← Library
High Court of Punjab and HaryanaRSA/4384/2012dismissed

Bhaskar Refractories & Sw Pipes Pvt. Ltd. v. Surender Kumar And ORS

2018-05-10Mr. Justice Augustine George Masih6 pages

 

    

 



  !"# ##$%&#%'( )&&**  +#, ,# #-,.# !# )&        

  %#  ##!/ 0' #!&&**   #!'-,.#0' ##&    

  

  , * 23 ! &&** 4&*

0  &#3 #  *# !!2.!5 # & 02353 '# & 0   ! , &#&#3   *  .,# 6  " *   .#*0 .&#   "!#  70 , 5!  ! #' ,    '**6 # -!58 #. 6 &#   !  ,#* &#.   ! &*

,

-!,##09#2    05! ! &,#!!, &#&#3 #.      0 &,#,    #6#* :

0! #6!0*# #!#   & ,.#, &&#,  6# 0  *, 6 ! * &&#, 30!&*

** 3'  ,&&# *.0  '  5 * 23 ## ("50 '  !    * 

 , 3' #6#!,! , &# 5,& !. ,* *30!#*;,#.!,, ###<,*  ! ;   ;'* %#,#  '  ! &&* &# ## 6  !  # * 5.'.&,6 8,6.  <

0 !&&** &*

 6,*# &&* # 1 &# ,#!#0  5,* 2 &&  # #  !  *, ##'23!&&**;,#05!!#!,  !  "#$" %$&""'()* #+,-" (, (. %",()"), ,$ /"),($)-"",- ,.+(,0 .#( "'0 12 &3$)!45!446 )'

(),(## - . .$+*-, ,-" '"&

,($) ,- , .

" '""' '

,"' !57!446%", ()()*,$,-".+(,

)'"8"&+,"'21'"#")'

),. )$9 )':()# ;$+$#'"#")'

),.)$  )'!2"'"&

"'

"*

)+

)';$(' )'%

(),(##2"'"&

"',$2"$0)" ()%$.."..($)$;",-".+(,

)' )&".+&-."($+.(*-,. " ();$ ;"' () ,-" (,(* ,($) (, & ))$, 2" %".+/"' ,- , ,-" %".$)0-$- .#( "',-".+(,0(

, 3",-".

/"& .+

1 '+,1(.& .,$),-"%".$)0-$&$/".,$&$+,,- ,-".-$+ '$ ";"1 "##$, (3" '()* ";('")&" ",& #$ #()

'<+'(& ,($)$#/ ,," "+.

$#=(/()($'".";"

,-

#," ,-" #( ()* $# ,-" .+(, () ,-" 1"

 !446 (..+". 0"" # /"' $) !9!!4  (" #," 2$+, .(8 1"

. ) 2",0"") ,-" .+(, "/ ()"' %")'()* )' $) ;

($+. $&& .($).

..$+*-,#$&$/%$/(.",(.%",()"),,$ /"),($)-"",- #,"!!7!44>,(

?6!4 4/$"$ ".. & ."0 .&$),()+$+.

'<$+)"'#$ (,()*&$/%$/(." ;").

/"0 . ,-" %$.(,($) #," ,-" # /()* $# (..+".

 ")'"

;$$#,-"%

(),(##0 .)$,,$ '";('")&" ,-",$ .""3 '<$+)/"),$),-"*$+)'$#&$/%$/(."  ) '<$+)/"),.2".$+*-,()'"#()(,"

1(),-" *+(."$# (,()*&$/%$/(." )')$,,$ '";('")&"21

(),(##(.,-"%$(),#$'","/() ,($),$'"&('",-(. %%"

 9 @-") #,",-"#( ()*$#.+(,$)!45!446(..+". 0""# /"'$)!9!!4 '+()*,-"(),";")()*%"($'$#

%%$8(/ ,"

1.(81"

.(#&$/%$/(."- ')$,, 3")%

&" 2",0""),-"% ,(". #,"# /()*$#(..+".%

(),(##.-$+ - ;" "'(,.";('")&",$%$;"(,.% '()*. )!9!!4 ,-" & ." 0 '<$+)"' ,$ >9!4  )' $) ,- , '

1 )$ ";('")&"$#%

(),(##0 .%"."), ,-"$),-" (3"

(-$$'$# &$/%$/(." ..$+*-, ) >9!4 (,0 / '"& 21,-" )"',(

&$+,,- ,(#$),-")"8,'

," $# -"

()* (" :!4  &$/%$/(." 0$+ ' )$, 2" "##"&,"' ,-" ";('")&" 2" "' 21 ,-" %

(),(## $0";" $) :!4  / ,,"0 '<$+)"',$ 56!4 -""

#,"$) 56!4 

)'.+2."A+"),'

,"("$):?!4 )$";('")&"0 "'21 ,-" %

(),(##  ,-" $) ,-" <$(), %  #$ &$/%$/(." ,-"

'<$+)/"), 0 . .$+*-, ) :?!4  )"' ,(

 &$+, / '" (, &  ,$

(),(## ,-

"

'1 .+##(&("), $%%$,+)(,(". #$ &$/%$/(." - ;" 2"") ;

"' )' ,-" / ,," %", ()"' ,$ ,-" 1"

 !446 &&$'()*

., $%%$,+)(,10 .* ),"',$ '";('")&"$)!!>!4  : * ()$)!!>!4 )$";('")&"$#,-"%

(),(## .%"."),-$+*-$).

(''

," ..$+*-,

 $) ,-" *$+)' ,- , &$+)."

 #$ %

(),(## 0 . -(. /$,-" 0 . () -$.%(,

 -$0";" ,- , &$+ ' - ;" 2"") *")+()"*$+)'#$)$)B"8 /() ,($)$#0(,)"..".- ',-"1 2"") %"."), "+.

 $# ,-" =(/()( $'" '

,"' !!>!4  ";"

.,- ,)$ @0 .%"."),";")$),- ,'

," ',-"

@. 2"") %"."), (, &$+ ' - ;" 2"") %".+/"' ,-

(),(##0 .."($+.,$ '";('")&"2+,'+",$ 2.")&"$# -(.&$+)."

,-"";('")&"&$+ ')$,2" "'$0";" )"' ,(

&$+, * ()* ),"'$)"/$"

.,$%%$,+)(,1,$ ";('")&" $) 47!4  +, $) 47!4  '<$+)/"), 0 .$+*-, #$ %

(),(## $) ,-" *$+)' ,- , ,-" 2("# $# ,-"

(),(##- .2""), 3") 121/(., 3"21.$/"2$'1,(. %",()"),,$/"),($)-"",- ,";")$) 47!4 )$ @0 %"."), ;") (# ,-" 2("# $# ,-" &$+)."  0 . , 3") 21 .$/"2$'1'+",$/(., 3"";"),-"),-"%"."),$#0(,)"..". &$+ ' - ;" 2"") *$, / 3"' ,$ .-$0 ,- , %

(),(## 0 .()&"",$ '";('")&" &&$'()* 1$).

(''

,")$#+,-"

.* ),"' )'(/%+*)"'<+'*/"),% .."' '(./(..()*,-".+(, 6

$/ ,-" '(.&+..($) / '" 2$;" ., $)"

.%"&,(.& ,- ,(*-,#$/,-"2"*())()*("().,(,+,($) $#,-".+(,%

(),(##0 .)$,(),"".,"',$, 3"(,,$(,. $*(&

")',(.., )*",- ,,-$+*-$+,")'"

;$$#2$,-,-".('". .,$.""3 '<$+)/"),.(),-"*+(."$#&$/%$/(." .(# .$/" #(")'

1 / ,&- 0 . *$()* $) 2",0"") ,-"/ /"),($)"'()% )$ !#$,-""1"

. '<$+)/"),.0""

 , 3") ,$ &$/%$/(." ,-" / ,,"  ' ,-" %

(),(## 2"") ."($+.(,.-$+ '- ;"2$+*-,,-"";('")&"(#)$, ,,-"#(.,

;

" $%%$,+)(,1 ,-") '"#()(,"

1 $) ,-" .+2."A+"), $&& .($).0-"),-"& ."0 '<$+)"' ($,$& $.()*$# ";('")&"21&$+,$'",0$

.,$%%$,+)(,(".0""* ),"' ,$ %

(),(## ,$ &$)& +'" (,. ";('")&" . '(.&+.."' "

("

(),(##'(')$, )1";('")&"'".%(,"(,0 .& +,($)"' 21* ),()*

.,$%%$,+)(,10(,-&$.,.";" )10(,)".. $# ,-" %

(),(## & /" %"."), $) >9!4  :!4  !!>!4  )' 47!4  $"$;" )";" )1 (., $# 0(,)"..".,$2""8 /()"'0 .#+)(.-"'21,-"%

(),(##C => 0!.#!   !## ##0 5!#  ! &*

 5   *3 #. # 6*6 0 2,    * 0&,#,5 ,?!,0 !6' , 0!#* ;,# 5 !4* 2,  . ! ,   2 6 & *3 "0 *#  , * # ! &*

 ,*  # #   3! 6   ##  !5 ! *, ##'232!!;,#5#!# ##3 ! ## # ,

# #.  3 .#* **6*3 ='  !#50   2'0!&*

*.*5 #!& !,&#&#323 53 '#& *#!,!&*,* *32  ,&     23 !   0   !# # ! , * 23 ! &*

 *. 6 * 23 &##&  # '# &  5 5!**3 . '

 ?!,0 @,  *50.,!* 3,2 *@,  *50 # #  #  ?! &&* 2 6 '   .#  # 6*3.

  8 +)

( +'*" $!!#&" 6#  A= $!!#&#2*