State Of Haryana And Another v. Indian Hardware Industries Ltd.
! " !
! "# $ % & '(( ) * + % , +* -. # $ % &% ' $ % ! %%!
!'. ) / ' ' 0
% & "
(( !1 , 0 & ' "
! %%! ' 3"
$ % & " " -
'(( 4 "
5*4.
6+ % , +* -. $ % & 6
,"
& , ( & "
, 3"
7 .( & " "
, ( .(*44 "
8
#9 7:,"
& "
..* ##9 7#: ;*4 <
4, " " 4
#;& . #9 7: 3 " 9$ :
= * "
(
3"
% & > *
&9! 4 ( :' ?
, , " ,
3"
44 . "
( 4 " "
.
+ " ;* # "
+* 3 ,"( = 9 "
@ +3A: ( ( . / ! 5 ( " , 4 * * '( !
*. '4
#9 7:
,
( .
*4 BB , * "
7 .( && "
0 .
+ ( & 3"
4 &*4 4, " 9 .
*4 #B :
4 .( 4 #D*4 , ( .
*4 B;& 3"
7 .( & .
( " ( & . " 4
3" 4
8
"
, 3"
7 .( &(*" "
&
4, " "
*4 . "
0 .
+ $
,
* B& "
0 .
+ .
*4 #B 3" , * "
3"
(
9 .( " :' #3"
*4" .( C.
*4 , . .( & * "
.
.
E (. & * "
7 .( & 4
(*" "
,"" , & 0 .
# + ? 0 .
+ * &
( +3 = $ % & 4 ( &.
. "
3"* "
**4 ,, " B; & ,"""
4 & 7 .( & ) !
,"
, (*
"
. 5 "
.( & 4 * 3"
&, B+ , , /4F*
*4 "( . & * * "
E ( .
,"
." , " "
.( & "
*( "
( & .
( ( / 3"
* * "
E *( "
.( &
(( "
"
$ 0 .
. * "
( * "
& * C " .
,"" 8 ,"""
* * * "
E *( .
,""* * "
* *( + . " .(4 "
$ 3 ,
!*( ( = " 9$ := " '4 = , * * & "
. ( * 3"
( (
' ( , ( ( ( / , "
, ( & , &
*( , " * * 3"
.( & & (( 4 "
"
.
&3"
* "
" . & " 4
B 3"
% & > *
&9! 4 ( :
' ?9"
6?' 6:, ( . 4 ( *
( & "
$ % & .
"
, "'( $ 9:@ *
( &A & *
( & ,"" "
& "
$
.
. "
0 .
+ &. "
*
( && & , * & ( & *" "
* 3"
$ " .
% & > *
&9! 4 ( :* 9"
@* A:* "
' * 3"
( > *
& $ # ?' ,"" *
! ! " "
#$ # % %
!
& ! !
!
'
!
"
( )
" *
!
)
'
!
+
$ '( " " . & *
( & *" . . & (
'( $ B &( 44 &
" . &, " " & &( (( 9$ : '&( 44 & 9$ :
. & , " ( C & & . "
( " 9$ :* $ ? ' $ * &( $ 0 .
( ,""+"
$ 0 .
. & & .
"
&(
4 * "
' . &( *" "
( *. ;* ,"" , " "
' "
* 3"
( $ 0 .
& $ & 3"
( ( * , !
% ,
"
!
+
"
!
#!%
"
!
!
"
!
"
!
+
"
!
"
! #!%
"
!
! % " *
,
-
,
+
" *
"
+
$ 3"
;* * $ #9:9: ' ,"" .( "
( * &( & "
* * , "3 * ( & *( * $ #9:9: $*7* 9: 9#: * * . !,
& &
/ #00
%
-
"
*
#!%
%
1
%
2 / #002 3!2
%
) ) )
*
%
"
!
4
%
5!6)
3!
7
$ * (
. 4 & * $ #9:9:+ * # .# !
4 %
1
4 #!
% %
9
/ #00
+
, ,
% %
% %
1 $ * , " - E (( * $ #9:9:+ * 3 : % 9
) %
%
%
"
!
2
"
! %
%
"
!
%
!
3"
7 .( & *. ( 8 (( ?B 9 7: B 9 7: = 0 .
% & ( * ' , / "
B
3" ( , ( # 9 7?:, " "
$ ( ?B + .( , " "
3 " 9 " :
( B 3"
, *
( &#?;& 4 . B;& 3"
" , "
9$ : 4 . (( #?;&
+ . ;* "
. 4 , 3"
9$ :
=
(( "
( & "
3 " 9$ : #? ;& + "
;.
& '4 "
"
9$ : =
( "
0*4 0*4 9 4 "
( " :* $ ? ?' ,"
*4" 4 " " (( .
*4 ;& + , ( & "
B " 9$ : #?; & (( 3"
0*4 0*4
? 9 7: 9 :
( & 9$ : "
B
( &3 " 9$ :3"
"
" 9$ :
= *
# <
( ?
B?
B87 "
. 4 .(
#?;& , * *
' "
# "
0*4 0*4 9 4 ( " 9$ ::* $ ? ?
' 3" , 4 "
B " 9$ : "
" " "
. "
( &.
*4
B;& *
B ; & "
"
9$ :,""" .
"
.
3"
, & #B#3"
.(*4 ,
"
, . / 3 " 9$ :
=
" 44 (( * & .( & ( *
3"
" 9$ := ( #9' C* 7:"
4 " "
" ( . #;& + ., " 4
. 4 , ' "
( "
7 .( &, " .
#;& , * & . . 4 3"
.
*4 #;& ,
"
.
(
# 87+ , < .
*
?
?87, " ( &3"
.( & "
.
.
* " #9 7 :3"
.( &
##9 7#:
*
. * * ,"
& , .
*
#
?87 4< (
*
*( " 4 * #
87 , * * 87, " ( &3"
.
* , ' C* 7 3"
"
.( &
#9 7:
. 4 " ( # (* & = "
##9 7#:
.
* "
, " , # 3"
"
, ( 4 " #,"""
.(*4 5*4.
+ "
, ( , & "
"
.(*4 # & , " , ..* ##3"
.( & " & "
.
* .
##3"
, .
.(
' "
( * ;* "
.( , "+ "
" 9$ :
# 4"
" "
.( &, ( .
*4 #;& .*" 3"
.( &" 4 *( . . 4 *5
(
" 3"
, 5* ( 4 # , " ,4 "
## " $
(&"
& "
" 9$ : = ,"
, " " , "
4 "
.
, ? #B#, ( "
(
4 4 "
.
%
, ( " , ;* . "
*" , & " "
. "
* , " ,+ , " "
( "
+ , * "
" "
0*4 " * "
' " $ & = 0 .
% & * ! 4 ( .
9 " D ":
" 4 ","""
. "
* ( "
.
, 4 '* "
& ' ? 1" 1*. 3 " 9$ := ,
,"" , " 4 "
.
&, . $ 0 .
/4 "
5* = * 4 "
.
"* 4 ;*&"
"
C . ,"
* * "
E . ( 4 (* "
7 .( &+ , * "
" "
< .
*
& "
, * *( " 4 "
*
+ "
* "
" ( " 4
, " ,4 "
# "
"
"
< .
* # "
.
* "
$ B "
"
, * , " $ *4 " "
(( 8 "
& . .( &" . & #?;& 4 *( "
%
(. & , "
4 "
B , ? 9 7: 4 "
.
,
.
&, "
( 4 4 "
.
, 4* " *" * ,
.( . "
(( " *
* =* "
.
, 4* " "
( .( & #;& , * . "
? 3"
-$4 F*4 "
4 4 " .
-$4 F*4
" *" 5 "
/ & "
$
'* "
& 4 * ( . / " * 3"
- $4 F*4 * "
" "
, 4& " "
$ " "
.( & "
) 4" #?;& ," 4 "
3
& .( &"
4 4 .4 "
. 4 &4 ( ( ) * ;* # #;& , * (** "
.
* ( "
* "
-$4 F*4 " 5 4 $ # ?' 9 .
: , *
* " "
" 9$ :"
4 "
*
( . ( * "
' 3" ( , *5 * && 9$ :
,"" * * "
..
"
" 9$ : ( "
( + *" ..
" 9$ :, * "
(
< .
* , " (
" + "
(
9$ :" ( # /43 " 9$ : "
( & "
3"* "
9$ :" (( "
(* ( & " " & . . .( , "3"
"
.
*"
& "
, & * ( &.
"
.( & ,"" . &, -$4 F*4 * "
" "
" = " ?" . " ;* & "
( -$4 F*4 * 4
,"& & .( &"
. ,"
"
. ( &
5* -$4 F*4 * "
" ( 4 "
"
" "
.( &, ( ( * "
* *
, " "
.
4 4 "
"
' " $ &
% & -$4 F*4
" * ( $ ?' "
$ 0 .
"
, "( "
& .
* &(
4* "
' ( *" "
( "
*. ;*
, , " &( "
' * .
* D* . "( $ 0 .
* * E ( & ,"
, (( . "
" & "
. & "
& "
(* , ' ,"
&( '
* "
' "
( ,
&' * *
* $ ?' ' 4& .(*4
$ 0 .
, "
4 3"
$ ,
. 4 #;* & .( &, " , .
" - * "
$ 4* " "
-$4 F*4 "
"
4 " .
& * 5 4 4 "
. & "
* "
* ( . , ( %4" * % 4* " "
" .
B;& D* * & " 9$ :
" B *". &#?;& % . ;* "
. 4 , ( & 3"
9$ :
=
(( "
( & "
3 " 9$ : #? $;G + "
"
;.
&'4 "
9$ : "
( 0*4 0*4 ,"
? 9 7:
9 :( & 9$ : B ( & 3 " 9$ : ' "
(
4 "
"
B
4" . "
. 4 " & *
&, & * ;* % 4* " * "
"
' "
, ( 4* 8.* (
4 4 + , ( . , * (
4 .* ( 4 & & "
.
* "
& " " (( "
( ,"
"
#B# "
" 9$ :0*4 "
* ,,"", * *&* B ,"" "
.
"
? (** ,"
.
*4#?;& "
* % 4* " "
.
, 4" &
$ 0 .
* $ ' "
.
" "
4" &8 ? #B#( "
, & "
% 4* " "
-$4 F*4 *4" "
"
* &( "
$ 0 .
"
" "
3"
.( & * 44 & & ( & "
$ 0 .
- * "
7 .( & "
" 4* " "
$ 0 .
, ,"
&* "
, . & "
% 4"
- * "
( , " "
(( # '( $ #9: ' " . & & > *
( & *" . . & ( 3"
( *
. 4 & E (( * $ #9:9:( * *
,"""
( * '( * (( * ( && *( "* 77 ,"
( .
. F * & .
" 4, " *.
*(( " . + &4 "
4 & . "
*.
"
" "
(( 4 ( & @"
"
, . / ( /4 ( & "
. / ( ( & , " ( *.
" . "
( (( A 3"
( & ". @" *5 (( & "
9$ :A '( * ,"
" * & 6 "
* *.
&
( * & "
(( " "
*( 4 "
( &"( "
;* ( ( /4 " 4 3"
"
" " "
9$ : ( 4 (( ( + *
(( (( & "
9$ :
" *
& , & ( ( ,"""
( , " .
" . "
( 4,"" "
(( " & "
" "
9$ : , " "
& "
" "
" ( (( ( 4 4 "
(( 4 (( * & 4"
(( '( $ B &( 44 &
" . & , " " & & ( (( 9$ :'&( 44 & 9$ :
. & , " ( C & & . "
( " 9$ :* $ ? ' $ * &( $ 0 .
( ,""+"
$ 0 .
. & & .
"
&(
4 * "
' . &( *" "
(
*. ;* ,"" , " "
' "
* 3"
( $ 0 .
& $ & + "
(( ?B " . B;& 3"
" 9$ : " B *". & #? ; & + . ;* " . 4 , 3"
9$ :
=
(( "
( & "
3 " 9 " :
#?$;G + "
"
;.
&'4 "
9$ : "
( 0*4 0*4 ,"
? 9 7:
9 :( & 9$ : B ( & 3 " 9 " : 9 "
:,"
., * @%
00;#03'
##<3- ;0=#03 % "
> 5?7<-
&#$ B '( "
( ' * , 44 & "
B
" 9$ : ,4 . & #?;& 4 "
, ;* " (
9$ :&, & (( * $ B ' , " "
( . ( " & & ,"" *
* * "
,-$4 F*4 " "
" "
9$ :," 4 "
(( B " 9$ : .
*4 #?;& " , " "
* 4 (( % " "
4 "
" (( > " "
*" "
4 .;* "
. 4 "
+ "
. , & " "
9$ : " "
(( .
*4 ;. B ( & "
" 9$ :
= .
*4#?;& * (( 3"
, " 4 " ( ,"
& . "
. 4 , 3" , 3"
*4#?;& , * ? ' "
"
#,"" ., @@
"
7 A
B !, #007
;0=#03
% "
!>
&#
#;=<- =?<#- 3<# ! 5?7< -
0;#03
B & &
"
!>
&
-
$ 3"
, #B#3"
* , , 3"
*&, * * B ,"" "
.
"
? (** ,"
.
*4#?;& "
+ "
*. ,"
"
, , ? #B#( , 4 .
B " 9$ :
, " , ;* . "
"
0*4 C . .
* "
' " $ & =
.
% & * ! 4 ( .
9 " D ":
" 4 "
,
. & "
.
$ * &( $ 0 .
( ,""+"
$ 0 .
. & & .
"
&(
4 * "
' . &( *" "
( *. ;* ,"" , " "
' "
*
(
+ (
" "
? 1" 1*. " 9$ := "
" 4 ;*&"
.
C . ,"
* * "
E . ( 4 (* "
.( &
'4" & 4* & "
- * " $
"
" "
3"
.( & * 44 & & ( & "
$ 0 .
4" (( 8 $ * $ B ? ?' ( 4 (( 8 3"
.( 4 (( 4 ( & &,"" "
(( . & 44 + , (
.( ( 4 .(*4 , .
4 .
(( 8 4&
. 4*" *
* ( 4 .* * ,"
&
. & ( & "
(( 8 * "
& 4 4 "
.
=* "
"
*4" "
(
4* "
?'
4 & "
( * * "
(( " * ( ,"" (
. * & ;*"
&( " .
"
" , * ( . ;*"
4 * &(( , * * *4* "
4
3"
( "
.
,""
'( * "
" 9$ : "
(( ;* ( ( /4
3" *5 (( 9$ : -$4 F*4 ( 4 (" 5*4.
" * .% % "
!
#0547#05 )
@3077004&
035?=7005 #05
"
!
+& %)
% #,B,4B68 )
"
!
% "
!
% "
!
% @
# 3 #0@
$
# & ( 9$ :
(( 4 "
" 9$ : #
#;& -$4 F*4 " "
(( . "
4 9$ : / , . "
..
3"
* * 3"
( . & ( 3"
) " 9$ : ;* ( ( /4 ," ,4 "
.H * "
" 9$ :. *5
(( 9$ :3"
;* *& " "
9$ : 4 (( , **& ((& ". ( ( (( 48 (( 4 "
" 9$ :
3"
. ( ' 8* ,"
( & * "
&@" *5 (( A * "
&+*" * "
(( "
. & "
( & "
* "
& / &,"
(( & "
* "
& ,"
(( . *5
B + ./012/32!.4/.3%567897/2.723:276;+/'
,
%) ' "
% 6 $*( * , *4 4* $ 4* >.( &
9 " "
"
=&4 , "
"
' >4
4 ( .
:'( * 9:
" 4* .( &
"
.( & * * . &&44 "
.
"I * & . "
'( ( * 9:@
!
+$
? % 6 $*( * "
" "
* , @" A (
" "
( .( 3"
* , @*5 A * 3"
C( @" *5 (( A .
"
* & (( & "
.( &
& * 9 :
&*( (( & "
.(
* "
&+ , "# @
# "
@
)
??
#0
C
,
??
@
#
2
-
??
#0
2
!
#0
C
!
$" % .
$
%
2
. $% . $
%
.
$
!
%
)
!
$
+ .<6;5 =04.3 9 '
% * ' % 6
$*( * , *4$*7$ 9': $ #
+ 3 C' ,"
* & 4 (
4 ".
"
' 4 " 4 4 "
* .( C & *
"
*
* , " "
( * (( "
" "
4 "
* * & * % 6 $*( * "
" "
(( & "
" .
" &4 3"
.
"
*
" 4 4 .
"
* ( " "
' 4 3"
# " &
#&,! #&(! #& ! #&B! 3! "
5# , + .5# #&,!2
@
&
#!
#77
- #&(!%
&
#&,!
*
$ % ,
%
%
% - A
A
-
A
)
@
%
) 4
:
2
2
-
-
1
$ 3"* & * " "
;* ((
" 9$ :& "
9$ :. & 3"
9$ : ;* C . ( & "
" 9$ :, " 4 & "
(( & "
4 (( '( 4 4 (( "
;* * 3"
.
(( &.( + "
( ( (( # "
, 9$ :& "
9$ : # ' 4& " (( 3"
5*4 - $4 F*4 + "
" "
. & "
# (* & 9' C* 7: "
* "
. "
' " $ &J= 0 .
% & * "
( .
& "
0*4 0*4 3"
.
. &(
, " , &% ! %%!
! ! .3-5 '
4 "
$( /48 G "
8