National Insurance Co Ltd v. Suman And ORS.










 

 












    

   

 

!

" #

 !


 "#

 $
 
$
$

$

%$   

& "

 '

 % &

(!) &

& 

 *' !  +++ , #
-# ., 
,/0 1"

"   "  

" "2

 3

45"%   !

1 4 #2 6

"7"1 4 78 9 

 " !    " :3

.& ! 
; 
 0";;&"  <

 &&  2 ,#'3'=3=36"  "7"

&" 782"   (! "

 1" 2   "&4   "

 & "

&"  >#

" 2    $    0";; ?

 !    "& 4   45"   &

     (!  "  1 4   

 "  !    "     # @' ! " 

  *A2

 



 @*"
2

"

 B



  "!       *  5 8   1"  

  

5  2  

  # **@'6*BB8# C"2

7

 7

7   B

7  2     2        !

    # **@' 2 "  2 2  " " 2 



"

 D

 "  

"" "

 " "  &" 

&" 2  & 4"1 4    " "" 2  45"

D ! ""!5 "  2 "   4<45"

&" 4"!"   & ""!52 ! !

 5

 " &"  !42 !   ">#2" "2  

45$"(!"""     

""

 &"

&" 2 E  " !

  



" 

"  "

 "

 

4 "&4 & 4"1 4  1"1 " ! "2 

 "   "

 & "

&" 

F
 

             

   

   

    

     !"# "$ $ %  '() ?

"4

"&  45"   "1 4 

 "4&

 &" ! '

 2

" "" "   "

 & "



&"  1 &"" "   "

 & "

&" 45

3D

;6   *

+" ! " B!

?!$< "

5'2 

"  $G 1"   4!  

   :$45"$  ">#

" 5  

:3 

 45  0    %   !

  "  



32      $G?!$< "  

 & "" 2"  !

!"

9" "

!5 " ! !"

&"   2 4 #   ,#'3'=3=3  & 45

;  "

!



" "

 !!4"

" "!5"

  " "  &"

&"  

 2" 

"  25!"

 1"!2 &   45"  $    0";;

 2 

"" "   "

 &     "  

  &"   45  

;  D  

  3



5 "   

   :$4"E % "$ 

 " !!!  " 

  

*'

$ >""1  

  !  

" !! " 

" !  4 "># "

 """

 "&"  !    < 2 9"  ! 5?!

$< "6$G852 

"  45



45" 1 4 & !

 44" &&! "

&"  >""$   "'

"



3

 &"

&"  " 2 !  45"1  

" !

" 45 "

 &  "

"   ! & ""  &" 

&" " &!& 5

   4""   " "" 4  5 !

  "  1"" %"  "!5"&  !

2 ! !

 52     !"

 "

 & "  &"

&"  1"  !

       "  4  2  B   45  "  5'2 

&   45"$ 

"  !' 4 & 45"1  2" "! " 

"  &"

1" " 4

 2 ""

"1 4  "

  1"! "



"

 '

"

 

  

3" 4 E 

" !

  

4   " 4 

 5" 45" ""1 4   ; "  5 "4

&    4 



"4

  !  & 4" !

  %&'(')*+
,,'--../
%++%&0%1
2
$31'
,.43
$*55'
*&0 -3.14

6


7
& 9 ""



 " E  

F
,       &   

          -  

  

  

   -

 

   

   .  /   0 

*

 

1  &

  "0 .2 /  -1 & & 

 1 3 

 ,      %& 

  HI

2 " ! 2 4 & 

 '

##*

 &    &    

    

% , % - &   %  -

 %    -



 % %   % 

 41--   % 

     &   ,

 

0 0 

 ./ 0  *

-



""

 

"" 

 *

  0     #5 /-

&  6

   /  -1  &&

 0  #741-- && 

     ,

 &

&% ,   0 

  ./ 0  *

-%

  

     

 , %  *,  0 0 -   - 

 %& &  3     7# 5 / #89  (:* &  ,  -1

1;

 

 1



-    && 1 1  6  

 <       1 1=""

>*<   0 0   &   

    -





   -

 

 

 ./

0  *

- 

1  &



 "0.2 /-  



1  1%  & &        &     .  /  0 

*



,   1-   % & &  3  &  7# 5 /> 2 " ""; ! " !

 !

" 

 "  &"!&"     "   & 4

 "%   !

1 4    2 " !    

"%"  1"

"

 "2 "  &2"5 & "  "   !  " !    4"%   !

1 4  "; ! &  5"B

     

*"-&   1"4&& 22    81'43*&
$9
*&5'1*,
2 *1*:*-'
;'0:
*&0
-3.14

7
#
62 " " !

 7 ; ! E    &2 "& &   4"1 4 

"1 4 2 

"

 

"4

"& 

 4 

  45""

5" !

 "E "  ?#4         1

       1 %  

*

* 

 6&  --  0 @ ,   ;



 1        *

*   &                 

         ;

     *

 *

1 

  

%    -

  %  &  %              ;

    %    0 41                  

 0 4

 

 % & & - 



                  

  0 1  %  0  

  1     *

)  3.
.&.1*+
*&*5.1/
'3*1
*0
1*&4)1-
1)1*-'& 2
$,-
,*
*&'
.3%1*
*&0
-3.14
66
;#
7<<
& 9 "

", "" "; ! E   !

   !

4  & ! 5"   "2 "  !

 2   

! 

"  "

 !

 9"

" !

 4

 "

 &   ? /  ,      ;

   &

           



      %& & 

1

           1         & 



  4 11

& & 1 

  0  



 00  

    )   .,
*,
*&0
&-3.1
2
81'43*&
3*&0
*&0
&-3.1 = 6

'2'+
7/
  2 " 45", !"$ ", "

"     "2"  &    45"  !

  "" ""  &"  & "&"   "5

54"

E 2 4 



!

"  !   

 ?*;

  "1

 % 0 0   



           %     %     A , 1   

&

' $ 4    1     

%0 0 -    

     %   %-

-    ;

 - 

   

 

  & )   .+3'
1*&4)1-

*&0
&-3.1
2
*2>?-
$'&53
*&0 -3.14
= 

1
=/"
" , "

 "2 " 4;

" ""E "  &"

&" 45" !



4< "& 5 & 

"

" 45"1 4 

!

    ?/   -!  8  3   
"7  % B  %1

  1

/&&  &   



&&    1   41          /&&

  ;

     

&



  #7"/40    1

         &     /&&     *  0 

*

-1-   &  

              

     /&&     1

     1  -       

      4     

                &  

         &



 

.2 /-$C/+   4   1    ;

      -0  *

 3&  6  &   ;

%   

 1

  & 

 

 &    &&  &

% ! 

 & &    

!!"#$ ""#%&  '

 ()) -

&0 

=" >*&        ;

 

 --



1

-1

,     %  *  ;

      & 

  #7"/40  

  

  

     1           %> $/

<  0  ( # * + ,#-#.# #.

. (/ 0#- !"# & ) '2&

*3$ *

.

 

=" >  % ;

 

 &&  %  

  6   %   

 

%*

  &  &    *  ./0*                 1 

   &  

      >   4 $"%# 4*$  ,$"#3/#% 5#

6#.7

)7# $.

& ' ()) -

&0       & % 

 

    &&   &

  

/  0   3& 

     &&  &

%)  ..-*
.2'
*&0
-3.14
2
*>.43
*&0
-3.14
 


'2'+
6"

2 B!

"

   B 2" "E 2  "

"2 



"  2 "

""1 4  4   45"""5'2 

2"" 4"1 4 "  "    " 

'

 !

 

1"1 4  E   ; "  " 4

&    4 

 "4

  !

 & 4" !

 ?

/ &

&

 %        1  1

  
  /
  -   -    &  %"1

-/
"    & 

   &  1       94!      & /

  *

-1/
  1

&  %"1

-/
"  1  %"

1

 1-  *

    %/
"-  -   %

   %/
"  -   %

     -/
  1 &  %"

1

&   4  

%-/
"  

    *

- 

 

&& &       

&

%-  *

   6   %/
#-.  *  *

  

1 % %  1  % 

 94! &D  

      % -1    % 3&&  && - 1 -1     94!* % -  *

           %   

   94!-  1 

   1 1  

 %   &%    &   %  94! / &

&

 1      % &&           *

     &   4    

%E

   /
   .  -   *

    %   1

11&  %"1

    

  &

 4      %  %/
  4 - -    1

 00 

  0 0 -

 0 0   

      *

**

&&     ,         

     &     

   

0 0 4  1 - 1   %;

        6   *

*  *

    1  &    &&% ,  ) 1" " 

 2 " " 

  "

 1 4 "" 2   "

 &  "

&"  "! 2  



!



  

 
$
$
 

  G"" < @#

)

G""# 4 ) @