Dhiraj Jain v. Shobhini Gupta






   
  
 
   

  

!!"" #

$ % &'!

(!     

 
   
     )   
!!""*! 



$'"+  *$ ,* -  $-# .*,*  ! /// ('0

*  " !!" %"2 '2.  

!%3 ") !" '2*."3 +'

*  &'

'2 .*  - %3  !  "  %3  $ %   &'!
!

! ' $4   5'

2 62"'.

2* %""- 

2%- -".78

4

' -"6* "-%  0 !!"" ! &, ..!"3   '.! ."  * 3 '"!'""2

""3* !
-"!'

$4   5'

2 "' 

.

2 2 ' '"3  ..'

9-  '% !!"""-3.% ,- - % !'%""3 5''

% . !
!* - -%  !*%3.62!

""

5'


"" -  '"%  " 5* ! :!  *  !
'%  !!""    " - .62!

". 3%- ". . ";!%2"*,<'%" . * "" ""2",""%3 !
-- !

3 

." !-.  .     !"2       ! *  ""-2  '  -  . =  ! "  ,  2 '. !>)) (" 9  !

, *!
- "!! -%<)=
<.$3$  . )=
*  $  . )=
4*($2 )=
*$ "&'! )=
?*$'

% 22 -"

)=
8*)+$2" )=
 "6 )=
 $ "  ,  !

2 !

    .

2  @< )    @< )8*  3      !  @< )*  !3    ."  @< ) *  !3    %     

!  @< )A*  .      2  "!    ! B  .

@< ) @< ) *!3!

 !"!@< )?*!39(@< )8* !3 
 -- ""@< )*!3!

 !"!

@< ) *!3.' !  !@< )A!3 2.''"!@< )

       *  !
'%  !!      -%<(=
<.

:

, 0 $2 **)

*+  1'% '"$*99$(=
 ."3+'

* 22

'2 , "%3

4
! *  ""-     !    2   ,        -     ""-22 '

! .2* 6)* '% !!""- %"    3   ."   <'"        -

!  9 .2C."* 6* ." . 2 %"3!  .< ""  .'." '"3



 $3*         '%*    .!   !  .  3. % ,  '% !!"" .

- . "6

$3  2 * - 3 2- 

$3  -   3.  1   -    <!"     

  '

*! - .* '%

  .       -    ,     !

,'

3.  "  6  !"    "   $*  '

2   

3.  !  .'. %" '"""   - 9-'%",%" * - '. %"- " !* - 3    !" "  3.

1 '%-,",, ' "2-

!

,'-*, 22,  .

,     .

2*          2 *     -  - .!"""!  -2 . 2, - -'.  *-  '!" - ""-"!2   2 

".'." '"3

,1 '%  '%- !

 

 "6*,* -!

  , 3 

 "6!! )=
 %2,"22*-!

   -%26""$"1<  =  % ,*     ""2  ",""  '!  .  -  %3 .  -- , 3  "    %     . "  '"  ",    %  9  -  % ,        -   2 ''

"*. %"! -. ,   ", .

= "  ""-2     !*    -  .     '2.!   



? !<+'

'2.4 $ + * ! "#  $ "#99 4+ ?

0"

* "" %&  ' '(+,"!!"D A  4



4 ! )&   )&

 !< +'

 '2.?

5 

9 *""3!!" +
4 A
+99 -., !"2  - 2"'.   %" !

'

""!- "!2 .!'2'2. 5-, * !!"-.,"  4

?

A

 *  ,       

?

A  !    +
4 4
 * !!"
'%- !3 .'( ?*

C
! .

 -- .
* -' '!

?
. -

 .* -, *.%" "' '"%

,%-  A

*%  !! , '""3 3 -  !! %  +'

!

3""3

  <      

*    .!  -  .    ",     .

.%"3*%' . .'''"



* +'

2,  !!""! 

 .

( ?*

C
! .  . "2 !!"



"

 .%'( ?*?

*

C
*-  %!%3 !!"" !
-"" 

    
!!""    !!   , '""3  3   '2 2 .!'2'2. ""-22 '

1 ."3+'

*- '22 . - ."%3 .* - 2"32, 2 !!""

"2

1   ,  2,  %3         %  6    %  2* - !, .-  

1 .  !
- !2

'2   -.623  .

2-

,1 -* !* .3 2-

 "6-"""2' 3

,%<.-%3!"2 '2.2,%3  %.- ' <.2 ,$4   5'

8


2*A??

!!"" "

 '2.!%3 5B%" $'!

.+'

 *+" "#  ++ &, - $.AA?

9(8 8*/"

'

++ !  $

!+,"!!"D 44



A 

A* 0 1+ )&  2 3$  &+A8A9(8 5 "

'2.!%3 "

52 +'

 4

"& #

 ) . #

1 ))  +  C ? 

8* ! 

 ,%"% 6-.

22 '2    , ' 5'

2 

$'"+  *"  '" !*  '%
!!""*  
<.%  ."3+'

* . ."  22,  .   -
$ 6 * -"22-

= ! ,2, %3  *

+     
<.

$3 $  . )=
* !!""
'%*- .

)=
"2- - $  . )=
4 .! !   3.  

+  *"  '"

!'

 2 '6%3 !!""  - . ,%

"%3  '2. 9! A .!'2'2.*   % , ! .2C." 6BB* '% .

2 %"3!  .< 9 - ."*  . "6  

$3*%'  !!""B 62* .! ."2- - 3.

=  .2,%3 .  !
-


$ "&'! )=
?* !2 '2  3 .

 ""3*  2' ' $4   5'



2  *     '%      "  3  ,     -*  -

!
-  6,2 -- 2 , 

% 2 "32 ,'

 -6!2,- "-" -    

 A8A)E ?8* 5* 6""

6  ' - 6""AA4 $++4*4

& "

 4

& " 

8 $++??

*  ! )&   )& 

  $++  * "" %&  ' '( 4 ?$++8* !+

! 

.  ?    (+(  +,"  8    "*  +"!  $++E$+ 5 

 '*- ! 2 '6%3 !!""*

%.  
<.*- -'

 * ",!   !

'' 

92,  ..3 - 3 

9

 '22 .3 -"3!!"2 ,    @, !2,  *.3, "- - .3 - ."3  9 "..!" 2  ."3..%  9"" ."2 . , 2..'- %!%3.

3"2- .""22

! '"  ."3+'

 - ,  !' $4 5'

2*"%3$. $ 6 *  -!!""
  *-""-,  

?

! '2.*.

2!

!!""
  - ".7- !

,'-$ 6 8

5-, * 3 ! ?



 * "  !'

$4 5'

2  . 
<.  

 *-.%3 . "2-  ---""22  . -  !  .   -  ""  

 *    -    "2  -

  5    "   ..!"-"" ."2  -

."3..%  , 2 ..' "2 -""22  5-, *!!""
   !"   !3    .!"   

8  @< ( *  -  -  .  %3

!
-$ % &'! $ "" C!!"

8@< ( $5 *2   " .!"

8@< ( 2 '% $ - 3".3 . '%"3-,  . .

9- '

  '"6!"" %"22C2-

.

 

2       !   -  ".7    8

4     3 !  3  ?



 "* !!""-!'

'2

"2-  - @, - 32,, 

-$ % &'!

!  '

2 !3 !!"* !
-  . "         -  3 ! .  ".3 .

'% !
- !"  !3!'

$4
0 5'

2@< )

!-"%3 "33* ?

= ! !* !!""  .-22%3 !
- ''""3  *- , .  * !

,  6B)B%- !!"" !*  -         % 62 !  2  ."

A
 6 .

 1 !!""  ,   6B)B %6 !*-'"% '"<!

!
-"" %". " " 5* 22,%3  '% !!""-

"2* 2 *- .".'

2 
<.    !!""*  -    
<.    

 *   . 6-$3$  .A 8$'"" A

5. $3$  .-.   .

2

2"  $3B



$3$  . )=
* '

2  
<.*.  H'!!""

."*  - .! !!""   

-  3. 5'

 --  - .

2% "" .! .

5

6 . -

$. $ "&'! )=
?*- . 

!
$ % &'!*'

2  
<.  '" '2  -'" $ ,$ %  

..* . -'"%"-  '"%! $ '

 !!""  '3 .

2 -'" ' -""

, %3!

3".3%-  . , 3%22 $ , 3 22

- '2 

 5*     2 '       .!'2 '2.  0  *,-" -* -

!
-  6,2 -- 2 ."3 +'

 

 .2C." 6BB  = ! , "6*" %2,*',


 !-  "<<- 6*-

 -2

5'. !
-' "-

'

2 !3 !!"*.!-.  '+'

".*- " 9-<! % * %2+"
   !,! .*-'"., " 5-, * !!""-.2 ,  -  !
'!

#  

!%3 +'

*  -2, !!""! 

  ( ?*

C
! .  . "2 !!"  ..



9 ..-!!%3 !!"" ' !
--+"
9  '", 3-""

"6 " ( * 2*%. '2. !"*"

)  5"$ ) 

A9( $+*-   % " ,* - 2* '%%'.

!. .! 6!2,- -- 62, - '3! .".3- !!""* -  .'!!!"

 , *'

2 !3!!"*     -    !
'!  -     -*        '"  "  !3 .

=  .

 *

 . .%'( ?*?

*

C
*- !!"" !"" "3"'% - -. - %2

"2

9 * !!"" 62,  .   - 3 

*"""22-

 =  


.

2- !
$ % *- 6!"8

4* 3 32! "3 ?

9 %".,

3  3 !  !  !
--3! . ".3* !!"""22-   %2 , %3 9% * 22

'2 *"3"' % - !!""

"2!3.

   ..*- .( ?

?"6 *-'" -  - !
-., "   '2.

%3 !!""-'"% "! .

 03!!"32  '2. ! "" 

"+   8$++4    * +'

 ,- 2 ' '"3*"'%%- "

% 6-.

2*'2 ,  -  . , %22*.

2%- - 6'!

! "3  2"3*,- %,'* +'

 ,- !
- % 2 "32 , %3 ."3 +'

*&'

'2 .2 '.'    ,  %!!

 2 ! !,  ('""3*  2    . *     !

  !!"    .

5-, * !!"" !3 

  .. '( ?

?E6  !
-- ! 4 3 (91:05(9  :&@

$5II:(#@( 

  :&@ !

 
 

 JCD    
   JCD