High Court of Punjab and HaryanaCRM-M/39419/2025allowed

Gulshan @ Tania v. State Of Punjab

2025-09-08Mr. Justice Sumeet Goel6 pages

% &' 3%2"

"& * % &' 3%2"

"& * #%1$%9)%+ 0 #%1$%9)%+ 0 #%1$%9)%+ 0 #%1$%9)%+ 0

$% $% $% $%

! "

D5%$"$"& %+ 6%+

#$$% &' ( D5% 1& 3% $ * * * * +% % $* +% % $* +% % $* +% % $* <, 5 # # <, 5 # # <, 5 # # <, 5 # # , , , , 3 =/ 36&2$% '

+5 # 3%%1 #" "/ 36&2$% '&+ '&+ % 1%$"$"& %+5 +5 (" 3%+ #" - #+/ 33"$"&

()5 >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> >>>>> , , , ,/ 5 7,8 / 5 7,8 / 5 7,8 / 5 7,8 # # # # +% % $ 1%$"$"&

)%% '"

3%+ #%2$"& &' +$"4

-+". #+ .

# "$/ 7'&+

&+$ ?

##<8 '&+ -+ $ &' +%- $& + " 2 % )%+" - &50 3$ $%3 0C50A5 / +%-"

$%+%3 '&+ $ &''% 2% 1

% 3%+ #%2$"&

0@ A@

: &' $ +2&$"2 +- &$+&1"2 #) $ 2% 2$/ : 7'&+

&+$ $ ?

# 2$<8/ $ & "2% #$$"& "$4 (1+/ / "

$+"2$ $"

/ ()5

% -+69% &' $ % " B% $"& "

% 1%$"$"& %+ "

22 %3 &' )% %" - " 6& 6%3 " 1%+$" " - $& # 2$ " 6& 6" - : .- # '

%- -%3 4 +%2&6%+%3 '+&9 $ % 1%$"$"& % %+ 3 %+ 2&22 %35 5 ,%+ %3 2& '&+ $

"$%+$%3 $ % 1%$"$"& %+ "

" 2 $&34 " 2% 0C50A5 5 ,%+ %3 2&

'&+ $

'+$

)9"$$%3 $

% 9 3$&+4 1+&6"

&' $ # 2$ 6% &$

2+1 &

4 )%% 2&91 "%3 ="$ / 3 $ / $ % 1+& %2$"& 2 ''%+ '+&9 %+% $ 3%'%2$ 5 ,%+ %3 2& '&+ $

"$%+$%3 $

3% 4%3 3 $ ")"

"$4 $ %+%&' 2 &$ )% '

$% %3 1& $ % 1%$"$"& %+5 ,%+ %3 2&

'+$ %+ "$%+$%3 $

''%+%3 " 2+2%+$"& '&+ 9&+% $ 0 4%+5 / +%- 1+4%3 '&+5 5 ,%+ %3 #$$% 2&

&11& %3 $ % 1+% % $ 1%$"$"& )4 +-" -

%-$"& +"

%3 -"

% 1%$"$"& %+ +% %+"& " $+% 3/ $

% 3&% &$ 3% %+6% $ % 2& 2%

"& &' $ % +%- 5 ,%+ %3 #$$% 2&

'+$ )9"$$%3 $ % "

$ $ )"

% "

)++%3 )4 $ % +"-&+ &' #%2$"& C &' $ # 2$/ 3 $ / $ 9% &- $ $& )% 3"

%35 ,%+ %3 #$$% 2&

%%.

$& 1 2% & +%2&+3 2 $&34 2%+$"'"2$% 3$%3 0C505 : " &+$/ $.% & +%2&+35 :5

%+3 2& '&+ $ % +"6 1+$"% 6% -& % $ +&-

% 6"

% +%2&+3 A5 % 1%$"$"& %+ = ++% $%3 & 0C50A5 = %+%" '$%+ " 6% $"-$"& = 2++"%3 &$ 3 2

1+% % $%3 & 0:50 5 &$

1+& %2$"& ="$ %

6% )%% 2"$%3/ 3 0

)%% 1+$ 4 %E9" %3 $"

3$%5 % +"6 2& $% $"& +"

%3 $ + -"6% +"

% $& 3%)$) % "

% / =

)% +$"&2" $%3 1& 3+" - $ % 2&+ % &' $+"

5 &+$ 3&% &$ 3%%9 "$ 11+&1+"$% $& 3% 6% 3%%1 " $& $ % +"6 2& $% $"& / $ $

$-%/ $ "$ 94 1+%(3"2% $ " - $ -")

)%% )+&- $ '&+=+3 $& " 3"2$% $

".% &&3 &' $ % 1%$"$"& %+ ) 2& 3" - '+&9 $ % 1+&2%

&' ( $"2% &+ " $%+'%+" - % 1+& %2$"& %6"3% 2%5 A55 1%+

% F"9 " &+3%+

%3 )4 $ &+$/ )+&- '&+$ )4 $ % 1%$"$"& %+/ " 3"2$% " 3%%3 1+&2+ $" $" - 3 '&

%+%&' 2 &$ )% %3 1& $ % 1%$"$"& %+5 1%+ 2 $&34 2%+$"'"2$% 3$%3 0C505 : '"

%3 )4 $ %+ %3 #$$% 2& / $

+%34

''%+%3 " 2+2%+$"& '&+ 1%+"&3 &' 0 4%+/ 0 9& $

A 34 ; "

&= $& )% " 6& 6%3 " 4 &$ %+ 7 6"%= &' $ % 9$$%+/ $ % +"-&+ "91& %3 3%+ #%2$"& C &' $ # 2$ $ 3 3"

$%3 "

"- $ &' $ % +$"2

&' $ % & $"$$"& &'

3"5 A5 &+$ " (3-9% $ $"$ G =" 3%+ 6%+ #$$% &'

G =" 3%+ 6%+ #$$% &'

() () () () 1

%3 " A0C A0C A0C A0C

7 :**00 A:8H '$%+ +% 4" - 1& $ % +$"& 3%2"3% 3" &' $ % (3-9% $ &' $ % & <) % #1+%9% &+$ "

" + G $&& 6 5 &9% #%245/ #$$% &' "

+ 7 08 # H )3

% 9 $ 4 6 5#5 4. 7 8 #

:H 6%3 )" # ".

5 #$$% &'

$+ 3 &$ %+/ 78 7+"9"

8 H &

"9 !

" 6 5 #$$% 7 &' %

"8 +%1&+$%3

# H +"9"

11%

&5 :@ 0 3$%3 0C50 0 $"$ I "$$ "

5 % #$$% &' J% $ % - KH I "$"

3 ".+4 ! 1 6 5 #$$% &' J% $ % - K/ #1%2"

,%6% $& 11% 7+ &5::0

3$%3

$"$ I& 993 # 9 "' # ".

5 % #$$% &'

(+$KH +"9"

11%

&5A &'

3$%3 0:50

$"$ &1

G+"

$+ ! &1 + 9 6 5 "& &'

3"/ 3 .+ 3 +4 6 #$$% &' 3 4 +3%

78 7+"9"

8 C

3/ $ * IC5 % +"- $ $& 1%%34 3 %E1%3"$"& &$ & 6"$

'%-+3 $& 1+%6% $ 3% 3 &11+%

"6% " 2+2%+$"& H $& 9"$"-$% E"%$4 3 2& 2%+ 22&91 4" - $ $"& =%

$& 2+$"

"91"+9% $ " $ % )"

"$4 &' 22 %3 $& 3%'% 3 "9 '/ )$ $ %+% "

&6%++2 " - &2"%$ " $%+% $ 16" - =4 '&+ 1%%34 $+"

)%% +%1%$%3 4 2$$%3 " $ % +%2% $ 1 $ 3 $ % +$"& 3%2"3% 3" &' $ )&6%+%'%++%3 $& #1+%9% &+$< (3-9% $

"3 3&= %+"% 3%2"

&1% " - 1 %= 6"

&' ' 39% $ 5 % 2& 2%1$ &'

1%%34 $+"

-9$%3 " $& $ % +$"2

% $"

1+$ &' $ $ $& "'% 3 ")%+$4/ -+ $%%3 3 1+% %+6%3 3%+ &+

& $"$$"& 5 % +"- $ $& 1%%34 $+"

)%-"

% 2$ +% $+" $ "91& %3 $ $ % $"9% &' $ % ++% $ &' $ % 22 %3 3 2& %B% $ " 2+2%+$"& = 2& $" %

$-% / 9% 4/ $ $-% &'

" 6% $"-$"& / " B"+4/ $+"

/ 11% 3 +%6"

& $ $ 4 1&

") 1+%(3"2% $ $ 94 +% $ 3% $& "91%+9"

") % 3 6&"3) % 3% " 2% % $"9% &' $ % 2&99"

"& &' $ % &''% 2% $"

% 2+"9"

1+&2%%3" -

2& 99$% " $& '"

"$4/ 2& 3 )% 6%+$%35 1%%34 $+"

/ %+

%+" - 3 B"2. 3"

+% " % B & &' 2+"9"

(+"

1+3% 2%5 &6%+2+&=3%3 &+$3&2.%$ / $ %64 6& 9% &' =&+. 3 $ % +% $ $ 1+%

+% & $ % 1+& %2$"& 3 $ % & "2%/ " 3)"$) 4 .%%1 % % $"+% 2+"9"

(+"

1+3% $"

9%2 9 3%+ $+%

$+" 5 &=%6%+/ $

2 &$ )% %E2 % '&+ .%%1" - $ =&+3 &' 9&2

-" - & $ 22 %3 '&+ " 3%'" "$% 1%+"&3 &' $"9%5 $ 3&% %+6% 4 2+%3"$ $& $ 2+"9"

( $"2% $%9/ +$ %+ "$ 9.% '&+ $$% &' ''"+ 5 -+ $%% &'

1%%34 $+"

" $% 3%3 $& 6&"3 &11+%

"& 3 1+%6% $ 3% 4 )4 "91& " - & $ % &+$ 3 $ % 1+& %2$"& &) "-$"& $& 1+&2%%3 ="$ +% & ) % 3"

1$2 5 % -+ $%% %+6%

+%%'& 3 1+1& %5 "+ 4/ "$ 1+&$%2$ %3 -"

$ &11+%

"6% 1+% "91+"

& 9% $H %2& 3 4/ "$ +% "%6% % 22 %3 &' $ % E"%$4 3 1) 1"2"& 3% $& +% 6%3 2+"9"

+-%

4/ "$ 1+&$%2$

% +"

. $ $ %6"3% 2% ="

)% $ &+ 9%9&+"% 3"99%3 )4 $

-% &' $"9%/ $ / "91"+" - $ % )"

"$4 &' $ % 22 %3 $& 3%'% 3

"9 '5 $ -&% &$ 4" - $ % 2& %B% 2% &' 1+%$+"

3%$% $"& +% -+6%5 22 %3/ 1+% 9%3 " &2% $/ $"

1+&6% &$ %+="

%/ +%

)(%2$%3 $& 1 &-"2 3 1 3%1+"6$"& &' ("

"'%/

3%+ & %+& 2& 3"$"& 5 B

4 "91&+$ $/ $ % )+3% &' 3%$% $"& &'

2 22 %3 '+%B% $ 4 '

%6"

4 & $ % " &2% $ 9%9)%+

'9"

%+% "

4%$ &$ 1%2$ &' $ % 9$$%+ = 3% %+6%

2& "3%+$"& $ $

$-%5

%-$"& " $ % 1+% % $ 2 % +% $% $& 22 %3 )%" - " 6& 6%3 " +% $" - $& 2&99%+2"

B $"$4 &'

2& $+) 3 3%+ $ # 2$/ :5 J % 2& "3%+" - )"

1%$"$"& " 2 % " 6& 6" - 2&99%+2"

B $"$4/ $ % &+$

$& .%%1 " 9" 3 $ +"-&+ % 9%+$%3 3%+ #%2$"& C &'

# 2$/ : = 9 3$%

$ &+$ 2 -+ $ )"

$& 22 %3 & 4 '$%+ %+" - $ % 1) 1+& %2$&+ 3 '$%+ 6" - $"

'"%3 "$ ' &' $=" 2& 3"$"& +% +% & ) % -+& 3 '&+ )% "%6" - $ % 22 %3 "

&$ -"

$4 &' $ &''% 2% 2 +-%3@

%-%3 3 $ $/ % "

".% 4 $& 2&99"$ 4 &''% 2% % & )"

5 $+" -% $ +"-&+ &' #%2$"& C &' $ # 2$/ 9 $ )% 9%$"2 &

2+$" "F%3 -"

% )2.3+&1 &' 22 %3<

$ $& 1%%34 $+"

5 % +"- $ $& "'% 3 1%+

")%+$4 2 &$ )% +% 3%+%3 -$&+4 )4 =++ $%3 3% " $ % (3"2"

1+&2%

1+$"2 4 = %+% 2 3% 8 "

%"$ %+ $$+")$) % $& $ %3 &+ ( $"'"%3 $ $ % % 3 &' $ % 1+& %2$"& )4 2&-% $ +% 5 " 3"6"3

2 &$ )% .%1$ )% " 3 )+ '&+ " &+3" $% 1%+"&3 &' $"9% )4 $." - +%'-% " +"-&+

"3 3&= " #%2$"& C &' $ # 2$/ :5

%-"

$+% " "$ ="

3&9/ " &+3%+ $& % +% 1%%34 3 $"9% 4 3"

3%+ $ % 2$/

1+&6"3%3 '&+ $ % 2& $"$$"& &'

1%2"

&+$

3%+ #%2$"& A &' $ % 2$5 &=%6%+/ $ &+$ 2 &$ $+

& <

%4% $& $ % 1+&$+2$%3 3% $%9$"2 " %''"2"% 24 $ $ '+ $+$% $

%-"

$"6% 1+1& %5 &+$ &'

= "

3$4)& 3 $& % +% $ $ "$ 3&%

&$ )%2&9% 2&91 "2"$ " 6"& $"& &' " 3"6"3 < &$="$

$ 3" - 4$ " - 2& $" %3 "

$$$%5 J % 3% " - ="$ )"

1%$"$"& " 2 % -&6%+ %3 )4 $ % +"-&+ &' #%2$"& C &' $ # 2$/ :/ $ % &+$ 9 $+".% (3"2"& 2% )%$=%% $ %-"

$"6%

" $% $ $& 2+) $ % 9% 2% &' 3+- 3 $ 2+& 2$ +"- $ &' $ $& '"+ 3 %E1%3"$"& 5 +& & -%3 " 2+2%+$"& / ="$ &$ ( $"'") 2 %/ +"

$+ '&+9" - 1+%$+"

3%$% $"& " $& 1 "$"6% "91+"

& 9% $/ &$2&9% $"$ %$"2 $& $ % 1+" 2"1 % &' ( $"2% 3 %B"$45 +-&/ $ % %B"6&2 " '%+% 2% "

$ = %+% $

%3 $& 2& 2 3% ="$ " +% & ) % $"9%/ +% $" - " 1+& & -%3 " 2+2%+$"& / "$ 9"

"$$% -"

% 1+%2"& "'% ")%+$4 -+ $%3 3%+ $ = 3/

2 / 2& 3"$"&

")%+$4 &6%++"3" - $ $$$&+4 %9)+-& 2+%$%3 3%+ #%2$"& C &' $ # 2$/ : &- $ $& )% 2& "3%+%3 1%+ '2$ &' -"6% 2 =&+3 / -+ $ &' )"

" 2 % 1%+$" " - $& 2&99%+2"

B $"$4/ & $ -+& 3 &' 3% 3% 4 " $+"

/ 2 &$ )% "3 $& )% '%$$%+%3 )4 #%2$"& C # 2$/ :5K #''"2% $& 4/ '+$ %+ 3%$% $"& &' $ 3%+$+"

&$ =++ $%3 " $ % '2$ 3 2"+29 $ 2% C5

6"%= &' )&6%/ $ % 1+% % $ 1%$"$"& "

&=%35 %$"$"& %+ "

&+3%+%3 $& )% +% %3 & +%- %+ '+ "

" - )"

@ +%$4 )& 3 $& $

'2$"& &' $ % ,35 2& 2%+ %3 $+"

&+$@$4 -"

$+$%5 &=%6%+/ "

33"$"& $& 2& 3"$"& $ 94 )% "91& %3 )4 $ % 2& 2%+ %3 $+"

&+$@$4 -"

$+$%/ $

+%9" )& 3 )4 $ % '&

&=" - 2& 3"$"& * 7"8

&$ 9"

% $ ")%+$4 -+ $%35 7""8

&$ $91%+ ="$ 4 %6"3% 2%/ &+ &+ 3&29% $+4/ 3+" - $ 7"""8

&$ ) % $ ' & 4 3$% )%'&+% 7"68

&$ 2&99"$ 4 &''% 2% = % & )"

3%1& "$ %+ 1

1&+$/ "' 4/ ="$ &+$5 76"8

-"6% %+ 2%

& % 9)%+ $& $

$"-$" - ''"2%+@# &' 2& 2%+ %3 & "2% #$$"& 3

&$ 2 -% %+ 2%

1 & % 9)%+ ="$ &$ 1+"&+ 1%+9"

"& &' $ &+$@

B -"

$+$%5 76""8

&$ " 4 9 %+ $+4 $& 3% 4 $ 76"""8

)9"$/ & $ % '"+ $ =&+." - 34 &'

%6%+4 9& $ / ''"36"$/ )%'&+% $ % 2& 2%+ %3 $+"

&+$/ $& $ % %''%2$ $

&$ )%% " 6& 6%3 " 2&99"

&' 4 &''% 2% '$%+ )%" - +% %3 & )"

%/ $ 1%$"$"& %+ "

'& 3 $& )% " 6& 6%3 " 4 &''% 2% '$%+ )%" - % +-%3 & )"

" $ % 1+% % $ / & $ % )

%+ ''"36"$ &+ &$ %+="

%/ $ % #$$% "

9 3$%3 $& 9&6%/ '&+$ / '&+ 2 2%

$"& &'

%+ )"

%/ )$ &'

2&+ %/

)% +$"&2" $%3 1& 9%+"$ %+%&'5

% &' )+%2 &' 4 &' $ % '&+% "3 2& 3"$"& 3 $ 94 )% "91& %3 )4 2& 2%+ %3 $+"

&+$@$4 -"

$+$% 3"+%2$%3

%+%" )&6% &+ 1&

&=" - 4 &$ ''"2"% $ 2 %/ $ % #$$%@2&91 " $

)% $ ")%+$4 $& 9&6% 2 2%

$"& &' )"

% 1%$"$"& %+5 5 +3%+%3 22&+3" - 05

" - "3 %+%" )&6%

)% 2& $+%3 %E1+%

"& &'

&1" "& & $ % 9%+"$ 5 #" 2% $ % 9" 2

)%% 3%2"3%3/ 1% 3" - 9"

"2$"& / "' 4/

$ 3 3"

1& %3 &''5 7# , # , # , # ,8 #%1$%9)%+ 0 #%1$%9)%+ 0 #%1$%9)%+ 0 #%1$%9)%+ 0

6"+ J %$ 1%." -@+% & %3* % @ J %$ %+ +%1&+$) %* % @