High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/929/2016disposed of

The Medical Superintendent-Cum-Chairman And Others v. Hira Singh And Other

2018-07-17Mr. Justice Rajesh Bindal,Mr. Justice Amit Rawal5 pages

! " #$% & '& & !() *&''+ , !-.#/)01 2' '3 +*# 4.5'% !&'!3'!&6+.762* %7*!0 4'#'+& ! 77 &&''0 42% .%.'8*2*3.%,5 &*#%.507% &,*% &2'%, 55'##*!&, 9'%,., %*4 !82 *!&2'% ',5!3'!&,

!"# $%&'( #

$#& "( ) !"# $%&'( # ('

* +++

%','!&-

%*872*!2.77*!00 .!:*;0 %&2'*55'##*!&, !*##&2%''*55'*#,

%4*,<*#03"+*&'0 %%',5!3'!& !*##&2%''*55'*#, =====

* ,$ '#*/*55# +*& !,

% &2' %'*,!, 7'!& !'3 ! &2' *55# +*& !,0 <2 +2 *%' ,.55%&'3;/* 3*" &,03'#*/ ! # !8&2'*55'*#, ,+!3!'3 ,,&*!33 ,5,'3 ,0(*!3( / &2 , %3'%0 <' ,2*## 3 ,5,' '&&'%, *&'!& 55'*#, 0(*!3(*% , !8.&*3:.3 +*& !&2%''<% & 5'& & !," 3'+77!%3'%3*&'35*,,'3;/&2'#'*%!'34 !8#' '!+20<2'%';/&2'*<*%3&2' %', 3 !8 +'%0!3.,&% *#% ;.!*#0 7% &,*% %,2%&>&2'% ;.!*#>%' !,&*& !8&2'<%?7'!< &2@;*+? <*8',02*,;''!.52'#3 55'##*!&6 '3 +*# 4.5'% !&'!3'!&6+.762* %7*!0 4'#'+& !

77 &&'' 2*3 *,,* #'3 &2'%3'% &2'#'*%!'3 4 !8#''!+2 ! &2' 5%'7 ,'&2*&&2%''<%?7'!0" 3'*55 !&7'!&#'&&'%3*&'3(0<'%' *55 !&'3!&2'5,&#*,,69!+!&%*+&;*, ,%(A3*/,< &2&2'

% !+ 5*#0 .!:*;"&'!&*###'8'*!3,5 &*#07% &,*%!5.%,.*!+' &&2'*%'7'!& !'3*55 !&7'!&#'&&'%0&2'<%?7'!0" 3'!!'B.%' 6A0 ,.;7 &&'3&2' %* 3*" &,&&2'''+&&2*&&2'/,2*##*; 3';/&2'&'%7,*!3 +!3 & !,&2'*55 !&7'!&#'&&'%2',&*&' +'%0 .!:*;"&'!&*# ##'8'*!3 ,5 &*# !& 7*&'3 &2' % !+ 5*#&2',* 3,5 &*#" 3'

!!'B.%' 6C&2*&&2'5% "*&'%',5!3'!&,6<%?7'!%'7* !'3*;,'!&%7 &2' %3.&/!%7'!3'3&2' %<*/,03',5 &'%'5'*&'3<*%! !8,2' %,'%" +', <'%'&'%7 !*&'3*&'%&2'+!+#., !&2'+!&%*+&*!30&2.,0<%?7'! +.#3 !& %* ,' 3'7*!3 *##'8 !8 !!6+75# *!+' &2' 5%" , !, 4'+& !C6 &2'!3.,&% *# ,5.&',+&0A) %,2%&0&2'+&2'

% ;.!*#*!3&2'#'*%!'34 !8#''!+202*"''%%'3 !!&!& + !8&2'&'%7, *!3+!3 & !,&2'*55 !&7'!&#'&&'%2'<%?7'!* #'3&5%"'! %'+%3&2*&&2':;<*,5'%7*!'!&%&;'%'8.#*% D'3*&'%&2%''/'*%, ,'%" +' *!30 &2.,0 .%8'3 &2 , .%& % ,'&& !86*, 3' &2' %3'% .!3'% +2*##'!8'

'% +!&%*0 %4*,<*#0 #'*%!'3 +.!,'# %'5%','!& !8 %',5!3'!& !*##*55'*#,3''!3'3&2'*<*%3&2'% ;.!*#*!3&2' %3'%&2'#'*%!'34 !8#''!+2!&2'5%'7 ,'0&2*&&2'+!&'!&,&2' *55 !&7'!&#'&&'%5%"'3&2*&&2'5%" , !,4'+& !C6 &2'+& <'%';#*&*!&#/" #*&'3*,&2'<%?7'!2*35.& !7%'&2*!A3*/, !* +*#'!3*%/'*%2'3'5*%&7'!&+.#3!&%'&%'!+2&2' %,'%" +',*8* !,&&2' 5%" , !,&2'+&&<*,5%"'3!%'+%3&2*&&2'%5,&,2<? 3*% <'%'#/ !8"*+*!&*!3%'7* !'3.! ##'32'+!3.+&&2'<%?7'!2*3

!&;''!5%"'3!%'+%3*!30&2'%'%'0.%8'3%3 ,7 ,,*#&2'*55'*#, ;/* %7 !8&2'%3'%.!3'%+2*##'!8' $'2*"'2'*%3&2'#'*%!'3+.!,'#%&2'5*%& ',0*55%* ,'3&2' 5*5'% ;? *!3 *%' &2' " '< &2*& &2'%' , %+' *!3 7'% & ! &2' ,.;7 ,, !,&2'#'*%!'3+.!,'#%&2'*55'##*!&, , 5'% &2' *55 !&7'!& #'&&'% !!'B.%' 6(0 5% "*&'

%',5!3'!&,<'%'*55 !&'3!+!&%*+&;*, ,*&&2',*#*%/ (E6

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

%&!%2*"';''! 3'+#*%'3*++.,'3;/*!/+.%& C 2*&;'#!8& *D; 4 ?2+*,&'<2 +22*,;''!3'+#*%'3 *,4+2'3.#'3+*,&';/&2'"'%!7'!& .!:*; 2*&,2*##;'# *;#'*!32!',&&<*%3,&2'!,& &.& ! !3 * ) 2*&*7*8%''< &2*##+!3 & !,7'!& !'3 !&2 ,#'&&'%G !5'%.,*#&2'*%'7'!& !'3+!&'!&,0 & ,'" 3'!

<%?7'!<'%'*55 !&'3!+!&%*+&;*, ,!#.75,.7,*#*%/(E6 5'%7!&2&2'%;'!' &,<'%''B&'!3'3&&2'<%?7'!*!30&2'%'%'0 &2'/+.#3!&+#* 7&2';'!' &5%" , !,4'+& !C6 &2'+&!

'B5 %/&2' %+!&%*+&5'% 3 %" , !,4'+& ! ;;&2'+& '!" ,*8'&2*&&2'&'%7 !*& !*,*%',.#&&2'!!6%'!'<*#&2'+!&%*+& '75#/7'!&;'&<''!&2''75#/'%*!3&2'<%?7*!*&'%&2''B5 %/ &2'+!&%*+&+*!!&;'&'%7'3*,*%'&%'!+27'!& %&2',*?';%'" &/0 #*.,', ;;4'+& !&2'+&%'*3*,.!3'%-6 F)/ // 0!&2 ,+&0.!#',,&2'%' ,*!/&2 !8%'5.8!*!& !&2',.;:'+&%+!&'B&6 BBB BBB BBB

F%'&%'!+27'!&G7'*!,&2'&'%7 !*& !;/&2''75#/'% &2','%" +'*<%?7*!%*!/%'*,!<2*&,'"'%0&2'%< ,' &2*!*,*5.! ,27'!& !# +&'3;/<*/3 ,+ 5# !*%/*+& !0 ;.&3',!& !+#.3'6 BBB BBB BBB

;;

&'%7 !*& !&2','%" +'&2'<%?7*!*,*%',.#& &2'!!6%'!'<*#&2'+!&%*+&'75#/7'!&;'&<''!&2' '75#/'%*!3&2'<%?7*!+!+'%!'3! &,'B5 %/%,.+2 +!&%*+&;' !8&'%7 !*&'3.!3'%*,& 5.#*& ! !&2*&;'2*# +!&* !'3&2'%' !H%G 2'*%'7'!& !'3*,5'+&2*,!&;''!#?'3 !&;/&2' #'*%!'34 !8#''!+2<2 #'* %7 !8&2' !3 !8,&2'% ;.!*#0&2.,0 &2'%' ,'%%%*!3 ##'8*# &/ 9*+*!+/(5,&,2<? 3*%+*!!&;'*8%.!3% %':'+& !8&2' %+#* 7!&%*+&.*#'75#/'',+*!!&;''I.*&'3< &2&2'

5'%7*!'!&'75#/'',%*<%?7*!05*%& +.#*%#/ !*, &.*& !<2'%'&2' % <%?*!3+!3.+&2*,;''!.!3&;'.!,*& ,*+&%/

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

$#& "( ) ('

* $%)2# $%)2# $3 45,6 78 *88 9/ :; < =;

*88 > =;