High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4379/2012dismissed

Roop Singh And ANR. v. Amarjit Singh And ORS.

2017-07-31Dr. Justice S. Muralidhar12 pages

!" !

!#$%&#&'(

)%'*+,'&,'-+# ))#..,'-/ 0#/1/ 2,3%-%'*+,'&-+#/ #/)'&#'-/ ,2( 4 5 6

#/#'-(

,37%#+,8,-9 !" " " # "! ! " " #

$% %%%&' "

# (#" ! # " ) " !

" !

* #!

* " "

"" * # "

# !

# # # " +,% -..

/)01'2 1',"" # " * # * #* # "

+% --3 /)01'. 1'- # "" " 4

--3* 4

3, --3

+2%$ --3 # !

# * " # " # & # # ! #"+5$ 5 ,2&& 2&+ .& %2 --$

* " ! # #"5# ! " ! !"# ! * " # ! # ! ! & ! # # !" "

" "# # #" # +2%- --$ /)01'

+ # " " & 6 !

# ! # # "

+2 % --.

/)01'

# #

# " ! #""

" & "

" 784 + % --$1 #

,- 33, 3+, 3. 3-81

! 784 /)04'

&( #8784 " # # " # 8" 784

# # ! !

!'" ! ## ! 8 784 1 " +3 % --$4 " *"

! * # ! /)0 2!" # ! #

# ! # ! "1" # "

# # 8 # "# !" # " ! " # 7#

*" 5"9/ # 784 #

# " # " 5

! : # # $% %%%&' & " ! # # #" ! # 8

" 784 !#

# & 8# ":4; " ! "7 # # # # " --$< =1:4$%$ +%%$< =

# 22, : # ! " & # " # # >"#" # "# 5 )# # ! ! ! #

"# #" "# ! # # ! ""

# * # # "

8"#

# # "

?# "

"# # !

)

"" " 7 # # " 4*"

! !" #"$

%!*# # # " * ; #

# !& '( )#"*"++,# -"%.

/ , "

# # *! #

! @

# #

!" #!"# # " ! # ! #* # # " " # # #

%% 41 +%

# 8 ?# ?# " " 7 "# " !

# " ?# 4!"

# # " ! # 0 '!"+ (1 " //2/3 .

/# 4#

;

" " # # !

" # # ?# '?# "#

!# ! *# # # " 7# #*"

# 0 !"+

.#!

% !"+ !#

" # ""

*# # # " 20 '1!"+ - 35! # #

%2 8 # -+$< ;;= ! # "!

# & 8 #

# # "

! # # " # "

" " # '' * " "5#!

" # " "

# * &

5 ?# # #" " !

""784" #

" ! 5" "

# " # ! " ) !* ; #

# 8 )#" *"++,# 6+ %

# 0'

7 7 "+"89 84 :

4 ;+

< + "42!''=72% 8 "+

, % % + "8 ""

8 , 8 +/=$ $ "84/ +8"8</,4 4 ", /"+"84"

4 /+ +4+ ",4 +",9 "+""

//"+ +/, / / 8 "+ "",

+ >+ 4 8 " %

"+?%+ // "87 "+9+ // "8 ++%+/""8""% 4

"" / 8 " + "", 8

+ >+ !" #$%&&%'( !

) *+ ,,- .. / / !" #$%&&0'( !

) ,,- 1 /2 )" "/ ""8/ /"+

+4"/ """":

4 4 / / "" /% + 0 + // %+4 /"+

+ :

8 " + 8

+ >+ *

) $) 3 )

)

// 4$

< /5

/ - 6 7 8 . 2 9" ) :8" & '( ! % !

) ,,

+2,

# " * ; #

# # "#

! ### )#

#8 !!# # " "" * ! ! #5 "#! "# *"

#?#"

# "

" " ! # "# ! "# # # " # # !" "" ?# "!# !1 !

## " //2/ %4 # " # " "! ! ;% + ;# " " " # > " 1 !

# # 0'

A& + / /"+

% + % + // "8 *"4 / ,<!

!"+

+ "

% + !

,8 "", "8/ 4 +

% /+,

+ /% %% % &%"/ % % + / 8/"+

" + 4,/

% "4 /2 "

1'8" ,< "!30"

// +"/ + + = / / +"/ ++ =/ % 4/ % %,4 / % 4 " %" + & 8 7% + 9" + ++"8+ +/"

"80!9 7 &

+ / /"+

% + % +/"

% + 8+/"

% ++8+, /, + +",+ % + @ 8 +% ++ 8+/ %" "9 7# #*"

# 20 !"+ (1 ! 28"<""A!/+"8 $ : 8 # )/": : ?# 8 )! /" 7 # " # # ! "#!

" 3 # "

# 0'

< & 8 & 0 , + + "8 0+ / " *" 8 8+ /% 0 +/% 0 800" %+ & ,/,B + 8 & + /"+

% + "8 /"+

% + 0>+", / 8*"C

"8 + /"+

% + "

% + !

,8 "","8 / &"",++%""/ + + /"+

% + 4 + /,8/"+

+ = %"8% + , % + /

4 / ,8+% " +/ 8 " %

" + " + + % + % +

8/"+

448 8 "

/ 8 +,"8 + 0+"// /"+

% + %"+ +"// +

=?C / % C / % %,+C / % 9 *

# # "# !

" !! # 8 !

# " ! " " ! # ?#

1 ?#" ?# "# >?#

" #

" # # !

# * ?#!8 ! "

# 5# " )"# # # " # #"" #"# # : # "! # 7#9# " #*"

# 0

!"+ % "# # " "" ## # " ?# %2 !

# # " !)

# ! #! #" ! %2 8 # -+$

# 0'

<-,2# " ) 8!) 8 )

) ) 8 ) = " )5>2""/8 "" % + , + %+"

% +>

% / +4 >+ / @>+%+ +

/ 4 "40"

+ 4 % "

%,@>+%" +8 %,4 "

, 8

" ,9 # "

) ! %2 #

#! #

""#" %2 )

! * " # # # ! " & ! # "! " ! # "

"" "# 8

# " # # ! /-1.=9

> 6?

+%0,'%@,1/+%A ! )%$D E ) % " E