High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4269/2012dismissed

Dilbagh Singh And ORS v. Jarnail Singh And ORS

2019-02-15Mr. Justice Harminder Singh Madaan10 pages

!"!""#

$$ %#& '#!""#

$ (#

# )"*+ #"$$

,,,, -#.*"&$ ."$ "#$!#"$'!/!"0 #$# ."120#3&#4# "/3&#! 0"'!#!"0#$# ."1 0# ! "# &## "# 5"# 5 -3&#0"

"&!"0"#!#"$#$#.

."#6&"##$"52" 5 -3&#"+#"#"#" .0""5#555*"0+# #"#"*" " ! . 0" 0# 3&# 4# "/ 3&# 7"!#"#5"#*"$#""

" !# "#2 " " " #5 2"##+#!#5"#*"#&# "#+!7"8"#3".0""$ "$$. 5$"#2 " .9'&* :* 8 5 -3&#0""50""#"#5 - 3&#2"5 -3&#+#;$#"#58 .5#.$*"0+#"5"'&* :* 5 -3&#*0".!0"";$#2"" $0$"#50# /. $##5 . "5* "0+#* $#& #&&!< #7#==)## !5&#!#!$#$#. .5 -3&# 46(0##5&" "#2"" $>

" /0""0##0# 7# == )#* "0+#* 7# == )# 0"&$!$#$#$#&#!+!" $# 5& +&# " >

#!"$"0&$ .>

&* +*$#+#!#00#!.2" 5& " " 0 $#+ 0#!.2""&$#$#./"# " "$#2""> "$&#""# )&#$#!"'!#!"+: ?

? &#!$."&2""" .$#$ !*&+ !"#!"" $2"0""#&5"5" $*""$ #&!"&6&"7&# 8!###"<?

!* #&&*&+$#+6&#!""$ "5&> ?0!0#! 8!# #/$"&$#$#.*6&# 8!###$#5/&##!" #5!"&$#$#.."#0.##! :

+&#"> & + !&$"$

> " & 0 & " & &# &$ $ "#&!" $& * &" 0 $#!;$#

=##$#+"#*"$-#/!"! "5##(< "&#"#;5"

"!# !"(<

#"#!#&#"$#*"&0 #;$#""<?

;& #!# " #$ " #! 3"# > 9 9?9

* : *?

@ : ?

:99 ? *5# &7"8"#3"!0"#&+#"$

5&#!

;

&#.# & +&""0&#"### #5!*5#!!!"5.5#0 &#"# ## #5 $! " $ # . !.;$&&#0

A"/&!5#0#"! # " $$7&# ." !"!""# .0.! $$ 1# # '&!* 5## + /&!5

0"$$*"/&!5#

:#5""#7&#&#"# #!"$$5+$$#"#5$5 "& #!"#7&#0"$$ 5$"5"&&#"##"# 7&#"&#"#8!0#& 5#5 "$$ #!.*"#7&#5$" ##$ .#'&!*5##*0"$$ "#5$5

> "& .!0# 5 #! $#5#. / "!! " 5 ."&&#"#!"&5 ##2 "$""5#"$$#" "7&#0"" 5#&""

5$&!0 !+;& ."#; &$!5&#"#!"5&" "#+ A"0#!" $"$#$#.00"$&#!5 5 -3&#*#"##!"55 -3&# 0 &0#"&$#$#.*&""0# " $#$#. . 0. * !* ;"! # * #!."";&0?

+&#"# '!#!"B>

2""00#!#" & !###"5 -3&## 0" 0 # " '!# !" ?

* " )&#$# !" 5 0# " & $#$#.2 " " $&#""$#$#. 5"#+ :

".#&&+!$ "#""#."" #$# "/5 #".# @:* ?8"#!#0# #5# @4# :2""> # $&#"##+& #0"&. $."&"#5" #" 5&> @ 6&#*". " #$# A" #& " #5! ! " $ ! " " #; 0 ! 8# .'!#!".*0"0$#+!"#

"5"#$"!"# "#!2""0;& .5 -3&#+&# '!#!"$#.!+ A"#+# 5"&

=5. 5"#">

'!#!"

"&#!"$."&"10# #&!" ## &".$$#"7&##&" 0#$#!;$#

A" $ " #$ #+#! " ! " 0# 5* 0"# ##! " +#5"$

"$!"$#*0!&0# #5

<""# " < !. ;& . - 3&# ?

&+$#+6&"!#!" "$C ((

<""#5& ?

:!*& + !"$C ((

<""#"$!0""# "$#$#.C ((

<""#"+&#> " .#$C ((

<""#<! .-3&#!+C (

@ <""# " >

# $&#"# 0"&C (

@ <""#"+&#> " .#$C ((

=##$#+"#*$;5" -#/ !"(< *"

!#!"(<

""#"*";5"

'!# !"< *"

!" #!"<*"

8!" <?*"

&8"/#!"<*"

!"!"< * "

>#"(#"#< A"##!5&5* +"

#"#!"#&#"$#*"# 7&#&>

!"+&#" $* & > +&# " $ ! " *&> ?+&#"$!" *&> +&#"$!" *&>

!"+&#" $*&> @0$#.+&#"$ $#.+&#"*&> @0#! "#&!"&> " #.*!& > 0# #"& &.*"&" $0$#.#""$0#0#

: "&$#$#.";?9" "#"< ?

!.;& .5 -3&#*0& +0$#+*6&#!""$5& > ?

:0## "" > 0#0#"&$#$#.";

9""#.0####5!" &.5#5#" 9""# A"0+ /&!5#

D!!!#+ ."/&!5#*" > "$$"7&## '&!*5##*0""0!## '&!* 5##* 0" + /&!5 # 5"5 *0"""> !!#+ ".""$##!&#$$ #" 7&#*0""0&"#$ $ >

:"$$#"#&!"& $> 0& $##5#$*&""#+0$0"

& 6&.&##$>

:$$$$#! "7&#

="+"##&#"$$ !!"#&!""##=""# &.5# "$$

A"$#$$#+"##5"

'!/!"*0"&#" "5"0;& . 5 -3&#"+&# A"0" $#+ +#0"0:"E+ *0""0"$#;&&5#6&# . 0 $#+" &

& !0*+*" #"$&#$ $#+!;&*"# !0+* & /"$#"7&#$ !+!+

A" $#+ &# " 0+ " $#

E;5 ! 0 0 5&

5.*!0"00;5$#+ ;& A" " "# + 0"& ;5!."!0"0 ="# "!0"00+ E+0*".

&"+"#++ "#5;5! $#6&0""0#!9!&#"# !0# "0*#5"& !##*0"#0#!# &"!"#0* "##"0#5&$#+

F#"#&5*">

6&#." "0"+ ;& .5 -3&#"+&#*"9"!"#&$ . $ #"> *0"#$$

#"7&# A";& .)&#$#!" !#$#+'!#!""# +&#0!.# &+& &0" "5 -""7&# !"" #&5" .$#$#$$#$$# +###$#0"+#&#&## ! !"$$ > # "# &$&"!#"#& 6&0#

>"#$0$##$&#0# " "$$

D!5#"$#$$*"5 50"

-#/ "#$#%%&'( )'*&+

, ')( "#$#%%*(%$&-. ')(