$ /$/ /? /@%*: >0 . < 6 2"" =>1 ))"*$ ? 6" #" # $* 1 ) ". '@/00 # 6 .

# ."". /&?>0 . /$//&$/@%*:>0 5 -1-0."-0 (+ 8*$ - "-- $ "

-3- #

-8$*1-0)" */*?

; -, -

$%&%$&$'> "# @ " $ - , ."- 0

-9 ."-0 $*1 -

"", , <1()"*/+ - > # ##)$" ,"-A .

# .",*> , # =>1

8$*1- 0 -

" , ", $ !"

,"-- " 3

# " " . /'% 00

, #- " - #

, "-- - - "

, ",

-4- ",

"#- 7,."-

&' (

% ) * #$ + ,

$- "

/ $ 01

% ." "

"--

" '& 4"$ , #=>1 8$* 1-0 " -"!" #> <1"##- ) " > # ##" ". /$//&$/@%*: -" ,",- ". /&?>0 - -, - --,6 .

# ."" # -"# "- # -""-- # $ "

" # '' > " #

-5- '$ : #" - ",

. /'%00 . /'%00" *

! " !

# "

$ " " !

% " &

& '

( ! " ) * + '/ 7,."-0"

#$ " *

-6-

, - ! ! . /

" "

1 2

3 ! 3 0

" "

! & 1 1 ! ! 1&& 2

3 ! 3 0

" "

! ! ! 3 ! 3 ! 2

!) 0

" "

2 0

" "

1 ) ! 2

4 0

" "

1 567 567 ! 2 9 : 6;666

" "

1 2 666 3 ! 3 0

" "

! ! ! 3 ! 3 ! 2

-7- $ 64< ". * ) ! ! 0 * ) 0 " "

0 = > ! < 0

" "

! 2 0

" "

1 ! )

6 # ? $ &

6 0 #@@#@ #@#" "

' 0 A" "

" "

B " ! 1 0

" "

"# & 6! ! > ! < 0

" "

9 : 66 66 3 ! 3 0

" "

! & 1 1 ! ! 1&& 2 $ " 0

" "

-80

% " "

) * " ! & 1

9 : 6C 6C !) 0

" "

2 0

" "

1 ) ! 2 $ ? 0

" "

" ) * 0

" "

? ! 5 &

9 : C

C4 0

" "

1 567 567 & ! 2 $ $ 567 567 & 0

" "

! !

-9- D ! 0 @@ A" "

&' " *

#" " D 0 ! ! " 1

"" F ! 1&& " & 1 " ! & 1'

567 567 &

"" F ! ! ! 1&&

60 B 6!

G ")

#@ E0""##E" ! / 0"" #%

, 6 567 ! & "

-10- ! & $ ! 567 & - " !

"" F

D ! ! %6 7( !

0 D #@ E 0"" EA ! " D 0 ! " ! ! ! 567 & " !

"" F

! 567 ! !

$ " ?" ( ! &( $ " ! 1&&

-11- " & 1 6 1&& " " 1

"" F

$ & ( ! 567 . 40 &

! ! 40 6 ! ! 6 1&& &( ! 6 ! 1&& 567 ? &( 567 567 " ? ?"( !

: ( D" ? " D " H ! /

-123: ! 1 0( 0 ! 40 " 1 0

" "

$ 0( 0 00)0! B( 0 $( 0 7( 0 :! 0 0) ! 0 B( 0 $( 07(0! $ ( 0 # #% #E % 0

%6"

6 ! ! 0( 0 ! ( ! ! ! ) D ! ( ! ! 0 # #% #E % 0

%6"

? " 1 ( 1 !

? D" $ D " ( ) ! H !

-13- ( 1&& 1 ? ! ? D" ?" 1

"" F !

I! ! D " !

? ( D"

"" F

#6! ! ? ( D" #A @A #@#@ ! "77: # A#@ "7BB: ,,E

#@ A ? " ! ? ! ? " ?

(- " + >(

% ) * #$ " *

% ? "

F * /

? 1

"" F

-14- & '

( ) '

"" ) '

! '

"" F '

! ( 1 ( ! H '

"" F ! ) ! '

"" F 1 & ( 1 0 #@FH#@A""

-15- '

"" F ! '

1 3 ! 3

"" F

! '

1 ! ) B

"" F 1 ! '

1 B H! ! ! 1&& 1

"" F

B H! ! ! 1&&

"" F 1 '

"" F 1 ! 1&& ! & 1'

1! ! ! 567 & " !

"" F

! 567 & ! !

-16- 1&& '

1! 1

"" F " H( H !

, $ J " D"!

"" ! 1

6 567: %FF ! 6 ) B KLC D7&%@$&% ,# 0(0 0) ? (00 0 0( 0! ? (!0)! 0(! !!

0 ( 6 567 ) B KLCD7&%@$&% ,# ) 4 ! & H & ! 567 H) # 6 !

-17- ! ! # ! H ! 1&& D ! .( 0 0

D ! 40H & : 40 : 40 6! - I! H & ! ) # I & H 0(0

0 ! 34 ! 0.( 0D040$ 0 M D0 40 6 ? ( 00)0N !00 0 00B00 = 0) . 0 %A % % 6" ) # 0( " 3 .

: 1&& &!&( ! J " D"! ! $ ( & $ ! " 0 B !

B #@@

@ 0"" % % '$0 !

0 B #@ @ @0""#,'0

-18L ! : #@

%0"" #% ! ( ! ! 1 $ ! ! 1

"" " & 1 1&&

: ! D" ! J "

"" D " !

B( 0 ( ! ( D ! D" ! B( 0 ! ( 1 ( 0( 0 ! ) 0( 0 ) 0( ? $ 1

"" " H ? D" ! 0

@# @F % %A; %6"

? D" 0 %6" ! H !

-19- ? ! D "( 1

? J " D"! 1 (H 1

: ! ( D""77:

# A#@ A ( D" "77 : #A #@ A " 1 0 $

E - J " D"! ! ! " ! ( "77:

# A#@ A ! " ! %@ : ! & ! # " 7( 0

? " ! ! ! " 567 &

-20- !

"" F

% 0 ! ( D"

"" F 1 $ ! " D 0 0

"" F 1 I!

"" F ! 1 1&&

& 1

"" F ! ( J " ? - J " 6 J " ! ! ! . !

"" F 1 ! H

%# 6! ! ! ( D" J "

"" ! ! " !

-21- J " ! 567: %FF #F @F #@ E0 " :

E# #@ E 0 @# @F % %A; %6"

D ! ! ! ! 1

"" J " ! + (- " + > + ,

$" *

? ". ! 0

" 1 1 ! 1 1 ! ! ? 0 = D" ! " !)0

" = @=#@ + (- " + > - "

/ $ 01" *

! ) ! ( 1

-22- 0

"" % B( 0 ! 0 D - #@#

0""- 0"E # + (- " + '? #- "#- " " , ""-- #

" -",- ) -- ##," )

#"," "

"#-# " # ""-- #" , ) "#, # # !"

, -"," ",

.0" ) # ". /'% 00 !"

" # 9

- !"

," #" '5 #-

",""#,"--," - =>1 , ," - ,"",

8 # 0"8$*1-0 "" $, - ,

-23-

- - --," # , #,"

"-" # -

"," #" # '; >

- " > - $%&%$&$'()" *'+, . A"#2"" ,!" 1$ ,"-- ""

. /'%00 '@

- 0") ," - " , " # 0" "

" , 7,."- 0" , 0'

$%$%$ '

233( !,4 "56(!

" # !6

233( (, (78#