High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/942/2016dismissed

Jaideep Dhillon v. State Of Punjab And ORS.

2016-05-31Mr. Justice Ramendra Jain,Mr. Justice Jitendra Chauhan13 pages

!"## !!## $%& ' & () "% *! !"#$ %&'()!*+,-.) "/)+0-%1"( %&'()!*+,-.)"!-%1)!2-%302-10* % %+"#'"%,-$- %"!!##

"/)+0-%1"(4 ."%% #% ' /# &/, /"0%!

#)1"!!## ") ,!&/ )1 # /"!% 2 %3&% !!# ."#, "0%! 0 %/% #%1 %" !% %, 4

."#, "!!## 0%( )1"!%, )1! /"%%

- " #/# /%$)1", %% )1"5&% %!# "% -$%%

! 56 4

%"% /#% & # %"!!## - &%$0" !!# %$ ) , ." 0% ! " %/"#1 )

, & #"0## ,% ."!!## 0/% !%, !&%&"" %, 78# 7 $%1- 9"&$ "0%- %- $ ,,&

-&)(" ""

#&1 ",!#1

0## )

&"&1"!!## "!%

#$ %"!% %, 4

#&0%

"##/",8#% $%% /, -" - 0% /") ,,)1"&"%1 1",#%1 %" !% :& ;$ %/%#1 #" % -"&/"" #, %!1, #%1 %"!% %, 4

- "0$%- %0%! 0 # "5&% "1%

)1 # / 56 4

% "#,%/% /#%1, "#/#

."0%! # 0 #,% " "%1% %<!%1 "!% %0"""#%10#, )1"!!## -0""

)) & /& 2 0"% %"",! &"%1!"%%

- 0""0,!&/ "0%! :& -0""0, )1"#% ' /# &/$%%

." & %/% / #1 $8 / <%3% %1 (&% 0 %)1= >)#"'&!%,5&% 7 # /, "%$ 0 ' /" "%-

'55 2 0 0""% ,!#1%"&""10% #)#)%%"/ ?1%)&"&#)!%, & %$##"1 "/ 1%."10%## %$0"

"0%! 0% #."0%! 0%&#,#1##0 # /%# &! "(&/, -, ",!#1-0"#%1 %%- #0%! #, /,) ."0%! 0%##0)1"=/"5&% %, %#%(&/, ." (&/, " =/"5&%0,!&/ ) %= >)#"'&!%,

5&%-0"% 0"#% %% /%#%(&/, = >)#"'&!%, 5&% *&!, $7 2 - ? '55 @ '

A% 8$'A%11- '55 4@ /"#$'

=%1 - 4'55 ? B$% , 69 /#$.%& A *1-

'55 4-0! ""!% 0"!!%"" &%)#/!# /%# &! %%! ,"% %#%- ) "% %1%# & #"*#$ !%/%!""% %<%)#0

C' %"!% !#& % -"")

#)1"&%."% %-"% :&%%#$%" #/#!%! 9&" #1:& /% %# &""%!% 0"0% $/# 08&!

"## /"%%%, !",)& # 0%! %"(&/, "&% =%0 % A&,% $ 5" ;

/ %- A%,8-

'55

6""%"1% #,%# % D."% %- %&:& "% % % 0""%" ,!#10" 08&!"## /"%%%, !",-##"%!3%%, ) - &"!% )/$ "%# "#/" " &):& #$%)1"&%D .":& #"") <, )1" &% % #" #1")

% ) ,!% % <% " % %1%# & %%#

"5 & 6"

!% 0" $/# "%/" :&0"

"& - "0%! )"% %&!#

1% "/%& ",%# "&#)/% ", 0/% !% ,#%#1&0"0$/# )& "%/" "## /"%%, 0""0) , / " / ? 1% "% " )

&!!#& 0""") ! &")&0%

! 0% #)1",!#1 "/,) %"% %%, 0"% "%%%, 0,0"%)0

.00%! 0% #0"%

%# %, %% 0 ! ."1 0% /% %,%%."% %! 0%! ##0

0"",!#10"%% "1%

-08&! #0%!

,&" %"%%%, 6""%&"!% "&#) /% ",%# % D <<<<<<

."% %- ")#/ ,#%%# )/$ "!% 0""$ !!%""&% "0##&

%#1$%)&% "/, "/, 0##,!##1##!0""#)#1 !1, " !% %, 01%>#%1 %)

! "% :& #) ."% %-0% # /% 1%# "!% 0""$!!%" "&% %"%%%, #1"!% 0""$

#"0%! 0" "10% %$%0""$ ) %, %% % "% %%, - " !% "&# ) ##0 ) "%E F

'#*3*## /##$' A%# "%-

4 '554 0##-,&0 % ##0 /" %#%(&/, 7 #/,>&!%-0! & % .") (&/, < &,##16"#/% /%# 0%! -"=/"

5&% # %" & ) / "

#& /" & "! %2 /-" 5&% # 8 % " 0""%"0%! %"" $%",% " 08&! %" "&%2 & " "!!## !!%""5&% %# /#1-", ,1 #",) % %1%# E

% (&/, ' 7% "# "%$'% '"$5"% ' /"9" % "%-

'* -= >)#" '&!%,5&%-0"# % /"&%/% /#1 #" % %% / %#% (&/, " &- ! " %! %!% ,0## 8!"&#$#% &H!&

)/%$$$ &"%!% ""% ) )1"&"%1%/)1/ /% %," &%"&%/% /#1 #")0"% % %/ #& 0"% % 1&"%%! #1 #" "!% /$% , %$ ,1!%$",

") 0""") /$ "%%# "5 &

- & " &%-0## )%0##8 0

"#0# $&% "0"%#% $/# ;$ :&#1 ")#,"%/"(& &% <!%1 % )#, ;$ "% !%!%%) % # /"0%! & %%#

"5 & 2 -1"&#) #0" % )# ,'&" %%!%, /(& %"&# %,##1)"## / 0" !% <, "%", 1% &"!%, ."&/" %%&#-"&% #01 % %$ &):& "%-)& %# !% -0" ##0 " / "!! "

!!%""&% !& %0%##, %1& ## ,%- % #1)% & & #" 1 0"#!$%"%/")& &

% ,!#10"#!#8 *!+ 6 8# /&! %,#&,)%"0 #&%-%$) "%# & #"*#$ !%/%!" %,

" %(&/, %<%)#0

6"$ % &)""%! &#"$ "## / " " !%,

%% " (& % ,!#1"%#$ ,."1" %< 1% "(& %,!#1"#"!%, #! %< 1%##%/&#%!%, 8!#."&), " #% & # % " %! " "1 " /$

%!% "%#$ ,)&", ##

%2 % / "0" "%/&#%# 8 !#-"1!"! ##1)&" %1 0, -"% %-"18 8"% " %)& # #1

2#% 1""&

" % % # / " %% 0" " (& % ,!#10!%, ")

03 &/9 "0# /0"" ! %!% "% &)1"&%% %)& # %"%!% ""## /" %( "% %2 " <-"&%"<!% "& C;$%1%!% "B$% , %%# -,1

)%!# ,%*!% %# / ,% 0"" "$ ), # % )%% )1 #, - )%( "/%& # -0"& <, / " ,% " #, 2 %/% %!% & %#"!%, -"%!#1 ,1) #1

%,"",% %

" !%, %

%, " !!%!% !%, *!% 0" ,!# !%&#% ,1 ) %!# )1 8 / %#$ !%&#%."%!#&"%!% -

&% " %"& %%$$#% #,E

! "

# $ %

4 &-"5&%- %% %% /&!%"%&# "0" )#%!% %/%C#E% CE&H!& % - ,!# 0"% )1"&%H%)& #-" &"

) % &% " / %"&

%%$$ /"CE&%,3)%%!&." & #, %#1 #""&#) % 0"% % "%/ #& 0"

% % " 0"" %%! ,!# 0"5&%>% "%&%>% % %!% & 0"& <, / " ,%- % /$ ,!# 0"&"% -0##< "#, -%%"#1 #"

I%," %&"%#%%1#"$

" &% % %)& # % % %

%!% %# /##,%/%$ /$% %"& ."&

%#8!" <',#%#1-,%&),

%!% ",! &"%1 %% ,2 $ %'(

)* + #

, -

$.))

01-"5&%8 " &#! # 0 " 0" %#1 % 0 " %! 3 0%8, "% " %, # ,% ,8 /

%!% &# (& 1)#!!%"

2 2

## '

,, &33 1 1&/- " ) ! " ,8 / %! %!% %1<!# #1." !% !#0%% 2

## 4 +$+,

' % &3/ 1 3&

42 5 6 ,* , #, ##

0130"%3 &/9 " " 5&%%%"!% !# #* 7 &33 / 1 !%)%$" "%! "% !% %%#!$%"%%/"

? !!%""%)& # 4-"10&# /") "%%44

?2 .6 #,3 13-" 5&%- /":&#1#& ")%8 #"!% //% %$) -"%&#"& C # / %!% # 0&# $" !% #, #1%#"%#$ %

% &% #0 %, " :& 0""% " #, , )1 !!# %$ % #1 H% #" " !% /$% , %$ ,1 !%$ ", " ) 0"" " ) /$ "% %# " 5 & 2 0&# - & "

&%-)%0##8 0 "#0#

$&% "0"%#% $/# E

."% ) $#$%" ""#,

!%, ) " ! :&#1 :&)#1- )&"%# ")#,0" % )#, ."!% !#") +,8#* ,,+$#,

& 1

2 6 (

+ )+ '

4'55 4?-"5&%"! ""&/""% !% #, !%$ % # /0%! & % %#

"5 & 2 - 1% %#10% ! "&#) #0" % )#,2 " "%! " #"0%! %$

1% "&%-%#%-8 "#1 #"%#$ % "%%!)1" =/"5&%0"""<%"% %1(&%

% #1- / ,," -0,1% %03 &/9 " '# #( ., 6+ &3 -0"% ") #0 " !% //%$)1 %% !%, /(& %$%" ""&#!!%""&%#0" <, "%

",1% &"!%, 2 ""% !% #, %"5&%<%"%!0% & %%#

%""% $%)0"% "5&%

% % ,% %"!/ % # /" ,- )& 0&# ) & 0 <% % %"5&%% &<%"% <%% %1!0%& %%#

" !% 0" !!%"<!&#1 %"%# 0" )1 ##0" /"!! " !!%"" &%!& %0%##, %1& ## ,%

6%)#&#1 &" "" " %1" ) &%) "!%, #%

!%, ,1)& #."%,1 )& #, "#! )&-!%/ -"%! "#!#8*!+ 6 8# /&! %,"% #&,)% "% 0 #&%- % , % 0""

",)#", #19&&" ", / % )1 # & #0 1 0"#!$% "%/")& &

%0!%$ "%"%)& #

%"=/"5&%"!!%"! !%!% !%!$ !% " ) " (& % 0 !%, - "% %- " %

) " !%, *, /)#$&" &, #" /% /%# %%1###!% !# $ 0&# %,#1%" ! % 6 ,1" "",,1 )!!#)# ## %&, 0"%% /% & , #%/" %

% /9&-##, / /!%, #) #1"&# "$) % )1"%)& # !)1"=/"5&%.%&- #!%, # ) "$) /% )&",#8#1

" '<":&%%/%) /"" < !1 " ! ."!"$ ) 8 % 6" &%/ ) % & )1 " #% & # % "

%! ""1"&#"$) :&##1%0"

"$' /"./9&:&#1")#," %/"(& &% %<!%1 0 %

" /-") "$%1" /,1!)& " ,- %##% 01#$ ,."%,1 ) !%$ !%$ / %#, )&/%$ %# / !%,

)/$ 0# # 1!

%!# 6%'&!!#1 '0%/9% "%$..&%#9)&

'55

?-= >)#"'&!%, 5&%! & %

I%- 0 "## # 0" " #1 2

# 8.

#) ) 5( +

#4"8 &/& 1&-"5&%% %%"!% !#"") )1 '% 9% 8 * # '

+, '

,# 7+ 4 ,9

($ ,)

' -0"" ##0

C0"% #" 5&% ;:&1

%)%%1 % "

# % 6"% 0&# ) !%##1& (&/$%,1-"%)&" !%1"-)1" &- "0"",/" %#1) %/%:&$# 0$% -%0"%)1" & /#""-"&/"!%"! 0$ / "%,1-1!&""%!%1 & 0""

0&# )% )#!#", "%,1 0% %0%)% "% "- #! , #1%,,%#9& $%1 - %/&, / %# - 0"" "%0 0&#)(&- & &! ,%#1-"#1

&% ,& / )% )1 1 &

#, -"$#1 " ,&)% &! !% !# &) ##1 :&)# .0 %&, -#01,!% &"-%-"

# /" "#1 " &% " &% / " %$#-0"",/"

"%!%1 & )# (&% (& 8 /" &%% ""%- %%#"%,1E

, && 0/ 10"## /0"<% !0% "=/"5&%& % %#

"5 & -"5&%)%$"!0% "=/"5&%)<%& %%#

" 5 & - % %1-<%,&)(&& % )#-, %$%12 %"% - !% > #, %%# %,=/"5&%& %%#

"5 & -)/ "'% 1)1#- $ & "##/

% /, "#/# %/"-" %#1! &! & )#,0%"1 & "!% 8 /%# - "&%% &/% " % %1%# &"!% <% &"!0%- 0" "!!%"0"& # " %)#,0%"1 &

2 '

# 6 #(

# 4"8 & 3 "5&%)%$" 0###"!0% "=/"5&%&

!!%!% 0% & % %#

" 5 & % %1 "=/"5&% <% %

% %#1"%1 " # %" :& "#"%/2") &%"%"%

" "% % #1 "!% "! %

# /! &"#1 %#1<!# - "=/"5&%,1# %$ /% %# " <% 0% (&% ;,!" 0 # " !% !# #1 #" / " %% " <%% %1%,1& %"0%(&% )# /#8#1&

& !&)# $ )% / (&

."&-"% #""&# ) #/"#1)%&"0%&%%:&%0/""

<!#

% "!)#1 ",."&% "&#)% , "<% / <%% %1 :&)#(&% & #&%"&1 !%"%/" "J )&,&# &#18!

# #$"!%,%1!% !#"0" //%$ !% -0"&:&% -!!%""&%" 0 #&% % !#&%- " &% 0&# ) & % #/# )#/ %& J0""%"#)#/"&# ) % % 9 -#1, "01

:&12 % %&, #1 #",1 )

#)& ,%&, % #10&# #1 $% %"#/ 0"8 8"% " &%#1% # $1 "!% #/ 3#/ 0"" %/ ") %,- ,#1C!%% "/%" ,E -#0 !%, #! %#8!" <#1 )% / "J% & (&%1"#2 "" - "&/""%") &%1%>#1 !!%" /" &%-1"0%&%" %",2" &1 "&%%& J0""%&" %,&#1 ) / % 0"& 1 (& ." !%- " !% -&")#!!%"/ ,%/ "%! 3,!#1) /)#&#1%#"&1 &%&% /#8#&"%! )#1" %, & &"%#1) "!%< ,8

##"#"6%!" %! "%, /

&&#1)#$&&"#1 %"&

(& " %%1-)% / (&- %#8#1

"%'&"#1,1"$,! "%>%! %/" ,1&

%#1%/"% #/ 0""

!)#%#, !%))#1-,1"$) % "$ #1 &% <! /$ &#/ &" # !% 3 0" ,! 0"

KA&,)"8% >% %",%>*!+ 6 8#>2 &% %! -&"#1 %$ 1 &#/

"/%& # "0%&%"&#"$"%0

"! $%)%"$%1"%"#E

9#A%" $' & () "%-

*' ?- 0"% "! %- %% % /)& 1% %$-&/"%3

< "!1 %,""( %$)1 # /! ,% " "%1% %"%%, ."&%,"0%!

& #" #1 ',#%$00<!%)1"&% .%,#$ & ()'0%5%!% "%-

@=% , ' /"$' & () "%-

* 44@

*' @56

@56 ?

@ 7,' /"$' =%1

$0 " )$ &"%$ & #0 )1 = >)#"'&!%,5&% "5&%-0 1,% " !% !!#.",% /#1, *("9 # &/

=% %' /"'"& $ &/ * %*!%%