High Court of Punjab and HaryanaLPA/960/2016dismissed

Kitab Singh Through Lr And ORS v. Karam Chand Through Lrs And Others

2016-06-026 pages

!"# $

&'( )(*"+"#,

, - .. - . .. /(+(#', /&#0"/.1&21&#3)0*&'( /'1(&44(55&#'+ &6(+1"#)&5 1( 7/"' 4('"'"# "5() 89 '1( /(+4#)(#'+ &#) '1("/ 4/()(*(++/:"#:"#'(/(+'1&0"#;8((#&557()89'1(5(&/#()."#;5(2);(3 '1(&44(55&#'+1&0( "5()'1(4/(+(#'"#'/&:*2/'&44(&5 1(*1&55(#;(8( /('1(5(&/#()."#;5(2);(7&+''1(/)(/ )&'() <=

4&++() 89 "#&#*"&5 >>"++"#(/3 &/9&#&3 71(/(89 /)(/ )&'() < 4&++() 89 .28 "0"+"#&5

"*(/ "0"5!:*2>:

/(+*/"8()2'1/"'93 (1&>7&++('&+")( /"( 593 '1( &*'+ '1( *&+( &/( '1&' ?&/&> 1&#)3 4/()(*(++/:"#:"#'(/(+' '1(/(+4#)(#'+7&+&8";5&#)7#(/&#)*&+( /(;&/)"#;1"++2/452+5&#)7&+)(*")()89'1(55(*'/;/&/"&#31&#& 0")(/)(/)&'()

=371(/(891"+ +'&#)&/)&*/(+ 5&#)7&+ )(*5&/()+2/452+# 3?&/&>1&#) "5()&445"*&'"#45(&)"#;

'1&''1(5&#)"#@2(+'"#)")#'0(+'"#'1(.'&'(2#)(/.(*'"#

&/9&#&("5"#;#&#)5)"#;+*'3 <

/+1/'3-'1(*'-!&#)# 5&#)7&++2/452+"#'1(1&#)+ ?&/&>1&#)?&/&>1&#)1&)+2

(/() &)(*/(("# &02/ 1"+ &>"59>(>8(/+#= BB(7&+1&0"#;#( 2#"' &#) '1(/( 7(/( "0( &))"'"#&5 2#"'+ &#) & '(/ ;"0"#; 8(#( "'

4(/>"++"85(&/(& +"C2#"'+3#5&#)7&++2/452+"#'1(1&#)+ ?&/&> 1&#)D")(/)(/)&'()< 3.28

"*(/ "0"5!:*2>:

/(+*/"8()2'1/"'93 (1&>1(5)'1&'?&/&>1&#)7&+&8";5&#)7#(/ "# =A317(0(/3&''1('">( (# /*(>(#' '1(*'31(7&+1&0"#; 2#"'+ 5&#)&#)#5&#)7&++2/452+7(0(/3'1(.'&'( &/9&#& 4/( (//()/(0"+"#8( /('1("#&#*"&5>>"++"#(/3&/9&#&& '(/&5&4+( &82' A9(&/+371"*17&+&557()0")(/)(/)&'() <=

1(+&") /)(/7&+*1&55(#;()89'1(/(+4#)(#'+&#)'1("/4/()(*(++/:"#:"#'(/(+'3 71"*17&+&557()0")(">42;#()/)(/ (&/)5(&/#()*2#+(5 /'1(&44(55&#'+&#)4(/2+()'1(4&4(/ 8E 1(/(5(0&#'4/0"+"#+ .(*'"# B '1(*'371"*1)(&5 7"'1&44(&5&#)/(0"+"#3&/((C'/&*'()8(57,

!#94(/+#&;;/"(0() 89&#9)(*"+"#//)(/ '1(4/(+*/"8()&2'1/"'93#'8("#;

'1(55(*'/3>&937"'1"# "

'((#)&9+ />'1()&'( )(*"+"#//)(/34/( (/&#&44(&5''1(55(*'/"#+2*1 /> &#)>&##(/&+>&98(4/(+*/"8(), /0")()'1&''1(55(*'/>&9(#'(/'&"#'1(&44(&5& '(/'1( (C4"/9 '1(+&")4(/") "

'((#)&9+"

1("++&'"+ "()'1&''1( &44(55&#'7&+4/(0(#'()89+2

"*"(#'*&2+( /> "5"#;'1( &44(&5"#'">(

! #9 4(/+# &;;/"(0() 89 & )(*"+"# / /)(/ '1( 55(*'/ 71('1(/&*'"#;&+4/(+*/"8()&2'1/"'9/#'!#' 8("#;&)(*"+"#//)(/>&)("#&#&44(&52#)(/+28:+(*'"#

!>&937"'1"# "

'((#)&9+ />'1()&'( )(*"+"#//)(/3 4/( (/&#&44(&5''1(>>"++"#(/"#+2*1 />&#)>&##(/ &+>&98(4/(+*/"8() /0")()'1&''1(>>"++"#(/>&9(#'(/'&"#'1(&44(&5& '(/ '1((C4"/9 '1(+&")4(/") "

'((#)&9+"

1("++&'"+ "()'1&'

'1(&44(55&#'7&+4/(0(#'()89+2

"*"(#'*&2+() /> "5"#;'1( &44(&5"#'">(

A!CCCCCC

%!#94(/+#&;;/"(0()89&#/)(/ '1(55(*'/2#)(/ +28:+(*'"#

!3>&97"'1"#'1"/'9)&9+ />'1()&'( /)(/3 "5(&/(0"+"#4('"'"#8( /('1(>>"++"#(/+&+' *1&55(#;( '1( 5(;&5"'9 / 4/4/"('9 +2*1 /)(/ &#) '1( >>"++"#(/>&94&+++2*1/)(/&+1(>&9)((> "'1( /)(/ '1(>>"++"#(/+1&558( "#&5

=!CCCCCC

!'7"'1+'&#)"#;&#9'1"#;*#'&"#()"#'1( /(;"#;+28:

+(*'"#+3'1("#&#*"&5>>"++"#(/>&9+2:>'2&'&#9'">( *&55 /'1(/(*/) &#94/*(()"#;+//)(/ &#9&2'1/"'9 +28/)"#&'('1"> /'1(42/4+( +&'"+ 9"#;1">+(5 &+' '1(5(;&5"'9/4/4/"('9 +2*14/*(()"#;+//)(/3&#)>&9 4&+++2*1/)(/"#/(5&'"#'1(/('&+1(>&9)((> "'

<!CCCCCC

B!'7"'1+'&#)"#;&#9'1"#;*#'&"#()"#+(*'"#

3&4(/+# 71 "5(+&#&44(&5/&/(0"+"#&;&"#+''1(/)(/)(*5&/"#;1"+ 5&#)&++2/452+&/(&&#)'1(&44(&5//(0"+"# "5()891">

&"5+3+1&558(5"&85('4&93 /'1(4(/")1("+/1&+&'&#9 '">(8((#"#4++(++"# '1(5&#))(*5&/()+2/452+'71"*1 1("+/7&+#'(#'"'5()2#)(/'1(5&73&5"*(#*( (((@2&5' '1"/'9'">(+'1(5&#)15)"#;+'&C3/(*0(/&85("#/(+4(*' '1"+ &/(&

!CCCCCCG 1(2#)"+42'() &*'+#/(*/)&/('1&' +'&#)&/)&*/(+

5&#) 7#() 89 ?&/&> 1&#) 7&+ )(*5&/() +2/452+ 0")( /)(/ )&'()

=1(5&#)7&+#(0(/2'"5"+()&#)4++(++"#'1(/( /(>&"#() 7"'1'1(5&#)7#(/# 3?&/&>1&#) "5()&445"*&'"#45(&)"#;

% '1&''1(5&#)"#@2(+'"#)")#'0(+'"#'1(.'&'(0(/#>(#'&#)#5&#) 7&++2/452+"#1"+1&#)+(&5++2

(/()&)(*/(("# &02/ 1"+ &>"59 >(>8(/+#= BBD")(/)(/)&'()< 3.28

"*(/

"0"5!:*2>:/(+*/"8()2'1/"'93 (1&>1(5)'1&'#5&#)7&++2/452+ 0(#'12;1'1(/)(/7&+&44(&5&85(2#)(/.(*'"# B '1(*'382''1( .'&'(#(0(/4/( (//()&#9&44(&50(#'1(/)(/4&++()89'1(44(55&'( 2'1/"'9H55(*'/ 7&+ /(0"+&85( 8( /( '1( >>"++"#(/ '7"'1+'&#)"#;'1(/(>()9 &44(&5//(0"+"#&+4/0")()"#.(*'"#

B '1(*'3'1("#&#*"&5>>"++"#(/1&)+2:>'247(/'*&55 / /(*/)+ &#94/*(()"#;+//)(/ &#9&2'1/"'9+28/)"#&'('1"> / '1(42/4+( +&'"+ 9"#;1">+(5 &+''1(5(;&5"'9/4/4/"('9 +2*1 4/*(()"#;+//)(/&#)>&94&+++2*1/)(/"#/(5&'"#'1(/('3&+1(>&9 )((> "')28'3#'">(5">"'1&+8((# "C() /(C(/*"+( +2:>'2 47(/2#)(/'1(*'#'1(*&+("#1&#)3'1(.'&'(4/( (//()/(0"+"#8( /( '1("#&#*"&5>>"++"#(/& '(/&5&4+( A9(&/+& '(/4&++"#; /)(/ 89'1(/(+*/"8()2'1/"'9371"*17&+*#+")(/()2#)(/.(*'"# B !

'1(*'"#0E"#;+2:>'247(/ 1(5(;&5"++2("#050()"#'1(4/(+(#'4('"'"#"+&+'71('1(/ +2:>'247(/*25)8((C(/*"+()89'1("#&#*"&5>>"++"#(/2#)(/ .(*'"# B ! '1(*'& A9(&/+ 4&++"#; '1(/)(/(0(#"

'1(/( "+#'">(5">"'&++2*1 "C()"#'1(*' /(C(/*"+( '1&'47(/1("++2( 7&+*#+")(/()89#-85('1(.24/(>(2/'"#.&#'+1E2>&/.1"0;#)& &'"5&#)'1(/+0&5&+&1(82E&/&>.1(0&5(&#)'1(/+3

!. A= '7&+&*&+(2#)(/ &1&/&+1'/&&#)(0(#2()(3

/+1/'3 -'1()(-!1(+2:>'247(/7&++2;1''8((C(/*"+()"#'1(9(&/

A&;&"#+''1(/)(/4&++()89'1(+28/)"#&'(&2'1/"'9"#'1(9(&/ < 1(+2:>'247(/'1(/("#*25)8((C(/*"+()2#)(/.(*'"# =< )( $1"5(/( (//"#;''1((&/5"(/62);>(#'+ #-85('1(.24/(>( 2/'"#.'&'( 26&/&'0&'"5&;1&0&'1&3

! . B<I 1) ?&0" 1&>&)>"#0&'>&8&"8/&1">3

<! .< &#).'&'(

2#6&801&'"#)& "+'/"*'4 "5E/)2*(/+#"#')3

.A A3"'7&+4"#()'1&'(0(#"

&+'&'2'()(+#'4/(+*/"8(&#9'">( 5">"' /(C(/*"+( /(0"+"#&547(/3"')(+#'>(&#'1&''1(+&>(*&#8( (C(/*"+()&'&#9'">('1&+'8((C(/*"+()7"'1"#/(&+#&85('">(1"#;+ +(''5()*&##'8(2#+(''5()& '(/5&4+( 5#;'">(#'1&'*&+(3/(&+#&85(

= '">(7&+4"#()'8('1/((9(&/+C(/*"+( 47(/& <9(&/+7&+1(5) '8(&82+( 4/*(++ 5&7(5(0&#'4&/&;/&41 '1(/( "+(C'/&*'() 8(57, '+((>+'8( &"/59+(''5()'1&'"

&+'&'2'()(+#'

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

*2/+(3''1((C*(4'"#&5*"/*2>+'&#*(+"#&;"0(#*&+(382' +2/(59(C(/*"+( /(0"+"#&547(/& '(/&5&4+( <9(&/+"+ #'&/(&+#&85('">(#0*&'"# /(0"+"#&547(/89'1( .28:

"*(/2#)(/.(*'"# =< '1( &1&/&+1'/& &#)(0(#2()("+45&"#59&#&82+( 4/*(++"#'1( &*'+ &#)*"/*2>+'#*(+ '1(*&+(&++2>"#;'1&''1(/)(/ &1+"5)&/4&++()#A A < "+ 5&7()&#)5(;&559#'*//(*' (/'"#(#'5932E&/&>.&E1&/&>.1(0&5(3)2/"#; 1"+ 5" ('">( #(0(/*1&55(#;()'1(5(;&5"'9&#)*//(*'#(++ '1(/)(/ &1+"5)&/3.1"/5&5'12;1"'7&+4&++()#A A < =&#)1( 7&+&5"0(24' '"+#'(0(#"#'1(*&+( (+4#)(#'+ '='1&'2E&/&>7&+#'&7&/( '1(/)(/)&'()A A < 1(/("+# "#)"#;89'1(.28:

"*(/("'1(/'1&''1( /)(/)&'()A A < 7&+8'&"#() /&2)25(#'59G 1(& /(+&")62);>(#' #-85('1(.24/(>(2/'7&+

557()89& "0"+"#(#*1 '1"+*2/'"#.'&'( &/9&#&&#)'1(/+0 1&#);"&>3

!% 371(/('1(/)(/4&++()"#0E"#;/(0"+"#&5 62/"+)"*'"#&

9(&/+7&+1(5)'8(8&) 1( "++2( 7&+ +28+(@2(#'59 *#+")(/() 89 '1"+ *2/' "# 1&#);"&>0.'&'( &/9&#&&#)'1(/+3

=371(/('1(

+2:>'247(/7&++2;1''8((C(/*"+()&

9(&/+ 4&++"#; /)(/'7&+4"#()'1&'(C(/*"+( +2:>'247(/*&##'8(5( '&''1( 71">+&#)+7((':7"55 '1(/(0"+"#&5&2'1/"'971(#(0(/&#)71(/(0(/"' 7&#'+')++">"5&/(

(*'&/('1(62);>(#'+ '1"+*2/'"#$ BA AJ2/&#."#;10.'&'( &/9&#&3)(*")()# %<

%&#)

%J&'/."#;1&#)'1(/+01(.'&'( &/9&#& &#)&#'1(/3)(*")()#=

/'1(/(&+#+>(#'"#()&80(3"#'1(4/(+(#'*&+(+2:>'2 47(/1&0"#;8((#(C(/*"+()89'1("#&#*"&5>>"++"#(/& A9(&/+ 4&++"#; /)(/89'1(/(+*/"8()2'1/"'93'1(+&>(*&##'8(+&")' 8(/(&+#&85(&#)5(;&559+2+'&"#&85($1"5(*#*2//"#;7"'1'1(0"(7+ (C4/(++()89'1(5(&/#()."#;5(2);(3'1(&44(&5"+3&**/)"#;593)"+>"++() #+(@2(#'593'1(&**>4&#9"#;&445"*&'"#+&/(&5+)"+>"++()

&6(+1"#)&5!

2);( &/"#)(/."#;1.")12!

2);(

( (/'(4/'(/!